Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in the US

Locally owned pie

Made for those who prioritize supporting independent businesses and believe that a slice of pie is the best way to judge a kitchen.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Ya Hala Pizza Halal image 1
Ya Hala Pizza Halal image 2
Ya Hala Pizza Halal image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza restaurant offers a warm, family atmosphere with a cozy, homey feel. The space plays the Holy Qurโ€™an softly, creating a welcoming, respectful vibe. It serves halal meat with well-seasoned pizzas and wings, standing out as a friendly, family-run spot.

Mediterranean pies come fresh with Akkawi cheese, zaโ€™atar, and haloumi options. Meat and cheese pies also stand out as family favorites.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and made with fresh ingredients."

"It's a mom and pop shop, just like the pizza joint."

"I thought the Mediterranean pies were the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer halal pizza and wings.

2

The wait time is usually under 15 minutes.

3

Prices are very reasonable for the portions.

02
Zorba's Greek Kitchen image 1

Small, cozy restaurant with authentic Greek decor and classic Greek music playing in the background. Atmosphere feels homely and inviting, transporting diners to Greece. Offers a unique, intimate dining experience with a few tables and a friendly vibe.

Spinach pie stands out with its flaky crust and rich filling. It pairs well with creamy tzatziki and warm pita, making it a solid choice alongside other dishes like dolmades and baklava cheesecake.

Cozy and locally owned, this spot feels like an old school mom and pop Greek restaurant. It offers flavors and customer service that stand out from larger chains.

People are saying

"The food here tastes so authentic and fresh."

"The spinach pie has the flakiest dough and creamy feta."

"It's a great locally owned mom and pop shop."

Good to know

1

Pastitsio is available every Monday.

2

Takeout and delivery options are available.

3

The restaurant has limited seating, so expect a wait during busy times.

03
Jewel's Noodle Kitchen image 1
Chinese restaurant

Small family-owned Chinese restaurant offers authentic northern-style dishes with freshly made noodles and generous portions. Atmosphere is quiet and chill with basic decor and calming music. Food is cooked to order, creating a slow but fresh dining experience without Americanized options.

Pies feature savory pork fillings like celery and leek that pack great flavor. Vegetable pies come out crispy and piping hot, while pan-seared meat pies add a delicious twist.

People are saying

"The dumplings here are juicy and flavorful."

"The crispy haim sui gok here are perfectly crispy and flaky."

"The food here is so authentic and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Food takes a while to prepare since it is made fresh for each customer.

2

The portion sizes are very generous.

3

The prices are very reasonable.

04
Lake Villa Restaurant image 1
Family restaurant

Small diner with old-time charm and a family-run atmosphere offers a cozy, welcoming vibe that feels like dining at a relative's home. The space is intimate and relaxed, busy but never rushed, with a view of the nearby park adding to the calm setting.

Fresh homemade pies stand out here, especially the pumpkin and apple pie. Cinnamon rolls also pair well with the pie selection.

A mom and pop diner with a loving atmosphere sits in a beautiful downtown area. It offers a typical mom and pop experience with food and sights that stand out.

People are saying

"This family owned spot serves delicious scratch kitchen food."

"I thought the apple pie's crust and filling were perfect."

"It's a sweet mom and pop place you'll love supporting."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is closed on Monday and Tuesday.

2

Expect longer wait times during weekend brunch hours.

3

Reservations are recommended for large groups, especially on weekends.

05
The Three Mothers Cuisine & Bakery image 1

Small bakery with beautiful decor and ornate floral arrangements creates a warm, cozy atmosphere. Quiet and peaceful, it offers a family-friendly vibe with a wide selection of fresh baked goods and desserts. The space feels intimate with a few tables and booths, making it ideal for relaxing meals.

Mini pies stand out with apple and pecan varieties that taste fresh and delicious. Chess Pie and Tres Leches cake also offer rich, satisfying flavors alongside a wide assortment of delicate baked goods.

Locally owned with a clean atmosphere and a mom and pop feel. The place operates as a small, independent establishment.

People are saying

"The Lunch Spot's bakery items smelled fantastic and were filled with delicious treats."

"I loved the delicious food made from scratch here."

"The apple mini pies were awesome, some of the best pastries I've had."

Good to know

1

Get there before 6 pm to avoid waiting until the next day for sweets.

2

Prices are reasonable, with sandwiches costing around $16.99.

3

Biscuits and gravy are available for $7.50.

06
Giant Hamburgers image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Retro diner with 50s decor and a semi-spacious layout featuring booths, bar seating, and tables creates a nostalgic vibe. Atmosphere feels warm and lively, with classic music and friendly, cozy energy. Regulars enjoy fresh, old-school style burgers and thick fries in a simple, no-frills setting.

Slices of fruit pies and creampies come in a nice variety here. The pies are consistently delicious and stand out alongside the burgers.

A mom and pop spot with a locally owned vibe. It serves hamburgers and fries in a cute, small setting.

People are saying

"These burgers are truly giant and super tasty."

"It's a simple, no-frills diner with an old-school vibe."

"I thought the burgers were good at this locally owned spot."

Good to know

1

The burger costs $18 for a pastrami or bacon burger, fries, and a small drink.

2

You can only get takeout after 7:30 PM as they close at 8 PM.

3

Expect minimal air conditioning, which can be uncomfortable in hot weather.

07
Welton Brewing Co And Oyster Bar image 1

Small brewpub offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating with a simple, unassuming decor reminiscent of a lodge. Atmosphere stays relaxed and friendly, welcoming casual visitors who enjoy fresh craft beer and authentic northern New England seafood.

Homemade Whoopie Pies stand out as a scrumptious dessert option. They are popular enough to be taken to go and often recommended for dessert.

Locally owned brewery brings in fresh seafood from Maine weekly and creates a welcoming atmosphere.

