Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Illinois

Pizza and cookies

A slice of pizza followed by a warm cookie is the only way to settle a craving for something savory and sweet.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Zazas Pizzeria - Lincoln Park image 1
Zazas Pizzeria - Lincoln Park image 2
Zazas Pizzeria - Lincoln Park image 3
View all

Cozy space with a family-owned warmth and Chicago neighborhood vibe creates an inviting atmosphere. Energy stays chill and lively, perfect for enjoying authentic thin crust pizza with rich, flavorful sauce. Unique pizza options and a refined ambiance set it apart from typical pizzerias.

Pizza features a crispy crust and fresh ingredients with flavors that invite another slice. Mike's Hot Pepperoni stands out as a favorite topping.

Cookies come with ice cream for a classic dessert combo. They stand out as a must-try finish to the meal.

People are saying

"The NY style pizza here has bold, unforgettable New York flavors."

"You have to try the ice cream, especially with the cookies."

"The cookies here were worth the trip."

Good to know

1

Order by the slice is limited.

2

The pizza is reasonably priced.

3

Zazaโ€™s offers a variety of pizza styles.

02
Zella's Catering And Dessert image 1

Loft space offers a welcoming atmosphere with a friendly vibe and clean kitchen practices. Food features generous portions and includes standout items like jerk chicken Alfredo pizza and large eggrolls. Ordering is efficient with minimal wait times and a reliable pickup system.

Pizzas come with a perfect thin crust and rich, flavorful cheese. Varieties like pot roast, jerk chicken, and Italian beef offer bold, unforgettable flavors that melt in your mouth.

Soft texture and rich flavor define the cookies here. The turtle cookies stand out as a staple, alongside strawberry cookies that earn high praise.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing, always fresh and full of flavor."

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"These cookies are so soft and flavorful, they're to die for."

Good to know

1

Pizza day is on Wednesdays, a popular event not to miss.

2

The ordering system allows for easy call-in orders with specified pickup times.

3

Prices are reasonable and portion sizes are generous.

03
Scudiero's Italian Bakery & Deli image 1

Small setting combines cozy atmosphere with a mix of old school and younger flair. Bakery display at the front offers classic Italian specialties alongside pizza slices and baked goods. Space includes a few tables and supports takeout, creating a neat and clean environment with reasonable prices.

Pizza slices come with a pizza bread style crust that tastes very good. The sausage pizza stands out for its flavor, and the pepperoni rolls are a must-try alongside fresh-made pizzas.

Cookies stand out as a highlight, often described as amazing and incredible. They pair well with other items like pizza and sandwiches.

People are saying

"The deli sandwiches here are delicious and made with quality ingredients."

"The pizza slices here are hot, delicious, and have a great crisp."

"I found the cookies here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited, with one hour available in front.

2

Cash is preferred for payments at this family-owned business.

3

You can get pizza to go for a quick meal.

04
Al Medina Bakery image 1

Middle Eastern bakery with freshly baked flatbreads and traditional Manakish made from original Palestinian recipes. Intimate atmosphere with inviting hospitality and a family-owned feel. Known for warm, delicious bread and tasty sesame cookies.

Oval-shaped pizzas come out light and tasty with a fresh, authentic flavor. The halal pepperoni pizza and Zaโ€™atar flat breads stand out for their quality and remind of pizzas from France.

Cookies come freshly baked and pair well with tea. Sesame cookies stand out for being not too sweet and just perfect.

People are saying

"The food here is so fresh and delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and so fresh."

"The staff here are so friendly and courteous, it's like a warm cookie."

Good to know

1

Everything is made fresh daily at the bakery.

2

The bakery offers a variety of Middle Eastern desserts and flatbreads.

3

Prices are reasonable compared to other bakeries in the area.

05
Crust Tap Room image 1

Spacious brewpub with tavern-style sports bar design and many TVs showing the same program. Atmosphere feels laid back and comfortable with a hidden gem patio that welcomes pets. Offers flavorful beer and top-notch pizza with gluten-free options.

