Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Brookfield

Seafood and sandwich spots

Made for those who demand high-quality marine ingredients whether they are sitting down for a meal or grabbing a quick handheld bite.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01

Neighborhood bar with outdoor patio seating and multiple TVs creates a lively yet comfortable atmosphere. Space feels cramped inside but opens up outside for larger groups. Regulars bring a local vibe, while arcade games and slot machines add casual entertainment.

Fish fry stands out with consistently good quality, often changing usual orders. Shrimp and wings also show up as very good options.

Brisket and tenderloin steak sandwiches stand out for their tenderness and rich flavor. The Smoked Reuben and Italian Beef sandwiches also deliver strong, impressive taste.

People are saying

"I loved the nice outdoor seating area."

"You have to try the fish fry; it's fantastic."

"The tenderloin steak sandwich is so tender and juicy."

Good to know

1

They have a weekly Italian beef sandwich special; arrive early as it can sell out.

2

Happy hour features discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

Parking can be challenging; arrive early to secure a spot.

02
O'Sullivan's Public House image 1

Irish pub combines classic Wisconsin bar comfort with a quiet, spacious atmosphere and a cozy, second-home feeling. Walls display Packer memorabilia while sports games play on TV, creating a relaxed setting for conversations. Dining area resembles a basic supper club, catering to a calm, welcoming crowd.

Fish fry varies widely, with some servings featuring great fried fish and others showing undercooked batter and little fish. Breadings sometimes resemble a corn dog texture without the stick.

The Reuben sandwich stands out with its impressive size and satisfying flavor. The steak and mushroom sandwich appears as a notable special option alongside a larger selection of fish fry sandwiches.

People are saying

"The pub food here is delicious, especially the ribs."

"I enjoyed the reuben sandwich; it was great and impressive in size."

"The fish fry here is always great."

Good to know

1

O'Sullivan's offers a variety of Irish food and drink options.

2

Prices at O'Sullivan's are very affordable for both food and drinks.

3

The bar is fully stocked and tends to be busy during peak hours.

03
Schmidty's Bar and Grill image 1
American restaurant

Spacious layout with freshly remodeled interior and large new TVs creates a bright, welcoming setting. Energetic atmosphere thrives on live music weekends and a packed bar scene. Outdoor patio offers ample seating and a fireplace, enhancing the lively vibe.

Fish fry features crispy cod with Italian breading that is light and flavorful. Options include beer battered and baked fish served with veggies, all offered in generous portions.

Large portions stand out with sandwiches like the prime rib and Reuben, both noted for their size and flavor. The grilled chicken sandwich also offers a solid, tasty option.

People are saying

"The fish fry here is perfectly breaded and not too greasy."

"The fish fry here is perfectly breaded and not too greasy."

"The Reuben sandwich was outstanding, with lean corned beef."

Good to know

1

Comedy night happens every Sunday at 7pm, featuring local talent.

2

Thursdays feature free music bingo with a special on wings.

3

Live music is offered on Friday and Saturday nights, starting at 8pm.

04
Bobby's Bar Great Place Good Times image 1

Bar offers an upbeat atmosphere with friendly crowds and seasonal decorations. Multiple televisions cater to sports fans, and an upstairs patio provides comfortable space for gatherings. Energy is lively, with occasional live music and a warm, inviting vibe.

Friday fish fry features pan fried walleye and perch, both served with sweet potato fries. Staff provide excellent service during the fish fry.

Italian beef sandwich stands out with its rich sauce and large chunks of meat. Other options include a Reuben with corned beef and a Jersey breakfast sandwich.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic, especially the prime rib."

"I thought the fish fry was of a great standard."

"I can't wait to get back and try that Italian beef sandwich again."

Good to know

1

During local sporting events, Bobbyโ€™s Bar offers signed sports memorabilia giveaways.

2

Don't miss the chicken wing special on Mondays.

3

The prime rib special on Saturdays is a highlight.

05
Bar Louie - Brookfield image 1

Bar & grill offers large open seating with indoor and outdoor options, including seats by open garage doors. The atmosphere stays lively and fun, suited for gatherings and after-work drinks. Multiple TVs show games, and martinis stand out among the drink choices.

Fish dishes feature fresh salmon and shrimp with light seasoning. The fish sandwich cooks perfectly and pairs with chips. Some seafood plates come in small portions and cost over $20.

Spicy fried chicken sandwiches come loaded with jalapeรฑos, pepper jack cheese, bacon, and spicy aioli. Fried chicken sandwiches offer flavorful, well-cooked meat, and fish sandwiches are cooked perfectly.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and flavorful."

"I'll be dreaming about these flavorful chicken sandwiches."

"The seafood, like the salmon and shrimp, tasted fresh."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-off drinks and appetizers.

2

Parking can be difficult to find during happy hour.

3

Military discounts are available for cardholders.

06
Murf's Frozen Custard & Jumbo Burgers image 1

Small dining space combines with a lively, all-American atmosphere and friendly smiles. Burgers are large and flavorful, often topped with a fried egg, while frozen custard stands out as a local favorite. Patio seating offers a pleasant alternative to the cozy, sometimes crowded indoor area.

Fish options include a Friday fish fry and a fish sandwich with a small amount of tartar sauce. Fries served with the fish fry are limited in portion.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with tender, flavorful meat and a Cajun grilled option. Fish sandwiches like the Cod sandwich offer a delicious alternative.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"The Cajun grilled chicken sandwich was delicious."

"I thought the fish sandwich was great."

Good to know

1

Expect a 25-minute wait for pick-up orders of two burgers.

2

The restaurant can get very crowded, especially during busy hours.

3

Prices have increased, but the quality of food has declined.

07
Margaux Brasserie image 1
French restaurant

Bright, elegant space with gorgeous feminine decor and gold-plated utensils creates a memorable setting. Atmosphere feels creative and welcoming, with comfortable seating and a private dining area. Cocktails arrive in unique glassware, complementing exceptional French dishes like onion soup and pork chop.

Seafood shines in the bouillabaisse, packed with scallops, mussels, shrimp, cod, and lobster tail in a saffron broth. The snow crab shrimp cocktail also stands out with fresh, perfect flavors.

Croque Margaux stands out as a terrific sandwich. The French dip with frites earns a perfect rating. The steak sandwich is also a favorite, while the lobster salad sandwich is just okay.

People are saying

"The French food here, especially the steak frites, is the best I've ever had."

"The seafood bouillabaisse was full of lots of seafood in a delicious saffron broth."

"The roast beef sliders were awesome, ranked first."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 to 6 PM with a special menu.

2

Reservations are recommended for larger groups, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of vegan options on the menu.

08
The Elbow Room Brookfield image 1

Enclosed patio with outdoor heaters creates a cozy atmosphere that suits relaxed visits. Live music and multiple TVs add energy, especially during game days. Food highlights include smash burgers and unique sandwiches, while drink quality varies.

Fish fry stands out with excellent flavor and generous portions. Bang bang shrimp offers a generous serving size for a starter. Truffle fries and margaritas complement the seafood well.

Pastrami sandwich impresses with its rich flavor and pairs well with a side of chips dipped in au jus. BBQ brisket sandwich comes with truffle fries for a savory combo.

People are saying

"The food here is great and the drinks are too."

"The fish fry here is a large portion and delicious."

"The Birria Grilled Cheese sandwich was outstanding and incredible."

Good to know

1

Ladies night on Wednesdays features half-price bottles of wine.

2

Live music occurs on Wednesdays and Sundays from 1-4pm, except during football games.

3

Karaoke night starts at 10pm on Thursdays with a two-drink minimum.

Discover more

Brookfield, Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...