Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to the US

Peanut butter and jelly

Made for those who refuse to outgrow the simple, reliable satisfaction of a classic peanut butter and jelly sandwich.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Pearl Street Restaurant image 1
Pearl Street Restaurant image 2
Pearl Street Restaurant image 3
View all

Counter seating wraps a petite kitchen where chefs craft dishes in full view, creating a cozy vibe. Foie gras adds a luxury twist to peanut butter and jelly, blending comfort with creativity. Intimate chef interaction and soft background music complete the personal dining experience.

Peanut butter and jelly gets a luxury twist with foie gras mixed in, creating a rich and creative dish. This version stands out as a comforting yet elevated take on a classic.

People are saying

"The tasting menu was fun, creative, and incredibly tasty."

"The wine list here is creative and perfectly balanced."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly with foie gras was pure genius."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the chef's tasting menu, especially on busy nights.

2

The Valentine’s Day prix fixe menu is served at the chef counter.

3

The restaurant offers an 8-course tasting menu for under $100.

02
Marble Fox Brewing Company image 1

Brewery offers a dog-friendly indoor space with games and a shaded patio. Taplist spans two walls with art displays and many beers. No Crust PB&J features smooth peanut butter and balanced jelly, pairing well with hazy IPAs.

No Crust PB&J stands out with its smooth peanut butter and balanced jelly flavors. It pairs well with hazy IPAs for a unique combo.

People are saying

"I enjoyed their unique, fun, and tasty beers."

"It's a nice spot to cool off and chill with friends."

"I enjoyed the PB&J and the hazy IPAs."

Good to know

1

Parking is free for two hours, but spaces are limited.

2

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 7pm.

3

All beers are brewed in-house with unique formulas.

03
Prana Café image 1

Outdoor seating with lush plants and sacred geometry art creates a peaceful vibe. Unique toasts like the Kid Again peanut butter and jelly blend classic flavors with fresh twists. Dog-friendly space offers healthy smoothies and a relaxed energy with casual sound baths.

Unique twists on toasts include a version with tomato, peanut butter and jelly, and avocado. The Kid Again toast features a classic peanut butter and jelly combo.

People are saying

"The staff here makes amazing smoothies with a great attitude."

"The outdoor seating here is so cozy and beautiful."

"The AB&J sandwich with peanut butter and jelly was really good and filling."

Good to know

1

Prana Café hosts yoga and meditation events regularly throughout the week.

2

Sound bath classes are offered in the back area during select times.

3

Specials are available on specific days, check the schedule for details.

04
da Toscano image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian spot shines with exceptional pasta and cozy atmosphere featuring dim lighting and a wine bottle wall. Try the unique PB&J Bombolone with foie gras filling blending peanut butter and jelly for a bold twist. Perfect for intimate dinners and adventurous eaters.

PB&J Bombolone features a foie gras filling mixed with peanut butter and jelly. This combination creates a hamburger-like texture that may not appeal to everyone.

People are saying

"I'd return just for the exceptional Italian food desserts."

"The duck pappardelle was tender and deeply savory."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly bombolone was unforgettable."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation before visiting to ensure a table.

2

The Porchetta pop-up is available at lunchtime on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.

3

The restaurant has a 90-minute limit for meals, which is mentioned in the small print on their website.

05
Big Mike’s Sandwich Co. image 1

Smart sub shop shines with fresh fried chicken sandwiches and huge portions. Deep-fried peanut butter and jelly offers a crispy, rich twist on a classic. Lively food hall vibe makes every visit feel engaging and fun.

Deep frying turns the peanut butter and jelly sandwich into a crispy, rich treat. This version feels like a more grown-up twist on the classic.

People are saying

"I thought the Ribeye sandwich was the best I ever had."

"I found the French fries to be delicious and cooked perfect."

"The deep-fried Peanut Butter And Jelly sandwich is amazing."

Good to know

1

Credit cards are the only accepted payment method; no cash is accepted.

2

The average meal costs around $20, including a sandwich, fries, and drink.

3

The sandwich portions are large, making it a good value for the price.

