Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in the US

Consignment watch stores

Made for those who hunt for pre-owned watches that carry a history and a price point only found in the consignment market.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Time Lords - Watch Dealers image 1
Time Lords - Watch Dealers image 2
Time Lords - Watch Dealers image 3
View all

Storefront showcases luxury watches with top notch quality and incredible pricing. Atmosphere feels well done and professional, supporting smooth transactions and appraisals. Specializes in hard-to-find brands and offers personalized service including detailed product insights.

A wide selection of luxury watches like Cartier, Rolex, Patek Philippe, and Richard Mille is available. Staff members like David and Michael assist with buying, selling, and consigning watches, ensuring high-quality transactions.

They handle watches on consignment, including brands like Rolex and Cartier. Some watches sell immediately, while others stay on consignment for longer periods.

People are saying

"David was prompt and professional finding my watch."

"David is super knowledgeable about consignment."

Good to know

1

Payment process is smooth and accepts various methods including credit cards.

2

Expect competitive pricing for luxury watches and jewelry.

3

The appraisal process is straightforward and meets expectations.

02
WOLVYN Luxury Timepieces image 1

Showroom presents a beautifully appointed interior with an elegant yet comfortable atmosphere. Selection includes extraordinary luxury watches sourced globally, attracting both seasoned collectors and novices. Pricing and transaction processes are smooth and fair, creating a welcoming environment for watch enthusiasts.

Extensive selection of luxury watches caters to both seasoned collectors and novices. The team offers professional service and can locate specific timepieces quickly, often under budget and with fast delivery.

The consignment process here is simple and easy. Staff like Derek handle sales personally, and items like watches get dropped off for luxury consignment.

People are saying

"Derek helped me find the perfect watch and made the process smooth."

"I found the perfect luxurious watch with Derek's patient guidance."

"I found the staff nice and cool when selling my piece on consignment."

Good to know

1

WOLVYN Luxury Timepieces offers a wide selection of luxury watches and jewelry.

2

The purchasing process at WOLVYN is straightforward and user-friendly.

3

WOLVYN provides fair trade-in values for watches.

03
Watch Space image 1
Watch store

Clean, professional space showcases luxury watches with beautiful displays and a welcoming atmosphere. Enthusiasts find expert advice and fair pricing for buying, selling, and trading high-end timepieces. Transactions happen smoothly and quickly, supported by fast, secure shipping.

Luxury watch transactions here are consistently smooth and professional. The store offers authentic luxury timepieces like Cartier and Rolex with top-tier customer service and fair trade-in values.

Selling watches happens through a consignment model here. Jay assists with the process, which can lead to a better price.

People are saying

"I got my dream watch from this Watch Store quickly and smoothly."

"The service here is professional, knowledgeable, and responsive."

"Jay helped me sell my watches through consignment and kept me updated."

Good to know

1

Shipping is fast, with next-day delivery available for most orders.

2

All watches come with original boxes and paperwork for authenticity.

3

Prices are competitive, often lower than the grey market for similar conditions.

04
The RealReal image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop offers a beautifully curated selection of high-end designer items in impeccable condition within a clean, organized space. Atmosphere feels comfortable and relaxed, with knowledgeable staff providing a personal touch. The process runs smoothly with no pressure, making it a place for luxury with heart and expertise.

Staff offers patient guidance while trying on several watches. Selection includes vintage designer and luxury timepieces at reasonable prices.

Consignment here is handled with fast and thorough service. Staff like Tiffany, Tochi, and Kai guide you through an easy and streamlined process, making large consignments simple to manage.

People are saying

"The consignment process with Tochi was so easy and friendly."

"The staff here is so knowledgeable about luxurious pieces."

"Grayson at this Watch Store helped me find a great timepiece."

Good to know

1

There are no returns on bags, putting sellers and buyers at risk of scams.

2

Make an appointment for personalized assistance with luxury items.

3

Expect to pay a commission based on the estimated net selling price for items.

05
Mr Goods Buy & Sell image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop with a well-organized layout and eye-catching displays creates a quiet, serene atmosphere blending luxury and hypebeast culture. The environment feels welcoming and comfortable, attracting those interested in exclusive designer goods and fair, immediate transactions.

