Sicilian pizza shines with its thick crust and crunchy texture. Space is tiny with limited seating, perfect for quick takeout. Walls show exciting art that adds unique character.
Thick crust stands out with its crunchy texture and rich flavor. Only Sicilian-style pizza is served here, focusing fully on that style.
"I thought the pizza here was the best I've had in years."
"The owner's passion for food ingredients and delicious treats really stands out."
"I thought the Sicilian pizza here was really good."
Good to know
Teglia Pizza Bar is primarily a takeout place with limited dine-in seating.
Parking in Montclair can be challenging, but they offer curbside pickup.
They only serve Sicilian pizza, crafted with sourdough dough.
Old-school pizzeria offers intimate atmosphere and affordable prices. Sicilian pizza shines with thick fluffy crust and rich tomato sauce. Owner's hand-made pies boast authentic mozzarella and meaty toppings, drawing locals who value classic charm.
Thick, fluffy crust defines the Sicilian pizza here, baked with a crispy bottom and rich tomato sauce. Cheese layers melt evenly, creating a satisfying, hearty slice.
Good to know
The prices are affordable, and they accept both cash and credit.
Metered street parking is available nearby.
The seating space inside is very limited.
Old-school pizza joint serves Detroit-style pizza with thick crust Sicilian slices topped with pepperoni cups. Retro vibe blends laid-back and lively moods, perfect for casual chats. Intimate space features a Super Mario arcade for fun.
Square slices highlight Sicilian-style with thick crust and a crispy base. Pepperoni cups add a distinctive touch to the flavorful toppings.
Good to know
Mario's has an incredible all-day happy hour.
A single $25 pizza can easily feed three people.
Mario's can get busy on Friday or Saturday nights, so expect wait times.
Small cafe offers authentic Italian charm with a warm, cozy vibe and covered outdoor seating. Sicilian pizza shines with a thick, fluffy crust and crispy bottom. Guests enjoy a relaxed setting with mellow music and classic desserts.
Sicilian pizza here features a thick, fluffy crust with a crispy bottom. It pairs well with authentic toppings and stands out alongside stramboli and classic desserts.
Good to know
The menu features authentic Italian street food with fresh ingredients.
Prices at the cafe are very reasonable for the quality of food.
Reservations are recommended during peak hours to avoid long waits.
Small pizza shop offers affordable prices and generous portions in a chill setting. Known for Chicago style pizza, it also serves authentic Sicilian pizza with thick crust and rich sauce. Clean and welcoming, perfect for pizza lovers.
Sicilian pizza here features a thick crust with a rich tomato sauce and a generous layer of cheese. It stands out as a solid choice for those craving authentic Sicilian-style pizza.
Good to know
The lunch deal offers two slices and a drink for $6.99.
Expect longer wait times for Chicago style pizza preparation.
Take and bake options are available for easy home cooking.
Old school pizza joint buzzes with a loud, cafeteria vibe and a cash-only policy. Thick, fluffy crust and crispy edges define the Sicilian pizza, especially the crunchy corner slice. Family-friendly crowd enjoys authentic, quality slices in a classic setting.
Thick, fluffy crust defines the Sicilian pizza here, with a crispy edge that stands out. The corner piece offers a particularly crunchy texture and the sauce balances well with the cheese for a satisfying bite.
Good to know
Sal's Pizza only accepts cash; an ATM is available on-site.
There is no table service; orders are taken at the counter only.
Expect long lines during peak hours due to the restaurant's popularity.
Cozy spot with a small bar serving six beers on tap and a friendly vibe. Sicilian pizza shines with its thick crust and rich toppings. Outdoor seating is simple but can be noisy near the highway.
Sicilian pizza stands out as a highlight with a thick, flavorful crust and rich toppings. It ranks among the most memorable versions, offering a satisfying, hearty slice.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times, especially on weekends.
Expect wait times of at least 1 hour and 45 minutes during peak hours.
The restaurant has limited indoor seating and is often busy.
