Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Illinois

Coffee cake and cookie spots

Coffee cake that holds its own alongside a fresh cookie instead of just filling space in the display case.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Peterson's Tasty Delight Bakery image 1
Peterson's Tasty Delight Bakery image 2
Peterson's Tasty Delight Bakery image 3
View all

Family-owned bakery offers old school charm with a focus on fresh doughnuts and a variety of baked goods like muffins, cookies, and cakes. Atmosphere is quick and efficient with a steady flow of customers, reflecting its status as a local staple for over 30 years. Pricing is fair but sometimes inconsistent between in-store and online listings.

Coffee cakes come out super rich and addicting with a fresh taste that stands out among other baked goods.

Cookies come out fresh and delicious alongside pies and coffee cakes. They share shelf space with donuts and muffins, all baked with consistent quality.

People are saying

"These donuts are the best I've ever had."

"The coffee cakes here are always fresh and delicious."

"The cookies here are always fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a quick in and out experience even during busy hours.

2

The cake can be ready for pickup the next day.

3

Prices in-store may differ from those listed on the website.

02
Schlegl's Bakery & Cafe image 1

Bakery offers beautiful presentation and in-house freshness with top-quality pastries like coffee cakes, strudels, and specialty Danish. Atmosphere feels unwelcoming due to staff disinterest. Prices run high, reflecting premium quality but may deter some.

Coffee cakes come fresh and high quality with a focus on chocolate varieties. They offer excellent taste and represent a great value compared to other baked goods.

Cookies come in a solid assortment including pecan and large chocolate chip varieties. They have a good consistency and taste, fitting well with other baked goods like donuts and pastries.

People are saying

"I thought this was the greatest bakery in the USA."

"I thought their pecan cookies were out of this world."

"I found the coffee cakes to be amazing and an excellent deal."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers Paczkis around Fat Tuesday.

2

Cake slices cost between $3.50 and $10 each.

3

Parking can be tight, especially for larger vehicles.

03
Kirschbaum's Bakery image 1

Classic bakery atmosphere fills the air with warm cinnamon scent and homemade from scratch baked goods. Crowds gather early for exceptional donuts and pastries, reflecting a strong local tradition and community presence. Ordering ahead is common to secure favorites like tea cookies and coffee cakes.

Coffee cakes come in a variety of flavors like cinnamon nut, raspberry, blueberry, and chocolate. They taste homemade and delicious, with each one often better than the last.

Smiley face cookies stand out with their nostalgic charm and consistent quality. Tea cookies come in generous assortments and are highly recommended for their homemade taste.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best local bakery around."

"I was obsessed with the smiley face cookies."

"I thought their chocolate coffee cake was a must-have."

Good to know

1

Order ahead online to ensure your favorite items are available.

2

Expect crowds, especially on weekends and mornings.

3

The bakery offers a wide selection of baked goods, including donuts and pies.

04
Lilac Bakery image 1

Small space with a wholesome family feel and a small town hello neighbor vibe. Offers fresh baked goods with exceptional donuts and pastries that stand out in the area. Prices lean reasonable, and the bakery maintains a strong connection to the neighborhood.

Cardamom coffee cake stands out with a unique spice that adds warmth. The coffee cake and cake donuts pair well, offering a soft, sweet treat often chosen for special occasions.

Cookies come in cute designs and include smiley faces and edible images. They taste sweet and are often described as scrumptious.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts here were delicious."

"I found this to be the best bakery around."

"I especially enjoyed the coffee cakes."

Good to know

1

The cinnamon rolls are usually only available on Saturdays unless pre-ordered.

2

Prices are reasonable for the quality of baked goods offered.

3

The bakery offers a variety of desserts and breads to choose from.

05
Pticekโ€™s & Son Bakery image 1

Old-world style bakery offers a comforting, homey atmosphere with freshly baked pastries and classic desserts like cheesecakes and kolackys. Early visits reveal the best selection before popular items run out. Family-run operation maintains traditional quality and recipes passed through generations.

Cheese coffee cake and Potica, the Slovenian Coffee Cake, are available here. Coffee cakes often feature apple filling, though the amount can vary from what staff describe.

Cookies come in a very delicious variety with some being light and airy like the old-fashioned butter cookies with sprinkles. Almond chocolate and dream cookies stand out, and many are decorative.

People are saying

"The coffee cakes here are always amazing."

