Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Pioneer Square's best

American sandwiches

Sometimes a classic American sandwich is the only thing that hits the spot during a busy workday.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Hole In the Wall BBQ image 1
Hole In the Wall BBQ image 2
Hole In the Wall BBQ image 3
View all
Barbecue restaurant

Small, clean, casual barbecue spot with a southern atmosphere and good music playing. The vibe stays nice and mellow, making it easy to sit and talk. Known for excellent pulled pork and brisket that melt in your mouth, it offers affordable prices and limited lunch hours.

Brisket stands out with a rich, smoky flavor that draws repeat visits. Pulled pork, ribs, and cornbread also deliver solid, classic American BBQ tastes.

Brisket sandwiches feature tender, melt-in-your-mouth pulled meat with a great price point. Chicken sandwiches come with a spicy medium sauce that adds a nice kick.

People are saying

"I thought the brisket and hot links were the best BBQ I've ever had."

"These ribs are fall-off-the-bone tender and smoky."

"I'd never had a sandwich with such tender, melt-in-your-mouth pulled meat."

Good to know

1

Hole In the Wall BBQ is open for lunch from 11am to 2:30pm, Monday to Friday.

2

Ribs are available only on Fridays, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Catering orders can be placed easily through the website.

02
Cookie’s Country Chicken image 1
Fried chicken takeaway

Small dining room blends southern, Jamaican, and white-washed styles with well spaced tables and a clean, neat interior. Atmosphere feels cozy and chill with good music and occasional TV. The vibe suits casual meals and relaxed gatherings.

Fried chicken stands out with super juicy meat and a perfectly crispy, mildly spicy crust. The southern style flavor and spice levels hit just right for those craving authentic southern fried chicken.

Chicken sandwiches come large, juicy, and crispy with fresh, hot chicken breasts. The Hot Honey sandwich offers a spicy kick at habanero level, paired well with sides like Pot of Gold.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the juicy chicken."

"This American food, the fried chicken, is juicy and perfectly crispy."

"I thought their chicken sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Cookie’s Country Chicken is a 3-minute walk from the Amtrak station.

2

Expect to wait during busy hours, especially for dinner.

3

The total cost for a meal averages around $34 for multiple items.

03
Tat’s Deli image 1
Cheesesteak restaurant

Small space with cozy wood decor and Philadelphia Flyers memorabilia creates a lively, East Coast deli vibe. Crowded and loud during peak times, seating is cramped but tables turn over quickly. Counter service and a classic deli setup add to the bustling, neighborhood atmosphere.

Philly cheesesteaks stand out with their sweet peppers and onions and large portions. The Tatstrami offers a smoky, meaty flavor paired with coleslaw and dressing, alongside other sandwiches like Cajun turkey and Italian roast pork.

Pastrami sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and perfect preparation. The Tatstrami and Philly steak sandwiches earn strong praise for taste and quality, matching or exceeding New York standards.

People are saying

"I found the cheesesteak sandwiches here to be amazing and huge."

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"This American food is humongous and so good."

Good to know

1

Expect a long line during peak lunch hours, especially on weekdays.

2

The deli closes by mid-afternoon, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality and size of the sandwiches.

04
Mediterranean Mix image 1

Casual restaurant with an old school feel and cozy atmosphere hosts a mix of neighborhood regulars. Affordable prices and generous portions attract those seeking quick, satisfying meals. Open late on weekends, it offers authentic Mediterranean dishes with standout falafel and shawarma.

Beef hot dogs from the cart outside stand out with meat, onions, and cream cheese. The cheeseburger also impresses with its incredible flavor.

Falafel sandwich stands out as a consistent favorite and is highly recommended. Gyro sandwich offers a solid choice, while the Philly sandwich delivers good taste at a reasonable price.

People are saying

"The Mediterranean food, especially the falafel, is amazing."

"You have to try their American Food hot dogs; they're the best."

"You have to try the falafel sandwich; it's the star."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open late on weekends, making it a good late-night option.

