Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Sandwich spots in Bay View

A sandwich built with enough substance to last through the afternoon, rather than just a pile of bread and air.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Pizza restaurant

Vintage tavern offers thin crust pizzas with fresh toppings and a cash-only policy. Sandwiches come in huge portions, with the chicken sandwich being awesome. Casual vibe encourages real talks, making it a great spot for food and friends.

Sandwiches come in huge portions that often fill you up with half left to take home. The chicken sandwich stands out as awesome, and the Cheese Steak Sandwiches get strong mentions too.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic and highly recommended."

"I found the sandwiches to be huge and amazing."

"I thought the thin crust pizza here was the best."

Good to know

1

Vinchi's Pizza only accepts cash.

2

The restaurant's hours are limited from 5 PM to 9 PM, Wednesday through Sunday.

3

The medium pizza costs $32.

02
SmallPie image 1

Small cafe offers covered patio with plants for sale and a quiet outdoor area welcoming dogs. Sandwiches shine with cheddar and apple combos and a flavorful bacon biscuit. Relaxed vibe suits casual stops perfectly.

Sandwiches feature interesting combinations like cheddar and apple or blueberry turkey. Options include breakfast sandwiches and a bacon biscuit sandwich that stands out for flavor.

People are saying

"I found the pies here to be so delicious."

"I loved the blueberry turkey sandwich; it became my favorite."

"The outdoor seating area is beautiful and serene."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging in the area, so plan accordingly.

2

Hand pies are priced at $10 each, which may be considered expensive.

3

SmallPie is dog-friendly, allowing pets on the outdoor seating.

03
Street Munchies Food Truck | Burgers, Fried Chicken, Loaded Fries & More image 1

Food truck offers well-seasoned burgers and fried chicken at good prices, drawing a relaxed crowd. Chicken sandwich is especially flavorful and memorable. Loud generator noise breaks the park's calm but families enjoy the inviting, easygoing vibe.

Chicken sandwich stands out for its flavor and leaves a strong impression. Sandwiches do not come with fries on the side.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were delicious and cooked to perfection."

"The food trucks here have delicious, perfectly seasoned burgers and fries."

"I seriously couldn't stop thinking about the chicken sandwich."

Good to know

1

The food truck serves burgers, fried chicken, loaded fries, and more.

2

The meal cost $12.

3

Keep an eye out for the green trailer!

04
Crafty Cow - Burgers & Fried Chicken image 1

Vintage building offers a lively atmosphere with nostalgic decor and outdoor seating. Chicken sandwiches stand out with large size and amazing sauce, including a spicy fish and Buffalo chicken option. Music and energetic crowd make it feel homey and comfortable.

Chicken sandwiches feature a large size and an amazing coating with an incredible sauce. Options include a spicy fish sandwich that lives up to its name and a Buffalo chicken sandwich.

People are saying

"I thought the burger was tender, juicy, and well-balanced."

"These Wisconsin cheese curds are some of the best I've ever had."

"I thought the chicken sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 2-5 pm with $3 drafts.

2

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday at 8 pm with a $5 entry fee.

3

Expect a busy atmosphere during Saturday events; arrive early.

05
Casera Cafe & Bakery image 1

Bright, spacious cafe offers a calm vibe with natural lighting and indoor-outdoor seating. Sandwiches shine with supple yet crisp bread, featuring options like Melt Beef and Chicken BLT. Friendly staff and open space make it great for work or socializing.

Baked bread comes out supple yet crisp, making sandwiches stand out. Options include the Melt Beef, Chicken BLT, and Millie Cheesesteak**, all well made with attentive service checking in on orders.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the coffee; it was perfectly made."

"There's plenty of outdoor seating available."

"The sandwiches here are excellent and mouth-watering."

Good to know

1

The food side of the kitchen closes an hour before the cafe closes.

2

They provide super strong WiFi, making it a good spot for work.

3

Expect a long line on weekends, especially around noon.

06
Colectivo Coffee Bay View image 1

Spacious cafe offers natural light and both indoor and outdoor seating. Garden Goddess Sandwich shines with fresh flavors despite slow prep. Atmosphere shifts from cozy to lively with espresso machine sounds, perfect for casual meetings and people watching.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with good flavor, especially the Garden Goddess Sandwich. Sandwiches and wraps come wrapped in paper that sometimes gets inside the food. Preparation can take around 25 minutes.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was great and fresh."

"The outdoor space here has so much seating, it's great."

"I thought the breakfast sandwiches were standout items."

Good to know

1

Expect limited parking as the lot is often full, especially during peak hours.

2

The location is accessible via public transport on the Green/15/53 buses.

3

There is ample outdoor seating available for customers.

07
Gyros Stand image 1
Greek restaurant

Old, run-down space with a greasy spoon diner vibe offers generous gyros and a burrito sandwich packed with seasoned beef, melty cheese, and fresh tomatoes. Interior feels filthy but sets a chill atmosphere. Prices are high for the quality and condition.

The burrito sandwich features seasoned beef, melty cheese, and fresh tomatoes that stand out. It includes fluffy rice, creamy guacamole, zesty salsa, and a warm, pliable tortilla wrapped tight with no leaks.

People are saying

"This burrito sandwich is basically everything a burrito sandwich should be."

"I thought the gyros here were the best I ever had."

"I found the food here to be delicious and great."

Good to know

1

Credit card payments are currently unavailable due to a broken machine.

2

The establishment offers a secret menu item that is not widely advertised.

3

The restaurant lacks air conditioning, making it uncomfortable during hot days.