Pizza crust stays immaculate and all pizzas can be made with gluten-free crust. The Fig Is In pizza features prosciutto, pistachio pesto, and a light white sauce with fig sweetness.

Cookie skillet melts in your mouth and serves as a satisfying end to a meal. Some drive from nearby areas just to order it.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the pizza and steak sandwich."

"The pizza here is crazy delicious."

"I sampled a few pizzas and each one was delicious."

Good to know

1

Crust Tap Room offers a variety of cocktails and beers along with a diverse food menu.

2

All pizzas can be made on gluten-free crust, catering to dietary needs.

3

The venue is spacious and suitable for larger groups.

06
Nemec Brothers Pizzeria image 1

Small, lively restaurant with a quaint hometown vibe and a cool mural on the main wall. Atmosphere ranges from cozy and peaceful to crowded and noisy, especially when busy. Space feels tight with limited seating, often suited for smaller groups.

NY style pizza stands out with its traditional approach and hot pepperoni topping. This pizza offers a classic taste that many consider the best in the region.

Cookies and sweets on the menu are insanely delicious. The cookie dessert with sea salt stands out as extra tasty, though the chocolate cookie does not impress.

People are saying

"I thought this New York style pizza was the best around."

"I found the best New York style pizza I've ever had."

"The pizza here is delicious, especially the vodka sauce pie."

Good to know

1

They stop serving pizza by the slice at 4:00 pm.

2

Parking at Nemec Brothers Pizzeria is limited and can be challenging.

3

You can customize your pizza by adding or deleting items when ordering online.

07
Mortadeli & Lounge image 1
Italian restaurant

Cozy boutique-style deli with classic deli seating and a contemporary lounge vibe offers a welcoming, family-like atmosphere. Bright, clean interior feels fresh but small and sometimes cramped. Video gaming slots add a relaxed, fun element alongside authentic Italian sandwiches and fresh gelato.

Cheese pizza offers a delicious flavor. Spinach and ricotta pizza squares come with a tasty bite and pair well with marinara.

Lemon cookies and chocolate chip cookies stand out as tasty options. Cookies often come as a free treat for kids and add a sweet touch to visits.

People are saying

"The meatball sandwich was loaded and sloppy, so good I got a second."

"I loved the sausage pizza and the cheese pizza."

"You have to try the cookies; they're delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, so expect possible wait times during peak hours.

2

Limited seating is available, which may lead to longer wait times.

3

Some menu items may be unavailable due to freshness; check before ordering.

08
Liborio Baking Co image 1

Bakery fills the air with fresh aroma of baked goods and offers a cozy seating area. It serves a wide variety of authentic Italian pastries and is known for fresh, addictive bread and pizza. Family-owned atmosphere supports consistent quality and charm.

Pizzas have a nostalgic taste that reminds of weekend sleepovers. The pizza bread stands out but has gotten soggy in the middle recently and the price jumped from $8 to $14.

Variety of cookies stands out with many options to choose from. Cookies rank among the best I've ever tasted, matching the quality of their focaccia bread.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza bread was phenomenal."

"Their pizza and bread are the best I've ever had."

"I found the cookies here to be some of the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The price of pizza bread is now $14.

2

Liborio Baking Co offers a wide variety of authentic Italian pastries.

3

Expect fresh products daily at Liborio Baking Co.

09
Sicilian Bakery Inc image 1

Old-school Italian bakery offers a cozy atmosphere with a traditional vibe and authentic Sicilian pastries. Family-run with recipes from the old country, it draws people seeking genuine Italian breads and cannoli.

Slices come thick and very good with a genuine Italian style. The pizza pairs well with focaccia and pizza bread, offering a solid variety of authentic options.

Italian cookies stand out with authentic flavors like lemon and fig. The bakery offers a wide selection including cannoli and sfogliatelles, all consistently fresh and delicious.

People are saying

"Their Italian cookies are so tasty, you'll understand what great cookies should taste like."

"These cannoli are delicious and taste like the ones in Sicily."

"The pizza here is amazing, especially the meat-filled kind."

Good to know

1

The bakery accepts only cash payments, so plan accordingly.

