Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Illinois' best

New York style pizza and food

Made for those who hold a high standard for thin-crust slices and expect a complete dining experience every time they sit down to eat.

Based on 850 Opinions
+847
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Slyce of NY (Pizza) - Lombard image 1
Slyce of NY (Pizza) - Lombard image 2
Slyce of NY (Pizza) - Lombard image 3
View all

Pizza restaurant offers graffiti style artwork and retro NBA games on multiple TVs, creating a cozy, old school vibe. Comfy couches and a hand-painted mural add to the welcoming atmosphere. The space feels like a New York slice spot with a friendly, lively energy.

Offers authentic New York style pizza with a thin, foldable crust and balanced toppings. Prices reflect the quality, including halal options, making it a rare find for genuine NY pizza in the Chicago suburbs.

Food here is consistently amazing with a perfect rating and great service accompanying every meal.

People are saying

"I loved the halal pizza with unique toppings like gyro and chicken tikka."

"You have to try the gyro over rice; it's flavorful and well-seasoned."

"The food here is always fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Free pizza slices available until 5 PM on September 15, 2025.

2

The restaurant offers a late-night menu during Ramadan.

3

The restaurant is halal and serves zabiha halal options.

02
Zazas Pizzeria - Lincoln Park image 1

Cozy space with a family-owned warmth and Chicago neighborhood vibe creates an inviting atmosphere. Energy stays chill and lively, perfect for enjoying authentic thin crust pizza with rich, flavorful sauce. Unique pizza options and a refined ambiance set it apart from typical pizzerias.

Delicious slices capture the essence of New York style pizza with a classic thin crust and balanced toppings. This spot stands out as a favorite for those seeking authentic NY style pizza.

Fantastic pizza and meatballs stand out alongside ice cream and cookies for dessert. The food pairs well with a solid wine selection and comes with attentive service.

People are saying

"The NY style pizza here has bold, unforgettable New York flavors."

"I thought the pizza here was incredible, especially the pesto and sausage."

"The New York Style Pizza here is delicious and hefty with ingredients."

Good to know

1

Order by the slice is limited.

2

The pizza is reasonably priced.

3

Zaza’s offers a variety of pizza styles.

03
Da Pizza Company – Pizzeria & Food Trucks image 1

Food truck serves fresh New York-style pizza with a crispy yet chewy crust and generous slices. Atmosphere feels like a local spot with friendly staff and a casual vibe. Popular for quick bites and catering, especially for events and parties.

Proper New York style pizzas come with a thin, foldable crust and classic toppings. A full pizza truck service offers these pizzas at events, making it a solid specialty pizza option.

Food features freshly made pizza and authentic flavors. Portions come in generous amounts and offer good value.

People are saying

"This pizza is so delicious, I'd return two days in a row."

"The food here is delicious with great, consistent flavors."

"I enjoyed the New York Style pizza; it was fresh, light, and amazing."

Good to know

1

Da Pizza Company offers catering for various events, including corporate and special occasions.

2

They provide a full pizza truck service for events, serving New York style pizzas.

3

The menu includes 9 pizza toppings, 5 specialty pizzas, garlic knots, and drinks.

04
Nemec Brother’s Pizzeria image 1

Small pizzeria with intimate seating upstairs and a quiet basement area featuring TVs. Atmosphere is laid-back and inviting, though music can be loud and the upstairs gets crowded. Offers halal pepperoni and a house lager brewed locally, pairing well with their highly regarded New York-style pizza.

Offers authentic New York style pizza that matches the quality found in NYC and New Jersey. Includes halal options and delivers an exceptional taste that stands out in the suburbs.

Pizza stands out with its quality and flavors that recall Chicago style. A great selection of options pairs with good service to make meals consistently satisfying.

People are saying

"I found the best New York style pizza outside of New York."

"I thought the meatballs here were phenomenal."

"The pizza here is amazing, thin, crispy, and packed with flavor."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria offers halal pepperoni and a variety of vegetarian options.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours due to high demand.

3

Pickup can be challenging as there is no dedicated drive-up space.

05
Lusha Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy pizza spot with a chill neighborhood vibe and casual family joint atmosphere. Bright, clean space with pleasant seating and Serie A games on TV. Known for authentic New York style pizza and a friendly, welcoming environment.

Offers legit New York style pizza with a unique taste. Recognized for great quality and awarded Best New York Pizza in Chicago by Foxcito Peña.

Food here is consistently delicious with a variety that satisfies large groups. Service complements the meal well, making it reliable for gatherings.