Offers cash payouts within 15 minutes for watches brought in. Accepts trades, including for models like the Batman watch. Carries a wide selection of high-end watches alongside other luxury items.

Offers great consignment options with prices better than other shops. Stands out as a favorite consignment spot downtown with consistently good deals.

People are saying

"The staff here is knowledgeable about luxurious items and attentive to your needs."

"Ahmed made my consignment experience professional, knowledgeable, and trustworthy."

"Oleg at the Watch Store was super helpful."

Good to know

1

All items at Mr. Goods are authentic and high quality.

2

You can receive cash on the same day for your sold items.

3

Transactions are priced and negotiated quickly.

06
Atlas Jewelers image 1

Beautiful jewelry store with a friendly atmosphere and comfortable environment. Offers custom design services, repair and cleaning with timely, quality work. Presence of a Labrador Retriever adds a charming touch to visits.

Watch repairs and maintenance happen quickly and at reasonable prices. Services include band resizing, battery replacements with 5-year batteries, deep cleaning, and full overhauls for Swiss and other watches.

A large assortment of consignment items offers unique pieces like a teal sapphire ring. The selection focuses on items ready to be reloved and includes options for coins and custom work.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and helpful."

"The staff at this watch store are so nice and helpful."

"They really worked with me on the price for my consignment."

Good to know

1

The battery replacement costs $35 and includes a lifetime replacement.

2

The turnaround time for repairs is typically three weeks.

3

Atlas Jewelers offers fine jewelry at competitive prices.

07
Claydon Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Store combines family-owned warmth with impeccable craftsmanship in an immaculate setting. Friendly atmosphere includes a welcoming dog at the entrance. Offers custom designs, repairs, and a diverse, tasteful jewelry selection with reasonable pricing.

Staff provide expert advice on watches and jewelry, helping with repairs, custom designs, and selecting pieces. Inventory features beautiful watches and the store offers quick battery replacements and strap changes.

Beautiful jewelry fills the consignment area, with a nice selection of turquoise pieces. They accept and sell jewelry on consignment, offering space for personal items.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The staff at this watch store are so knowledgeable and make you feel special."

"The people here are so helpful and knowledgeable about consignment."

Good to know

1

Claydon Jewelers offers watch and jewelry repairs, custom designs, and engagement rings.

2

The cost for jewelry cleaning and repairs is very reasonable.

3

Claydon Jewelers provides resizing services for rings and custom orders.

08
The Jewelry Source image 1
Jewelry store

Store offers a family atmosphere with a beautiful, inviting space. Energy feels comfortable and friendly, supported by knowledgeable staff who handle repairs and customizations on-site. Selection includes high-quality, unique jewelry with antique pieces and quick, reasonably priced services.

Watch repairs and sizing happen quickly, often in under five minutes. Staff like Maria and Todd assist with watch purchases and consignment, providing efficient and friendly service.

Barb S handles consignment, including luxury items like a Rolex watch. Estate consignment jewelry features prominently, offering a range of unique pieces.

People are saying

"The Jewelry Store staff are so friendly and professional."

"The staff at this Watch Store are so nice and friendly."

"I had a great experience with Barb for consignment."

Good to know

1

The Jewelry Source offers quick turnaround times for repairs and customizations.

2

Resizing services are reasonably priced and completed in a timely manner.

3

They have skilled bench jewelers for any customization or repair needs.

09
Jeffrey's Jewelry Design Studio image 1

Jewelry store offers skilled craftsmanship and affordable pricing with a wide selection including unique and men's rings. Atmosphere feels like shopping with family, with no pressure and honest advice on care and repairs. Repair work is precise, often surpassing other shops in quality and cost.

Watch batteries get replaced quickly and repairs are handled with care. Services include custom design and diamond work, covering a wide range of watch needs.

A full-service custom jewelry shop offers a good selection of estate pieces on consignment. Prices of consignment jewelry do not reflect the rise in gold costs, making them a great deal.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so kind, helpful, and knowledgeable."

"They listened to my vision and made it happen for my necklace."

"I experienced wonderful, friendly service here."

Good to know

1

Jeffrey's offers a wide range of services and can accommodate specific requests.

2

The jewelers are skilled and provide honest opinions on jewelry care.

3

They charge significantly less than other jewelry repair shops.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...