Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Bay View

Cocktails

Made for those who appreciate the precision of a well-mixed drink and prioritize craft over volume.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Twisted Path Distillery image 1
Twisted Path Distillery image 2
Twisted Path Distillery image 3
View all

Open garage-style doors and abundant plants create a fresh, outdoor feel with a cozy, hidden-gem vibe. Cocktails focus on handcrafted quality with bold flavors, served in a laid-back atmosphere that suits quiet dates or small celebrations.

An excellent cocktail bar experience awaits with a focus on quality over quantity. Seating at the bar offers a direct view of the craft and atmosphere.

Cocktails here are well crafted with unique flavors like Chinese rhubarb root soda and turmeric-ginger bitters. The bar offers inspired drinks meant to be slowly savored, backed by attentive, detail-oriented staff who focus on the craft.

People are saying

"The bartenders here are true artists, crafting amazing cocktails."

"The spirits and cocktails here are truly unique and expertly made."

"The cocktails here are creative, well-balanced, and expertly made."

Good to know

1

Tours are available on weekends and require advance booking.

2

Visitors can purchase bottles to take home after tasting.

3

Expect a unique cocktail menu that changes seasonally.

02
17th Ward | Authentic Spirits image 1

Modern bar with an industrial edge combines warm lighting and local artwork for a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Craft cocktails stand out with balanced flavors and elegant presentation. Outdoor seating and a breezy patio add relaxed options to the experience.

A modern bar with seasonal cocktails and a breezy patio that opens to a lounge area. It celebrates local community and offers a genuine personality in its atmosphere.

Craft cocktails show incredible attention to detail with each drink being unique and beautifully crafted. The menu features a seasonal and intriguing list including a true Wisconsin Old Fashioned, espresso martini, and tequila/mezcal options.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are original and delicious."

"The vibe here is so cool and effortlessly chill."

"The drinks here are delicious and beautifully crafted."

Good to know

1

Wednesday nights feature open mic nights with Brew City Band.

2

Happy hour runs on weekdays, offering discounted drinks.

3

The venue is suitable for private events like baby showers and parties.

03
The Mothership image 1
Cocktail bar

Cocktail bar with dive vibes and colorfully rustic decor creates a funky, controlled-sort-of-rowdy atmosphere. Outdoor space includes a heated patio with food trucks nearby, adding to the lively setting. Sound system delivers exceptional music quality, enhancing the energetic and welcoming mood.

Sound quality stands out as the best at a bar. The bar offers a welcoming dive vibe with quirky cocktail options and friendly staff.

Cocktails here stand out for their incredible variety and well thought out recipes. The Martinez cocktail is a highlight, and staff help tailor drinks to your flavor preferences.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are top-notch and well thought out."

"The outdoor seating has an energetic and welcoming vibe."

"I loved this bar; it's a neighborhood gem."

Good to know

1

Maya Ophelia’s food truck is available on the patio, offering delicious food.

2

The Mothership is dog friendly on the patio.

3

The back patio lacks lighting, making it a safety hazard at night.

04
At Random image 1
Cocktail bar

Vintage cocktail lounge channels a 50s ice cream parlor with speakeasy lighting and retro vibes. Red lighting creates a romantic, cozy atmosphere indoors, while an open patio with heated greenhouses offers lively outdoor seating. Boozy milkshakes and ice cream cocktails stand out as signature drinks.

Cocktails show quality and care in every detail. The ambiance with its decor, booths, and lighting creates a vibe that feels like stepping back in time.

Cocktails here stand out for their amazing quality and consistent fantastic taste. Vegan options include ice cream cocktails with vegan whipped cream and cookies.

People are saying

"These ice cream drinks are so delicious and tasty."

"The dim, romantic lighting makes it a great spot for date nights."

"You have to try the ice cream drinks; they're so delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 5 PM to 7 PM with $8 ice cream drinks.

2

Happy hour deals do not apply to the Enchanted forest patio.

3

Reservations are not accepted for indoor seating; arrive early to secure a spot.

05
Lost Whale image 1
Cocktail bar

Small, cozy cocktail bar with a funky atmosphere and intimate vibe. Back patio features gas-lit bonfires and comfortable seating, creating a relaxed space for conversation. Regular themed pop-up bars and classic movies add unique character to the setting.

A cozy, intimate cocktail bar with a backyard patio that feels comfortable year-round. The vibe blends a cocktail lounge with a casual spot, making it great for both drinks and small events.

Expertly made cocktails offer fabulous, beautiful craft flavors with a focus on custom, bespoke creations tailored to customer needs. Bartenders stay friendly and prices remain a good deal throughout.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are delicious and pack a punch."

"I loved the cozy patio and bonfires in this outdoor space."

"The bartenders here are so friendly and fun to hang out with."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4 to 6 pm with half off specialty cocktails and draft beer.

