Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Colorado

Pepperoni pizza places

You have a specific standard for pepperoni pizza that most places fail to meet.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Phatt Matt's image 1
Phatt Matt's image 2
Phatt Matt's image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Neon sign and outdoor fireplace create a classic local joint vibe with family atmosphere and country music. Hand-tossed crust makes cheesy pepperoni pizza stand out. Menu offers gluten-free options and a popular Jazzy Cheese Steak.

Hand-tossed crust supports the cheesy pepperoni pizza. It pairs well with chicken wings and a Jazzy Cheese Steak option.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and fabulous."

"The takeout pizza here is outstanding and a great price."

"The pepperoni pizza here is delicious and a great price."

Good to know

1

Online ordering at Phatt Matt's is easy and convenient.

2

The prices at Phatt Matt's are reasonable and offer great value.

3

Phatt Matt's has a great variety of gluten-free options available.

02
Pantaleone's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old school spot shines with thin crust pepperoni pizza and authentic Italian dishes. Cozy vibe with a vintage Pac-Man adds charm. Focus on takeout and delivery makes it easy to enjoy unique spaghetti and meatballs at home.

Thin crust stands out on the pepperoni pizza. Both pepperoni and sausage pizzas offer a great flavor.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and amazing."

"The owner Pete is so friendly, he even threw in extra Nutella pizza slices with my takeout."

"I found the pepperoni pizza to be excellent and super delicious."

Good to know

1

Pantaleone's is closed on Sundays.

2

The dining room is closed; only takeout or delivery is available.

3

Website prices may be outdated; check current prices before ordering.

03
DoubleDave's Pizzaworks image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza joint with an open kitchen offers huge slices of pepperoni pizza topped with honey pepperoni for a sweet twist. Bright, fun vibe with TMNT posters and football screens draws a friendly family crowd. Fresh beer complements the homemade sauce perfectly.

Slices come huge and loaded with honey pepperoni that adds a sweet twist. Sauce tastes homemade and pairs well with the rich pepperoni flavor.

People are saying

"The food here is outstanding, hot, crispy, and delicious."

"I found the pizza here to be seriously delicious."

"I think their pepperoni pizza is excellent."

Good to know

1

Mention it's your first visit to receive complimentary pizza rolls with your order.

2

Employees offer a 10% discount for Walmart staff next door.

3

The restaurant has minimal seating, so plan for takeout during peak hours.

04
T-Mama's Pizza Centennial image 1

Pizza spot shines with five vegan cheeses and four sauces for diverse tastes. Large pepperoni pizza packs a jalapeรฑo kick and garlic sauce for bold flavor. Open late, it offers fresh dough in a quiet atmosphere perfect for late-night cravings.

Large pepperoni pizza comes with 12 slices and features jalapeรฑos and garlic sauce for extra flavor. This combination adds a distinctive kick beyond typical pepperoni pizzas.

People are saying

"This pizza's smell is amazing and distinctive."

"I found the vegetarian pizza absolutely delicious."

"The pepperoni pizza here is flavorful with evenly spread toppings."

Good to know

1

T-Mama's Pizza Centennial offers pizza at 2 am, perfect for late-night cravings.

2

They provide five different vegan cheeses and a wide variety of vegan options.

3

The restaurant is open until 3 am on most days.

05
Mountain Mike's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Big dining room with arcade games and big screen TVs offers a laid-back vibe for families and sports fans. Pepperoni pizza features crispy curling pepperoni paired with house-made ranch, making it a tasty, nostalgic treat. Seating blends comfy booths and casual chairs for relaxed socializing.

Curling pepperoni sits atop the pizza, creating a crispy texture that pairs well with their house-made ranch. The pizza arrives looking visually appealing in the box and delivers a satisfying flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was perfect, with fresh ingredients and a perfect crust."

"It's kid friendly with arcade games and prizes."

"I thought this was the best pepperoni pizza I had ever eaten."

Good to know

1

The buffet is only available Monday through Friday.

2

Online ordering is available for quick pickup.

3

Expect a wait if you arrive during peak dinner hours.

06
Upstate Pizzeria image 1
Pizza Takeout

Horseshoe-shaped bar and lively music create a semi-clubhouse vibe with indoor and outdoor seating. Enjoy New York style pizza featuring classic and hot honey pepperoni options. Warehouse-style setting hosts live bands and board games for a fun night out.

Cheese and pepperoni pizzas come with classic toppings and a crispy crust. Options include a hot honey pepperoni and a vegan pepperoni pizza.

People are saying

"The hot wings here were perfect, full of flavor."

"I finally found the best New York Style Pizza in Colorado Springs."

"I heard this place has the best NY pepperoni pizza in town."

Good to know

1

The lunch special includes two slices of your choice plus a soda for around $3.50.

2

Upstate Pizzeria has a full bar available since moving to their new location.

3

They offer unique menu items like pickle pizza and stromboli.

07
Little Caesars Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Fast-food spot serves hot and ready pizzas with fresh, cheesy crusts at great prices. Pepperoni options range from classic to extra toppings for richer flavor. Busy yet clean, it offers quick service and a family-friendly vibe for easy meals.

Regular pepperoni pizza offers solid value with classic flavors. The Bestest Pepperoni pizza features extra toppings and a richer taste. A W pepperoni pizza provides a hearty option after workouts.

People are saying

"The food here is always good and served fast."

"I got some really good bread, hot with lots of butter and cheese."

"I ordered the fanceroni pepperoni pizza with over 100 slices."

Good to know

1

The Deep Dish (Cheese) pizza costs $10.

2

Expect quick service, often faster than 20 minutes.

3

Hot and ready pizzas are available for immediate pickup.

Discover more

Colorado

Area guide
Loading Map...