Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Pumpkin pie in the US

A slice of pumpkin pie is the only thing that feels right when the season turns. It is a specific craving that only one flavor can satisfy.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Kerber's Farm image 1
Kerber's Farm image 2
Kerber's Farm image 3
View all

Bright, spacious bakery offers a cozy, coastal grandmother style vibe with fresh flowers and vintage charm. Pumpkin pie is a Thanksgiving favorite and highly praised for its delicious taste. Early hours and free WiFi make it perfect for a relaxed visit.

Pumpkin pie here gets rave reviews and is considered delicious by many. It stands out as a Thanksgiving favorite for ordering.

People are saying

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best of all time."

"The chicken pot pie pocket is flaky, hot, and has tender chicken."

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best I had ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-minute wait for food during busy weekend mornings.

2

The savory pie is a popular choice among regulars.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

02
Patisserie Tomoko image 1

Greenery-filled interior and natural sunlight create a warm, vintage vibe with a cozy atmosphere. Pumpkin pie features a flaky croissant-like crust and rich mousse, standing out alongside a fantastic Basque cheesecake. Seating is limited to bar seats and tiny tables, often uncomfortable and restrictive.

An incredible mousse pumpkin pie features a flaky croissant-like crust. The pumpkin pie is consistently very good and stands out alongside a fantastic Basque cheesecake.

People are saying

"The mille crepe cake is a must-try, so smooth and delicious."

"The desserts here are delicious, especially the pumpkin pie."

"The pumpkin pie here is unique and truly high quality."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for the weekend dessert tasting menu.

2

The dessert tasting experience is available on Fridays at 1pm.

3

The dessert tasting menu costs $28 for three courses.

03
Pop Pie Co. image 1
Pie shop

Cozy outdoor seating with heated lamps creates a warm vibe for casual meetups. Vegan pumpkin pie stands out, paired well with pecan and chicken pot pies. Busy street location offers great people watching and a snug, inviting atmosphere.

Offers a vegan pumpkin pie alongside classic slices. Pumpkin pie pairs well with pecan pie and chicken pot pie. The pumpkin pie is consistently very good and satisfying.

People are saying

"The key lime pie's flavor and texture were truly exceptional."

"I tried so many delicious desserts, my cravings were satisfied."

"I devoured the pumpkin pie; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Pop Pie Co. does not accept cash; they only take card payments.

2

Parking is challenging with only street parking available.

3

There are few tables inside, but plenty of outdoor seating.

04
Andy's Frozen Custard image 1

Old school ice cream shop shines with nostalgic charm and a shaded patio for relaxed outdoor seating. Pumpkin pie concrete blends vanilla custard with real pie pieces, making it a rich seasonal treat. Quick, affordable desserts keep customers coming back.

Pumpkin pie concrete features a vanilla base mixed with actual pie pieces. This seasonal flavor offers a rich dessert option during the holidays.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream here to be delicious and yummy."

"The Drive Thru staff was awesome and friendly today."

"The pumpkin pie concrete mixer was delicious with actual pie pieces."

Good to know

1

There is no indoor seating at Andyโ€™s Frozen Custard.

2

The drive-thru and phone app are convenient for ordering.

3

Parking is easy with no issues reported.

05
Little Pie Company image 1

Open kitchen fills air with buttery pastry aroma while bakers craft pies. Cozy space with outdoor shaded seating invites relaxed visits. Mini pumpkin pie shines as a fresh, tasty option and a holiday favorite for Thanksgiving and Christmas.

Mini pumpkin pie offers a fresh and tasty option, though it costs around $12. Pumpkin pie is a key part of holiday meals like Thanksgiving and Christmas here, with a delicious flavor that many enjoy.

People are saying

"I tasted the best key lime pie I have ever had."

"I found the cheesecake to be incredibly creamy and delicious."

"I loved the pumpkin pie; I wished we could eat it year round."

Good to know

1

Little Pie Co offers 50% off select pies at 7 PM daily.

