Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in the US

Sugar cookies

Made for those who appreciate the precise balance of butter and sugar in a perfectly baked cookie.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 1
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 2
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 3
View all

Small bakery offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with freshly baked pastries filling the air. Sugar cookies are adorably decorated and perfect for events or gifts. Friendly staff make visits pleasant and welcoming.

Adorable and delicious sugar cookies come personalized and decorated for events like baby and bridal showers. Kids enjoy the decorated sugar cookies and cookie cake, and these treats make popular gifts.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best chocolate chip cookie I've ever had."

"I tried the s'mores heart cake and it stole my heart."

"These sugar cookies are adorable and delicious."

Good to know

1

Vanilla Sugar offers a happy hour deal on cookies.

2

The bakery bakes cookies and pastries in smaller increments throughout the day to keep everything fresh.

3

This practice ensures they donโ€™t run out of popular items shortly after opening.

02
Sourdough Society Storefront image 1

Sourdough bread shines with organic ingredients and a Greek starter for unique flavor. Sugar cookies impress with soft texture and handmade dough that tastes amazing. Warm, inviting atmosphere complements the high-quality craftsmanship.

Soft texture and handmade with simple, organic ingredients define the sugar cookies here. The dough stands out as amazing, making the cookies very yummy.

People are saying

"This bread is the best I've ever had."

"I found the cookies and cookie dough to be incredible."

"I loved their sugar cookies; they were so soft and yummy."

Good to know

1

Sourdough Society offers home delivery services for their bread.

2

All bread is made with organic ingredients and a 100-year-old starter from Greece.

3

The bakery sells sourdough at the farmers market on Cole Street and in Weehawken Lincoln Harbor.

03
Gather Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery offers a sunlit space with a kids play area that keeps children busy. Custom sugar cookies feature fun designs like the hungry caterpillar and taste perfectly sweet. Friendly vibe invites you to relax with fresh pastries and coffee.

Custom sugar cookies come decorated for events and gifts with a hungry caterpillar theme and other designs. Frosted sugar cookies taste just right, not too sweet, and pair well with croissants.

People are saying

"Their cookies are soft, flavorful, and absolutely to die for."

"I found the croissants to be divine and delicious."

"I ordered custom sugar cookies that were darling and delicious."

Good to know

1

Gather Bakery offers cookie decorating events for all ages.

2

The bakery makes their products fresh daily.

3

Gather Bakery has vegan bread options available.

04
Simply Sweet Caroline's image 1

Custom cookies feature exquisite decoration with vibrant colors and metallic accents. Sugar cookies taste delicious and perfect, often becoming a family favorite. Friendly service and smooth ordering make visits easy and enjoyable.

Sugar cookies come out delicious and perfect with a taste that stands out. They often become a family favorite and pair well with the cookie cake.

People are saying

"The cookies here are beautiful and delicious."

"These cookies are adorable and delicious, a real hit for kids."

"I thought the sugar cookies looked and tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

The ordering process is easy and smooth for custom cookies.

2

Caroline offers cookie designs that can match your event theme.

3

Cookies are individually sealed for convenient transport.

05
Envy Design Cookies INC image 1

Custom cookie shop shines with detailed designs that match event themes perfectly. Iced sugar cookies boast lemon and vanilla flavors that delight even skeptics. Personalized service and affordable pricing make it a top pick for celebrations.

Iced sugar cookies come with lemon and vanilla flavors and feature adorable, detailed designs. They appeal even to those who usually do not like sugar cookies.

People are saying

"These cookies are amazing, delicious, and beautifully designed."

"The cookies for Birthday Parties were stunning and tasted phenomenal."

"Darina's sugar cookies are stunning and perfectly decorated."

Good to know

1

Order in advance as they book up quickly, especially during summer and holidays.

2

The cookies are beautifully designed and taste great.

3

Expect meticulous craftsmanship and attention to detail in every cookie.

06
Sweeterland by Steff image 1

Cookies shine with beautiful decoration and perfect flavor. Sugar cookies are soft and not too sweet, making them a favorite. Ordering is easy with custom designs and quick delivery.

Themed sugar cookies come decorated and look adorable. They taste soft and are not overly sweet, making them delicious and enjoyable.

People are saying

"These cookies are stunningly decorated and taste delicious."

"The decorative sugar cookies were adorable and delicious."

Good to know

1

Ordering and delivery are straightforward and efficient.

2

Cookies are beautifully presented and delicious.

3

Smaller gift box orders are available upon request.

