Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to the US

Gluten-free key lime pie

You shouldn't have to sacrifice the tartness of a real key lime pie just because you need it to be gluten-free.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Darlene's Ice Cream image 1
Darlene's Ice Cream image 2
Darlene's Ice Cream image 3
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop with warm, inviting scent of brownies and waffle cones fills the air. Space feels cheerful and welcoming with a cute, carefully crafted design. Offers vegan and gluten-free options alongside expertly made artisan ice cream and coffee drinks.

Offers a key lime pie flavor that stands out for its phenomenal taste and inventive approach. This flavor ranks among the most favored alongside unique options like coffee caramel crunch.

Gluten-free options include ice cream sandwiches and other treats that get as much care as regular menu items. Plenty of dairy-free and vegan choices are available and tasty.

People are saying

"The ice cream shop's flavors are so creative and delicious."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was a must-try."

"I found lots of delicious gluten-free options here."

Good to know

1

They offer 16 rotating flavors, including unique options like Toasted Sesame and Lychee Sorbet.

2

Darlene's Ice Cream has vegan and lactose-free options available.

3

The shop is family-run by two talented Denver chefs.

02
Fire Water image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers cozy hippie vibe with bright, colorful indoor and outdoor seating. Atmosphere stays relaxed and friendly, encouraging easy conversation. Menu focuses on vegan and gluten-free dishes, attracting both vegans and non-vegans with flavorful, creative options.

Key lime pie stands out as absolutely delicious and quickly enjoyed. It ranks among the best desserts here, often finishing meals on a high note.

Everything on the menu is vegan and gluten free, making choices straightforward. The gluten-free vegan mac and cheese stands out, along with a strong selection of vegan, gluten-free desserts.

People are saying

"I was so impressed with the fresh, delicious vegetarian food here."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was the best I have ever had."

"I thought the gluten-free mac and cheese was creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch due to high demand.

2

Expect higher prices, with entrees averaging $22.

3

The entire menu is vegan and gluten-free, catering to dietary restrictions.

03
Legacy Pie Co.- Wash Park image 1

Pie shop offers sweet and savory pies in a clean, minimalistic setting with no dine-in area, focusing on grab-and-go. Atmosphere feels cute and home-like with a friendly staff and a delicious smell upon entry.

Perfect balance of sweet and tart defines the key lime pie here. It comes gluten-free and stands out as absolutely incredible compared to other pies.

Multiple gluten-free pies are available, including cherry and key lime options. Both sweet and savory gluten-free choices exist, offering variety for different tastes.

People are saying

"I thought the pies here were amazing and delicious."

"The chicken pot pie, a classic American food, has a flavorful filling and flaky crust."

"I found the Key Lime Pie to be absolutely incredible."

Good to know

1

Legacy Pie Co. offers both sweet and savory pies in full and individual sizes.

2

Gluten-free cherry pie and other gluten-free options are available.

3

The shop is designed for grab-and-go purchases with no dining area.

04
Cait's Key Lime image 1

Online bakery specializes in small-batch key lime pies with gluten-free and nut-free options. Pies balance tart and creamy flavors without excessive sweetness and maintain quality for days. Strong focus on fresh, carefully sourced ingredients and dedicated craftsmanship defines the experience.

Offers a perfect lime taste with well balanced, light, and refreshing cream. The pie is consistently delicious and not too sweet.

Gluten-free options include a gluten-free crust for pies and a gluten-free key lime dessert. The gluten-free key lime pie tastes very similar to the regular version.

People are saying

"I thought this Key Lime Pie was the best I'd ever had."

"I thought Cait's key lime pie was the best dessert I ever had."

"I thought the gluten-free key lime pie was delicious."

Good to know

1

Cait's Key Lime is an online business; follow their Instagram for updates.

2

The pie comes with a gluten-free crust option and is nut-free.

3

I recommend visiting Cait's website to order some pie.

05
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Bakery offers cozy indoor seating and a quiet backyard garden with beautiful lighting for a relaxed atmosphere. Space feels crowded and noisy inside, with tables placed closely together. Outdoor area provides a calm spot to enjoy desserts and drinks away from the bustle.

Creamy texture stands out with a perfect balance of sweet and tart flavors. Consistently described as perfect and enjoyable by many.

Gluten-free options include vegan cakes and a chocolate mousse cake that taste like regular desserts. The bakery offers a wide variety of gluten-free and vegan choices, including a hazelnut cake.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be amazing and delicious."

"I loved their delicious gluten-free chocolate cakes and tarts."

"I found the Key Lime Pie to be so creamy and perfect."

Good to know

1

Mia's is open until midnight on weekends and 10 PM on weeknights.

2

Expect a 15-minute wait for to-go desserts during peak hours.

3

Parking near the bakery is challenging, with limited metered spaces.

06
Yardbird Table & Bar image 1

Dark interior with warm lighting and loud atmosphere creates an upscale yet laidback vibe. Frequent crowd noise rises to concert levels on busy nights. Dedicated gluten-free southern cooking and a well-stocked whiskey selection distinguish the experience.

Gluten-free key lime pie delivers a rich, tangy flavor that stands out. It pairs well with other desserts like fried Oreos and leaves a strong impression.

Gluten-free options include dedicated fryer and waffle maker ensuring no cross-contamination. The gluten-free fried chicken and waffles stand out as a rare and highly praised choice for those with celiac disease.

People are saying

"The fried chicken is crispy, juicy, and perfectly seasoned."

"You have to try the gluten-free fried chicken; it's phenomenal."

"The gluten-free Key Lime Pie made my wife cry tears of joy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times, especially on weekends.

2

Yardbird Table & Bar offers dedicated gluten-free fries and fried chicken.

