Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Illinois' best

Cake and cookie spots

You are looking for a place that understands the specific joy of a well-made cookie and a decadent slice of cake.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Bake It with Tina - Custom Cookies & Custom Cakes image 1
Bake It with Tina - Custom Cookies & Custom Cakes image 2
Bake It with Tina - Custom Cookies & Custom Cakes image 3
View all

Custom cookie and cake shop operates from an in-home setup with no seating. Creations feature intricate designs and creative decorations that serve as edible art. The atmosphere centers on personalized, detailed craftsmanship with treats that are both beautiful and delicious.

Cakes feature gorgeous florals and creative custom designs that serve as stunning centerpieces. Flavors like lemon and cannoli taste fantastic and pair well with the beautiful decorations.

Cookies come out beautifully decorated with attention to detail on small accents that make each one a piece of art. They taste absolutely delicious and stay soft for days after baking.

People are saying

"These custom cookies are gorgeous and delicious!"

"The custom cookies and smash cakes are adorable and delicious for kids' parties."

"This cake is gorgeous and tasted divine."

Good to know

1

Ordering and delivery from Bake It with Tina is easy and straightforward.

2

Custom cookie orders require at least one week's notice for best results.

3

All cookies are made fresh and can be customized to fit any theme.

02
Bliss Eggless Cookies image 1

Cookie shop offers soft, chewy textures with eggless options that appeal to all ages. Flavors range from chocolate chip to fudge-filled varieties, each crafted with care and high-quality ingredients. Presentation is neat, and packaging suits gifting.

Soft, moist texture defines the eggless dark chocolate and coconut cake, with rich chocolate and a perfect coconut twist. The cookie cake offers a wonderful flavor and comes at a reasonable price.

Soft, fresh cookies come in eggless options that kids enjoy. Flavors like Nutella, Raspberry white chocolate macadamia, and chocolate chip offer a delicious twist on classics with perfect texture and sweetness.

People are saying

"These egg free cookies are soft, gooey, and dangerously delicious."

"The chocolate chip cookies are moist, chewy, and bursting with rich chocolate."

"These eggless cookies are the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

There are multiple eggless options available.

2

It is easy to order and pick up.

3

Prices are reasonable for all cookie varieties.

03
Spill The Beans image 1
Coffee shop

Large open space with high ceilings and natural light creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. The café balances light and dark decor to invite relaxation and productivity. It serves as a community spot where people socialize, work, and enjoy unique touches like coffee ice cubes.

Lemon pound cake stands out for its moist texture and addictive flavor. Homemade cakes and cookies also appear alongside other dishes.

Butter cookies have a homemade texture and melt in your mouth quality. They stand out among other baked goods like cakes and wraps.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be delicious and phenomenal."

"This pound cake is so moist and delicious."

"I arrived a stranger and left feeling like family."

Good to know

1

Spill The Beans offers house-made food and beverages in a cozy setting.

2

The cafe is located on Chicago Avenue in the Austin neighborhood.

3

Parking is available on the street near the cafe.

04
Seedo’s Levantine Bakery image 1

Clean, organized bakery with seating offers a fully halal menu featuring unique Palestinian baked goods. The atmosphere holds a great vibe with fresh, flavorful options like pistachio croissants and distinctive sandwiches. It serves as a healthy lunch and breakfast spot with a welcoming, accessible layout.

Cakes feature a punchy lemon flavor with cream and a subtle labneh tang. A hibiscus glaze adds a balanced sweetness that complements the cake well.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a rich, classic flavor. Peanut butter cookies come with unique twists like tahini and jam for added depth.

People are saying

"I loved the date cake; it was rich and tasty."

"I found the lentil soup to be warming and flavorful."

"This cookie is so fresh and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The bakery is fully halal, catering to dietary restrictions.

2

Parking is limited and is paid street parking nearby.

3

Expect to find high-quality organic ingredients in all menu items.

05
Milk Cake Bakery image 1

Cafe space combines chic, stylish vibe with cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Decor is beautiful, modern, and charming, creating a welcoming environment. Desserts stand out as unique and highly praised for quality and flavor.

