Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Dayton

Italian food

Made for those who prioritize authentic pasta and regional specialties over everything else when they sit down to eat.

Based on 469 Opinions
+466
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Say Yes Cakes image 1
Say Yes Cakes image 2
Say Yes Cakes image 3
View all

Bakery shines with custom cakes perfect for celebrations and authentic cannolis piped fresh with crisp shells. Italian treats like chocolate cupcakes and Chi scones add variety. Prices stay affordable for the quality and size offered.

Cannolis stand out with fresh, authentic shells piped to order. Chocolate cupcakes, brownies, and Chi scones also feature as notable Italian-style treats.

People are saying

"They made my custom cake beautifully on-brand and exceeded expectations."

"I found this bakery had incredibly delicious treats available."

"The cannoli here are authentic and outstanding."

Good to know

1

Custom cakes are available and can be tailored for special occasions.

2

Prices for custom cakes are reasonable considering the craftsmanship involved.

3

Advance orders are recommended for custom cakes to ensure availability.

02
Jerardi's Little Store image 1

Cozy spot shines with handmade fresh products and a diverse deli counter. Bold street corn chicken pasta and fresh pasta salads offer satisfying Italian flavors. Warm, welcoming vibe suits quick lunches or take-home treats.

Street corn chicken pasta stands out with bold flavors. Pasta salads, including ham and seafood varieties, offer fresh, satisfying options.

People are saying

"Their sandwiches are huge and packed with fresh ingredients."

"The food here is amazing, with fresh ingredients prepared with care."

"I thought the Italian food was outstanding, especially the chicken salad."

Good to know

1

They offer a 10% discount if you buy 6 or more bottles.

2

Jerardi's Little Store has a great selection of wines, beers, and food.

3

They offer lots of vegetarian options.

03
Old Dayton Pizza at Riverside Hideaway image 1

Old Dayton Pizza serves handmade dough pizzas with fresh garden vegetables and homemade marinara. Cozy, old school vibe meets casual fun with a large bar and a spacious outdoor patio featuring a fire pit and kids' toys. Enjoy craft cocktails in a relaxed, family-friendly space.

Pizza features homemade marinara and meatballs with vegetables from their garden. Cheesy breadsticks come out gooey and golden, and garlic bread includes cheese and marinara sauce.

People are saying

"The food here is outstanding, especially the pizza."

"The meatballs were so juicy and flavorful."

"This Italian food's pizza crust is crispy, chewy, and perfectly baked."

Good to know

1

Most food items take about 25-35 minutes to arrive after ordering.

2

The restaurant offers a limited menu with only small pizza sizes available.

3

Expect higher prices for pizzas and drinks compared to average establishments.

04
Flavor House image 1
Caribbean restaurant

Small, intimate spot offers rich Fettuccine Alfredo and shrimp Alfredo that shine. Casual yet classy vibe with hand-laid marble floors and mellow old school R&B. Guests enjoy elevated soul food and strong, well-crafted cocktails in a friendly setting.

Rich and buttery Fettuccine Alfredo comes with a little kick, and the shrimp Alfredo stands out as very good. Homemade Alfredo sauce pairs well with dishes like the crispy chicken sandwich and chicken Fontaine.

People are saying

"The salmon was cooked perfectly, flakey perfection."

"The cocktails here are uniquely tasty and delicious."

"The Italian Food here is rich and buttery with a little kick."

Good to know

1

Reservations are appreciated on busy weekend evenings but not mandatory.

2

There is plenty of available parking nearby for guests.

3

Sunday brunch is available, and it's a popular time to visit.

05
Jimmy's Italian Cuisine & Bar image 1

Cozy Italian spot offers a beautiful patio for outdoor dining and a family-like atmosphere that feels welcoming. Signature dishes like Chicken carbonara and spicy marinara on Chicken & Shrimp Fra Diavolo bring bold flavors to the table.

Chicken carbonara stands out as a memorable dish. The Chicken & Shrimp Fra Diavolo features a spicy marinara sauce with a noticeable kick.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I loved the option to eat outside on the patio."

"The Italian food here, especially the lasagna, is amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for large groups to ensure seating.

2

Parking can be limited during peak hours, so arrive early.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is preferred for tips.

06
Bistecca image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian dishes feature in-house made pasta like carbonara with fresh peas and beef cheek. Upscale space boasts a wood-fired oven aroma but loud house music and close seating reduce intimacy. Perfect seasoning and flavorful pesto al rosa highlight the menu.

In-house made pasta shines in dishes like the carbonara, cooked perfectly al dente with fresh peas and beef cheek adding depth. Appetizers, pastas, risottos, and steaks come perfectly seasoned and cooked, with highlights like burrata and flavorful pesto al rosa.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is so flavorful, especially the burrata."

"The filet was cooked exactly how I asked and was well seasoned."

"The bar seating is great; the bartenders are attentive and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

A service charge is added for parties of five or more.

3

Expect delays if arriving past your reservation time; some guests waited over an hour.

07
Manhattan Pizza & Wings image 1
Pizza restaurant

Modern dining space offers extreme cleanliness and comfortable seating with accessibility options. Italian dishes shine with top shelf marinara sauce and high-quality mozzarella on pizzas. The atmosphere buzzes with great vibes and a delicious aroma, perfect for enjoying a wide variety of pizzas and wings.

Marinara sauce stands out as top shelf and enhances dishes significantly. Pizza features high-quality mozzarella and generous toppings, while fried cheese ravioli offers a perfect fry and solid quality. Pastas are consistently good.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza was the best I had in Dayton."

"I thought the salad was great."

"This Italian food's pizza crust and sauce are so good."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times for delivery, sometimes up to two hours.

2

Prices for salads can be high, with small salads costing $6.99.

3

They have a good selection of 26 different pizza choices.

08
Little Fish Brewing Company - Dayton Station image 1

Old factory turned brewery offers a cozy atmosphere with pet-friendly outdoor seating. Pork & Beef Bolognese features house-made noodles that are light and creamy, while music keeps the vibe relaxed and lively.

House-made noodles in the Pork & Beef Bolognese are meaty, light, and creamy, unlike typical pasta. The chicken gnocchi has a paste-like sauce and a less tender texture.

People are saying

"I really enjoyed the tasty beer here."

"The chimichurri fries here are amazing for Date Spots."

"The Italian food's house-made noodles were unlike any pasta I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The brewery offers gluten-free and vegan options for customers with dietary restrictions.

2

Happy hour features discounted appetizers and drinks on weekdays from 4-6pm.

3

Unique pizza is available every third Thursday of the month.

Discover more

Dayton, Ohio

Area guide
Loading Map...