2

Special orders for cakes require at least 48 hours notice.

3

They charge an extra 4% fee for credit or debit card payments.

10
Kung Fu Pizza Bar image 1
Pizza restaurant

Ordering happens through a tiny walk-up window decorated with ramen bags and collectibles, creating a nostalgic, quiet vibe. The place operates solo with no indoor seating, offering affordable, well-cooked pizza slices that attract a steady flow of customers seeking value and convenience.

Slices come warm and huge with a deep dish option that stays affordable. Prices run around $5 for two slices plus a soda, making it a great value for tasty, well-cooked pizza served quickly through walk-up service.

Fortune cookies come with the pizza and stand out as a unique touch. The cookie often impresses more than the pizza itself and adds value to the meal.

People are saying

"It's the perfect little late night pizza slice."

"The owner is so nice and a total pizza expert."

"I was impressed by the fortune cookie they included with the pizza."

Good to know

1

The price for two slices and a soda is $5, plus tax.

2

Kung Fu Pizza Bar operates as a walk-up and take-out only establishment.

3

The establishment is open late at night for pizza cravings.

11
Beggars Pizza - Hyde Park / Kenwood image 1

Restaurant offers clean space with chill atmosphere and awesome energy. It serves fresh, hot pizza with good cheese, sauce, and crust. No dine-in seating is available, making it a quick go-to for lunch.

Pizza comes out fresh and hot with a thin crust sausage option loaded with toppings. Prices for slices stay great and service is consistently excellent and friendly.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their extreme goodness. Free cookies often come with purchases, sometimes given thoughtfully, like one for a baby.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was always great and fresh."

"I thought the pizza was fresh and full of flavor."

"They gave me a free cookie when I supported them."

Good to know

1

Parking is tight in the strip mall; consider street parking instead.

2

The wait for takeout is typically around 45 minutes during busy times.

3

They offer a buy 2 get 1 free slice promotion during lunch hours.

12
D'Amato's Bakery image 1

Small bakery with old-school charm and narrow aisles creates a cozy but sometimes crowded atmosphere. Friendly staff and great tunes add to the inviting vibe, while a covered outdoor patio offers extra seating for a quick bite.

Unique pizza stands out with a dairy-free pan crust and a sausage topping that recalls classic family recipes. The pizza pairs well with authentic crusty bread and desserts like eclairs and cannoli.

Italian cookies stand out with amaretti, lemon ricotta, and butter cookies featuring chocolate and caramel. These cookies offer a fresh, delicious taste that pairs well with pastries and breads.

People are saying

"This bread is the best sandwich bread I've ever had."

"The Italian food, especially the cannoli, is really good."

"I highly recommend the subs here; they're great."

Good to know

1

D'Amato's Bakery only accepts cash payments.

2

The bakery has limited seating inside but offers outdoor seating with tables.

3

Expect longer wait times during peak hours due to a small kitchen.

13
Button Bakery image 1

Small bakery with no seating and European-style vibe offers a cozy atmosphere and affordable, high-quality pastries. The space feels like a slice of Europe with adorable window displays and nice decor. It attracts early visitors eager for fresh, flavorful breads and pretzels.

Artichoke pizza stands out as a notable gluten-free option. Pizza here pairs well with sandwiches and baked goods, offering a surprising mix from a dessert bakery.

Peanut butter cookies stand out as a highlight here. The bakery offers a variety of fresh cookies and macaroons that taste phenomenal and pair well with their other baked goods.

People are saying

"Their sourdough bread is perfection."

"I was surprised the pizza here was so good."

"I found the cookies here to be delicious and awesome."

Good to know

1

Button Bakery is closed on Sundays and Mondays.

2

Normal hours are Tuesday to Saturday from 9 am to 6 pm.

3

Prices are very reasonable compared to other bakeries in the area.

14
GoodTimes Brewery + Kitchen image 1

Massive bar and large open space with oak detailing create an inviting setting. Atmosphere feels warm and friendly with brewing equipment visible, adding to the vibe. Multiple TVs and games make it a chill spot for groups and events.