Cakes here are fresh and beautifully made with unique flavors like the Dubai chocolate cake. The ice cream cake stands out as a memorable dessert with incredible taste.

Skillet cookies come warm and gooey with rich flavors like Nutella and Lotus biscoff. The cookie skillet stands out as a favorite, often praised for its perfect texture and taste.

People are saying

"The desserts here are phenomenal and very good."

"I tasted the best cakes I ever had here."

"The skillet cookie is warm, gooey, and delicious perfection."

Good to know

1

They charge $12 for a small piece of cake.

2

Milk Cake Bakery offers a variety of desserts, milkshakes, and pastries.

3

Expect a wait time of 15-30 minutes during peak hours.

06
Bocaditos Café image 1
Restaurant

Patio space offers cozy atmosphere with pretty decor and adorable seating. Energy feels relaxed and inviting, though loud conversations can disrupt quiet moments. Empanadas stand out as a distinctive culinary highlight.

Custom cakes come in various styles and flavors, crafted with care. The cookie cake dipped in chocolate with dulce de leche stands out, along with the pionono, a sponge cake layered with caramel and shaved coconut.

Cookies come with dulce de leche in various forms, like in alfajores and shortbread sandwich cookies. Coconut and chocolate dipped cookie cakes also stand out as sweet treats.

People are saying

"I found the empanadas to be the best I had ever tasted."

"The empanadas were flaky, flavorful, and fresh."

"Juliana's custom cakes are the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 20-30 minutes during peak lunch hours.

2

The café offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

3

Prices range from $10 to $15 for most dishes.

07
Beanokio Cafe image 1
Coffee shop

Small space with bar seating and natural light creates a cozy atmosphere. Chill background music and a dog-friendly policy add to the welcoming vibe. Modern touches blend with a bright, charming interior.

Multi-layered Honey Cake offers a subtle honey taste with balanced sweetness. Other notable cakes include Pistachio Milk Cake, Salted Caramel Shaken Espresso, and Biscoff Cheese Cake served in convenient jars.

Cookies come in big chunks with flavors like Oreo, marshmallow, and Nutella almond. The Biscoff cookie stands out as decadent and delicious alongside Turkish Coffee options.

People are saying

"The coffee here is delicious in this cute, cozy spot."

"The pistachio cheesecake is amazing and a must-try."

"You have to try their Biscoff cookie; it's the best dessert I had."

Good to know

1

Beanokio Cafe is open from 7 AM to 7 PM, but closes from 10:30 AM to 3:30 PM for shopping, cooking, and baking.

2

Staff informed me that they will soon carry zabiha halal options.

3

Many alternative menu options were inclusive of dietary needs.

08
Pie, Pie My Darling image 1

Bakery space combines cozy vibes with a grab-and-go setup and a perfect aesthetic. Vegan cakes and sweets taste fresh and traditional, impressing even non-vegan palates. Pricing leans toward the higher side but matches the exceptional quality of baked goods.

Cakes here are incredible and often described as the best ever tasted, vegan or not. Flavors like red velvet, banana split, strawberry, and rainbow stand out for their unique and delicious taste.

Soft and flavorful cookies stand out here, especially the Chocolate Chip Cookie and NutterButter slices. A rotating menu offers a variety of cookie options alongside cakes and cupcakes.

People are saying

"These dairy-free cakes are the best I've ever tasted."

"These desserts are insanely delicious and blew me away."

"I've never tasted a better cake, vegan or not."

Good to know

1

Everything at the bakery is vegan, making it suitable for those with dairy or egg allergies.

2

The bakery offers a rotating menu of cake flavors, cupcakes, and cookies each month.

3

Pre-ordering is recommended to secure your favorite items, as they can sell out quickly.

09
The Prospect image 1
Restaurant

Modern restaurant offers a luxurious city vibe with top-notch interior design and a gorgeous outdoor terrace featuring a private bar and downtown views. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, blending trendy energy with a clean, bright space. Popular spot draws lively crowds, especially on weekend evenings.