2

Select drinks are $5.50 during happy hour from the house list.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere during happy hour, especially on weekends.

06
Burnhearts image 1

Cozy bar with dim, warm lighting and a welcoming atmosphere offers rotating craft cocktails and a pool table. Music leans toward old school hip-hop, creating a chill vibe where people connect easily. Outdoor seating adds a relaxed touch to this neighborhood staple.

Offers a world-class beer selection with a strong Irish pub vibe and a punk bar atmosphere. Includes unique drinks like Fernet, adding to its distinct character.

Rotating cocktails show a tiki influence with complex and balanced flavors. The menu includes an Old Fashioned, a cocktail on tap called Hop Wop, and the Funky Goose, all crafted by skilled bartenders.

People are saying

"This bar has a spectacular rotating cocktail list and great beer."

"I found the beer selection here to be world-class."

"The rotating cocktails here are spectacular and balanced."

Good to know

1

Burnhearts offers a rotating tap and craft cocktail list with plenty of options.

2

They only serve bags of chips or pretzels as food options.

3

There are no TVs in the bar, creating a relaxed atmosphere.

07
Sugar Maple image 1
Cocktail bar

Cocktail bar offers spacious outdoor patio with fire pits and retro '70s decor inside. Atmosphere stays chill and intimate, with live local music and board games adding to the vibe. Lighting is dim, and a large projector screen runs TV shows continuously.

Craft beer selection stands out with a large variety. Upholstered bar stools add a unique touch. The vibe feels immaculate and welcoming.

Cocktails here stand out for their well-balanced flavors and unique recipes. The menu includes a signature cocktail and even THC-infused options.

People are saying

"They have an awesome selection of craft beers."

"This bar has an awesome selection of craft beers."

"I found the cocktails here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Sugar Maple hosts pop-up events and live music regularly, creating a lively atmosphere.

2

Expect a variety of themed pop-ups, including art fairs and music shows.

3

Street parking is available and free after 6pm, making it easy to visit.

08
Voyager image 1
Wine bar

Large windows open to a lively community scene, creating a modern European vibe with a cozy, chill atmosphere. The space welcomes a young local crowd and offers interesting wines alongside simple snacks, fostering a relaxed and unpretentious experience.

A laid back spot with a strong focus on wine and a great cocktail menu. The bar offers some unique beers and features a knowledgeable, friendly bartender.

Strong and delicious cocktails feature fresh basil and Amaro for unique flavors. The menu offers a wide selection alongside wines and craft beers.

People are saying

"They have a great, frequently rotating wine selection."

"The bartenders here are so friendly and knowledgeable about cocktails."

"This wine bar has a great selection of interesting wines."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deals are available, offering great discounts on drinks.

2

Voyager serves only light snacks like olives, not a full food menu.

3

Prices for wine are reasonable, making it accessible for casual visits.

09
The Wiggle Room image 1

Bar with a vinyl-only soundtrack and a retro neon lounge creates a lively yet sometimes deafening atmosphere. DJs spin obscure, instrumental tracks on turntables, attracting a crowd that enjoys music over upbeat socializing. Spacious lounge and bar areas encourage gathering and chatting, with a unique vibe distinct from typical scenes.

A vinyl bar with a retro neon lounge vibe offers a spacious, comfortable spot for friends to gather. Batched cocktails come at premium prices in a swank HiFi setting that feels welcoming and cool.

Craft cocktails come in premium-priced batches and on draft, served quickly and tasting delicious. The cocktail list features a few interesting options alongside consistently great drinks.

People are saying

"This bar's DJ spins great music on vinyl."

"I found the vibe and low-light atmosphere really cool."

"The cocktails here were quick and delicious."

Good to know

1

The venue offers lots of non-alcoholic options.

2

Expect a diverse mix of people during events.

3

Soul Night is a popular event for dancing.

10
Cheba Hut "Toasted" Subs image 1

Sandwich shop with a weed-themed decor and an unexpected full bar creates a laid-back, stoner atmosphere. Music plays softly, and seating by the windows offers a view of the street. The vibe mixes casual dining with a unique, fun environment.

A full bar with a 420 theme creates a unique vibe at this sandwich shop. Skilled bartenders offer knowledgeable cocktail service and friendly conversation while you wait or eat at the bar.

Booker crafts impeccable cocktails with deep knowledge of drinks and bar procedures. The menu includes interesting cocktails and kolaid to quench cotton mouth.

People are saying

"I always went here whenever I craved a really good sandwich."

"The bartenders here are so knowledgeable and friendly."

"The bartender's knowledge of cocktails was superb."

Good to know

1

Expect food preparation to take about 5 to 7 minutes.

2

The restaurant is open late, perfect for nighttime cravings.

3

They do not accept gift cards for payment.

Discover more

Bay View, Milwaukee

Area guide
Loading Map...