"Their cookies are so light they feel like they're gonna float away."

"I was so happy to find their Slovenian Coffee Cake tastes almost like homemade."

Good to know

1

Arrive early to get the best selection of pastries before they run out.

2

The bakery has been family-operated since 1943, ensuring quality and tradition.

3

All items are made fresh daily and never frozen.

06
Misericordia's Hearts & Flour Bakery and Cafe image 1

Glass walls reveal bakers at work in a clean, modern space with natural light and varied seating including couches and chairs. The atmosphere stays cozy and quiet, welcoming for work or casual chats. A drive-thru adds convenience to this neighborhood cafe.

Varieties include strawberry, caramel and pecan, and orange and raspberry streusel. Coffee cakes come in many flavors and styles. They work well for taking home or grabbing to go.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their rich flavor and perfect texture. Shortbread cookies offer a buttery, dense bite that pairs well with tea or on their own.

People are saying

"The chocolate croissant was buttery with a perfect balance."

"I'd come back just for the chocolate chip cookie; it's one of the best."

"I grabbed a delicious coffee cake to take home."

Good to know

1

They close early at 4pm.

2

They have a drive-thru for quick service.

3

Parking is available at the bakery.

07
Weber's Bakery image 1

Old school bakery with a cozy atmosphere and warm, inviting aromas of fresh dough and cinnamon. Space feels small and crowded, creating a lively and sometimes loud environment. Known for superb donuts and cakes, it draws steady crowds throughout the day.

Strawberry coffee cake stands out with its amazing flavor and nostalgic taste. Chocolate and cherry cheese varieties also impress with rich textures and affordable prices under 10 dollars.

Cookies come in several varieties including almond crescents and almond horn cookies. They taste great and pair well with morning donuts and pastries.

People are saying

"This bakery is the best I've ever visited."

"You have to try their great tasting cookies; the cookies are a wonderland."

"I thought the strawberry coffee cake was phenomenal."

Good to know

1

They close at 5pm and are sold out of apple pies so early in the day.

2

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Parking is limited, so consider arriving early or using public transport.

08
Wood Bakery image 1

Wall of donuts and case of cookies create a homey atmosphere with a popular local vibe. Donuts sell out quickly, attracting those seeking fresh, varied flavors and made-to-order cakes. Prices remain reasonable, making it a staple for baked goods in the area.

Gooey butter coffee cake stands out with its gooey texture and option to add extra powdered sugar. Varieties include peanut coffee cake and nut-free versions, alongside other baked goods like strudels and mini cakes.

Cookies come with white icing and vary from little cookies that range from OK to very good, to bear-shaped cookies. The iced sugar cookies stand out alongside other sweets like butter gooey cakes.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the donuts; they were some of the freshest I've had."

"I loved their donuts; they were so fresh and delicious."

"Their coffee cakes are great, especially the gooey butter ones."

Good to know

1

The donuts sell out quickly, so arrive early to avoid disappointment.

2

Wood Bakery offers a wide variety of baked goods including cakes, pastries, and donuts.

3

There is convenient parking right in front of the bakery.

09
Loaves & Witches image 1
Coffee shop

Space blends witchy cozy magic with eccentric styling and light macabre touches, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Comfortable seating includes outdoor options, with tarot decks and card activities available on tables. Energy feels positive and lively, attracting a community-oriented crowd.

Coffee cake here has a great look and pairs well with a latte. It tastes excellent and feels fantastic to eat.

Chocolate chip cookies have a strong flavor and the lemon cookie is soft with a simple taste.

People are saying

"The coffee here is delicious, well-balanced, and made with quality beans."

"I thought the coffee cake here was amazing."

"The lemon cookie was divine and soft."

Good to know

1

They host community events regularly, including artsy and inclusive gatherings.

2

A knitting group and succulent planting event are examples of their unique activities.

3

Seating can be limited during busy times, especially on weekends.

10
DeEtta's Bakery image 1

Carry-out bakery fills the air with real butter and vanilla scents instead of typical donut or coffee smells. Energy feels quiet and focused, with a hint of annoyance from staff. Donuts appear only on weekends, and items sell out quickly, creating a sense of urgency for early arrival.

Rich and substantial pecan coffee cake stands out with a heavier texture. The almond coffee cake offers a delicious option but is limited in availability. Some coffee cakes, like the strawberry, can be overly sweet and lack softness.