Milk Chocolate Mousse Cake and cheesecake offer satisfying portions and rich flavors. The brown butter cake was a standout dessert that is no longer available.

Cookie skillet and cookie a la mode stand out with rich flavors. Desserts like the chocolate caramel Swiss roll and Valentine’s cheesecake also pair well with the cookie options.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here have perfectly cooked proteins and delicious, well-seasoned sides."

"The chocolate mousse cake was truly exceptional."

"The cookie a la mode came with a generous helping of ice cream."

Good to know

1

The upstairs space is ideal for private events and celebrations.

2

Brunch is served on Sundays from 11am to 2:30pm.

3

Happy hour features outstanding oysters and drinks on Sundays.

10
Simply Sweet Caroline's image 1

Custom cookies showcase exquisite decoration and detailed designs with vibrant colors and metallic accents. The atmosphere is friendly and professional, with a smooth ordering process and reliable service. Cookies are individually sealed, making them convenient for travel and special occasions.

Cookie cakes stand out with their amazing taste and adorable appearance. Guests often rave about their flavor, especially the sugar cookies and cookie cakes.

Cookies come beautifully decorated and individually sealed for easy transport. Custom designs match inspiration photos perfectly, making them a hit at birthdays and showers.

People are saying

"The cookies here are beautiful and delicious."

"These cookies are adorable and delicious, a real hit for kids."

"I had cookie cakes made for our wedding weekend."

Good to know

1

The ordering process is easy and smooth for custom cookies.

2

Caroline offers cookie designs that can match your event theme.

3

Cookies are individually sealed for convenient transport.

11
The Drip Bakery By Chef Ced image 1

Bright, inviting bakery with a beautiful setup and diverse desserts like cheesecakes and peach cobbler pound cake. Energy feels warm and community-oriented, with a focus on Black-owned local business pride. Customers often seek out specialty cakes and cupcakes known for unique flavors and quality.

Cakes here are soft, moist, and delicious with flavors like pineapple coconut, strawberry crunch pound, and caramel drip. Chef Ced ensures cakes look beautiful and delivers them on time, even for last-minute birthday orders.

Butter cookies have a rich, nostalgic flavor that stands out. Pecan lunchroom cookies come highly recommended by Chef Ced and are popular enough to be eaten quickly.

People are saying

"I loved the strawberry crunch pound cake; it was so good."

"The cheesecakes here are ridiculously rich and delicious."

"Chef Ced helped me get the pecan cookies."

Good to know

1

The Oreo drip cake costs $80.

2

The bakery is black owned and local.

3

The owner is not always open at the specified times.

12
YSG Dessert Bar image 1
Dessert restaurant

Cozy dessert bar with bright, clean decor and a friendly, inviting atmosphere. Offers a varied menu including unique desserts and savory options with reasonable prices. Known for a chill vibe and a community-oriented feel.

Mango cake offers a heavenly taste with a hefty portion that feeds a large group. The yema cheese cake is soft, creamy, and receives many compliments at celebrations. The ube cake is visually gorgeous, delicious, and priced well.

Red Velvet Cookie stands out with rich flavor. Other options include s'mores cookie, Oreo cheesecake, and ube cookie offering unique tastes.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and tasty."

"This ube cake is beautiful and utterly delicious."

"I loved the ube cookie and ube iced latte."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of about 10 minutes during busy weekends.

2

The dessert portions are large enough to share among several people.

3

The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness.

13
Lily's Cakes & Bakes image 1

Custom cakes feature space-themed designs that match provided photos exactly, combining moist texture with rich flavor. Pre-wrapped cookies and cupcakes offer adorable, tasty options. Ordering and delivery processes run smoothly with clear instructions and timely service.

Cakes come out exactly like the photo provided, with flavorful and beautiful designs. Custom orders like two-tier and peekaboo cakes arrive on time and match the vision perfectly.

Custom cookies come pre-wrapped with detailed designs that suit events like birthdays and company meetings. These cookies are both delicious and visually appealing.