07
Bake It with Tina - Custom Cookies & Custom Cakes image 1

Custom sugar cookies shine with detailed icing and perfect sweetness, ideal for birthdays. The shop crafts intricate designs that double as edible art. Operating from an in-home setup, it focuses on personalized craftsmanship without seating.

Custom sugar cookies come in perfect consistency and sweetness with detailed icing. They look great and suit celebrations like birthdays well.

People are saying

"These custom cookies are gorgeous and delicious!"

"The custom cookies and smash cakes are adorable and delicious for kids' parties."

"These sugar cookies are works of art and delicious."

Good to know

1

Ordering and delivery from Bake It with Tina is easy and straightforward.

2

Custom cookie orders require at least one week's notice for best results.

3

All cookies are made fresh and can be customized to fit any theme.

08
SD Cookie Guru image 1

Custom cookies impress with artistic detail and vivid colors, blending perfect texture and flavor. Sugar cookies shine with detailed graphics and a homemade taste, paired with quick ordering and smooth delivery. Packaging stays fresh and supports timely celebrations.

Sugar cookies feature a perfect recipe topped with frosting and detailed graphics. Custom designs combine a homemade taste with professional presentation and come with quick, easy ordering and pickup.

People are saying

"These cookies are stunning and delicious."

"The cookies for corporate events were a big hit and tasted amazing."

"These custom sugar cookies were delicious and beautifully personalized."

Good to know

1

The ordering process is easy and customizable for special events.

2

Delivery is reliable and typically on time, even for last-minute orders.

3

Custom cookies can be made with specific logos or designs for events.

09
Just Baked image 1
Dessert shop

Fresh-baked cookies fill the air with a warm, inviting scent and awesome energy. Sugar cookies with simple icing or Fruity Pebbles stand out among other varieties. Dog-friendly amenities add a thoughtful touch to the welcoming atmosphere.

Sugar cookies come with simple icing or topped with Fruity Pebbles. They appear alongside other varieties like snickerdoodle and red velvet in assorted cookie selections.

People are saying

"These cookies are massive, soft, and flavorful."

"This Late Night Spot's cookies are so soft and delicious."

"I thought the sugar cookies were some of the best I had."

Good to know

1

There is usually no wait at Just Baked.

2

Prices are reasonable, with small servings starting around $5.

3

Just Baked offers ice cream alongside their baked goods.

10
The Blessing Bakery image 1

Small bakery shines with Mexican sugar cookies topped with red sprinkles. Fresh breads like French loaves and Italian bread fill the air with a phenomenal smell. Friendly vibe and great prices make it a top spot for organic baked goods.

Sugar cookies come with red sprinkles and a Mexican style that stands out for its flavor.

People are saying

"I found the bread here to be the freshest and most delicious."

"I'll definitely be returning for this cake; it's my go-to spot."

"I thought the Mexican sugar cookies were wonderful and to die for."

Good to know

1

The bakery makes fresh baked goods every day.

2

Prices are considered the best in town.

3

French loaves are available fresh daily.

11
the iced whisk image 1

Bakery shines with perfect macarons and iced sugar cookies that have a strong vanilla kick. Charming decor and a friendly atmosphere make it cozy and inviting. Wide flavor variety and reasonably priced sweets complete the delightful experience.

Iced sugar cookies have a good vanilla kick and a cute, adorable look. They taste delicious and amazing with a solid sugar cookie base.

People are saying

"The French food macarons here are perfectly baked, crispy outside, chewy inside."

"These macarons are the best I've ever eaten."

"These sugar cookies are so cute and delicious."

Good to know

1

The cake pops are a bit on the pricey side.

2

The macarons and cake pops are very reasonably priced.

3

They have a big variety of flavors to choose from.

12
Chip Cookies image 1
Dessert shop

Small dessert shop serves soft sugar cookies with rich flavor and customizable toppings. Cozy, clean space offers fresh, quality ingredients in every bite. Perfect for a sweet treat late into the evening.

Sugar cookies here stand out for their soft texture and rich flavor. They pair well with the white chocolate chip cookie, both offering a satisfying sweet treat.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies were delicious and larger than I expected."

"My youngest loved this place; the cookies are fantastic."

"You have to try the sugar cookies; they're amazing."

Good to know

1

You can add toppings to your cookie for customization.

2

Theyโ€™re open late, perfect for late-night cravings.

3

The cookies are priced similarly to Crumbl's.

13
Swig image 1
Soft drinks shop

Soft drinks shop offers a huge menu with fun custom drinks for kids and delicious sugar cookies like mini chocolate chip and dirty little secret. Lines move fast, creating a stress-free atmosphere where people smile. Snack-sized bites round out the experience.