08
Rollup image 1
Southeast Asian restaurant

Southeast Asian spot shines with custom wraps and fresh ingredients in its banh mi. Bright, zen space invites diners seeking healthy options. Signature dishes like giant spring rolls and rich oxtail pho stand out despite some sandwich prep quirks.

Banh mi sandwich features fresh ingredients and bold flavors. Staff show some struggle with folding sandwiches and portioning noodles.

People are saying

"The Vietnamese food, especially the oxtail pho, is rich, flavorful, and deeply satisfying."

"The takeout spring rolls and sauces were packaged perfectly."

"This Bahn Mi sandwich is the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Rollup offers many vegan and gluten-free options that are clearly labeled.

2

Expect longer wait times compared to typical fast food places.

3

Beef and shrimp cost an extra $4 per bowl each.

09
South Shore Farmersโ€™ Market image 1

Market sits by a serene lake with downtown views, blending live music and a kid-friendly playground. Food trucks serve unique sandwiches like the raclette with pickles and the Ultimate Breakfast on ciabatta. Visitors enjoy a lively, dog-friendly beer garden atmosphere.

Food truck style vendors offer a wide range of sandwiches including a raclette sandwich with green onions and baby pickles, a Swiss sandwich, and the Ultimate Breakfast Sandwich on Rocket Baby's ciabatta with olive tapenade.

People are saying

"I loved the market's variety of food vendors and fresh produce."

"It's a fun little seasonal market with beautiful scenery."

"I tried a Swiss sandwich and some Serbian pastries."

Good to know

1

Street parking can be hard to find during peak hours of the market.

2

Most vendors accepted cash and card; some only accept cash and tokens.

3

There is a restroom right across the street from the market.

10
Palomino Bar image 1

Long bar offers a local vibe with a quiet crowd. Vegan hot chicken sandwiches and brisket burger shine alongside pimento fries. Strong bourbon selection pairs well with the excellent fish fry in a fun, relaxed space.

Vegan hot chicken sandwiches stand out as a delicious option. The menu features a brisket burger and a hot fried chicken sandwich alongside sides like tots and pimento fries.

People are saying

"The fish fry here is delicious and plentiful."

"I found the homemade oatmeal cream pie to be one of the best."

"I thought the vegan hot chicken sandwich was fantastic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the bar gets busy, especially on weekends.

2

The menu has limited options with only four entrees available.

3

The kitchen closes early, so arrive before the last orders are taken.

11
Cheba Hut "Toasted" Subs image 1

Sandwiches shine with fresh ingredients and unique options like the G-13 sandwich. A full bar adds a fun twist to the laid-back, weed-themed decor. Soft music and street views create a chill, casual vibe.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients and a wide variety of options. The G-13 sandwich and French onion soup stand out as notable choices.

People are saying

"I always went here whenever I craved a really good sandwich."

"The bartenders here are so knowledgeable and friendly."

"Their homemade sauces are divine and unique."

Good to know

1

Expect food preparation to take about 5 to 7 minutes.

2

The restaurant is open late, perfect for nighttime cravings.

3

They do not accept gift cards for payment.

12
G. Groppi Food Market image 1
Italian grocery store

Huge market blends old-world charm with a classic grocery feel. Sandwiches are huge and flavorful, like the Santa Fe with giardiniera. A small bar and bakery create a unique atmosphere where locals gather and enjoy outdoor seating.

Sandwiches come in huge sizes, with clear options between half and whole portions. The Santa Fe with giardinera and panini sandwiches offer hot deli flavors that stand out.

People are saying

"The bar inside this grocery store feels like stepping into a bygone era."

"I found this market to be a charming, historic gem."

"I enjoyed the huge, delicious sandwiches here."

Good to know

1

Meatball Mondays offer a unique start to the week with special deals.

2

G. Groppi Food Market features a butcher, cocktail bar, and deli all in one.

3

Daily deliveries of Peter Sciortino Bakery breads ensure fresh options.

13
Gather Bakehouse | Bay View image 1

Bakery offers high-quality croissants and vegan sandwiches with local sides like tots. Space feels plain and dark but suits an upper-class clientele seeking calm energy and fancy cakes. Hot ham rolls appear on Sundays for a tasty, quick lunch.

Offers vegan sandwiches and hot ham rolls on Sundays. Sandwiches include options like the Canfora Chop and come with locally made sides such as tots and lumpia. To-go sandwiches provide a quick and tasty lunch option.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts here were the best in town."

"I loved the vegan desserts, especially the glitter on the lemon bar."

"The vegan hot ham sandwich reminded me of childhood."

Good to know

1

The ham and rolls are only available on Sundays.

2

Parking may be tricky during events like the Milwaukee Marathon.

3

Vegan items, including sandwiches, are available during Vegan Dining Week.

14
Hot Head Fried Chicken by Crafty Cow image 1

Space has a comfy bar and a cute waiting area. Chicken sandwiches come with cornbread bun and waffle fries or chips. Juicy, well-brined chicken has a good crunch and seasoning. Beer options are cold and fresh, fitting the casual vibe.

Chicken sandwiches come with waffle fries or homemade chips and a cornbread bun. Orders sometimes have mistakes despite the price.

People are saying

"The chicken sandwich is super juicy with a great crunch."

"I thought the food here was excellent."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great deals on food and drinks.

2

Wednesday night deals provide meals for two at $22.

3

The serving sizes are large, perfect for sharing.

Discover more

Bay View, Milwaukee

Area guide
Loading Map...