People are saying

"I will order every birthday cake from here; you will not be sorry."

"These cupcakes are adorable and delicious, just like the pictures!"

"This cake is so moist and delicious."

Good to know

1

The payment process is easy via the web.

2

The ordering process is straightforward.

3

Delivery options are very convenient.

14
Steel City Bakery image 1

Cupcakes and cookies come in wide range of flavors with options like vegan and gluten-free. Cakes often feature custom edible art tailored to personal requests. The atmosphere suits celebrations, with treats that appeal to both kids and adults.

Custom cakes come out exactly as requested, including vegan and gluten-free options. Delivery is flexible, and designs can be detailed or simple with personalized images like characters or faces.

Cookies feature oatmeal walnut raisin, lemon white chocolate, and double chocolate chip varieties. These options offer rich flavors and a satisfying texture.

People are saying

"I ordered a custom cake and it was complete, tasty, and exactly what my kiddo wanted."

"This cake was amazing and so tasty."

"I've never had cookies this amazing before."

Good to know

1

Cupcakes are priced around $5 each.

2

Steel City Bakery offers a wide range of flavors.

3

Advance orders are recommended for large quantities.

15
Andrea Cake Artist by Mamine Krofnice and Yummy Bites Catering image 1

Cake shop showcases beautifully detailed decoration that makes sweets look like true works of art. Warm and welcoming atmosphere invites guests to enjoy high-quality, custom cakes with unmatched taste and originality. Cakes often serve as showstoppers for special occasions, combining stunning design with delicious flavor.

Cakes come with custom decorations and fresh, soft texture. Nutella-raspberry and other flavors balance sweetness well and taste delicious.

Delicious cookies stand out alongside cakes and crepes. Fasting cookies offer a unique, tasty option.

People are saying

"I highly recommend Andrea's cakes; they're stunning and delicious."

"The cakes for birthday parties here are perfect, tasting and looking amazing."

"I found the fasting cookies to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Custom cake orders require at least one week notice for best results.

2

Prices for custom cakes start at $50, depending on size and design.

3

The bakery offers a variety of gluten-free and vegan options upon request.

16
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop offers a clean and bright environment with a strong fresh cookie smell. The atmosphere feels welcoming and cute, often busy with people. Weekly changing cookie flavors add a unique variety to the experience.

Tres leches cake stands out with its rich, moist texture. Mini cakes and cookies like raspberry butter cake and pumpkin caramel cake offer a sweet, gooey experience with excellent icings.

Cookies here have a rich flavor and come out perfectly baked every time. They offer a delicious variety that leaves a strong impression.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were really good and fresh."

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I loved all the cookies; they were delicious."

Good to know

1

Crumbl offers new cookie options every week.

2

Online ordering is fast and easy through their app.

3

Curbside pickup is quick and convenient.

17
Oak Park Bakery Inc image 1

Small bakery offers fresh baked goods daily with a focus on old-style recipes and seasonal items. Atmosphere is quiet and cozy, with a bench outside for enjoying treats. Popular for Polish Pączki and other traditional pastries, it closes early after selling out most days.

Cakes come with soft textures and fresh fruit fillings like raspberry and strawberry. Options include carrot cake, German chocolate, and coffee cakes with cherry or plum flavors.

Large selection of cookies stands out alongside morning sweets and cakes. Cookies often come in holiday varieties and pair well with small pies or donuts.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be so fresh and delicious."

"I live an hour away just to get their awesome cookies."

"I thought their Polish Pączki from the bakery were the best."

Good to know

1

Fresh bread is only available on Fridays and Saturdays.

2

You have to call ahead if you want a Danish.

3

The Polish Pączki sometimes run out, so stop by earlier in the day.

18
City Skyline Chicago - Coffee Lounge image 1

Coffee lounge features aviation-themed decor with real plane seats, cockpit dashboards, and airplane parts used as furniture. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, suitable for reading, working, or chatting quietly. Space welcomes dogs and offers varied seating with some plugs for charging devices.