Small space with a quiet lively atmosphere suits casual dining. Sicilian pizza shines with thick fluffy crust and solid flavor, perfect for families. Moderate prices and takeout options add to its practical appeal.
Sicilian pizza here stands out for its excellent quality and solid flavor. It comes highly recommended and reflects a family-owned touch.
Good to know
Reservations are not accepted; it's first-come, first-served.
The restaurant has limited seating with only two tables available.
Takeout is recommended due to the small size of the establishment.
Square pies shine with thin crust Sicilian pizza offering large, flavorful slices. Cozy, local vibe suits those who love family-run takeout. Prices stay low, making it a great spot for affordable Italian-style pizza.
Thin crust Sicilian pizza stands out with its large size and satisfying taste. The Sicilian pizza here consistently delivers excellent flavor and generous portions.
Good to know
Calling in an order can take upwards of 20+ minutes due to popularity.
Prices at Sun-Ray Pizzeria are very reasonable for the quality offered.
Half a pie consists of 16 slices and fits in a traditional pizza box.
Small space with an open kitchen and rockin' music creates a cozy vibe blending Sicilian flair and Nashville grit. Guests enjoy authentic Sicilian pizza with a thick, airy crust while watching chefs prepare food up close. Perfect for dates or groups seeking unique Italian dining.
Authentic Sicilian pizza comes on a focaccia base with a thick, airy crust. The texture is heaven sent, capturing traditional flavors clearly.
Good to know
The pizza pricing is $15 for a slice and $45 for a whole pie.
A 20% service fee is automatically added to all orders.
Happy hour includes a focaccia and a glass of wine.
Simple, clean spot with best Sicilian pizza featuring thick, airy crust and rich sauce. Staff create a friendly vibe with playful chats. Many tables offer a pleasant environment for enjoying spectacular pizza.
Thick, airy crust and rich tomato sauce define the Sicilian pizza here. It stands out as a must-have with a perfect balance of toppings and dough.
Good to know
Rose’s Pizza charges $1.50 for marinara sauce without informing customers beforehand.
Rose’s Pizza does not serve wings or cheesesteaks.
The prices for the fare at Rose’s Pizza were reasonable.
Small space with old school New York vibe and outdoor seating creates a warm, nostalgic feel. Sicilian pizza shines with thick, fluffy crust and flavorful pepperoni. Music adds to the relaxed, casual energy making it a great spot for authentic pizza lovers.
Square slices come with a thick, fluffy crust and a variety of toppings. The pepperoni Sicilian pizza stands out for its flavor and texture.
Good to know
The dine-in area is open again now.
Prices are reasonable; expect to pay around $11 for two slices and a drink.
The restaurant is great for both dining in and taking out.
Open design with a central bar and multiple TVs creates a lively, sports-focused atmosphere. Sicilian pizza features a thick crust and hearty toppings, perfect alongside the classic meatball sandwich. Decor offers an old-school Italian vibe with plentiful seating and a welcoming feel.
Thick crust and hearty toppings define the Sicilian pizza here. It stands out as a solid choice alongside other dishes like the meatball sandwich and mozzarella sticks.
Good to know
Karaoke night is every Wednesday from 7pm to 11pm.
Kids eat free on Tuesdays with a paying adult.
Big Sammy's hosts all Bears games with special viewing events.
Outdoor seating with spacious picnic tables invites lively, casual dining. Sicilian pizza shines with its thick airy crust and rich tomato sauce. Energetic, family-friendly vibe adds nostalgic comfort to every visit.
Thick, airy crust and a rich, sweet tomato sauce define the Sicilian pizza here. The pizza holds up well even when reheated, maintaining its distinctive flavor and texture.
Good to know
Expect to wait 30 minutes outside during peak hours for a slice.
A tray of Sicilian pizza costs $29 and contains 12 slices.
Parking is not available; consider street parking around the block.
Nostalgic 1950s vibe meets cozy booths and lively chatter. Sicilian pizza shines with flavorful veggie slices that leave a lasting impression. Family-friendly and cash-only, it offers a warm, inviting spot for locals and kids alike.
