Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New Haven

Italian food

You are looking for Italian food that honors the craft of the kitchen.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
La Fenice image 1
La Fenice image 2
La Fenice image 3
View all
Coffee shop

Clean space with backlit marble walls sets a cozy mood with Italian music and chatter. Fresh focaccia and bruschetta shine in the Italian menu. Regulars enjoy hand-crafted gelato in a family-run spot loved by locals and students.

Focaccia stands out as fresh and well made, paired with bruschetta that is exceptional. Desserts like shelled tiramisu and Nutella crepes add a sweet touch to the Italian offerings.

People are saying

"I thought the gelato was delicious, especially the unique flavors."

"I had one of the best pastries I've ever tasted."

"This Italian food is authentic and made me want to return."

Good to know

1

The large, medium, and small cups of gelato cost $7.75, $6, and $5 respectively.

2

La Fenice has four salads on the menu, but only one is available.

3

Everything is made in-house, showcasing exceptional ingredients and care.

02
Carmines di Vega image 1

Warm, inviting spot with an old school ambience and large portions that satisfy. Pasta shines with rich sauces like vodka and puttanesca, while chicken parmigiana boasts a thick, flavorful sauce. Weekend Italian singer adds charm to the relaxed vibe.

Pasta dishes feature rich sauces like vodka and puttanesca, with standout options such as penne ala vodka and cavateli alla salisiccie. Chicken parmigiana comes with a thick, flavorful sauce, and bread is served with olive oil and Parmesan as a simple starter.

People are saying

"The food here is outstanding and authentically flavorful."

"The Italian food here is off the hook amazing, especially the pasta."

"The bread here is off the charts good."

Good to know

1

The meal cost $20 for an entrรฉe, which is quite affordable nowadays.

2

The portions are large, often leaving guests with leftovers.

3

Food should never take more than 45 minutes to arrive at a table.

03
Portofino's Restaurant & Bar image 1

Italian restaurant blends an elegant atmosphere with a relaxing vibe and friendly patrons. Lobster ravioli and homemade gnocchi shine on the menu. Seating feels cozy but suits both special occasions and casual visits.

Lobster ravioli stands out as a highlight. Gnocchi and lasagne feature homemade noodles. Penne alla vodka, chicken parmesan, and mussels also appear on the menu.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and perfectly cooked."

"The dinners here are authentic, delicious, and perfectly prepared."

"I had the best lobster ravioli of my life here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for large parties to ensure seating.

2

There is plenty of parking available nearby for guests.

3

The restaurant is on the pricier side, so budget accordingly.

04
Super Sandwich image 1
Sandwich shop

Large sandwich shop offers generous portions with a clean, simple atmosphere. Italian options shine with Chicken Parmesan and Bruschetta sandwiches. Wide vegetarian and vegan choices make it a great spot for varied diets.

Chicken Parmesan sandwich stands out with rich flavor and satisfying texture. Other notable options include Bruschetta and Italiano sandwiches, with the chicken pesto also favored.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are so good and the ingredients are very fresh."

"I paid $15 for a Banh Mi and expected more."

"The Chicken Parmesan sandwich here is unbelievable."

Good to know

1

Super Sandwich is open for only 5 hours a day.

2

Mini sandwiches cost less than $12 for two and a water.

3

Super Sandwich offers a variety of vegetarian and vegan options.

05
Est Est Est Pizza & Restaurant image 1

Small pizza spot offers shrimp pesto pizza and customizable pasta with generous portions. Cozy vibe shines with sports memorabilia and open kitchen where guests watch pizzas made. Prices stay reasonable, making it a casual, family-friendly choice.

Shrimp pesto pizza and chicken broccoli pasta stand out with generous portions and homemade mozzarella sticks. Pasta dishes come with customizable options and reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be fresh, flavorful, and delicious."

"I loved the pasta here; the portions were huge and fresh."

"The Italian food here, especially the pesto pasta, is amazing."

Good to know

1

Prices are affordable, with pizzas starting around $10.

2

The restaurant offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

3

Expect large portion sizes that are great for sharing.

06
Amity Brick Oven Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Brick oven creates a cozy ambiance in a deli-style space with custom wood. Penne alla Vodka shines with perfect vodka sauce coating al dente pasta. Thin, crispy crust pizza and chicken parmigiana offer classic Italian flavors in a well-organized setting.

Penne alla Vodka stands out with its vodka sauce perfectly coating al dente penne pasta. Chicken parmigiana and cheese pizza with bread knots also feature as popular Italian dishes here.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was thin, crispy, and cooked to perfection."

"The Penne alla Vodka's creamy tomato sauce had a unique depth."

"This Italian food's creamy tomato sauce had a unique depth."

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes by 8:10 PM, despite stated hours until 9:00 PM.