Cookies come in perfectly soft yet crunchy textures, especially the chocolate chip with sea salt and oatmeal varieties. Designs on cookies are highly detailed and decorative, delighting kids and adults alike.

People are saying

"I thought this bakery was the best."

"The cookies here are amazing and super yummy."

"I found the Coffee Cake to be the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

DeEtta's Bakery is carry out only and has no dine-in options.

2

Donuts are only available Friday to Sunday.

3

Expect long lines and crowds on weekends and holidays.

11
House Of Cakes image 1

Bakery offers fresh baked goods with an impressive variety of cakes, pastries, and breads. Atmosphere feels chill and energetic, attracting those who appreciate cash-only transactions and classic treats like cheese sticks and coffee cakes.

Cheese coffee cakes stand out with authentic flavor and individual wrapping for convenience. The 4 seasons and strawberry cheese varieties require ordering ahead due to popularity and make great gifts or office treats.

Large frozen chocolate chip cookies come with custom messages written on them. All cookies use real butter and maintain consistent ingredients for reliable taste.

People are saying

"I found the bakery goods here to be the best in the world."

"These brownies taste rich and homemade, like grandma used to make."

"Their cookies and pastries were delicious and made with real butter."

Good to know

1

The bakery only accepts cash or checks for payment.

2

Reservations for special orders are required at least one day in advance.

3

Expect a line during peak hours, especially for paczki.

12
Orland Park Bakery image 1

Old-school bakery with cases nearly end-to-end filled with freshly baked pastries and free samples. Atmosphere feels friendly and welcoming with a clean, bright interior despite limited space. Known for real ingredients and standout items like coffee cakes and cupcakes.

Strawberry, raspberry, and almond coffee cakes stand out with bold flavors. Cheese coffee cake ranks as a favorite item alongside chocolate chip and apricot varieties.

Soft peanut butter cookies and sprinkle butter cookies stand out here. A nice selection of cookies is always available, including themed cookies made with detailed pastel designs.

People are saying

"The pastries and mini desserts at this Bakery are delicious."

"I loved the soft baked chocolate chip cookies."

"The strawberry coffee cake was great, but could have used more icing."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Arrive early for the best selection of pastries and baked goods.

3

The bakery is well-organized for holiday pickups to minimize wait times.

13
Ganache Bakery image 1

Freshly baked goods fill the air with a warm, inviting scent. Seating offers a comfortable, shaded spot to enjoy treats. Known for custom cakes, freshness on demand, and affordable prices, it draws a mix of people celebrating special occasions.

Coffee cakes come warm and fresh with a size around 10 by 4 inches. They cost about $13 each and are popular enough to be pre-ordered as gifts.

Butter cookies stand out with rich flavor and crisp texture. A nice variety includes sugar cookies and decorative options that appeal even to kids who rarely eat sweets.

People are saying

"This cake is light, fluffy, and perfectly sweet."

"I loved the mango cheesecake; it was flavorful and soft."

"The coffee cake is warm and deliciously fresh."

Good to know

1

Ganache Bakery offers a wide variety of dessert choices, including cakes and cookies.

2

The bakery makes orders fresh to ensure quality and taste.

3

Prices for custom cakes start at $13 for a 10-inch by 4-inch size.

14
Sauer's Bakery image 1

Small, family-owned bakery with a warm, welcoming atmosphere and old-fashioned German style. Fresh baked goods sell out quickly, especially apple cider donuts known as the best in the area. Clean and quaint setting draws early visitors seeking plentiful, homemade pastries.

Coffee cakes come in various styles including a special Christmas Tree shape for holiday occasions. Staff can cut them into pie slices for groups, and prices tend to be on the higher side.

Italian cookies stand out with rich flavor and variety. Butter cookies and smiley face cookies add a nostalgic touch to the selection.

People are saying

"You have to try the danishes and paczki at this bakery."

"These Italian cookies are delicious and better than any others."

"I thought the coffee cakes and other baked goods were to die for."

Good to know

1

Arrive early to get the best selection; items sell out quickly.

2

Sauer's Bakery offers a wide variety of baked goods, including cookies and donuts.

3

Apple doughnuts are available in the fall, along with holiday-specific items.

15
Jarosch Bakery image 1

Old-fashioned bakery with a cozy vibe and traditional style offers a clean, charming atmosphere where the aroma of pastries fills the air. Interior blends modern design with classic touches, attracting a steady flow of people. Display cases showcase beautifully stocked baked goods, creating a welcoming, home-like feel.