Honey cake with blueberries stands out as a homemade flavor. Cocoa honey cake and Honey Roll cake with blueberry offer rich, sweet options alongside pastries like chocolate croissants.

A chocolate chip cookie sits on the coffee lid, and a small cookie comes with the coffee. The cookie tastes great.

People are saying

"This cafe's aviation theme and decor are super unique and cute."

"I loved the honey cake with blueberries; it tasted homemade."

"This place's Cookie is adorable and clever."

Good to know

1

The lounge is open until 6 PM daily.

2

Parking is limited in the area.

3

The coffee shop is dog-friendly.

19
Tony Cannoli image 1
Pastry shop

Tiny storefront focuses exclusively on fresh homemade cannolis with a crispy shell and creamy fillings made to order. Atmosphere is simple and functional, with a small outdoor seating area for enjoying desserts. The shop attracts those seeking authentic, high-quality sweets without dine-in distractions.

Cannoli cake stands out with its light and fluffy texture. It draws strong reactions and high demand, often chosen for birthdays and parties.

Lemon cookies stand out with a bright, tasty flavor. Cookie sandwiches and truffles add variety to the sweet options.

People are saying

"I'd fly back just to have their cannoli."

"I thought the cannolis looked amazing and were consistently delicious."

"The cannoli filling was so smooth and creamy."

Good to know

1

Parking is not available in this area.

2

Tony Cannoli is not an eat-in restaurant.

3

They offer assorted boxes of cannoli.

20
Gather Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with an open, sunlit space and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Features a small kids play area that entertains children while adults enjoy fresh pastries and coffee. The environment feels friendly and relaxed, making it easy to linger and chat.

Chocolate eclair cake features crispy layers, cream, and chocolate in perfect balance. Croissants and cinnamon cake also appear alongside fantastic chocolate cake offerings.

Frosted sugar cookies come in adorable designs and taste delicious. Custom cookies for events like graduations and baby showers impress with their freshness and flavor.

People are saying

"Their cookies are soft, flavorful, and absolutely to die for."

"I found the croissants to be divine and delicious."

"The chocolate eclair cake is insanely delicious."

Good to know

1

Gather Bakery offers cookie decorating events for all ages.

2

The bakery makes their products fresh daily.

3

Gather Bakery has vegan bread options available.

21
Geneva Baking Company image 1

Elegant bakery space offers beautifully crafted cakes and creative designs that serve as stunning centerpieces. Atmosphere feels refined and meticulously clean, attracting celebrations like weddings and birthdays. Staff delivers precise timing and consistent quality, making it a reliable choice for special events.

Custom cakes come with beautiful designs and delicious flavors like lemon and raspberry filling. Delivery and special requests, including gluten free options, are handled with care and attention.

Creative cookies come in custom designs like Mahjong themes and wedding crests. Each cookie is carefully wrapped and delivered on time, with flavors that match their charming looks.

People are saying

"Theresa made my dream cake and handled all the planning."

"These wedding desserts were beautiful and delicious."

"Theresa's custom cookies are gorgeous and creative works of art."

Good to know

1

Custom cake orders require at least one week's notice.

2

The bakery offers gluten-free options for most baked goods.

3

Delivery services are available for orders over $50.

22
Azucar & Canela image 1

Bright pink building creates a cheerful atmosphere with a cute, authentic vibe inside. Bakery draws a crowd seeking moist, flavorful cakes and perfect conchas, offering a fresh take on Mexican pastries. Energy feels welcoming and lively, making it a standout spot in the neighborhood.

Cakes here are moist, flavorful, and beautifully decorated. Staff help with design, size, and flavors, delivering gorgeous, delicious cakes quickly and at reasonable prices.

Cookies offer a perfect balance of soft and chewy texture with rich, homemade flavor. Chocolate Chip and Peanut Butter varieties deliver a flavor symphony with just the right sweetness.

People are saying

"The cakes here are gorgeous and taste amazing."

"I loved everything from this bakery, especially the mini cakes and cookies."

"These cookies are so delicious, they melt in your mouth."

Good to know

1

They are not open on Sundays.