People are saying

"This New York–style pizza has a perfect crust and balanced sauce."

"The food here is delicious, especially the pizza crust."

"I found the New York style pizza here to be really great."

Good to know

1

Lusha Pizza is family-owned and offers authentic Italian pizza.

2

The pizza is a bit more expensive than competitors.

3

Expect a clean environment with limited seating available.

06
Pizza Amelia image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small joint with limited seating offers New York style pizza known for its excellent crust and high-quality ingredients. Atmosphere feels homey and casual, welcoming neighborhood residents and dog walkers alike. Outdoor tables add to the inviting, lively vibe matching the neighborhood energy.

Incredible New York style pizza with a simple, classic approach. Known for serving some of the best NY style pizza in the city, it draws fans who order multiple pies for special occasions.

Food features a delicious New York style with high quality ingredients. Every dish feels cooked with love, making the flavors stand out clearly.

People are saying

"This East Coast-style pizza is the best I've had in Chicago."

"The food here is delicious New York style pizza."

"I believed this New York style pizza was some of the best in Chicago."

Good to know

1

Parking is best done by parking right in front; avoid the lot next door.

2

Order early on Fridays as they can get busy.

3

The restaurant often sells out on busy nights.

07
Pie Life Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Space features clean tables and unique paintings that create an old school vibe reminiscent of 90s pizzerias. Atmosphere feels upbeat and friendly, with a strong aroma of pizza welcoming guests. Thin crust pies offer an authentic East Coast style experience with well-balanced sauce and cheese.

Thin crust stands out as the key feature of the pizza here. It captures the essence of New York style pizza and convinces that it can rival Chicago style when cooked right.

Food features a just right texture in the pizza, making it enjoyable. The quality stays consistently good across visits.

People are saying

"The pizza's crisp crust and flavorful sauce are a must-try."

"The food here is great, with fresh ingredients and flavorful pizza."

"I thought the New York style pizza here was the best around."

Good to know

1

They offer a promotion where buying any 16-inch or Sicilian pizza includes a free 16-inch cheese or Margherita pizza.

2

Slices are available all day and are warmed to order.

3

The price of two slices is only $9, which is a good value.

08
Rocket Slice Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Strictly takeout setup with a ledge but no seating creates a quick, in-and-out vibe. Atmosphere feels laid back and welcoming, with a cozy, warm environment despite occasional smokiness. Known for kosher Chicago deep dish pizza, it draws a busy crowd seeking authentic, highly praised flavors.

Floppy crust defines the New York style pizza here, capturing the classic texture. The slices deliver a great balance of flavor true to the style.

Food arrives hot and fast with a nice variety of kosher options. Every dish shows clear pride and passion in preparation and service.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and flavorful."

"The food here is great, especially the pizza."

"I found the New York Style Pizza to be great and delicious."

Good to know

1

Rocket Slice Pizza opens at 7am on Saturdays.

2

Parking is limited near Rocket Slice Pizza.

3

Prices for cheese slices start at $4.

09
Venecia's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Recycled Pizza Hut space with bright lighting and plenty of seating creates an open, clean environment. Country music plays softly, adding to a pleasant, casual vibe. The atmosphere feels simple and functional, with hard, uncomfortable chairs and minimal decor.

Thin crust and foldable slices define the pizza here, capturing the essence of New York style. It stands out as one of the few spots nearby offering this style with a balanced sauce and cheese blend.

Food stands out for its consistent quality and delicious flavors. Every visit delivers amazing taste and satisfying meals.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be amazing."

"The food here is delicious and amazing."

"I was so happy to find New York Style Pizza locally."

Good to know

1

Kids eat free on Sunday afternoons with a purchase.

2

The pizza is served in less than 15 minutes.

3

The restaurant offers great lunch specials.

10
Volo Quality Meats image 1

Bright, cozy deli with homey table arrangements and a market-style layout offers a welcoming atmosphere reminiscent of an Italian cafe. In-house butcher and deli provide high-quality meats alongside a hot bar and fresh pizza, creating a unique blend of shopping and dining experiences.

Slices feature a thin crust typical of New York style pizza. The pizza offers a classic cheese and sauce combination that aligns with traditional New York flavors.

Food features in-house processed meat that stands out amid recent recalls. The menu offers a variety of authentic Italian dishes with consistently fresh and exceptional quality.

People are saying

"I loved the sandwiches; the ingredients were amazing."

"The food here is amazing, especially the juicy pastrami sandwich."

"Their New York Style Pizza has amazing flavor and a great crust."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of parking available in the back.