Sugar cookies come out delicious and yummy here. They appear alongside other treats like the dirty little secret and mini chocolate chip cookies.

People are saying

"I loved the sugar cookie and mini chocolate chip cookies."

"They helped me find delicious sugar-free options I loved."

"I thought the sugar cookie was delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during busy hours, but they move quickly.

2

Swig offers a large menu with many drink options.

3

Kids can enjoy designing their own drinks.

14
Jenn's Sweet Treats image 1

Custom cookies shine with detailed designs and custom frosting that match requests perfectly. Guests love the edible art that tastes as good as it looks. Every treat is crafted with care and clear ingredient labels.

Sugar cookies come with beautiful designs and custom frosting. They taste delicious and match specific requests perfectly.

People are saying

"Jenn's cookies are fabulous and she's a pleasure to work with."

"Jenn was so responsive and kind with the sugar cookies."

Good to know

1

Ordering cookies is easy and can be done through her Facebook page.

2

Jenn offers custom designs based on themes or specific requests.

3

Prices for cookies are reasonable and vary based on design complexity.

15
Jeremiah's Italian Ice image 1

Small ice cream shop offers a family-friendly atmosphere with games like giant Uno and Jenga. Sugar cookie jelati is a standout flavor among options like s'mores and Oreo mud pie. Enjoy authentic Italian ice and soft serve with generous samples.

Flavors include s'mores, Oreo mud pie, and sugar cookie jelati. The sugar cookie flavor stands out as a favorite.

People are saying

"The staff is so patient and friendly with kids."

"I thought the soft serve ice cream here was amazing."

"The Sugar Cookies here are made by the most friendly and generous staff."

Good to know

1

The menu offers a huge variety of flavors, ensuring something for everyone.

2

Prices are affordable, making it a great spot for families.

3

You can sample any flavor before making your decision.

16
Batch & Box image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop offers fresh baked goods with a creative selection of soft, gooey cookies. Sugar cookies shine with buttercream frosting, loved by kids and perfect for sharing. Online ordering makes pickup quick and easy.

Soft sugar cookies come with buttercream frosting that stands out. Kids often ask for these sweet treats and they are a common choice for sharing.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be the best I have ever had."

"These sugar cookies are so good, my kids begged for them!"

"I thought the sugar cookies were the best I had ever had."

Good to know

1

Online ordering for pickup is available for quick service.

2

They donโ€™t accept cash, only credit cards.

3

The cookie selection includes seasonal flavors added monthly.

17
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop shines with creative weekly flavors and a clean, welcoming atmosphere. Pink and white sugar cookies boast sweet icing loved by kids and adults alike. Friendly vibe and easy tablet ordering make it a calm spot for special treats.

Pink sugar cookies come with sweet icing that satisfies a sweet tooth. White sugar cookies feature icing loved by kids. Confetti, wedding cake, and biscoff cookies offer variety for sugar cookie fans.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here tasted amazing and were delicious."

"I found the food here to be delicious, especially the cookies."

"I loved the pink sugar cookie; it satisfied my sweet tooth."

Good to know

1

Crumbl offers a rotating menu of new cookie flavors every week.

2

The best deal is the 4-pack, which is popular among customers.

3

Cookies cost $5 each, making them a premium treat.

18
Galette image 1
Bakery

Small bakery with intimate vibe and European charm offers artisan-quality pastries like rich chocolate sugar cookies. Outdoor seating near a park enhances the cozy feel. Pastries often sell out early, showing their popularity.

Chocolate sugar cookies offer a rich flavor and a pleasant texture. They pair well with other pastries like the peach galette and pistachio croissant.

People are saying

"I loved their great pastries; the flaky crust was wonderfully delicious."

"This bakery's cruffins are the best thing in this world."

"I found the chocolate sugar cookies enjoyable."

Good to know

1

Parking is out front but fills up fast; side street parking is available.

2

Expect to spend around $13 per person for juice and a pastry.

3

If you arrive too late on weekends, they might sell out before closing.

19
Cake, Hope, & Love image 1

Quaint bakery shines with artfully decorated sugar cookies that match unique themes. Classes and party rentals create a happy, fun environment. Cakes and pastries boast beautiful details and rich flavors, making every visit sparkly and welcoming.

Artfully decorated sugar cookies come in small sizes and match themes perfectly. Frosted versions feature buttercream and look tasty and beautiful.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and taste incredible."

"This bakery has delicious treats and kind, helpful staff."