Thin crust pizza stands out with its crispy texture and flavorful pepperoni. The BYO option uses Pats pizza, adding a familiar touch to the menu.

Skillet chocolate chip cookie serves warm and tastes like homemade. The cookie skillet stands out as a popular dessert choice.

People are saying

"The German and Czech style beers here are some of the best I've had."

"The cracker crust pizza had premium toppings."

"You have to try the cookie skillet; it's warm and delicious."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

3

On Mondays, the BYO pizza is half off.

15
Sauce & Bread Kitchen image 1

Small space with a hole-in-the-wall deli atmosphere offers a cozy and friendly vibe that feels like home. Ethically sourced homemade food includes technically perfect pastries and standout sandwiches. Occasional live jazz adds to the relaxed, charming environment.

Pizza night offers a community feeling with great food. The granny pie, a focaccia pizza with amazing toppings, stands out for an easy Friday dinner.

Peanut butter sandwich cookies and tahini-chocolate chip cookies stand out as sweet treats. Pastries and cookies offer a decadent and unique flavor experience.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and original."

"I loved their amazing pizza on Friday nights."

"You have to try their tahini-chocolate chip cookie; it's one of the best."

Good to know

1

Dinner is available only on Fridays and Saturdays.

2

Fridays feature spoken word or jazz nights.

3

Pizza night is a popular community event.

16
Minelli Italian Meats and Deli image 1

Old school Italian deli with nostalgic mall vibes and family-run atmosphere offers fresh Italian meats and homemade sausages. Plenty of seating in a common area invites casual dining. Known for exceptional sandwiches and a hot food counter in the back.

Locally made pizzas stand out with Italian meats and pizza sauces that taste fresh and rich. The spot offers made-to-order subs and a refrigerated section with pizza slices and fresh pasta.

Fresh baked goods include Italian cookies and cakes with a homemade touch. Display cases feature fresh baked cookies alongside other sweets.

People are saying

"Their sandwiches are fresh and delicious, especially with the meat sliced to order."

"I found the sandwiches to be pretty good."

"I thought their locally made pizza was among the best."

Good to know

1

Expect busy weekends and lunch hours; arrive early to avoid long waits.

2

The deli offers a variety of fresh meats, sandwiches, and hot meals.

3

Premade Italian sauces and meals are available for purchase.

17
Slyce of NY (Pizza) - Lombard image 1

Pizza restaurant offers graffiti style artwork and retro NBA games on multiple TVs, creating a cozy, old school vibe. Comfy couches and a hand-painted mural add to the welcoming atmosphere. The space feels like a New York slice spot with a friendly, lively energy.

Offers genuinely good New York style pizza with a focus on Halal options. Specialty pies like the pepperoni pie stand out for their amazing taste and quality.

Freshly baked cookies come warm and pair well with vanilla ice cream. Some cookies can be undercooked, and the ice cream topping may taste off. Cookie pie size varies and can be unclear.

People are saying

"I loved the halal pizza with unique toppings like gyro and chicken tikka."

"I'm coming back to try more of this pizza."

"I enjoyed the freshly baked cookie with ice cream."

Good to know

1

Free pizza slices available until 5 PM on September 15, 2025.

2

The restaurant offers a late-night menu during Ramadan.

3

The restaurant is halal and serves zabiha halal options.

18
Allegretti's Bakery image 1

Small, crowded bakery with an old school local feel and a busy, friendly atmosphere where people often know each other. Early lines form due to wide variety of baked goods including renowned donuts and pastries. The space feels like stepping back in time with a focus on quality and pride in work.

Soft, fresh pizza bread stands out here, perfect for reheating at home. Options include cold pizzas ready to go, alongside a variety of Italian cookies and fruit pastries.

Cookies come in a wide variety including walnut cookies with powdered sugar and raspberry-centered sugar cookies. They taste delicious and stand out alongside other pastries and doughnuts.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be fantastic."

"I thought their chocolate donuts were the best in the city."

"I found the pizza bread to be exceptionally soft and delicious."

Good to know

1

This bakery is cash only, so bring cash for your purchases.