2

The menu offers a wide selection of high-quality sandwiches and meats.

3

Prices range from $75 to $100 for a meal, making it a premium option.

11
Gigio's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, hole-in-the-wall pizza spot with a classic, old-school charm and casual, family-friendly vibe. Atmosphere feels welcoming and chill, offering authentic New York-style pizza with affordable prices. Space is no-frills and intimate, with some outdoor seating available.

Pizza arrives hot with a thin crust and classic foldable slices. It captures the authentic New York style with a balance of sauce and cheese that stands out in Chicago.

Food stands out for being consistently solid and delicious with a quick and efficient delivery. The dishes often impress with their amazing flavor.

People are saying

"I believe Gigio's Pizzeria offers the best pizza."

"I thought the food here was fantastic and delicious."

"I'd say this is the best New York Style Pizza I ever had."

Good to know

1

Gigio's Pizzeria opens late until 2am for late-night bites.

2

Pizza by the slice is available for quick meals.

3

They charge extra for card payments without prior notice.

12
Dough Bros Pizzeria & Sub Shop image 1

Small pizzeria with a walk-up window and brick oven creates a rustic, cozy atmosphere. Seating fits solo diners or small groups, with a few tables and ESPN on TV adding a retro vibe. Weekend nights bring a chaotic energy, while police presence adds security but a slightly sketchy feel.

Authentic New York style pizza stands out with its melt-in-your-mouth texture and delicious flavor. It offers a quality experience that rivals pizzas from New York itself.

Food comes out hot with enough cheese and pepperonis. Ingredients stay excellent and the menu stays affordable, making it a solid late-night choice for groups.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was amazing and really legit."

"The pizza here has a perfect crunch and cooks to perfection."

"I found the New York style pizza here to be authentic and amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking is not available nearby, so consider alternative transport options.

2

Pizza slices are available for $4.50 each, which is a good deal.

3

The pizzeria is open late, making it a great option for night owls.

13
Marisa's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Traditional pizza joint with a cozy setting and fresh dough made up front creates a welcoming atmosphere. The menu offers New York-style pizza with a variety of slices and reasonable prices. The place draws a steady crowd looking for a casual, wholesome meal with familiar Italian dishes.

Slices feature a thin, foldable crust with a classic balance of sauce and cheese. The flavor closely matches authentic New York style, making it a solid choice for that distinctive pizza experience.

Authentic food stands out here, especially the pizza which is the highlight. Overall, the food tastes good with a generally clean dining area and friendly service.

People are saying

"I thought the New York Style Pizza here was delicious."

"I thought it was a great lunch spot for pizza."

"The food here is pretty good, especially the pizza."

Good to know

1

Marisa's Pizza offers great lunch specials throughout the week.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak dinner hours.

3

Pizza is available by the slice at any time, not just during lunch.

14
Pazza Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza spot with limited indoor seating and a casual, unpretentious vibe offers a quiet, chill atmosphere ideal for relaxed meals or late-night orders. The place draws a steady flow of takeout and delivery customers, creating a true neighborhood feel.

Slices come with a nice crisp crust and classic New York style toppings. The shop focuses on serving authentic NY pizza by the slice in a small setting.

Pizza by the slice arrives hot and fast, often earlier than expected. Food quality stands out with amazing taste and quick service, sometimes within half the promised time.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be absolutely delicious."

"The food here is amazing, especially the pizza."

"I enjoyed a nice, crisp New York Style Pizza here."

Good to know

1

A slice of pizza costs between $5 and $6.

2

Pazza Pizza is not a dine-in place; it's mainly for takeout.

3

The shop has limited indoor seating and is more of a to-go place.

15
Chomp Pizza image 1
Pizza Takeout

Urban train station lobby sets an unpretentious, minimalist vibe with a four-item menu focused solely on cheese pizza slices. The atmosphere suits commuters and active individuals seeking quick, easy-to-eat options. Pizza features a thin, crisp crust with balanced sauce and cheese, reflecting a genuine New York style.

Slices feature a classic thin crust with a foldable texture. Toppings balance well with the tangy tomato sauce and melty cheese typical of New York style.

Food shows high quality with some dishes rated as great. Overall, the menu offers fine options but can vary in appeal.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was so good."

"I loved this New York Style Pizza; it really scratched an itch for authentic."

"I thought the food here was great."

Good to know

1

The place specializes in pizza by the slice, with a minimal four-item menu.

2

It's conveniently located inside the 18th Street Station for commuters.

3

The pizza is easy to eat on the go, perfect for a quick lunch.

