Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Cincinnati

Pizza places

A slice that honors the traditions of a proper Italian kitchen, rather than just another greasy pie in a box.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Pastizza's Pizza and Pasta image 1
Pastizza's Pizza and Pasta image 2
Pastizza's Pizza and Pasta image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Thin crust New York-style pizza defines the menu in a cozy space with old school vibes and a family atmosphere. The setting feels like a grandma's kitchen, simple and inviting, with small tables and fun decorations. The place draws a steady crowd who appreciate authentic flavors without fuss.

Pizza and pasta dishes come with rich, authentic flavors that recall the east coast style. The meat lasagna and cannoli stand out with their velvety filling and perfect texture.

Classic New York-style pizza shines here with a thin crust that is foldable and has the right crunch. The dough offers a wonderful airy texture that melts in your mouth, making the pizzas consistently excellent and authentic.

People are saying

"I had the best New York style pizza I've ever had."

"I thought this pizza was the best I ever had."

"The pizza and pasta here are amazing Italian food."

Good to know

1

Parking is easy and available near the restaurant.

2

The restaurant primarily offers takeout service.

3

A large pizza costs $23, making it an affordable option.

02
Your Momโ€™s Pizzeria image 1

Small pizzeria with cozy seating including a bar and two-person tables creates an intimate setting. Atmosphere stays quiet and relaxed, offering a pleasant, authentic New York vibe. Limited seating and mostly carryout shape a casual, neighborhood feel.

Pizza comes with a solid crust and fresh toppings. Cannolis stand out with small snack sizes and a peanut butter option that adds a unique twist.

Thin crust pizza offers a slight crunch with a soft interior and ample toppings. The sauce and combination of white cheese, tomato, and pepperoni deliver a consistently delicious flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"The food here is amazing, hot, fresh, and flavorful."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, has a great crust."

Good to know

1

The space is small with limited seating; parties larger than two must carry out.

2

Expect to wait or carry out at peak times, especially during dinner rush hours.

3

There is lots of parking available for anyone not in walking distance.

03
Lucy Blue Pizza OTR image 1
Pizza restaurant

Blue ceiling and cute tile floors create a charming, homey environment with a warm, inviting atmosphere. The pizza features a crispy, flavorful crust and fresh ingredients, offering a real-deal New York slice experience. The space feels clean and comfortable, suited for casual dining or picking up orders.

Freshly made breadsticks come sprinkled with minced garlic and stand out as a signature item. Large pizzas are available alongside these garlic breadsticks.

Pizza here features a real-deal New York slice with a crisp, flavorful crust and fresh, high-quality ingredients. Options include many varieties and build-your-own pizzas with good side sauces, all at very affordable prices.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was incredible."

"This food, the pizza, is a real-deal New York slice."

"The Italian food breadsticks were outstanding and freshly made."

Good to know

1

Prices are very affordable for a casual meal.

2

The location is convenient for dining in or picking up orders.

3

They are open from 4 pm to 8 pm on Tuesdays and until 9 pm on weekends.

04
Guardia image 1
Pizza restaurant

Tiny space with limited seating and a walk-up window creates an old school neighborhood joint feel. The vibe mixes 90โ€™s hip hop deep cuts with festive tunes, offering a cool, cozy atmosphere. Quality pizza and craft cocktails attract a crowd despite tight quarters.

Burrata pizza stands out with fresh, milky burrata on top. The hot honey pepperoni pizza offers a sweet and spicy kick. Caesar salad also pairs well with these dishes.

New York style pizza stands out with hot honey pepperoni and burrata pizza as notable options. The pizza features a phenomenal crust and toppings, often compared to East Coast quality.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be the best I've had in years."

"I enjoyed the fresh chopped salad with balsamic dressing."

"The burrata pizza here is amazing, truly worth the wait."

Good to know

1

Parking at Guardia is one of the worst places in the country.

2

There is limited seating, so calling ahead is recommended.

3

Prices for the 18-inch pie are competitive compared to local options.

05
Goodfellas Pizzeria - OTR image 1

1920s speakeasy theme shapes a small pizza restaurant with a top-end bourbon bar upstairs and rustic lounge seating. Atmosphere blends great music and a lovely outdoor space allowing eating, drinking, and smoking. Pizza ranks among the best in town, served quickly in a chill environment with lively energy.

Pizza stands out with a rich marinara sauce and excellent breadsticks. The cannoli matches quality found in New York City, and pasta salad complements the Italian offerings well.

New York-style pizza arrives fresh in about 15-20 minutes. The 22-inch plain cheese or pepperoni pizzas stand out for their great taste and quick service.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"I loved getting pizza here; it's the place to go."

"The Italian food here has massive pizza slices and breadsticks."

Good to know

1

They offer 50% off on their 12-inch pies every Monday.

2

The lunch special is a fantastic value.

3

Parking is available just down the block or through street parking.

06
Strong's Brick Oven Pizzeria image 1

Big brick oven dominates an open, modern space with a clean, welcoming vibe. Noise levels run extremely loud, making conversation difficult. Friendly staff serve phenomenal pizza and house-made lager.