2

Expect long lines, especially on weekends, as they sell out quickly.

3

The bakery opens at 7 am on Sundays, so arrive early.

19
Baby's Cheesesteak & Lemonade image 1

Sandwich shop with a small dining area and a logically set up drive-through offers a fresh, cozy atmosphere that feels warm and inviting. The environment stays clean and well managed, creating a welcoming vibe for quick, pleasant visits.

Slices come made to order with thick, seasoned cheese in true Chicago style. Options include jumbo slices and veggie pizza, all tasty and satisfying.

Cookies come fresh daily and often accompany orders as a small treat. Their freshness stands out and makes them a notable part of the menu.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever ate."

"I found the cookies here to be fresh and cooked well."

Good to know

1

The drive-thru is fast and convenient for quick meals.

2

The eating area is clean and well-maintained.

3

Expect reasonable wait times during peak hours.

20
Palermo Bakery image 1

Vintage Italian bakery offers authentic pastries and crusty bread in a clean, organized space with a warm atmosphere. Cakes and cookies show beautiful decoration and traditional flavors. Variety includes seasonal goodies like packzi and cannoli, with a focus on quality and old-school style.

Slices include Sicilian pizza, sausage and giardiniera, and eggplant pizza. The eggplant pizza stands out as especially flavorful. Variety covers focaccias and Italian pastries alongside pizzas.

Italian authenticity shines in every cookie, especially the almond cookies and lobster tails. The decorated butter cookies look beautiful and hold up well during shipping.

People are saying

"I was so impressed with how beautiful my custom cake turned out."

"The bakery's packzi are fresh, soft, and delicious."

"I loved the Italian cookies and pastries."

Good to know

1

Today, they hold their first annual cookie buffet for the holidays.

2

Individual items like large cannolis cost $3.25 and minis are $1.75 each.

3

Parking is a nightmare due to limited, timed spaces.

21
The Staley image 1
Sports bar

Large sports bar with huge projector screens and plenty of TVs creates a strong focus on watching games. Atmosphere feels like a dark basement man cave with a mix of upscale gastropub dรฉcor. Free arcade games and a mini game room add casual entertainment beyond sports viewing.

Margherita pizza and sweet heat pepperoni stand out for their flavor. Pizzas come in vegan and sausage options and are affordable while maintaining quality.

Skillet cookie stands out with its warm, gooey texture and rich flavor. It often comes as a sweet finish after meals and pairs well with other dishes like wings and pizzas.

People are saying

"The food here is unique, delicious, and top-notch."

"You have to try the buffalo chicken pizza, it's fire."

"The staff here are gems, always attentive and helpful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted on game days; plan accordingly.

2

A 20% service charge is automatically added to bills on game days.

3

Happy hour features discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

22
House Of Cakes image 1

Bakery offers fresh baked goods with an impressive variety of cakes, pastries, and breads. Atmosphere feels chill and energetic, attracting those who appreciate cash-only transactions and classic treats like cheese sticks and coffee cakes.

Pan cheese pizza stands out with its surprisingly good flavor. Pizza-type breads come out light, fresh, and delicious.

Large frozen chocolate chip cookies come with custom messages written on them. All cookies use real butter and maintain consistent ingredients for reliable taste.

People are saying

"I found the bakery goods here to be the best in the world."

"Their cookies and pastries were delicious and made with real butter."

"The pan cheese pizza was surprisingly good and light."

Good to know

1

The bakery only accepts cash or checks for payment.

2

Reservations for special orders are required at least one day in advance.

3

Expect a line during peak hours, especially for paczki.

23
Pizza Ranch image 1
Buffet restaurant

Buffet restaurant combines all-you-can-eat fried chicken and unique pizza varieties with a family-friendly arcade that fills half the space. The atmosphere is loud and lively, often crowded with children, creating a busy, energetic vibe. Seating feels cramped and close together, making the dining area feel tight despite the fun amenities.

Variety of unique pizza options like Macaroni & Cheese and Taco pizzas stand out. Buffalo chicken pizza offers a fresh take, and pizzas arrive piping hot whether dine-in or delivery.