3

The menu is clearly labeled for allergies, making it easy to identify gluten-free options.

07
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 1

Upscale diner with cramped seating and dim lighting creates a classic yet hectic atmosphere. Live music and a small patio add to the vibe, while bottomless mimosas and standout dishes like the burger and French toast draw attention. Crowds fill the space, making it lively but noisy.

Not too sweet or tart, the key lime pie has a buttery flaky crust and contains no coconut. It comes highly praised for its balanced flavor and is often chosen over other desserts.

Kitchen easily handles gluten-free needs with gluten-free buns and pasta clearly labeled on the menu. Staff stays helpful and accommodating, especially for those with Coeliac disease.

People are saying

"The food here is a peaceful escape from busy routines."

"They easily accommodate gluten-free needs with clearly labeled options."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was delicious."

Good to know

1

Make reservations for Easter Sunday to ensure a spot.

2

Unlimited mimosas for $20 are available every day all day.

3

Bottomless mimosas and waffles are available on Sunday morning.

08
Hamburger America image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Vintage burger diner with retro-modern design and old school American vibe fills a small space packed with eager diners. Formica counters and sizzling flattops create a nostalgic atmosphere where the burger assembly line is visible from the counter. Outdoor seating and a bar add variety to the lively, crowded setting.

Chocolate key lime pie offers a rich twist on the classic with a creamy texture. The traditional key lime pie stands out as a dream dessert with a bright, tangy flavor.

Gluten-free buns come in excellent quality and are widely available. Some buns feel mealy and under-toasted, and occasionally the gluten-free option is not served when requested.

People are saying

"The American Food here is simple, delicious, and perfectly satisfying."

"I loved the fried onion burger, it was greasy in the best way."

"They have gluten-free buns, and they're excellent."

Good to know

1

You order food and pay upfront, which makes the process easy and efficient.

2

Be warned that lines can be long on certain days at George Motzโ€™s restaurant.

3

Opening time is the best time to visit to avoid crowds.

09
Peacefood - Upper West Side image 1

Open layout with close tables creates a loud, bustling atmosphere marked by constant kitchen noise. Hipster vibe recalls Northern California, blending relaxed, cozy elements with energetic service. Outdoor seating adds a pleasant option amid the lively indoor scene.

Raw key lime pie stands out for its refreshing taste and vegan preparation. It pairs well with other items like chickpea fries and dumplings.

Many gluten-free options exist alongside vegetarian and vegan choices. The gluten-free savory biscuit is notably moist, and the double chocolate cookie offers a tasty treat.

People are saying

"This dairy-free place has truly delightful, creative vegan food."

"I noticed they had many gluten-free options on the menu."

"I thought the raw Key Lime Pie was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect at least an hour and a half wait if ordering online.

2

The bakery only sells slices of cake and does not sell whole cakes.

3

The restaurant has a policy that prohibits customers from eating outside food.

10
The Guest House Austin image 1

Steak house offers an elegant setting with chandelier sparkle and private seating areas for intimacy. Music ranges from a live DJ to carefully curated playlists, creating a dynamic atmosphere. Signature cocktails feature theatrical presentations that complement the upscale vibe.

A dessert plate features a brie-shaped key lime pie that is nicely tart and pairs well with crackers. This faux cheese board style dessert includes lemon cake, sorbet, and other sweets, creating a creative and cute presentation.

Staff provide detailed guidance on gluten-free options and modifications. The kitchen handles dietary restrictions carefully, even removing gluten-free dishes from the bill when needed.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, thanks to the super nice and proactive staff."

"They were so knowledgeable about the gluten-free options."

"The key lime pie here is nicely tart and shaped like Brie."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

Reservations are required for private events and must be confirmed in advance.

3

A $25 cutting fee applies if you bring your own cake.

11
Au Cheval image 1
New American restaurant

Graffiti-adorned alley leads to a lively spot with a secret speakeasy downstairs. Burgers offer lettuce wraps for gluten-free needs, with marked options and Udiโ€™s bread available. The key lime pie shines with a perfect sweet and sour balance that cuts through rich dishes.

A perfect balance of sweet and sour defines the key lime pie. It offers a sourish balance that cuts through richer dishes, making it a standout dessert.

Burgers come with a lettuce wrap instead of a bun for gluten-free needs. Fries and broccoli are also gluten-free. The menu marks items that can be made gluten free and offers Udiโ€™s gluten-free bread for an extra charge.

People are saying

"You have to try these burgers; they're perfectly cooked and juicy."

"The Key Lime Pie here is the best I've ever had."

"They offer great gluten-free options, like a burger."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to avoid long waits, especially during peak hours.

2

The wait to get in is about 20-25 minutes depending on party size.

3

The speakeasy operates from 6-11 pm on certain days downstairs.

12
Knead Luv Gluten Free Bakery & Cafรฉ image 1

Gluten-free bakery with cute decor and a cozy vibe featuring a comfortable lounge and a small patio. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, enhanced by a kids corner and a photo zone. Offers visually stunning desserts and a welcoming environment for enjoying organic, allergen-conscious baked goods.

Offers a decadent key lime pie alongside other pastries. The pie is delicious and can be frozen for later enjoyment.

Gluten-free items come freshly made with a wonderful selection including cakes that satisfy gluten intolerance. Staff explain all options clearly, and organic coffee pairs well with the baked goods.

People are saying

"I couldn't tell these delicious baked goods were gluten free!"

"Their cinnamon rolls and croissants are amazing bakery items."

"I got the Key Lime Pie and it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Order in advance because they sell out quickly.

2

All baked goods are gluten-free and sourced from local farms.

3

Just one single cinnamon roll is $10.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...