Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Unique pizza spots in Ohio

A standard slice just won't cut it when the hunger calls for something unconventional.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Lori's American Pies image 1
Lori's American Pies image 2
Lori's American Pies image 3
View all

Hole-in-the-wall takeout spot offers homemade crust and sauce with authentic Sicilian style and gluten-free options. Friendly, cute vibe with bins of condiments and utensils for convenience. Prices reflect quality ingredients, attracting those seeking detailed, flavorful pizza experiences.

Pizza stands out for its Detroit style and unique toppings like Brussels sprouts and loaded potato. Options like the Chase pizza offer unusual but delicious flavors.

Pizzas feature unique recipes with standout ingredients like Brussels sprouts. Flavors are exciting and the quality of ingredients really shines through.

People are saying

"The meatballs here are tender and delicious."

"I found the pizza to be delicious and amazing."

"The pizzas here are so unique and delicious."

Good to know

1

Lori's American Pies is takeout only, no dine-in available.

2

Online ordering is available for specific pickup times.

3

Expect prices over $30 for two small pizzas with toppings.

02
GlendAlehouse Brewery image 1

An old Victorian house converted into a brewery offers cozy small rooms and a laid-back, homey atmosphere. Live, impromptu music and a brick pizza oven visible from the bar add to the relaxed vibe. Outdoor garden seating and family-friendly games create a welcoming space for locals.

Great pizza stands out with Cincinnati Chili and Chicken Alfredo varieties. The pies offer a delicious and satisfying taste similar to Philadelphia-style.

A unique vibe sets this brewery apart from others, creating a wonderful, chill environment. The venue feels quaint and distinctive, offering a different experience alongside great tasting beer.

People are saying

"I thought the craft beers here were exceptional."

"Their wood-fired pizza is amazing and delicious."

"It's a unique, cozy, and homey vibe in this little house."

Good to know

1

Public parking is available across the street behind the police station.

2

The brewery is family friendly.

3

The brewery offers wood-fired pizza.

03
True Slice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Bright, bold space with a cozy vibe and clean, hygienic environment. Offers gourmet pizza with unique options like tandoori chicken and butter chicken, served fresh and flavorful. Stays open late, creating a lively spot for diverse pizza lovers.

Butter Chicken pizza and tandoori chicken pizza stand out with fresh, crisp toppings and perfect dough. Options include vegetarian pizzas with pineapple, large pepperoni and sausage pizzas, and generous portions with cheesy garlic bread.

Food offers a unique pizza experience with both special dishes and typical options. It stands out for delivering something different from usual pizza places.

People are saying

"The Indian Food here is great, with perfectly seasoned meat and fresh vegetables."

"This pizza is just perfect and really good."

"I found the Indian style pizza to be a unique and flavorful experience."

Good to know

1

Pizza by the slice is available until 5 pm.

2

The restaurant is open until 2 am daily.

3

They offer gourmet pizza with unique flavors like tandoori chicken.

04
Pizza Twist image 1
Restaurant

Spacious restaurant with a family friendly and buzzing atmosphere filled with fun music. Offers a complete Halal menu featuring Indian-style pizzas with bold, spicy flavors. Clean and bright space attracts those seeking a unique dining experience with a variety of options.

Pizzas here blend Indian flavors with a solid bread base, especially the Achari Paneer and Paneer Tikka pizzas that pack a spicy, cheesy punch. The crust stays crispy and the spice level hits just right without extra toppings.

Indian-style pizzas offer a unique twist with bold, flavorful toppings. Each pizza brings a distinctive taste that stands out from classic options.

People are saying

"I was never disappointed with their pizza."

"The pizzas here have unique Indian flavors that are delicious."

"You have to try the tacos; they were really good."

Good to know

1

Pizza Twist offers a complete halal menu with both halal and non-halal options.

2

A large pizza costs around $21, which is higher than typical pizza chains.

3

The restaurant charges an extra 75 cents for dipping sauces.

05
Rossville Pizza Company image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza restaurant with a historic steel mill theme and wood-fired oven set outdoors. Cozy indoor seating and a covered patio with heaters create a welcoming atmosphere connected to a local brewery. The vibe is relaxed with fresh, high-quality pizza and a selection of craft beers and cocktails.

Wood-fired pizzas come out hot and fresh with an artisanal touch and unique Blast Furnace option. The quality and passion behind each pie make the price feel worth it.

Blast furnace pizza stands out as a unique option not found elsewhere in town. The arugula salad also offers a distinct and flavorful twist.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was hot and delicious."

"The salad here is fresh and flavorful."

"The blast furnace pizza was a unique option not available elsewhere."

Good to know

1

Rossville Pizza Company is reservation-only, so plan ahead.