Pizzas feature super fresh ingredients with generous pepperoni and thick Italian sausage chunks. The menu includes bruschetta, pesto cheese flatbread, and cannolis that stand out for their flavor.

Quattro Formaggi pizza features a rich ricotta cheese flavor that stands out. Both the Meat pizza and bruschetta receive strong recommendations. Pizzas consistently satisfy cravings with delicious taste and quality.

People are saying

"This Lunch Spot's pizza has a great crust and is loaded with toppings."

"I thought the pizza here was the best around."

"The pizza here is fantastic, truly the best I've had."

Good to know

1

The lunch special from Tuesday through Friday for $13 is a good deal.

2

Expect a 15-20 minute wait during peak lunch hours.

3

You cannot order pickup online; only call for takeout.

07
Adriatico's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant combines brew pub style with a sports bar vibe, featuring numerous TVs showing games. Atmosphere feels lively and cozy, attracting a college crowd and families alike. Space is used efficiently to fit many tables, creating a busy and fun environment.

Parmesan breadsticks come warm, fluffy, and coated in cheese, often paired with garlic butter for dipping. The pesto base pizza and veggie lasagna offer solid Italian options, while the fried mozzarella stands out as a notable appetizer.

Thin crust and deep dish pizza stand out for their quality and flavor. The Sicilian style thick crust and NY style pizza also show consistent excellence and strong local reputation.

People are saying

"I thought the Sicilian style pizza was the best in town."

"They have a great selection of beer on tap."

"You have to try the Italian food; the pizza and breadsticks are great."

Good to know

1

Parking at Adriatico's is limited; consider using the garage across the street.

2

They charge $2 for paper plates, which may be unexpected.

3

Expect a wait for pickup orders; time estimates can be inaccurate.

08
Lucy Blue Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers laid-back atmosphere with clean, well-decorated interior and seating including a bar. Energy stays quiet and inviting, with a focus on fresh, delicious pizza and salads. Toppings come generous, and the vibe suits casual dining without fried items.

Meat lasagna comes frozen and is easy to order for pick up, with a rich, yummy flavor. Breadsticks arrive hot, short, and heavy, paired with a chunky homemade marinara sauce. The fig and prosciutto pizza offers a unique twist on Italian flavors.

Pizzas come with a very thin crust cooked perfectly through and served hot. Varieties include fig and prosciutto, buffalo chicken, Thai with crisp vegetables, and BBQ chicken, all fresh and flavorful.

People are saying

"The pizza here is phenomenal, especially the Thai pizza."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza crust, is really good."

"The salad here is bright, green, and so fresh."

Good to know

1

The buffet is priced at $14.99 for adults, offering good value.

2

They close at 8 PM, so plan to order before 7:30 PM.

3

Expect limited seating; arrive early for a table.

09
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Pleasant Ridge image 1

Pizza restaurant combines upstairs speakeasy bar with outdoor balcony patio for a relaxed vibe. Atmosphere shifts from warm and inviting inside to incredible back patio vibes outside. Frequented by those who enjoy top-notch pizza paired with craft cocktails and bourbon tastings upstairs.

Pizza and breadsticks come with a homemade, hearty marinara sauce that tastes like it has simmered for hours. The cannolis stand out as extremely delicious, and the pesto bread is exceptionally good.

Offers authentic New York-style pizza with old-school charm. Both by-the-slice and whole pizzas come out fantastic with attentive service.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The upstairs bar has an incredible atmosphere and holiday decor."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Goodfellas offers different food and drink specials every night.

2

Parking can be tricky, so plan ahead.

3

There is typically a 30 to 50-minute wait at most.

10
Angilo's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Take-out only pizza joint with a friendly atmosphere and unique Indian fusion menu. Offers crispy fresh crust pizzas alongside classic Cincinnati favorites at reasonable prices. Known for prompt service and a neighborhood vibe.

Meatball Spaghetti offers a classic Italian dish with hearty flavors. The Italian hoagie adds a sandwich option, while mozzarella sticks appear as a common side, though their quality varies.

Pizzas come with a fresh crust, sauce, and toppings that balance well. Indian style options like Tandoori Chicken and Saag stand out with bold flavors and plenty of cheese.

People are saying

"I loved their flavorful Indian style pizzas."

"The Italian food portions are huge and the prices are great."

"The garlic cheese bread here is huge, like a medium pizza."

Good to know

1

This location is carry out only.

2

Parking is a bit restricted.

3

The price point for the food is excellent considering how expensive everywhere else is.

11
Luca Pizza di Roma image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza spot offers authentic New York style pizza with a perfect crust and punchy sauce. The setting is quiet inside a largely empty mall, making it easy to find parking and order quickly. Prices are reasonable, and the menu includes standout items like garlic knots and vegetable pie.

Mozzarella cheese roll resembles a cinnamon roll but without sweetness or cinnamon. Pizza, spaghetti with huge meatballs, and garlic knots stand out. Mozzarella bread sticks add to the Italian offerings.