2

Pre-order pies for holidays like Thanksgiving to ensure availability.

3

Expect high prices; pies can cost around $64 each.

06
Sweet Sweetz Ice Cream and Desserts image 1

Cozy dessert shop features a giant checkers board for family fun and a welcoming vibe. Pumpkin pie shines with silky texture and generous whipped cream, balancing sweetness perfectly. Homemade pies fill the air with comforting smells, making it a kid-friendly spot.

Pumpkin pie has a slightly silky texture and comes with a very generous amount of whipped cream. It balances sweetness well and stands out among other desserts like peach cobbler and banana pudding.

People are saying

"I went back the next day for another peach cobbler."

"I thought the pie here was the best I've ever had."

"The pumpkin pie was delicious and perfectly sweet."

Good to know

1

Whole pies can be ordered in advance through their website.

2

Desserts include ice cream, cakes, and pies made in-house.

3

Slices of pie are available for individual purchase.

07
Beets and Carrots image 1
New American restaurant

Small New American spot shines with farm-to-table freshness and a cozy artistic vibe. Pumpkin pie stands out with rich smooth texture and pumpkin ice cream on the side. Soft jazz music adds to the relaxed atmosphere for fine dining without fuss.

Pumpkin pie comes with pumpkin ice cream on the side. The pie has a rich, smooth texture and deep pumpkin flavor.

People are saying

"The Date Spots here have dishes packed with flavor, like the borscht."

"The farm to table dishes were delicious and beautifully presented."

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times for food due to a small kitchen and limited staff.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your own drinks to enjoy with your meal.

3

Prices are on the higher side, with a half chicken costing around $30.

08
Honeypie Bakeshop image 1

Small space offers a warm, cozy vibe with pies featuring graham cracker crusts ideal for nut allergies. Pumpkin pie divides opinion, some praise its beautiful presentation, others find it slimy. Late hours and focus on dessert and coffee create a relaxed, casual feel.

Pumpkin pie shows mixed results. Some find its presentation beautiful and taste enjoyable, while others describe it as slimy and disappointing.

People are saying

"I was assured they could make the pie with a graham cracker crust."

"I was so disappointed to miss out on dessert because they changed the pie crust."

"I thought the pumpkin pie was the best my family and I have ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special dietary requests, especially for allergies.

2

Pies cost $8.50 each, with slices being small for the price.

3

The shop offers a pie of the month, which changes regularly.

09
Winston Pies image 1
Pie shop

Pie shop shines with freshly baked aroma and a charming outdoor area perfect for coffee and pie. Pumpkin pie is a seasonal hit, often selling out fast. Prices are high but match the exceptional crusts and quality ingredients.

Pumpkin pie draws early queues during the festive season, showing its seasonal popularity. The last pies often include both apple and pumpkin, highlighting demand.

People are saying

"The pie crust here is perfectly buttery and delicious."

"The pies here are heavenly, with a perfect balance of sweet and flaky crust."

"I enjoyed having the pumpkin pie every year for Thanksgiving."

Good to know

1

Winston Pies offers gluten-free and vegan options without sacrificing taste or texture.

2

The price of the slices is $10.00 each.

3

A whole pie costs $59.

10
House of Pies image 1

Classic American diner offers a cozy vibe with vintage dรฉcor and a clean outdoor patio overlooking the Hollywood Hills. Pumpkin pie shines with balanced flavor and pairs well with soy milk. Perfect spot for casual meals and enjoying superb pies.

Pumpkin pie has a balanced flavor and a delicious taste. It pairs well with soy milk and stands out among other pies like banana cream and chocolate cream.

People are saying

"The lemon meringue pie had perfect meringue and lemon flavor."

"I enjoyed a great breakfast here; the food is the real star."

"I thought the pumpkin pie had the best balance of flavors."

Good to know

1

Parking is available, but the lot can be limited and small.

2

Expect delayed service during peak hours as the place gets packed.

3

Prices for pie slices are over $7 each.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...