Pizza delivery operates with curbside pickup only, set on a beautiful property that resembles a wedding venue. The atmosphere is straightforward and efficient, with orders placed online and food brought out upon arrival. Known for authentic New York style pizza and legendary Gladiator pizza, it draws those seeking high-quality, traditional flavors in a rural setting.
Crispy crust and delicious sauce define the New York style pizza here. Pepperonis add a classic touch, making it a standout for those seeking authentic NY pizza.
Chocolate-dipped cannoli stand out with rich flavor and perfect texture. Garlic breadsticks and knots offer a strong, savory punch. Pizza options like the Gladiator and white pie come alongside classic spaghetti and meatballs.
"This New York style pizza has a flavorful, textured crust."
"I thought this New York style pizza was the best in Murfreesboro."
"This Italian food is the best pizza I ever had."
Good to know
Currently, you have to order online and let them know when you arrive for curbside pickup.
They only offer curbside pickup; no dine-in seating available.
You can’t get slices but can order a personal-sized gladiator pizza.
Small takeout spot with pizza by the slice and a couple of tables offers a dog-friendly patio. Atmosphere feels fun and cute with a playlist that fits a classic pizzeria vibe. Known for thin crust New York-style pizza and a gluten-free option, it draws a crowd looking for quick, high-quality slices.
Slices come thin and foldable with a classic New York style crust. The pizza features a super classic taste that stays true to traditional New York flavors.
Pesto pizza stands out with a sriracha drizzle and a gluten-free option. Marinara sauce carries a slight kick, and pizzas come light and crispy.
Good to know
There is a dog-friendly patio for outdoor dining.
Parking is available off to the side and is free.
Bathrooms are clean and well-maintained.
Small space with New York style pizza and homemade sauces creates a cozy, warm atmosphere. Sinatra music plays inside and outside, adding to the vibe. Outdoor seating offers a relaxed spot near a gym, though the interior can be noisy and cramped.
Offers true New York style pizza with a taste and texture that matches what you find in New York. Stands out as the most authentic option for those familiar with NY pizza.
Lasagna stands out with its large portion, balanced sauce, and exceptional tomato flavor. Pasta dishes like fettuccine and eggplant parmesan also impress with rich, authentic tastes. Cannolis offer a sweet finish to the meal.
Good to know
Reservations are not required, but expect busy takeout service during peak hours.
The pizza is available by the slice or as a whole pie.
Portion sizes are large, making it a good choice for sharing.
Indoor space features abundant plants, comfortable sofas, and an indoor fountain, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Outdoor seating adds a charming option for diners. The vibe is relaxed and family-friendly, with a quiet, clean environment and Southern rock music playing at a reasonable volume.
Offers authentic New York style pizza with a taste that matches the classic NY flavor. The store stays spotless and new, making it a solid spot for this style in the area.
Creamy Fettuccine Chicken Alfredo and freshly built cannoli stand out. Specialty pastas with Alfredo and pesto, plus pesto chicken Sicilian slice pizza, show a strong pesto presence.
Good to know
A slice costs $3, while a medium pizza is $26.
They offer a lunch deal of two one-topping slices and a drink for $9.
The slices are a good size for under $4 with one topping.
Small pizza spot with authentic New York vibe and live music playing, creating a laid-back atmosphere. Inside space is limited and casual, with a side counter and outdoor patio for extra seating. The smell of dough and pepperoni fills the air, adding to the experience.
Offers authentic New York style pizza with a taste that matches what you'd find in NYC. Stands out in a town known for other foods by delivering classic NY flavor and killer slices.
Lasagna pizza blends traditional lasagna ingredients on a pizza crust. Cannoli recipe stands out, and lactose intolerance is accommodated by swapping cheeses on calzones.
Good to know
Expect a 15-20 minute wait for food during peak times.
Parking is easy and free, making access convenient.
The menu offers a wide selection of pizza styles.
Strip mall setting hosts a small, homey dining area with a friendly, welcoming vibe and quiet atmosphere. Authentic New York style pizza and homemade sauce create a true Italian flavor reminiscent of Little Italy. Quality ingredients and affordable, large portions distinguish the experience.
Slices come in huge sizes with a taste that matches authentic New York pizza closely. Few spots in the area serve true NY style pizza like this one.
Lasagna stands out with rich layers and fresh ingredients. Pasta dishes like Fettuccine Alfredo and spaghetti with meatballs feature perfectly prepared sauces and fresh pasta. Pizza and calzones come with flavorful tomato marinara sauce and tasty fillings.
Good to know
A small pizza costs $18.21, while a giant slice is $3.
The restaurant offers delivery, carry-out, and dine-in options.
Expect large portion sizes that provide good value for money.
Small space with a pizza parlor feel and New York style pizza creates a casual, authentic atmosphere. The vibe is quiet on Sundays but can become chaotic with busy staff during peak times. Seating is tight with a narrow aisle, making navigation challenging when crowded.
Slices capture the classic New York style with a taste matching local Bronx spots. The ambiance feels like a genuine New York pizza shop, delivering a familiar vibe and flavor.
Cannoli stands out as a sweet finish, often noted as the best part of the meal. Tiramisu also earns praise for its flavor. Toasted ravioli adds a nice touch to the Italian offerings.
Good to know
They sell pizza by the slice, with popular options available within minutes.
A regular slice costs almost $5, and cannolis are $6 each.
Expect a 15-minute wait during busy times, especially on weekends.
Pizza restaurant combines classic New York style pies with a Goodfellas-themed interior featuring real photos and detailed décor. Back area hosts a speakeasy lounge with live music and a bar, creating a cozy yet lively atmosphere. The vibe mixes a cool hangout spot with a touch of vintage gangster style.
Slices feature classic thin crust with a balanced sauce and cheese blend. The pizza captures the authentic New York style taste well.
Pizza features about five small rounds of mozzarella and several thin shaves of Parmesan cheese. Breadsticks stand out as affordable and delicious, with some pesto bread also very good.
Good to know
The lunch special is $10 and includes a slice of pizza, a side, and a drink.
Goodfellas Pizzeria participates in Nashville Pizza week, attracting pizza lovers.
Expect limited seating, which can make it crowded during peak hours.
Italian restaurant offers classic Sicilian style with a cool Nashville vibe and spacious outdoor patio featuring games and kid-friendly activities. Atmosphere is quiet and relaxed, with comfortable indoor seating and community-style tables. Cocktails stand out with unique flavors like bergamot and bold citrus.
Perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings defines the New York style pizza here. It delivers a solid, classic taste true to the style.
Mozzarella flight and house bread stand out alongside a seasonal tomato salad. Sicilian pizza features a sourdough crust that tastes like focaccia, complementing chicken scarpariello and sweet potato ravioli dishes.
Good to know
Frankies 925 Spuntino is primarily a takeout place with some tables.
Parking is currently free and available.
The pizzeria stays open until 9pm on weekdays and 10pm on weekends.