06
The Side Chick image 1
Halal restaurant

Halal spot offers a cozy atmosphere and top-rated chicken sandwiches. PB&J sliders are melted and soft, pairing well with mac n cheese and jalapeño burgers. High demand means menu items often sell out quickly.

Sliders with peanut butter and jelly come melted and soft, creating a unique texture. The PB&J sliders pair well with other items like mac n cheese sliders and jalapeño burgers.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was amazing and tasted so fresh."

"I thought the food at this food truck was the best I'd ever tried."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly sliders just melt in your mouth."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times during peak hours.

2

The food truck often runs out of popular menu items, so arrive early.

3

The restaurant is fully halal and well signposted for easy identification.

07
Henry’s Donuts image 1

Donut shop shines with 24-hour service and a quiet, clean atmosphere. Fresh donuts impress, especially the peanut butter and jelly flavor, loved for its perfect balance. Classic vibe and unique tastes make it a top pick.

Peanut butter and jelly donut stands out as a favorite with a delicious, well-balanced flavor. It pairs classic sweet and savory notes that make it a popular choice among the donut options.

People are saying

"The donuts here are soft, fresh, and flavorful."

"It's a 24/7 late night spot, always open."

"I loved the Peanut Butter And Jelly donut; it was my favorite."

Good to know

1

Henry’s Donuts is open 24/7 for late-night cravings.

2

Expect a good variety of donuts available at all hours.

3

Prices at Henry’s Donuts are generally considered high.

08
Rain City Hot Dogs & Burgers image 1

Small trailer serves smokey peanut butter and jelly hot dogs with spicy jalapenos. Casual spot offers unique toppings like Seattle dog ingredients. Food is flavorful and fast, perfect for quick bites during errands.

Smokey peanut butter and jelly sandwiches come with a strong, immediate flavor. The PB&J hot dog pairs smokey taste with options like Hot Link or veggie dogs, and jalapenos add a spicy twist.

People are saying

"The smokey peanut butter and jelly dog was delicious and flavorful."

"I always grabbed the delicious BBQ burger."

"My work crew loved the BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger."

Good to know

1

Most of the fixins are on the side, allowing for customization according to personal preference.

2

With one order ahead of us, it only took about 4 minutes for our food to be ready.

3

The total cost was less than $25, including chips and a drink.

09
Urban Luxe Cafe image 1
Coffee shop

Coffee shop offers modern decor and an upscale vibe with live open mics and poetry. Fried peanut butter and jelly sandwiches provide a grown-up twist and pair well with a coffee flight. Space supports local artists and serves diverse food options.

Fried peanut butter and jelly sandwiches stand out with a grown-up twist. The dish pairs well with a coffee flight, making it a mind-blowing choice.

People are saying

"This cafe hosts live music, open mics, and performances."

"It's a laid-back, chill vibe perfect for relaxing."

"The fried Peanut Butter And Jelly sandwich was excellent."

Good to know

1

Urban Luxe Cafe hosts live entertainment events every weekend, including karaoke and comedy nights.

2

Open mic nights occur every Thursday, providing a platform for local talent.

3

Family fun events are held monthly, making it a great spot for community gatherings.

10
Just Chippy's image 1
Cookie shop

Bright, fun cookie shop offers a warm vibe with fresh, soft cookies made from real ingredients. Mom's PB&J treats shine with peanut butter flavor and unique, delicious taste. Charming space filled with purples and flowers creates a happy mood.

Mom's PB&J sandwiches and cookies pack so much flavor with peanut butter leading the taste. The PB&J treats are baked just right and stand out for their unique, delicious taste.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing."

"These cookies are so soft and delicious, my kids loved them!"

"Mom's Peanut Butter And Jelly sandwich was to die for."

Good to know

1

Orders typically arrive within 4 days, ensuring freshness.

2

Online ordering is straightforward and user-friendly.

3

Cookies are made with wholesome, real ingredients for better taste.

11
Sidecar Slider Bar Plymouth image 1

Historic building hosts a lively bar with long bar and open patio featuring wicker chairs. Loud dance music fuels an energetic vibe, while multiple large TVs keep sports fans engaged. Try the PB&J slider for a fun twist on classic flavors.