2

Prices are reasonable, with an X-Large pizza only $1 more than a Large.

3

They have a large menu with many options, including pizza by the slice.

07
Yorkside Pizza & Restaurant image 1

Old building with classic pizza parlor feel offers a cozy spot filled with Yale memorabilia. Oven-baked pasta and fettuccine alfredo shine alongside handmade baklava. Laid back vibe suits students and families, though it gets noisy when crowded.

Oven-baked pasta comes out piping hot and pairs well with handmade baklava. The pizza, pasta, and calamari stand out, especially the fettuccine alfredo and spaghetti with meatballs.

People are saying

"I thought their pizza was the best I've ever tried."

"The staff here is so friendly and accommodating for kids."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta with meatballs, is gargantuan."

Good to know

1

Slices cost $3.50 each with a topping, a good deal compared to New York.

2

Reservations are recommended for large parties, especially during graduation weekends.

3

The restaurant automatically adds an 18% tip to your bill.

08
Koolbreeze Jamerican Cuisine Restaurant image 1

Small, intimate space with a cozy layout and a bar creates a warm vibe. Old school Reggae music adds a relaxed atmosphere. Rasta pasta shines with rich flavor and flexible options like shrimp and oxtail, blending Italian food with a unique twist.

Rasta pasta stands out with its rich flavor and holds up well even the next day. Variations include options like added shrimp and oxtail, showing some flexibility in the dish.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, fresh, and served hot."

"The staff here is so welcoming and kind."

"The Rasta pasta here is fantastic, I ordered it again."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the lot next door, not in front of the restaurant.

2

Lunch specials are offered daily, providing good value.

3

Happy hour is a great time to visit for discounted drinks.

09
Casanova image 1
Italian restaurant

Classic Italian charm meets house-made pasta and Cioppino Seafood Stew in a cozy, elegant space. Unique pizzas with fig and prosciutto add flair while the vibe stays relaxed and feels like being in Italy.

House-made pasta stands out with dishes like Caramelle pasta and corn ravioli. Seafood shines in the Cioppino Seafood Stew over spaghetti with lobster tail and shellfish. Pizzas feature unique toppings like fig, prosciutto, arugula, and Tartufo Nero. Desserts include a light, creamy tiramisu.

People are saying

"The Italian Food desserts, especially the tiramisu, were light, creamy, and just right."

"The pasta here is full of flavor and perfectly cooked."

"The Cioppino seafood stew was outstanding with lobster, mussels, and shrimp."

Good to know

1

Bringing a cake incurs an additional charge for serving and plates.

2

The menu does not clearly communicate the prices of extras.

3

The restaurant is small, which may be uncomfortable for groups larger than four.

10
South Bay Mediterranean Kitchen image 1

Modern space with charming decor and jazz music creates a relaxed vibe. Seafood risotto and scallops shine in Italian dishes, alongside praised pasta like fettuccine and bolognese. Spot suits casual lunches and relaxed dinners for groups and couples.

Seafood risotto and scallops stand out with rich flavors. Pasta dishes like fettuccine, bolognese, and tagliatelle come highly praised for their taste and quality.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the melt-in-your-mouth steak."

"The service at these dinner spots is friendly and attentive."

"The pasta dishes here are fantastic, especially the bolognese and tagliatelle."

Good to know

1

The $25 lunch deal offers great value for a full meal.

2

Happy hour runs on Fridays with special drink prices.

3

The restaurant validates parking tickets for the garage across the street.

11
Town House Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza shines with crispy dough and a cheese pull that satisfies. Fries are on point and grinders come with flavorful marinara and soft meatballs. Cash-only and recyclable boxes keep the vibe simple and eco-friendly.

Marinara sauce stands out as flavorful. Pizza options include bacon mozzarella and pineapple. Parmesan cheese and ranch dressing each cost an extra dollar.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious."

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the pizza."

Good to know

1

Town House Pizza only accepts cash for payment.

2

The grinder costs $15 and does not come with fries.

12
Siena Ristorante New Haven image 1

Italian bistro offers intimate dining with a rooftop area for lively vibes. Pasta like bolognese with pappardelle shines alongside creative dishes such as squid ink fettuccine. Cozy, dim lighting sets a warm mood for enjoying classic and inventive flavors.

Pasta dishes like bolognese with pappardelle and lamb sugo stand out for their flavor. Creative dishes such as squid ink fettuccine and iberico pork belly show care in preparation and service.

People are saying

"The pasta dishes here are excellent, especially the spicy rigatoni."

"The cocktails were unique, tasty, and presented beautifully."

"The Italian food here is served with such charming and attentive service."

Good to know

1

On Mondays, they have 50% off all wine bottles.

2

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating.

3

Valet parking is not available; use nearby garages instead.

Discover more

New Haven, Connecticut

Area guide
Loading Map...