2

To-go portions are generous and satisfying for the price.

3

Expect quick service; food typically comes out fast.

05
Underbelly image 1

Small underground bar with original architectural details like encaustic tiles and wainscoting creates an intimate, low-light setting. Live jazz and other performances on a small stage add a speakeasy vibe. Cocktails are carefully crafted, and the crowd enjoys delicious food like pizza and grilled cheese.

Grilled cheese sandwiches stand out with hot, buttery bread and options like ham. Pizzas also appear as a solid choice alongside the sandwiches.

Ham and cheese sandwiches stand out with simple, classic flavors. Grilled cheese sandwiches offer a warm, melty option with a crispy exterior.

People are saying

"The bartenders here are so friendly and nice."

"Their American Food, especially the grilled cheese, is really solid."

"You have to try their grilled cheese sandwich."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Underbelly hosts live music every Tuesday night starting at 8pm.

3

Expect a cover charge for special events like burlesque shows.

06
Collins Pub image 1
Bar & grill

Local pub with laid-back atmosphere and family-friendly vibe offers both indoor and outdoor seating near transit. Outstanding craft beers, including unique selections like Pliny the Elder, complement a menu featuring exceptional seafood and sandwiches. Artwork decor adds a touch of class without pretension.

Fried chicken sandwiches come with a terrific sauce and crispy fries. Reuben sandwiches stand out as among the best in the area. Crab cake BLT sandwiches add a unique twist to the menu.

Ahi Tuna and fried chicken sandwiches stand out with strong flavors and great sauces. The Reuben and crab cake BLT sandwiches also offer solid, satisfying options.

People are saying

"I had the best Ahi Tuna sandwich I've ever had."

"The pub has a good selection of local beers."

"The American Food here is great, and the service is even better."

Good to know

1

Collins Pub is a good spot for pre-gaming events at Lumen Field.

2

The menu at Collins Pub is limited during late hours.

3

Collins Pub can get extremely busy during Mariners games.

07
Cone & Steiner General image 1

General store offers an eclectic selection of local and artisanal products including food, drinks, gifts, and pantry staples. Atmosphere feels cozy and laid-back, with a candy counter and space to sit and watch the world go by. Regulars stop by throughout the day for snacks, coffee, or to top up supplies.

Menu includes hot dogs, nachos, and cold beer. Food options come alongside coffee, wines, and groceries.

Fresh sandwiches come with a pasta salad side and a drink option. Prices range around $15 to $16 for a combo. Ingredients are average but the quantity is generous.

People are saying

"I found awesome local brews and tasty sandwiches here."

"I grabbed a Seattle Dog and nachos for a quick bite."

"I bought a delicious sandwich here."

Good to know

1

The store offers a variety of groceries, snacks, and drinks.

2

Expect higher prices compared to other local grocery stores.

3

Grab-and-go options are available for quick meals.

08
Fat Shack image 1
Sandwich shop

Small sandwich shop with a laid back vibe and lively atmosphere featuring music and videos. Casual, diner-style interior feels larger than its size despite some worn furniture. Popular as a late night eatery with a unique, inventive menu and overstuffed sandwiches.

Hamburgers come out juicy and rich, with a nice messy texture. Mac and cheese appears both on sandwiches and as bites that taste like real cheese. The Philly cheesesteak offers solid flavor, and sides like onion rings and jalapeno poppers complement the meal well.

Sandwiches feature unique combinations like buffalo chicken strips with fried cheese and marinara sauce. They come in large portions and include colorful ingredients that blend well despite appearances.

People are saying

"The burgers here are juicy and packed with flavor."

"The late night food here is great."

"The American Food here, especially the cheeseburgers, is juicy and messy."

Good to know

1

Fat Shack is the only food place open past 12 am in the area.

2

The restaurant claims to be open until 3 am but only accepts online food deliveries after 2:30 am.

3

The Monday wing deal offers great value for customers.

Discover more

Pioneer Square, Seattle

Area guide
Loading Map...