Large sliced chocolate chip cookie and dessert pizzas stand out among the sweet options. Soft serve ice cream pairs well with cookies, and special treats like birthday cookie cakes add a fun touch.

People are saying

"The pizza buffet here is great, with always a new pizza to try."

"I loved trying all the fresh pizzas they kept putting out."

"The fried chicken here is super good."

Good to know

1

Tuesdays are when kids eat free at Pizza Ranch.

2

The buffet offers all-you-can-eat pizza, ice cream, and chicken.

3

Expect limited pizza options available at a time, with quick turnover.

24
Rex Italian Foods image 1

Decorated with Old World Italian touches, the deli offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating. The vibe is laid-back and welcoming, encouraging sampling and interaction. It stands out as a hidden gem known for authentic Italian specialties and a strong local presence.

Pizza features salty slices and a bitter sauce. It pairs with lasagna and subs as popular choices.

Homemade cookies stand out here, especially the lemon knot cookies. Fresh baked treats come alongside paninis, subs, and pastas.

People are saying

"The panzerotti's flaky, crunchy puff pastry crust is the star of this Italian food."

"I found the pizza and lasagna to be amazing."

"You have to try the homemade cookies, they're amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has a parking lot outside.

2

They accept both cash and card payments.

3

Rex Italian Foods offers delivery through Uber Eats.

25
Chicago Pastry image 1

Bakery offers Italian pastries and cakes with a high-end look and outdoor seating. The atmosphere feels welcoming with regular customers and strong aromas. Pastries and cakes are known for being fresh and flavorful with unique options like tiramisu and almond croissants.

Sheet pizza and pan pizza stand out, especially on Fridays when pan pizza is featured. Large trays of pizza are available, alongside pastries and other baked goods.

Cookies have a deep chocolate flavor in varieties like the harvest and double chocolate. Options include turtle cookies and other pastries with consistent quality and taste.

People are saying

"The pastries here are delicious and the perfect amount of sweet."

"I loved their cookies; they were delicious."

"I enjoyed the sheet pizza and pastries."

Good to know

1

Pre-order holiday pastries and cookie trays for best selection.

2

Prices are on the higher side for a small bakery.

3

Zeppoli are available individually or in trays for St. Josephโ€™s Day.

26
Paisans Pizzeria - Oak Lawn image 1

Full-size airplane and vintage vehicles hang inside a spacious, stylish dining area creating a unique, fun vibe. Music and TVs add energy, making the atmosphere lively and family friendly. Bar area buzzes with activity, blending casual dining with a sports bar feel.

Pizza here comes with great flavor and arrives ready on time for pickup. The spot pairs good service with solid food and drinks, making it a reliable choice for dine-in or takeout.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out, especially served a la mode as a dessert highlight. Staff sometimes offer cookies to cheer up kids, adding a thoughtful touch.

People are saying

"This pizza's crust is crispy and chewy, with generous, fresh toppings."

"The servers here make it feel like you've made a new best friend."

"The chocolate chip cookie a la mode is the best part."

Good to know

1

Tuesdays feature a special of 22 oz draft beer for $5.

2

99 cent wings are available on Tuesdays.

3

Mondays have a special on Micheladas.

27
Chuck's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers large pizzas with reasonable prices and hot, flavorful pies. Atmosphere suits a neighborhood spot with a steady local following. Toppings and sauce can be generous, sometimes leading to a messy but satisfying experience.

A 24-inch pizza loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and broccoli offers a solid balance of toppings with plenty of meat. The pizza delivers great value and a taste that keeps people coming back for over 14 years.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out for their soft texture and rich flavor. Homemade cookies come mouth watering and memorable.

People are saying

"I've been getting their pizza with my family for years."

"I thought the chocolate cookies were the softest I had ever had."

"I got the proper sandwiches delivered fast."

Good to know

1

For about $35.00, you can get a pizza that's almost 33 inches in diameter.

2

Order the slice first for $3.50 to try before committing.

3

It's best to order the pizza an hour ahead of time.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...