"I thought the frosted sugar cookies were tasty and beautiful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special events like cupcake decorating parties.

2

The bakery hosts themed days throughout the year, including Star Wars and Ohio State.

3

Cupcake decorating classes are available for birthday parties and group events.

20
Moose & Me Baking Company image 1

Spacious bakery offers a calm, sensory-friendly atmosphere with gluten-free options and innovative cupcakes. Sugar cookies are beautifully decorated and taste great. Games and books create a welcoming space for children and families.

Sugar cookies come with detailed decoration and look beautifully decorated. They taste great and appeal even to those not usually fond of sugar cookies.

People are saying

"The cake was SO SO delicious and beautifully decorated."

"I found the cookies to be amazingly delicious."

"These sugar cookies are so yummy and pretty to look at."

Good to know

1

They offer custom cakes for special occasions with a variety of flavors.

2

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

The bakery hosts cookie decorating events for groups and parties.

21
The Bearded Baker image 1

Cozy shop offers a quiet spot to enjoy fresh baked cookies and soft sugar cookies. Creative, detailed treats like the oatmeal cream pie stand out. Limited menu keeps quality high and flavors excellent.

Soft texture and fresh taste define the sugar cookies here. They come out yummy and excellent, standing out even among other well-known options.

People are saying

"These cookies are beautiful and delicious."

"I thought the cookies were pretty tasty."

"I thought the sugar cookies here were the best."

Good to know

1

Walk-in orders are available, but selection may be limited.

2

Custom orders require at least three months' notice for fulfillment.

3

Prices for cookies are around $20 for a dozen, which some find high.

22
Luke's Custom Cakes image 1

Bakery shines with custom cakes and fruit topped sugar cookies that blend fresh fruit and sweet base. Beautifully decorated desserts come in a cool, air-conditioned space but lack indoor seating, which can feel uncomfortable in cold weather.

Fruit topped sugar cookies stand out with their fresh fruit and sweet base. They offer a variety of sugar cookies alongside other desserts like pumpkin roll and lemon brownie.

People are saying

"I found the wedding cake to be gorgeous and delicious."

"I think these cupcakes are the best in the area."

"I've never had a better fruit pizza sugar cookie."

Good to know

1

Luke's Custom Cakes can fill orders within 24 hours for last-minute needs.

2

The bakery is closed on Sundays, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Parking on the street in front of the bakery can be difficult due to heavy traffic.

23
The COOKIE Box image 1

Clean, cute bakery offers personalized sugar cookies with detailed buttercream icing perfect for celebrations. Fresh, beautifully decorated cookies come in many flavors, including gluten-free options. Drive-up service adds convenience to the calm atmosphere.

Personalized sugar cookies come with detailed icing and themes for events. The cookies have buttercream icing and a delicious, cute appearance that fits celebrations like weddings and birthdays.

People are saying

"These decorated cookies are delicious and beautiful."

"The takeout cookies here are almost too beautiful to eat."

"These sugar cookies are so cute and delicious!"

Good to know

1

The Cookie Box offers gluten-free cookie options.

2

Custom orders for events are available, including themed cookies.

3

Pricing includes $6.99 for 3 cookies, $13.99 for 7, or $20.99 for 12.

24
Eileen's Colossal Cookies image 1

Offers large, soft sugar cookies with bright, seasonal frosting. Pricing is clear and fair, perfect for quick pickups. Cookies balance sweetness and quality, making them a delightful treat for any occasion.

Large, soft sugar cookies come frosted and decorated with many options. The frosted sugar cookies stand out as affordable and delightful treats.

People are saying

"These cookies are delicious and amazing."

"These frosted sugar cookies are the best I've ever had."

"I loved the cookie cake; it was so good!"

Good to know

1

Eileen's Colossal Cookies offers a wide variety of cookie flavors.

2

Special orders can be placed for events and holidays.

3

Cookies are ready for pickup right on time.

25
Glitz Bakery image 1

Family-owned bakery shines with custom-shaped cookies and thoughtful packaging. Soft, delicious sugar cookies stand out for flavor and size, perfect for baby showers. Atmosphere feels cute and inviting, making it a great spot for special events.

Soft texture and delicious flavor define the sugar cookies here. They come in large sizes and work well for events like baby showers.

People are saying

"I thought the sugar cookies were the best I've ever had."

"These cupcakes are the best I've ever tasted, especially the frosting."

"I found the cheesecake to be the best I ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers custom cookie shapes and sizes for special orders.

2

Prices start at $20 for three cookies and two cupcakes.

3

The bakery is family-owned and has a friendly atmosphere.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...