2

Parking can be tricky, so arrive early or be prepared to walk.

3

The restaurant does not offer online ordering or call-in takeout.

06
Old Dayton Pizza at Riverside Hideaway image 1

Old Dayton Pizza offers a large bar and a spacious outdoor patio with fire pit and kids' toys. The atmosphere blends an old school, cozy vibe with a casual, fun setting. Regulars enjoy handmade dough pizzas and craft cocktails in a relaxed, comfortable space.

Pizza features a crisp and flavorful crust with a unique taste from homemade marinara and fresh local ingredients. Tiny, oven-kissed pepperonis add a crispy, flavorful touch without burning.

Old Dayton Pizza stands out with its flavorful and fresh-tasting sauce. Unique combinations of pizza flavors add to the distinct experience.

People are saying

"The food here is outstanding, especially the pizza."

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and flavorful."

"I loved the unique combinations of pizza flavors."

Good to know

1

Most food items take about 25-35 minutes to arrive after ordering.

2

The restaurant offers a limited menu with only small pizza sizes available.

3

Expect higher prices for pizzas and drinks compared to average establishments.

07
Bella Sorella Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Open fire wood-fired pizza oven creates a rustic and modern dining space with gorgeous indoor and outdoor decor. Atmosphere feels warm and family-friendly but can be noisy due to hard surfaces and tight seating. Outdoor patio offers a casual Italian vibe that complements the overall experience.

Wood-fired pizza stands out with phenomenal flavor and a deluxe style that impresses every time. Service is timely and efficient, making the dining experience smooth and enjoyable.

Fresh pizza features unique combinations and flavors. The marinara and calamari stand out as distinctive appetizers. Caesar Salad offers one of a kind croutons and sauce with fresh lettuce.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be spectacular and amazing."

"You have to try the meatballs; they're truly next-level."

"The pizza crust here is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant gets crowded quickly, especially during dinner hours.

2

Reservations are not accepted, so expect possible wait times.

3

The menu features 11 specific pizza combinations with no customization allowed.

08
Tandoori Crust Pizza image 1

Restaurant offers fusion pizza blending Indian spices with classic crusts in a casual, cozy setting. Atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed despite occasional warmth and humidity. Setup resembles a popular burrito chain with vegetarian options available.

Fusion pizzas feature Indian spices and toppings like Tandoori Chicken Tikka and Paneer Tikka. Crusts are thin and crispy with a smoky tandoori flavor, served hot and fresh with mild spice options.

Toppings bring a unique twist while keeping the pizza familiar. The menu blends world fusion flavors into comfort food that stands out.

People are saying

"Their fusion pizzas blend Indian and Italian-American flavors so naturally."

"I thought the samosas here were pretty good."

"The pizzas here offer a unique blend of Indian and Italian-American flavors."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a unique fusion of Indian cuisine and pizza.

2

Expect a wait time of around 20-30 minutes for pizza during peak hours.

3

They offer three spice levelsโ€”mild, medium, and hot.

09
The Benninghofen House image 1

Victorian charm blends with modern luxury in a stunning house featuring stained glass windows, intricate woodwork, and a grand staircase. The atmosphere stays peaceful and inviting, fostering relaxation and creativity with smooth, unhurried days. Outdoor spaces offer quiet spots and social areas, supporting both calm and conversation.

Fresh pizzas come from a brick oven or a backyard stone oven with fresh basil from the garden. Slices are often enjoyed in the courtyard.

Craftsmanship and intricate details create a unique ambiance throughout the house. Hosts bring distinct talents that add to the experience's originality.

People are saying

"It's a charming century home, a truly relaxing spot."

"It's a truly unique place for a nice getaway."

"Bekki and Michael baked homemade pizza in their stone oven."

Good to know

1

The Benninghofen House hosts monthly ladies events that are well organized.

2

Yoga classes are offered regularly, perfect for relaxation and rejuvenation.

3

The venue is ideal for hosting retreats, providing a calm atmosphere.

10
Angilo's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Take-out only pizza joint with a friendly atmosphere and unique Indian fusion menu. Offers crispy fresh crust pizzas alongside classic Cincinnati favorites at reasonable prices. Known for prompt service and a neighborhood vibe.

Pizzas come with a fresh crust, sauce, and toppings that balance well. Indian style options like Tandoori Chicken and Saag stand out with bold flavors and plenty of cheese.

Menu blends classic favorites with Indian fusion pizzas and wings. Drinks include a Mango Lassi with a unique mango yogurt flavor. Gift certificates also stand out as distinctive.

People are saying

"I loved their flavorful Indian style pizzas."

"The Italian food portions are huge and the prices are great."