Sicilian pizza here stands out for its flavorful and yummy slices, especially the veggie ones. It offers a sublime experience that many find excellent and memorable.
Good to know
This place is cash only; an ATM is available on-site.
The price of the 16" plain pie is $12.50.
The restaurant offers $12 pies daily.
Cozy spot serves crispy Sicilian pizza with thick, square slices and unique options like chicken pizza. Small indoor seating and covered picnic tables create a comfortable atmosphere with great music. Strong aroma of fresh pizza adds to the classic New York vibe.
Thick, square-shaped Sicilian pizza offers a crispy crust with a satisfying texture. Options include a classic low triangular slice and a white Sicilian pizza alongside varieties like chicken pizza.
Good to know
The restaurant serves late night slices right before closing.
The pizza place is open late on weekends.
There are no toilets available in the restaurant.
Small spot with Brooklyn-style Sicilian pizza offers a cozy, lively vibe. Pepperoni and Hot Honey slices bring a sweet and spicy twist. Outdoor seating lets you soak up Miami's energy in comfort.
Pepperoni and Hot Honey Sicilian pizza stands out with a unique sweet and spicy twist. The menu keeps it simple, focusing on Brooklyn-style Sicilian slices that deliver solid flavor.
Good to know
Expect to pay a 15% lunch dine-in fee on your bill.
The lunch special offers 2 slices of cheese pizza and a soda for $9.50 between 12 PM and 2 PM.
Validated parking is available if you park in the garage.
Tiny pizzeria offers soft bread Sicilian pizza with a perfectly crisp crust and flavorful sauce. Outdoor seating spills into the street, creating a grab-and-go atmosphere with nostalgic music. Family-run vibe adds genuine New York pizza shop energy.
Soft bread and a perfectly crisp crust define the Sicilian pizza here. The sauce is flavorful, and the pizza has the right height, making it both fluffy and crunchy to the bite.
Good to know
The restaurant only accepts cash; no credit cards are accepted.
Pizza slices are priced at $2.75, and soda costs $1.50.
They are celebrating their 50th anniversary this year.
Simple, slightly cluttered interior sets a casual tone. Known for crunchy crust on NY and Sicilian pizzas, with a cheese-heavy topping on Sicilian style. Pairs well with dishes like shrimp Parmesan, though cleanliness can be uneven.
Round Sicilian pizza comes with a cheese-heavy topping and a house special option. It pairs well with other dishes like shrimp Parmesan.
Good to know
Leo's Pizza offers fast delivery, ensuring your order arrives hot.
A 2-slice meal with a drink costs $8.64, providing good value.
The extra large pizza is enough for three people, perfect for sharing.
Local pizzeria offers New York Italian vibes with lively music and pizza dough flipping. Sicilian pizza shines with thick crust and hearty toppings, perfect for families. Small space has both indoor and outdoor seating, making it cozy and inviting.
Square-cut slices highlight the thick crust and generous toppings of the Sicilian pizza. It draws families and groups who focus on this classic style for a hearty meal.
Good to know
The restaurant is cash only; no credit cards accepted.
Slices of pizza are only $3 each.
They always have pizza slices ready to pick up.
Small, artsy spot serves crispy Sicilian crust with unique flavors like Eggplant Pie. Outdoor seating under a covered patio creates a vibrant atmosphere welcoming families and groups. Cashless setup and a small bar add a modern, casual vibe.
Crust stands out as quite delicious on the Sicilian pizza. Options include the Sicilian slice and Eggplant Pie, with the Sicilian slice offering a distinctive flavor compared to other pies.
Good to know
Show your voting sticker for a free slice of pizza during the election promotion.
Parking can be tough to find during peak hours.
Home Slice Pizza does not accept cash payments.
Interior boasts 1980s design with arcade machines and a jukebox, creating a nostalgic vibe. Large deep dish Sicilian pizza has a caramelized crust topped with sausage and peppers. Quiet, cozy atmosphere suits those who enjoy an old-school pizza experience with a salad bar on the side.
