Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in the US

Coconut cream pie spots

Nothing settles the mind quite like a slice of cake and a piece of coconut cream pie.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated July 2026
01
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market image 1
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market image 2
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market image 3
View all

Small market with a cozy, charming atmosphere and a fresh farm food vibe. Shelves are beautifully organized and spotless, offering a unique selection of prepared meals and desserts. Quiet and inviting, it feels like a hidden gem with standout pot pies and comfort foods.

Carrot cake stands out with its no raisins and perfect frosting. Chocolate cake also tastes delicious.

Rich coconut cream fills the pie with a smooth texture. The crust holds up well, making it a satisfying sweet treat to enjoy.

People are saying

"I loved their pot pies; the chicken pot pie was delicious."

"The spinach, feta, and tomato quiche was consistently good and fresh."

"I thought the carrot cake was delicious and the frosting was perfect."

Good to know

1

The market offers a variety of prepared foods, including pot pies, salads, and desserts.

2

Prices for prepared meals are reasonable, making it a good option for takeout.

3

The store has a points program that rewards customers with discounts on future purchases.

02
Joey Biscotti image 1

Sugar scent fills the air with hints of fresh lemon and blueberry. Baked goods include cookies, scones, and cakes known for balanced flavors and freshness. Prices remain affordable despite high quality, attracting those willing to travel for standout desserts.

German Chocolate Cake stands out with its rich flavor and moist texture. Large crumb cake slices offer a dense, satisfying bite, while options like cranberry walnut cake and lemon bars add variety.

Coconut cream pie features a shortbread crust and sells for $5.00 per piece on weekends. It stands out as a top choice with a rich, creamy texture.

People are saying

"The bakery's desserts are so fresh tasting and fantastic."

"The salted caramel brownie was to die for."

"The German Chocolate Cake here is amazing and moist."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of fresh baked goods made on-site.

2

Prices for baked goods are very reasonable, making it affordable for most visitors.

3

Desserts are made daily, ensuring freshness and quality.

03
Sister Honey's image 1

Scratch bakery with an adorable shop and open display case lets customers watch baking in action. Atmosphere feels mom-and-pop and intimate, with award-winning cakes like Carrot Cake and Hummingbird Cake that sell out quickly. Flavors change daily, and full pies require advance orders.

Pound cakes like rum and brown sugar stand out for their moist texture and rich flavor. The Hummingbird Cake and pistachio cake offer a perfect balance of sweetness and moistness that impresses consistently.

Coconut cream pie stands out as a favorite with a rich, creamy texture and a flavor that many find unforgettable. It often gets called the star of the show and is praised for being exceptionally delicious.

People are saying

"You have to try the amazing cupcakes and cakes at this bakery."

"This pistachio cake is amazing; I ate it for breakfast, lunch, and dinner."

"I thought the Coconut Cream Pie was to die for."

Good to know

1

Full pies are available only by order.

2

You need to plan a few weeks in advance to order a cake.

3

The cakes sell out quickly, so arrive early.

04
The Neighborly image 1
Restaurant

Large outdoor patio offers shaded, comfortable seating with heaters for cooler times. Interior features spacious, tasteful design with a huge bar and two levels including an epic center bar upstairs. Atmosphere stays warm and lively at a volume that allows easy conversation, making it a popular local meet-up spot.

Butter cake stands out with its rich flavor and often comes as a complimentary treat. Desserts like brown butter yellow cake with ice cream and key lime pie also appear alongside fresh whipped cream.

Great texture and consistency define the coconut cream pie. It comes in a slightly larger-than-slice sliver and is served in a cardboard to-go box.

People are saying

"The Happy Hour wings were crispy and flavorful with sauce on the side."

"I thought the butter cake was a must-have."

"I found the Coconut Cream Pie to be excellent and to die for."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all night on Mondays with $6 mini tinas.

2

The restaurant hosts a special restaurant week menu from May 17 to 26, 2024.

3

Private events can be hosted upstairs, offering a unique space.

05
Al Biernat's Oak Lawn image 1

Elegant steakhouse with old world charm and a lively bar scene. Atmosphere feels crowded and loud, with some seating areas less refined. Features include complimentary valet parking and outdoor seating with heaters.