Coffee cakes come with plenty of tasty filling and fresh, delicious flavors. The chocolate chip coffee cake stands out as a favorite, often chosen for gatherings and enjoyed by many.

Frosted cookies stand out as a favorite, especially among kids. Custom options exist for events, and the cookies consistently look and taste amazing.

People are saying

"I found the donuts here to be delicious and not too sweet."

"I've never had a coffee cake as delicious as this."

"Their frosted cookies are a favorite for kids."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but calling ahead is recommended for large orders.

2

Pick up a number outside the shop before ordering inside.

3

Expect limited cookie selections due to recent ownership changes.

16
Calumet Bakery image 1

Bakery offers an old-time feel with a family atmosphere and lively, welcoming vibe. In-house seating provides a place to relax and enjoy treats. Known for best donuts and standout cakes, it feels like a local treasure.

Nut roll stands out among the coffee cakes. The bakery offers a large selection of sweet rolls and coffee cakes that pair well with donuts and brownies.

Fresh, customized cookies come in unique shapes and flavors like almond crescents and butter cookies. They offer personalized designs and gift-worthy options that are both delicious and visually appealing.

People are saying

"I thought the chocolate cake was top notch and so delicious."

"I found the cookies here to be fresh, delicious, and beautiful."

"I loved the coffee cake and other bakery items."

Good to know

1

The bakery has a large selection of sweet rolls, donuts, cakes, and coffee cakes.

2

The bakery was busy but the line moved quickly.

3

Placing the order is easy and straightforward.

17
Harner's Bakery Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

Restaurant combines old-fashioned charm with river views and a homey atmosphere. Bakery at the front offers highly regarded baked goods alongside a casual dining experience. Lighting and decor blend history with a welcoming vibe.

Butter pecan coffee cake stands out with its rich flavor and buttery texture. Maple nut coffee cake offers a sweet, nutty twist that many enjoy repeatedly.

Cookies come in a wide variety alongside other baked goods. Cherry cookies stand out with their distinct flavor. Pumpkin bread also pairs well with the cookie selection.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the great food and service at the bakery."

"I bought smiley heart cookies thinking they were sugar cookies."

"I thought the coffee cake was the best I'd ever had."

Good to know

1

Half-price donuts are available after 2 PM on Sundays.

2

Daily specials are offered, check the menu for details.

3

Dinner for two typically costs around $83.

18
Chicago Pastry image 1

Bakery offers Italian pastries and cakes with a high-end look and outdoor seating. The atmosphere feels welcoming with regular customers and strong aromas. Pastries and cakes are known for being fresh and flavorful with unique options like tiramisu and almond croissants.

Strawberry cheese stands out among the coffee cakes here. Some cakes can be stale and prices run on the expensive side.

Cookies have a deep chocolate flavor in varieties like the harvest and double chocolate. Options include turtle cookies and other pastries with consistent quality and taste.

People are saying

"The pastries here are delicious and the perfect amount of sweet."

"I loved their cookies; they were delicious."

"I carry on my grandma's tradition with their Coffee Cake."

Good to know

1

Pre-order holiday pastries and cookie trays for best selection.

2

Prices are on the higher side for a small bakery.

3

Zeppoli are available individually or in trays for St. Josephโ€™s Day.

19
Deerfields Bakery - Buffalo Grove image 1

Spacious bakery with European design and bright, clean interiors offers a homey, cozy atmosphere that feels welcoming and serene. Seating spans multiple levels including a small patio by a pond, creating a relaxed environment for enjoying coffee and pastries. The place stands out for its friendly vibe and well-designed display cases.

Offers a lovely assortment of coffee cakes alongside other baked goods. Coffee cakes here are noted for quality and can be added to a rewards program.

Cookies come in customized designs and classic flavors with excellent taste. Staff handle orders quickly, and cookies work well for events like engagement parties and weddings.

People are saying

"Our wedding cake was a beautiful and delicious centerpiece."

"I got custom cookies for my bridal party and graduation parties."

"I found their coffee cakes to be out of this world."

Good to know

1

Deerfields Bakery offers a large variety of breads, pastries, and breakfast items.

2

Prices at Deerfields Bakery are reasonable for the quality of baked goods.

3

The bakery has a great selection of cakes and cupcakes for special occasions.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...