"They have unique Indian fusion pizzas and wings."

Good to know

1

This location is carry out only.

2

Parking is a bit restricted.

3

The price point for the food is excellent considering how expensive everywhere else is.

11
Liberty Collective image 1

Large space combines family-friendly activities like sand volleyball and giant Jenga with areas to relax and enjoy live music and a self-pour beer wall. Atmosphere balances lively energy with spots for adults to unwind, though noise and crowd size vary. Design is clean and modern, featuring multiple seating sections and a notable bar area.

Pizza features a perfect crust and fresh toppings. Small 10-inch build-your-own pizzas cost around $13 and taste exceptional.

Unique seating choices fill the space both inside and outside, creating a distinct vibe. A self-serve drink wall adds a fun, interactive element to the experience.

People are saying

"The bar and food here are awesome."

"It's a unique place with a beautiful open-air design and fun concept."

"I found the pizza here to be really good, especially the crust."

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult during busy times, especially on weekends.

2

The venue has a no cash policy; only credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

3

Auto-gratuity of 18% is added to all drink purchases without prior notice.

12
Izakaya image 1
Bar & grill

Anime-themed decor and continuous anime screenings create a unique atmosphere with neon signs and group-friendly tables. The vibe is fun and welcoming, blending light music with occasional karaoke. Japanese whiskey and themed cocktails add to the distinctive experience.

Build-your-own pizzas come hot and fresh. The pizza stands out as delicious and a highlight among other dishes.

Atmosphere stands out with its quirky charm and anime playing on-screen, creating a vibe unlike any other. The overall experience feels positive and unique, making it worth the visit.

People are saying

"The Korean corn dogs here are amazing, especially the half cheese, half meat ones."

"The crab rangoon dip was the winner here."

"The atmosphere here is pretty unique and fun."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to secure a table, especially on busy nights.

2

Karaoke night happens every Friday, starting at 9pm.

3

Trivia night is held every Tuesday evening with themed questions.

13
Dorothy Lane Market image 1
Grocery store

Upscale grocery store with retro stylized theming and beautiful interior design creates a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Shoppers often enjoy a glass of wine or beer while browsing, with impressive deli, bakery, and salad bar options enhancing the experience.

Wood-fired pizzas stand out with Napoli style and unique options like Alsatian pizza rarely found outside France. Weekly specials add variety alongside smoked meats and baked goods.

Varied aisles offer unique items and a wide selection of specialty foods and fresh baked goods not found elsewhere.

People are saying

"The grocery store staff are so friendly and helpful."

"I thought the pizza was very good and delicious."

"You'll find unique groceries and specialty items in every aisle."

Good to know

1

Expect higher prices compared to typical grocery stores; budget accordingly.

2

The market features a unique selection of local and organic products.

3

Parking can be limited, so arrive early during peak hours.

14
Traders World Flea Market image 1

Former self storage building converted into a giant flea market with outdoor booths and live entertainment including music and magic. The atmosphere blends family-friendly charm with a busy, cluttered vibe and plenty of unique decorations and merchandise. Visitors spend hours exploring diverse vendors and enjoying casual food options in a lively setting.

Slices come from a lady with grey hair who makes pizza without gloves. The pizza tastes like gas station style or frozen pizza and is considered decent but cheaply made.

Many vendors sell one-of-a-kind handmade products and unique collectibles. The market offers a wide variety of odd shops and cool finds not seen in mass-produced goods.

People are saying

"The outdoor space has a yard sale feel with many vintage finds."

"You can find so many unique handmade and antique items here."

"I thought the pizza here was decent."

Good to know

1

The flea market is only open on weekends.

2

You must pay $2 to park your vehicle.

3

Bring cash for parking and some purchases inside.

15
Hops and Berry Taproom image 1

Self-serve taps with a key fob system let people pour drinks at their own pace. The space combines stylish interior with indoor and outdoor seating, including a patio with a fireplace. Loud music and multiple TVs create a festive, sports-focused atmosphere that fills with energy during events like music bingo.

Flatbread pizza stands out with its amazing flavor. Options include cheese flatbread and pepperoni pizza, but vegetarian choices are limited to cheese-based dishes.

Amazing selections and a unique setup allow immediate drink service and flexible tasting amounts. This creates a unique experience and helps find a unique favorite on tap.

People are saying

"You pour your own beer and pay by the ounce with a key fob."

"The pizza here has a great variety of drinking options."

"It's unique how you can serve yourself drinks on tap."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on Thursdays to secure a table.

2

Self-pouring drinks are available, priced by the ounce.

3

Parking is free for the first hour, then $1 for additional hours.

Discover more

Ohio

Area guide
Loading Map...