Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

New York style pizza in Seattle

Made for those who refuse to settle for anything less than an authentic, foldable slice of New York-style pizza.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Swing Sandwiches and Pizza image 1
Swing Sandwiches and Pizza image 2
Swing Sandwiches and Pizza image 3
View all

Small casual spot with bright cozy atmosphere offers authentic New York style pizza that hits east coast cravings. Fresh, flavorful sandwiches complement the menu at great prices. Warm vibe and laptop plug-ins make it perfect for relaxed dining or work.

Offers authentic New York style pizza that satisfies cravings for east coast flavor. Delivers the classic taste and texture expected from this style.

People are saying

"The pizza here is crazy good, with a thin crispy crust."

"The burrata pizza is totally next level Italian food."

"This is authentic New York Style Pizza done right."

Good to know

1

A slice of cheese costs only $3.5.

2

The sandwiches sell out quickly, so ordering ahead is recommended.

3

All the bread is baked fresh in-house.

02
A.K. Pizza image 1
Pizza Takeout

Chef Alex serves crispy thin crust pizzas with a true New York style foldable slice. Limited parking and no seating create a grab-and-go vibe. High-quality ingredients attract serious pizza lovers despite busy, functional atmosphere.

Chef Alex crafts pizzas with precise technique. The pies have a clear New York style influence, capturing that classic thin crust and foldable slice.

People are saying

"I considered this the best NY-style pizza in Seattle."

"You have to try the cookie; it's unreal and perfectly balanced."

"I thought their New York Style Pizza was the best in Seattle."

Good to know

1

A.K. Pizza is takeout only; online ordering is recommended due to high demand.

2

Parking can be tough; consider carpooling for easier pickup.

3

Pizzas are 18 inches, serving 2 to 4 people, priced fairly for quality.

03
Big Mario's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Big New York style slices come loaded with toppings in a chill spot with vinyl banquettes and a stamped tin ceiling. Dim lighting and a casual vibe make it perfect for late nights. The back bar offers inexpensive beer and a unique setting with VHS tapes and red lighting.

Big, NY style pizza slices come with a nice amount of toppings and a dive-bar vibe. The pizza tastes very close to authentic New York style, especially by the slice.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza tasted authentically NYC and was delicious."

"The bar has a cool dive bar vibe with comfy booths."

"I enjoyed the great New York style pizza with a crispy crust."

Good to know

1

Big Mario's Pizza offers slices priced under $5.

2

The restaurant has a 5% mandatory service charge on all orders.

3

Expect busy times; calling in your order is recommended.

04
Post Alley Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small spot with cozy atmosphere and a walk-up window for quick takeout. Offers authentic New York style pizza with standout crust and character. Limited seating makes it perfect for grabbing pizza to go.

Crust and character stand out in the New York style pizza here. It offers a taste close to authentic New York pizza, rare to find in this city.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was legit New York style."

"The Italian hoagie's bold flavors and quality meats made it the best sandwich."

"I thought the New York Style Pizza here was amazing."

Good to know

1

Post Alley Pizza only offers takeout services.

2

They close at 6 PM.

3

A single cheese slice costs five dollars.

05
Stevie's Famous Beacon Hill image 1

Large interior blends punk rock vibes with a chill bar atmosphere and live music setup. Sourdough crust delivers fresh, crispy pizza by the slice or pie. Seating with outlets and footrests adds comfort and convenience for guests.

Sourdough crust gives the pizza a fresh, crispy, and chewy texture. Available by the slice or whole pies, it matches the style of classic New York pizza.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be seriously delicious."

"The pizza's flavors really open up after it cools down."

"I loved the sourdough New York style pizza; it had a crispy, chewy dough."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but checking the event schedule is recommended.

2

Expect longer wait times during events, especially on weekends.

3

The pizza costs $6.50 per slice, with some specialty options priced higher.

Discover more

Seattle, Washington

Area guide
Loading Map...