16
New York Slices image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small tables and a high counter with bar stools create a cozy mom-and-pop atmosphere with New York graffiti decor. The place offers affordable New York-style pizza by the slice with a thin, crisp crust and varied toppings. It attracts people looking for a quick, casual meal with a local, family-owned vibe.

Classic thin crust dough matches traditional New York style pizza. Best served straight out of the oven or by the slice for authentic texture and flavor.

Food here is consistently good with great service most of the time. The meals offer solid quality that satisfies.

People are saying

"I thought the New York Style Pizza here was great and legit."

"I'd never eaten a chocolate chip cookie that was so good."

"I thought the food here was good."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a 2-for-1 large pizza deal on Mondays and Thursdays for $20.

2

Pizza is available by the slice with different varieties offered daily.

3

Prices are very affordable, making it a good option for families.

17
Pizza Lobo Logan Square image 1

Outdoor seating includes a heated patio with fire pits and a gravel floor, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere. Music plays loudly, adding energy but making conversation difficult. The space welcomes groups, kids, and dogs, blending modern and retro design elements.

Offers casual dining with a DJ playing music. Serves New York style pizza that some find delicious while others disagree on its authenticity.

Food offers crave-worthy flavors with a variety of tasty options. Ordering through the phone keeps it simple and lets everyone pay for their own meal.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was great, especially the crust."

"The pizza here is crave-worthy and defines the experience."

"The New York Style Pizza has a huge patio with fire pits."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays and Wednesdays, they offer $1 wings.

2

Trivia night happens on Wednesdays with a fun atmosphere.

3

Dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating area.

18
Nonna's Pizza & Sandwiches image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, bright space with covered outdoor seating surrounded by flowers offers a cozy, authentic vibe. Energy feels like a home-cooked Italian kitchen with a casual, bustling atmosphere. Regulars enjoy best sandwiches and exceptional chicken Parmesan in a setting that blends city hustle with intimate dining.

Slices come in classic New York style with a thin, foldable crust. The truffle oil pepperoni adds a unique twist to the traditional flavor.

Food stands out for its high quality and amazing flavors. Chocolate cake shows the kitchen's skill and hints at the overall excruciatingly good menu.

People are saying

"I thought the chicken Parmesan sandwich was the best."

"I found the food here to be excruciatingly good."

"I found the New York style pizza slices to be incredible."

Good to know

1

They accept cash, credit, and debit cards for payment.

2

The restaurant only offers takeout options with no indoor seating.

3

Expect busy lunch hours, which may lead to longer wait times.

19
Professor Pizza Slice & Pie - West Town image 1

Rooftop space offers fantastic city views and a trendy tavern-style decor filled with nostalgic art and family photos. Atmosphere shifts from chill and cozy indoors to a loud, day club vibe with DJs on weekends. The place attracts lively crowds enjoying excellent music and spacious seating.

Thin crust slices define the New York style pizza here, with toppings like mushroom and leek standing out. The pizza tastes authentic and delivers a perfect balance of flavors.

Food features a grandma style deluxe pepperoni that stands out with a unique twist. Dishes consistently deliver fantastic flavor and a distinct approach that feels fresh and satisfying.

People are saying

"The pizza here is insanely delicious with fresh, flavorful toppings."

"The pizza here is fantastic, especially the New York style."

"This New York Style Pizza is undeniably delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a 40-minute wait for a table during peak hours.

2

Only online orders for pickup are accepted; no dine-in or curbside service.

3

A QR code is required to order and pay upfront.

20
Betty's Pizza & Pasta image 1

Restaurant offers New York style pizza with large slices and a thin, crisp crust featuring cornmeal for crunch. Atmosphere includes low volume 50's music and a clean, welcoming dining area suited for families. Pricing is reasonable with specials, and the place maintains a busy, lively energy.

Chewy, tasty crust with a floppy inside and crispy edges captures the classic New York style. This pizza offers a solid alternative to deep dish and thin crust varieties.

Thin crust pizza stays fresh thanks to high food turnover. The dining area feels comfortable and relaxing with impeccable service and a clean environment.

People are saying

"The pizza crust here is outstanding and satisfyingly chewy."

"The New York Style Pizza here is great, and the staff is so friendly."

"The food here is really good, especially the pizza."

Good to know

1

Thursday night offers half-price wine and a $22 pizza special.

2

A large pizza costs approximately $20 and serves 3-4 people.

3

The restaurant is known for using fresh ingredients in their dishes.

Discover more

Illinois

Area guide
Loading Map...