Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of US

Key lime pie and coconut cream pie

Made for those who refuse to settle for just one slice and insist on comparing the citrus tang of key lime pie with the tropical richness of coconut cream pie.

Based on 751 Opinions
+748
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Pied Piper Bakery image 1
Pied Piper Bakery image 2
Pied Piper Bakery image 3
View all

Small shop with pink, lovely decor and a warm, welcoming atmosphere creates a calm, friendly vibe. Bright, clean space features a fun girly style and a cozy pink sofa. Pies stand out for their variety and quality, including gluten-free and no added sugar options.

Smooth and creamy filling balances tangy lime and sweetness perfectly. The graham cracker crust adds a tasty crunch, topped with homemade whipped cream for a refreshing bite.

Coconut cream pie here is exceptionally delicious with a stunning presentation. It tastes rich and creamy, often described as pie heaven.

People are saying

"I found the pies here to be amazing and delicious."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was absolutely delicious and refreshing."

"I thought the Coconut Cream Pie was divine."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers both slices and whole pies with a variety of flavors.

2

They had slices ready to go and whole pies available.

3

The prices are very reasonable for the quality offered.

02
Winter Park Pie Company image 1

Pie shop offers thoughtfully crafted pies with beautiful presentation and light, flaky crusts. Atmosphere feels family owned and locally made, with easy ordering and careful packaging for convenience. Pies stand out for exceptional flavor and texture, often considered the best by those who try them.

Key lime pie offers a fresh, sweet, and tart flavor with an old fashioned homemade taste. The crust tends to be on the thinner side, but the pie remains delicious and satisfying.

Topping, filling, and crust all come together perfectly in the coconut cream pie. It consistently pleases families and works well for celebrations.

People are saying

"I loved their cherry pie; it reminded me of grandma's baking."

"I found the Key Lime Pie to be phenomenal, sweet, and tart."

"I thought the Coconut Cream Pie tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

Ordering from Winter Park Pie Company is easy and communication is seamless.

2

Delivery is very convenient and can be arranged for special occasions.

3

Expect to pay a premium price for high-quality, homemade pies.

03
Sister Honey's image 1

Scratch bakery with an adorable shop and open display case lets customers watch baking in action. Atmosphere feels mom-and-pop and intimate, with award-winning cakes like Carrot Cake and Hummingbird Cake that sell out quickly. Flavors change daily, and full pies require advance orders.

Key lime pie stands out as a delicious and amazing dessert here. It often tops the list alongside other favorites like coconut cream pie and hummingbird cake.

Coconut cream pie stands out as a favorite with a rich, creamy texture and a flavor that many find unforgettable. It often gets called the star of the show and is praised for being exceptionally delicious.

People are saying

"You have to try the amazing cupcakes and cakes at this bakery."

"I heard the Key Lime Pie here was amazing."

"I thought the Coconut Cream Pie was to die for."

Good to know

1

Full pies are available only by order.

2

You need to plan a few weeks in advance to order a cake.

3

The cakes sell out quickly, so arrive early.

04
The Neighborly image 1
Restaurant

Large outdoor patio offers shaded, comfortable seating with heaters for cooler times. Interior features spacious, tasteful design with a huge bar and two levels including an epic center bar upstairs. Atmosphere stays warm and lively at a volume that allows easy conversation, making it a popular local meet-up spot.

Key lime pie offers a fresh, tangy flavor that closely resembles the taste from Miami, Florida. It stands out as a notably good dessert option, often enjoyed as a satisfying finish to a meal.

Great texture and consistency define the coconut cream pie. It comes in a slightly larger-than-slice sliver and is served in a cardboard to-go box.

People are saying

"The Happy Hour wings were crispy and flavorful with sauce on the side."

"I found the Coconut Cream Pie to be excellent and to die for."

"I thought the key lime pie was one of the best."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all night on Mondays with $6 mini tinas.

2

The restaurant hosts a special restaurant week menu from May 17 to 26, 2024.

3

Private events can be hosted upstairs, offering a unique space.

05
Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole image 1

Small pie shop with a quaint, 40-year-old small town interior and a casual, hole-in-the-wall vibe. The air fills with a heavenly baked pie smell that welcomes visitors. A cozy coffee shop sits beside the pie area, creating a calm and inviting atmosphere.