Pizza here is very New York style with large slices offered at a fair price. The food comes out quickly and the pizza ranks among the best in the area.

People are saying

"The pizza at this Mall has the best thin, crispy crust."

"I tasted the best pizza in Cincinnati here."

"I found the Italian food, especially the pizza, to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Expect limited pizza options by 5:30 pm on Tuesdays.

2

Parking is easy near the food court entrance.

3

The pizza is reasonably priced at $7 for a 12-inch pie.

12
LaRosa's Pizza Sharonville image 1

Pizza restaurant offers drive-thru convenience and a party room for large groups. Atmosphere feels dated but very clean with minimal seating inside. Pizzas come with generous toppings and the menu includes affordable lunch specials.

Pizza and cheese breadsticks stand out as highlights. The menu includes spaghetti and lasagna, with the lasagna containing meat despite some menu photos showing otherwise.

Pizza comes with generous toppings and a delicious, affordable taste. Options like the Buffalo chicken bacon pizza stand out for flavor and quality.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I've ever had."

"The service at this lunch spot is always super quick and friendly."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and spaghetti, tasted great."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a lunch special with several different options.

2

Prices for breadsticks have increased from $10 to $15 over the past year.

3

The restaurant has a drive-thru for convenient takeout.

13
Werkhaus Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, local pizza shop with a homey, cozy atmosphere and lively energy when busy. Tables fill quickly in a somewhat crowded, nostalgic space that feels like an Italian friend's dining room. Known for authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza and a strong family vibe.

Spaghetti carbonara and lasagna with meat sauce stand out for their rich flavors. Deep dish pizzas, chicken fettuccine Alfredo, and cheesy breadsticks add variety alongside classic spaghetti with meatballs and sausage.

Deep dish pizzas feature a sesame seed crust and heavy meat and cheese toppings. Traditional and Chicago-style stuffed pizzas stand out with a creamy garlic dressing offered for salads and appetizers.

People are saying

"You should save room for the delicious desserts here."

"I thought the pizza here was the best of the best."

"The Chicago style pizza here is a family favorite."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited and fills up quickly, so arrive early.

2

A buy one, get one half off deal is available on medium and large pizzas.

3

Expect to take home leftovers as portions are generous.

14
Al'Lupo Ristorante image 1

Dining inside an old pottery mill with tables in historic kilns creates a unique setting. The atmosphere is lively and loud, yet guests can still converse easily. Outdoor seating offers city views, and the bar curves around the kiln, adding to the distinctive vibe.

Pasta dishes like clam linguine and pork jowl stand out with perfect cooking and rich flavors. The Bucatini Carbonara offers a creamy sauce with crispy guanciale, delivering classic comfort food. Desserts include a unique sweet potato tiramisu that finishes the meal well.

People are saying

"I love the Italian food here; it feels like a blessing."

"The Caesar salad was missing key components, like fingerling potatoes."

"The pizza crust has a perfect chew-and-char."

Good to know

1

Reservations are definitely recommended to ensure a table.

2

Being able to pay by the QR code on the receipt allows for quick departures.

3

The restaurant offers a non-fried option for calamari, which is a rare choice.

15
N.Y.P.D. Pizza Colerain / Peachgrove image 1

Pizza restaurant offers quick preparation and friendly delivery with affordable prices. The atmosphere is cold and the pickup area is limited to standing space near a drink refrigerator. Menu features hoagies and pretzels alongside pizza, with some items praised for taste and others noted as dry or unevenly topped.

Chicken alfredo pizza and pepperoni pizza stand out as flavorful options. Pasta dishes like spaghetti do not meet the same standard here.

Perfect pizza every time comes with options like chicken alfredo and pepperoni with extras under and over the cheese. Service is fast and friendly, with quick preparation and reliable online ordering.

People are saying

"This pizza is awesome and always good."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, is always good."

"Delivery is quick and the food arrives hot and fresh."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has permanently closed and is no longer in operation.

16
The Filson Queen City Kitchen & Bar image 1

Large patio offers breathtaking river views and dog-friendly outdoor seating with fire pits. Energetic atmosphere fills the space, especially during sports games shown on wall-to-wall TVs. Seating is crowded and lively, creating an upscale yet bustling vibe for fans and diners alike.

Crispy yet tender crust and fresh mozzarella stand out on the Margarita Pizza. The bourbon street pasta features well-cooked penne with a flavorful sauce, and the Cajun pasta offers a spicy twist.

Pizza features a crispy yet tender crust with fresh mozzarella and balanced tomato. Options include a Margarita Pizza and a cauliflower dough version, both well received.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the burgers and fries; they were cooked perfectly."

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the pizza and chicken."

"I loved the cheesy, delicious buffalo chicken pizza."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times, especially during busy events.

2

Happy hour offers $2 off craft beers and $10 food specials.

3

Thursday Martini day features $6 martinis, a great deal for cocktail lovers.

Discover more

Cincinnati, Ohio

Area guide
Loading Map...