The PB&J slider stands out as a fun and popular choice. It combines classic flavors in a slider format, making it a unique twist on the traditional peanut butter and jelly.

People are saying

"I found the food to be amazing and great."

"The bartender Allie is so skilled, every drink she makes is perfectly balanced."

"You have to try the amazing PB&J slider."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 3-6pm with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

3

Late night happy hour specials are available until 1am on weekends.

12
SKŌSH image 1
Coffee shop

Coffee shop blends vintage store and community space with cozy, eclectic vibe. Gourmet peanut butter and jelly bar offers unique flavors in a cozy side room. Occasional live music and unique art create a lively, inviting atmosphere.

A PB&J bar offers gourmet peanut butter and jelly options beyond the usual. These unique, delicious combinations come from a partner business in a cozy side room.

People are saying

"The coffee here is delicious and definitely worth trying."

"It's a unique space where everything, like the decor and goods, is for sale."

"I tried the gourmet peanut butter and jelly, and it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Open mic nights are held on Mondays and Tuesdays, creating a lively atmosphere.

2

You can rent SKŌSH for private events in the evenings.

3

Street parking is available nearby, but there's no dedicated parking lot.

13
Doughnut Plant image 1
Donut shop

Tiny shop offers a colorful doughnut display with a cozy, modern vibe and loud music. Seating is limited but casual, including sidewalk spots. Peanut butter and jelly doughnut shines with a rich filling and yeast base, paired with chocolate Valrhona for extra flavor.

The peanut butter and jelly doughnut features a yeast base with a rich peanut butter and jelly filling. It often comes paired with chocolate Valrhona for extra flavor.

People are saying

"These donuts are world class and out of this world."

"I thought the coffee here was quite good."

"The peanut butter and jelly donut was our go-to choice."

Good to know

1

Their new store hours are 8am to 4pm.

2

You should go early because they sell out fairly fast.

3

A single donut at The Donut Plant costs around $4.50+.

14
5-8 Club image 1
Bar & grill

Bar and grill offers a laid back vibe with a small restaurant feel. Juicy, sticky PB&J JuicyLucy burger delivers a unique twist on classic flavors. Outdoor patio is semi-private but noisy from nearby airport.

Juicy, sticky peanut butter and jelly burgers stand out here. The PB&J JuicyLucy offers a fantastic, delicious twist on classic flavors.

People are saying

"I found the juicy Lucy burger to be spectacular."

"You have to try the sweet potato fries with that unique marshmallow bleu sauce."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly burger was something special and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in their own lot, making access easy.

2

Expect a long wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Only bottled or canned beer is available; no draft options.

15
Red Gate Bakery image 1

Small shop offers a cozy, nostalgic vibe with fresh baked cookie aroma and visible bakers. Unique pickled PB&J cookie divides opinions, while limited space adds to its boutique feel. Outdoor seating is minimal but charming.

Pickled peanut butter and jelly appears as a cookie and a sandwich. The pickled PB&J cookie stands out with a unique flavor that divides opinions.

People are saying

"The chocolate chip cookie was crispy, warm, and one of a kind."

"You have to try the pickled PB&J bar from the bakery; it's dense and rich."

"I'd buy the cinnamon bun again; it was worth it."

Good to know

1

The cookie shop opens at 11 AM.

2

They sell out quickly, so arrive early.

3

Red Gate is not open late.

16
I'm donut ? times square image 1

Minimalist space feels like a donut laboratory with chefs crafting precise, creamy PB&J donuts. Nostalgic flavors meet Matcha Cream innovation in a calm, upscale Japanese setting. Small, takeout-only spot offers wheelchair accessibility and a sleek, museum-like vibe.

Creamy and filling, the PB&J donut delivers strong, nostalgic flavors. Creative options like Matcha Cream add variety beyond the classic peanut butter and jelly taste.

People are saying

"The donuts here are amazing and really, really good."

"The pistachio donut is fluffy and delicious."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly donuts were flavorful and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

There is no seating area, as the shop is meant for takeout.

2

The shop can draw a large crowd, but the line moves quickly due to their efficient system.

3

Going early in the morning helps avoid long wait times.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...