White chocolate raspberry cake stands out as a rich and flavorful choice. The coconut cake offers a sweet finish to the meal.

Light and delectable, the coconut cream pie avoids a fake coconut taste and stays balanced without being too sweet. It stands out as a favorite dessert with a smooth, authentic flavor.

People are saying

"Nick brought out all the steak sauces, including black peppercorn."

"The filet mignon was cooked to perfection and incredibly tender."

"The Coconut Cream Pie here is amazing, not too sweet."

Good to know

1

If it's your birthday, you get a free dessert with candles.

2

Brunch is available on Sundays at 12:30pm.

3

Expect to spend at least $100 per person for a full meal.

06
Nation's Giant Hamburgers & Great Pies image 1

Spacious interior with comfortable booths and fresh flowers on clean tables creates a calm, homey atmosphere filled with great music. Friendly environment offers free samples of freshly baked pies and cheesecakes, adding a welcoming touch. The vibe recalls an early 1900s diner with a modern, well-kept look.

Creamy texture and balanced sweetness define the coconut cream pie here. Portions include a mini size option, delivering a dreamy dessert experience.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of great flavor."

"I loved the cheesecake, especially the strawberry."

"I thought the Coconut Cream Pie was creamy, dreamy, and sweet."

Good to know

1

They have a promotion offering free pie after 9 PM.

2

Parking can be difficult to access and not very accessible.

3

Free samples of pies are available to try before purchasing.

07
Salty Lunch Lady's Little Luncheonette image 1

Restaurant offers a vintage decor with teal paint, tile, and unique hanging lamps from former Yugoslavia. Atmosphere feels welcoming and kid-friendly with a self-service setup and seating inside and outside. Sandwiches and desserts are thoughtfully crafted and highly praised for flavor and quality.

Rotating cakes and pies offer a variety of flavors. Options include tres leches, coconut cake, and a yuzu and strawberry cake with lemon curd in the middle.

Rich, creamy texture defines the Coconut Cream Pie here. A Pandan Coconut Cream Pie is also available for preorder online.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best in town."

"The orange cake slice was super delicious and fresh."

"I thought the Coconut Cream Pie was the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-30 minute wait for orders during peak hours.

2

Customers should arrive early as supplies run out quickly.

3

Sandwiches are priced at $15, and portions are small.

08
Gregory's Gourmet Desserts image 1

Small shop offers wall-to-wall sweets with takeout only service. Atmosphere feels like a fun hole-in-the-wall with a strong dessert aroma. Desserts, especially cheesecakes and pies, receive consistent praise for quality.

Carrot cake stands out with a rich, delicious flavor. Chocolate cake also impresses with its moist texture. Other options include lemon bars, pound cake, and an 8-up cake similar to 7-up cake.

Generous portions highlight the coconut cream pie, making it a standout dessert. It pairs well with other sweets like the pecan caramel cheesecake.

People are saying

"The cakes here are exceptional, especially the sweet potato."

"The peach cobbler is great, but a little too sweet."

"I was so excited to try the Coconut Cream Pie!"

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for holiday specials at Gregory's Gourmet Desserts.

2

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Street parking can be difficult; there's a garage across the street.

09
Jonathan's The Rub image 1
American restaurant

Mid Century Modern design shapes a clean, beautiful space with spacious patio and ample bar seating. Atmosphere blends upscale yet approachable vibe with warm, welcoming lighting and occasional live music. Guests enjoy a quiet outdoor area ideal for dates or business meetings.

Rich chocolate cake stands out with its delicious flavor and moist texture.

Rich texture and perfect taste define the coconut cream pie here. It delivers a satisfying, creamy finish that stands out as a memorable dessert.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the fried chicken, is perfection."

"The dinner spots here offer flawless service and attention to detail."

"You have to try the apple crumble cheesecake."

Good to know

1

Happy hour is available on the patio or in the bar only.

2

Brunch happy hour runs until 6pm on Saturdays.

3

Thursday Night Steak Night features special menu items.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...