Quality key lime pie comes with a tasty crust that holds the filling well. It serves as a solid example of classic pie perfection in a tin.

Coconut cream pie stands out for its rich, creamy texture and fresh coconut flavor. It matches the quality of pies made by skilled pastry cooks and is a favorite choice here.

People are saying

"I thought their homemade style pies were some of the best I'd ever tasted."

"I thought the Coconut Cream Pie was the best I ever had."

"I think this key lime pie is the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Pies are available for $9 each, despite some signs indicating $8.

2

You need to place orders in October for Thanksgiving and Christmas pies.

3

The pie truck sells only one-person pies.

06
Nation's Giant Hamburgers & Great Pies image 1

Spacious interior with comfortable booths and fresh flowers on clean tables creates a calm, homey atmosphere filled with great music. Friendly environment offers free samples of freshly baked pies and cheesecakes, adding a welcoming touch. The vibe recalls an early 1900s diner with a modern, well-kept look.

Key lime pie stands out as excellent and delicious with a flavor that many find to die for.

Creamy texture and balanced sweetness define the coconut cream pie here. Portions include a mini size option, delivering a dreamy dessert experience.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of great flavor."

"I thought the Coconut Cream Pie was creamy, dreamy, and sweet."

"I found the Key Lime Pie to be excellent and delicious."

Good to know

1

They have a promotion offering free pie after 9 PM.

2

Parking can be difficult to access and not very accessible.

3

Free samples of pies are available to try before purchasing.

07
Gregory's Gourmet Desserts image 1

Small shop offers wall-to-wall sweets with takeout only service. Atmosphere feels like a fun hole-in-the-wall with a strong dessert aroma. Desserts, especially cheesecakes and pies, receive consistent praise for quality.

Bright, tangy flavor and a crisp, well-made crust define the Key Lime Pie here. It delivers a perfect balance of sweet and tart with a smooth, creamy texture.

Generous portions highlight the coconut cream pie, making it a standout dessert. It pairs well with other sweets like the pecan caramel cheesecake.

People are saying

"The cakes here are exceptional, especially the sweet potato."

"The Key Lime Pie here is so delicious and tart."

"I was so excited to try the Coconut Cream Pie!"

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for holiday specials at Gregory's Gourmet Desserts.

2

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Street parking can be difficult; there's a garage across the street.

08
Piefalootin image 1
Pie shop

Pie shop with vintage decor and mismatched China creates a homey, comforting atmosphere. Quiet and inviting space features antique tools and repurposed furniture that add unique charm. Regulars enjoy tasting flights and homemade ice cream in a setting that feels like a grandmother's kitchen.

Key lime pie stands out with a great tartness and solid flavor. It comes without whipped cream, which some might notice.

Coconut cream pie here melts in your mouth with a rich, creamy texture. The chocolate coconut cream pie offers a unique twist alongside classic versions like The Zillionaire.

People are saying

"The pies here are deep, delicious, and decadent."

"I found the Coconut Cream Pie to be extremely delicious."

"I found the Key Lime Pie here to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Parking has expanded to make it easier to get in and out.

2

They can make a custom pie if given a heads up.

3

The package includes an ice pack to keep the pie cold during transport.

09
Miramonte image 1
Restaurant

Open dining room with a long bar creates a lively, sometimes loud atmosphere with dimmed lights for a cozy, moody vibe. Thoughtful interior design includes a mountain view through window walls and a quaint table area near the bar. Drinks like craft cocktails and sharp steak knives add to the upscale, detailed experience.

Generous portions of key lime pie stand out with a delicious flavor. It pairs well with espresso martinis and serves as a showstopper dessert.

Rich coconut flavor and creamy texture define the coconut cream pie. It serves as a perfect ending to the meal.

People are saying

"The American Food here is outstanding, with knowledgeable service."

"The seafood here is outstanding, with attentive and knowledgeable service."

"The Coconut Cream Pie was fantastic and a perfect ending."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekend evenings.

2

The restaurant is located next to Whole Foods with ample parking available.

3

Expect food to arrive within 7 to 10 minutes after ordering.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...