2

The bakery sells some day-old pastries at a discounted price.

3

Expect a variety of baked goods, including Mexican pastries.

23
Chocolat Uzma image 1
Chocolate shop

Small, neat chocolate shop offers handcrafted chocolates with unique South Asian flavors and bold, intense dark chocolate. Cozy atmosphere complements well-curated, exquisite treats like flourless cake and rich brownies. Customers find it a specialty destination for high-quality, artisanal sweets.

Flourless chocolate cake stands out with rich, dense texture and deep cocoa flavor. The cake pairs well with spicy cocoa for a bold dessert experience.

Warm, gooey chocolate chip cookies come with rich chocolate chunks and a perfect balance of crisp edges and soft centers. They pair well with hot chocolate and offer a satisfying, indulgent treat.

People are saying

"The handcrafted chocolates here are exquisite and unique."

"The chocolates here have unique flavors, like Kala Namak Caramel."

"These chocolate chip cookies are warm, gooey, and studded with rich chocolate chunks."

Good to know

1

Chocolat Uzma offers unique flavors inspired by South Asian traditions.

2

Prices are around $12 for four chocolates, which may be considered high.

3

Almond milk options are available for drinks.

24
Haylie B's Bakery image 1

Shop offers a thoughtful elegant design with a comfy couch perfect for photos. Atmosphere feels immaculate and inviting. Known for custom cakes and cupcakes that impress with taste and decoration, orders require advance planning due to high demand.

Cakes feature amazing detail and match exactly what is wanted. The vegan lemon cake stands out for its beautiful look and delicious taste, with frosting that blends well and a perfect citrus tartness.

Cookies come fresh from a small, local bakery with options for smaller sizes. The s'mores cookies stand out as rich, gooey, and full of flavor. Cupcakes and cookies consistently please crowds.

People are saying

"Haylie was so professional and creative with my cake."

"These cookies are delicious, rich, and gooey."

"The desserts here looked like art and tasted even better."

Good to know

1

Advance notice of a few weeks is needed due to high demand.

2

The bakery often sells out quickly, especially on weekends.

3

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

25
Believe Cakes image 1
Cake shop

Cake shop offers custom-designed treats with beautiful decoration and delicious flavors. Classes provide beginner-friendly, fun, and therapeutic experiences suitable for many ages. Events often feature themed cakes and edible art that impress guests.

Cakes come in custom shapes like croissants, salad bowls, and minions with edible details. They taste moist and delicious, often impressing guests and matching party themes perfectly.

Cookie decorating classes offer a fun and therapeutic experience with delicious, beautifully done cookies. Custom cookies come quickly and impress with their stunning designs and great taste.

People are saying

"I found the cookie decorating class to be fun and informative."

"I was blown away by how realistic and beautiful the custom cake looked."

"They do amazing, creative cakes for kid-friendly birthdays."

Good to know

1

The cookie decorating class is suitable for all ages and skill levels.

2

All tools and ingredients are provided for the cookie decorating class.

3

Classes are interactive and designed to be fun and engaging.

26
Shalom Kosher Bakery image 1

Bakery offers fresh bagels, soft challah, and rich chocolate pastries with options free of nuts, dairy, and eggs. Busy atmosphere reflects its popularity, with warm owners contributing to a welcoming vibe. Prices remain reasonable, encouraging frequent visits.

Chocolate coffee cake features a soft and fluffy texture with a chocolate swirl inside. Birthday cakes come out absolutely perfect, and chocolate chip fudge alligator coffee cake appears regularly.

Cookies come dairy and nut free, making them light and easy to enjoy. Chocolate chip varieties taste balanced, not too sweet or bland, and frozen cookies offer a different texture to try.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the best I've ever had."

"The chocolate coffee cake is amazing, soft, and fluffy inside."

"This cookie was really good, not too sweet or bland."

Good to know

1

Bring cash when visiting as credit cards may not be accepted.

2

The bakery offers egg and dairy-free items for those with restrictions.

3

Expect the bakery to be very busy, especially during peak hours.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...