People are saying

"These oysters are unbelievably fresh and bursting with ocean flavor."

"I'm already craving another homemade whoopie pie."

"The oysters here are so fresh and tasty."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $10 off a dozen oysters on the first Thursday of each month.

2

The brewery features a rotating selection of local craft beers.

3

Parking is available behind the German-American Club, but can fill up quickly.

08
Hasty Tasty Pancake House image 1
Breakfast restaurant

Old school diner with 1950s memorabilia and retro family atmosphere creates a warm, nostalgic vibe. Oldies music plays softly, adding to the cozy, welcoming energy. Friendly environment feels like a step back in time with classic country diner charm.

Homemade pies stand out with an assortment of fruit pies made from scratch. The pecan pie is especially tasty and a popular dessert choice.

Locally owned with an old school style, this spot feels like a classic mom and pop diner. It has a nostalgic atmosphere and has been around for a long time.

People are saying

"This diner has a cool, old-school vibe with vintage stuff."

"The roast beef hotshot food here is awesome and really good."

"It's a cute, old-fashioned mom and pop diner."

Good to know

1

Every Friday, they offer an all-you-can-eat fried fish special for $10.99.

2

Expect daily specials that change regularly.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash is preferred for smaller purchases.

09
Bennett Shellfish image 1
Seafood market

Takeaway-only seafood market with a cute cottage design and mom-and-pop feel. Atmosphere is authentic and inviting, reflecting a family-run tradition spanning generations. Known for fresh lobster rolls and smoked fish spread, it operates on a cash-only basis with no seating available.

Clam pies stand out as a Montauk delicacy here, made homemade and offered alongside other seafood items. Many pies and shellfish cakes come prepared and flash frozen for convenience.

Seafood comes from a family-run operation that catches fresh fish daily. The small shop serves a lobster roll praised for its quality and freshness.

People are saying

"The seafood here is always so fresh, especially the oysters."

"You have to try the clam pie; it's full of flavor."

"I had the best lobster roll from this locally owned shop."

Good to know

1

Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.

2

There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.

3

The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.

10
Premier Meat Pies image 1

Large windows fill the space with natural light, creating a setting ideal for people watching. The atmosphere blends cozy and efficient, serving as a local hangout, date spot, and sports bar. Specialty cocktails stand out alongside comfortable seating and a full service bar.

Pies feature an amazing crust with a perfect meat-to-crust ratio and fillings full of flavor. Toppings like caramelized onions enhance the taste, and small pies offer a variety of unique stuffings.

A locally owned family business runs the place with a friendly staff that creates a mom and pop vibe. The food quality matches the care in ownership, making spending here feel worthwhile.

People are saying

"The steak and mushroom pie here is so tasty and delicious."

"Their cocktails were unique and delicious."

"The service at this locally owned spot is so friendly."

Good to know

1

Parking can be a challenge, so be prepared for a light walk.

2

The price of $20 per pie is steep for a size comparable to a frozen banquet pot pie.

3

They offered frozen pies to go for customers not near a location.

11
Cafรฉ Babette image 1

Pastry shop offers over 15 uniquely crafted baked goods with a simple, unadorned layout featuring old mismatched tables and no labels. Atmosphere feels laid-back and comforting with a bustling, positive energy especially on busy days. No eat-in service or coffee is available, and waiting or preordering is common due to high demand.

Blueberry hand pie features a crunchy outside and soft inside with orange icing. Cherry sumac pie lacks quality compared to cheaper options. Other desserts like croissants and brownies also stand out.

This spot operates as a mom and pop establishment known for its perfected croissants. It leans more toward a traditional bakery vibe rather than an artisan setup.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and thoughtfully executed."

"This locally owned spot has amazing, flaky croissants."

"The blueberry hand pie is high quality and crunchy."

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid long waits on weekends.

2

Expect long lines, especially on Saturdays and holidays.

3

Arrive early to secure pastries before they sell out.

12
Sunny's Cafe image 1
Restaurant

Space expands beyond a small diner into a larger area with a hidden party room and a banquet hall seating over 100. Atmosphere blends a mom and pop vibe with warm, welcoming energy despite occasional muggy heat. A huge hand-carved German cuckoo clock stands out as a unique visual centerpiece.

Homemade pies have great flavor but come with a thin crust, topped by a thick layer of whipped cream. They look exceptional and visually appealing.

Feels like a mom and pop shop with a cozy, personal touch. The vibe stays simple and welcoming, reflecting a locally owned spirit.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was amazing and fresh."

"It's a locally owned spot with a real mom and pop feel."

"I thought the homemade Pie was exceptional."

Good to know

1

Sunny's Cafe offers an all-day breakfast menu.

2

The portions at Sunny's Cafe are generous for the price.

3

Prices at Sunny's Cafe are reasonable compared to similar diners.

13
Mom's Kitchen image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers a nostalgic diner vibe with homey, warm atmosphere and authentic memorabilia. Outdoor patio provides dog-friendly seating and occasional live music, creating a relaxed and inviting environment. Booths and furniture show wear, adding to the vintage feel.

Chicken pot pie appears often but varies widely, from a tasty but salty dish to a chicken filet lacking the traditional filling. Dessert pies like blueberry pie with ice cream are available but overall, pies and cakes are just decent, not outstanding.

Feels like a mom and pop diner from another time with a strong sense of tradition. Offers home cooking in a sit-down setting that stays true to its roots.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious breakfast here."

"It's a great family-run restaurant with a home cooking feel."

"I had a nice size serving of chicken pot pie that was tasty."

Good to know

1

The breakfast specials are available before 8 am on weekdays.

2

Weekly specials include a free glass of wine or beer.

3

Open mic nights are held weekly, providing entertainment.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...