Large deep dish Sicilian pizza features a caramelized crust with toppings like sausage, green pepper, and onion. It pairs well with salad and breadsticks and consistently delivers a delicious experience.
Good to know
Lunch specials offer 4-5 options for $10, providing good value.
The restaurant operates on a counter service model; order first, then sit.
The medium cheese pizza costs around $17.
Cozy spot serves homemade Sicilian recipes with fresh, flavorful pizza topped with authentic anchovies. Italian chatter fills the air, creating a homey atmosphere. Outdoor seating adds a relaxed vibe perfect for enjoying the extensive menu.
Sicilian pizza comes with authentic anchovies as a classic topping. The chef's Sicilian background shows in the good quality and ability to customize with any toppings.
Good to know
The menu features a variety of homemade pizza options by a Sicilian-born chef.
Pizza by the slice is available for those looking for a quick bite.
Prices are reasonable, making it a good option for budget-conscious diners.
Small, crowded spot buzzes with energy and 90s dance hits. Sicilian pizza shines with thick, crispy crust and standout pepperoni slice. Limited outdoor tables add to the bustling vibe and quick service at separate counters.
Sicilian pizza here features a thick, square crust with a crispy bottom. The pepperoni slice stands out as a delicious example of this style.
Good to know
Prince Street Pizza only accepts cash payments.
There is no seating available; it's primarily a takeaway place.
The pizza costs $8 per slice.
Outdoor seating offers a stunning view of Brooklyn Bridge, perfect for enjoying the thick Sicilian crust that holds up well for takeout. Loud, energetic music creates a club-like vibe while authentic New York-style pizza shines with its cash-only policy.
Thick and soft dough stands out on the Sicilian pizza. The crust is amazing and the pizza holds up well for takeout.
Good to know
The restaurant only accepts cash for all payments.
Expect a 40-minute wait for pizza after ordering.
This season, Ignazio's offers two unique slushy cocktails.
Cozy dining room offers a homestyle vibe with clean decor but simple, uncomfortable chairs. Sicilian pizza stands out with its thick crust and classic toppings. Popular spot fills up fast, showing its busy energy.
Square shape and simple toppings define the Sicilian pizza here. It features a thick crust with just sauce and bread, focusing on classic flavors.
Good to know
Bruno's Pizza offers a cash discount, so bring cash for your order.
There is plenty of parking available at Bruno's Pizza.
The restaurant gets busy, especially when schools are out.
Small space with standing tables creates a quick vibe but gets very hot without air conditioning. Sicilian pizza has soft airy dough and a crunchy bottom with rich tomato flavor. Classic pizza seasonings chained to tables add a unique touch.
Soft, airy dough with a crunchy bottom defines the Sicilian pizza here. It features a rich tomato flavor and melts in your mouth, making each slice very delicious.
Good to know
There is no seating available, only standing tables.
The price of $20 for 2 slices is considered high.
A slice of Artichoke pizza may contain 600 - 800 calories.
Pizza spot blends New York vibe with a lively cocktail bar and NBA Jam arcade. Sicilian pizza shines with crispy garlic crust but can arrive cold. Late hours and a gourmet touch make it a fun, unique hangout.
Crust stands out with a crispy texture and a garlic-based flavor, similar to Detroit style. Pizza sometimes arrives reheated but cold.
Good to know
Expect a wait on weekends, especially during peak hours.
Seating inside is only available for those ordering a full pie.
If you want a whole pie, go inside and order at the bar.
Pizza place shines with high-quality cheese and light dough. Mondays bring affordable Sicilian pizza that surprises with its unique taste. Atmosphere feels like a family neighborhood gem with generous portions and good deals.
Offers affordable Sicilian pizza on Mondays. The pizza has a distinct taste that can change opinions about Sicilian style.
Good to know
The restaurant offers a $14 special on certain days.
Lunch specials provide great portion sizes.
Prices are generally fair, with a 1-topping slice costing $5.