Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Indiana's best

Cake and cheesecake spots

Deciding between a classic cake or a rich, creamy cheesecake is the only dilemma that matters right now.

Based on 764 Opinions
+761
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
The Forever Bakery (formerly known as JaaCakes) image 1
The Forever Bakery (formerly known as JaaCakes) image 2
The Forever Bakery (formerly known as JaaCakes) image 3
View all

Bakery showcases beautifully designed cakes with moist, flavorful textures and real caramel frosting. Presentation is consistently fancy and detailed, matching themes perfectly. Cakes attract those seeking stunning and delicious options for weddings and special occasions.

Wedding cakes stand out with impressive decor and delicious taste. The bakery offers two-flavor options like strawberry crunch, and cake decorating classes let you create and take home your own cake.

Mini cheesecakes appear at church programs and receive strong positive reactions. Options include strawberry crunch with a cheesecake layer and lemon cheesecake, noted for their quality and flavor.

People are saying

"The cake here is beautiful and tastes amazing."

"The cakes from this bakery were beautiful and tasted amazing."

"I've never had cheesecake this good, anywhere."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of beautifully designed cakes for special occasions.

2

Prices are competitive compared to other local bakeries in the area.

3

Cakes are presented in attractive boxes for easy transport.

02
YAFA GOLDEN COFFEE image 1

Coffee shop offers unique decor and comfortable seating with both indoor and outdoor options. Atmosphere feels cozy and relaxing, encouraging long stays with board games and plenty of outlets for work or study. The vibe blends cultural richness with a welcoming environment suited for socializing or quiet moments.

Saffron cake stands out with its unique flavor. Other options include honey cake, Medovik cake, and a peanut butter shaped cake that blends sweetness with an international twist.

Biscoff cheesecake stands out with its rich and creamy texture. Unique options like the Dubai pistachio chocolate cheesecake and the San Sebastián cheesecake add variety to the dessert menu.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the most delicious coffee I've had in a while."

"The fruit cakes here are delicious and fun to eat."

"The Dubai chocolate cheesecake was the best I’ve ever had."

Good to know

1

YAFA GOLDEN COFFEE opens on Fridays and Saturdays till midnight.

2

YAFA GOLDEN COFFEE opens until 10:00 pm on the rest of the week.

3

They offer pastry items that you can't find anywhere else.

03
Commission Row image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers modern elegance with tasteful decor and an open kitchen that creates a lively atmosphere. Downstairs speakeasy features live music and a bustling bar scene. Space fills with background noise during dinner, balancing a super chill vibe for events.

The princess cake features a pistachio and marzipan topping and is expertly made. The chocolate cake has about 10 layers and is quite large. Pineapple brulee and lemon pound cakes also stand out.

Desserts include a deep-fried wheel of Brie called Brie cheesecake and a lemon cheesecake. Presentation shows attention to detail.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the steaks cooked perfectly."

"Ben made our anniversary feel so special with his attentiveness."

"You have to try the chocolate cake; it's massive and worth saving room for."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch, especially on holidays like Father's Day.

2

Movie nights occur every Sunday, providing a fun weekly event.

3

Devour Indy offers a $65 four-course meal, a great deal during the event.

04
When Cheese Met Cake image 1

Colorful, cozy interior creates a welcoming atmosphere with a cute setup. Cheesecake offerings stand out for exceptional quality and wide flavor variety, often selling out daily. Prices are higher than average, reflecting the premium taste and freshness.

Cheesecakes here stand out for their original flavor and visible quality. The NY style pineapple upside-down cake also gets attention, with options suitable for birthdays and special occasions.

New York style cheesecake stands out with a fresh, rich texture. Varieties like mocha chip and original flavor offer distinct, satisfying tastes that impress with every bite.

People are saying

"I thought the cheesecake was the best I ever had."

"The chocolate chip cookies and double chocolate brownie bites were amazing."

"I thought the cheesecake was exceptional and the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The bakery often sells out daily, so arrive early for the best selection.

2

Prices for cheesecake slices are around $13 each, which is higher than average.

3

The bakery has unique hours and is not open 24/7; check before visiting.

05
Eat Da Cake image 1

Bakery fills the air with an amazing aroma of fresh desserts. Cheesecakes stand out as homemade with quality ingredients, offering varied, rich flavors like Biscoff and red velvet. The place feels like a family-owned business focused on delivering a superior, authentic dessert experience.

Cakes here feature soft, creamy cheesecakes like blueberry and caramel pecan. The Strawberry Crunch and Biscoff cakes stand out for their rich flavors and texture.

Cheesecakes offer a melt-in-your-mouth texture with smooth, velvety cream cheese filling. Varieties like peach cobbler, Biscoff, and strawberry crunch stand out for their flavor and visual appeal.

People are saying

"The cheesecakes here are delicious and perfectly balanced."

"You have to try the banana pudding; it's classic and perfectly sweet."

"The cheesecakes here are delicious and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

The price of a slice is $8.00, which may be high for some budgets.

2

All desserts are made from scratch, ensuring quality and freshness.

3

There are a few seatings available to enjoy the cheesecakes in the shop.

06
Two Chicks Whisky Business image 1

Bakery offers wide variety of large cupcakes and exceptional cheesecakes with flavors like pistachio and lemon blueberry. Atmosphere feels cute and clean with a pleasant scent. Desserts combine sweet, crunchy, and smooth textures appealing to diverse tastes.

Beautiful wedding cakes and cupcakes come out well decorated and fresh. The Carrot Cake Cheesecake stands out, and desserts rarely go to waste here.

Chocolate chip cheesecake stands out with rich flavor. The Carrot Cake Cheesecake and cookie dough cheesecake offer unique twists on classic cheesecake.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are so generous and thoughtfully presented."

"This bakery's owners are so generous, they gave away cupcakes to someone in need."

"The cake and desserts tasted amazing; guests loved them."

Good to know

1

The dessert selection includes a variety of textures and flavors to satisfy different tastes.

2

Prices are on the higher side, reflecting the quality of the desserts.

3

Wedding cakes are available and often do not go to waste.

07
Del Frisco's Double Eagle Steakhouse image 1

Steakhouse offers a stylish interior with live piano and vocal music that creates an elegant atmosphere. The setting includes a small, quaint bar and options for private dining. The energy suits romantic dates and groups seeking a refined experience.

Butter cake stands out with its light texture and pairs well with delicious ice cream. It finishes the meal on a sweet note.

Cheesecake here comes as a free celebratory slice and a birthday treat. The flavor is over the top delicious and stands out among other dishes like wagyu meatballs and lobster mac n cheese.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be the best I ever had."

"You have to try the butter cake for dessert; it's amazing."

"The cheesecake here is over the top delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

Dress code is business casual; avoid shorts and athletic wear.

3

Expect to pay around $200 for a meal for two, excluding drinks.

08
Mt. Olive Mediterranean Grill image 1

Small space with comfortable booths and colorful murals creates a cozy, welcoming vibe. Charcoal grill aromas and spice scents fill the air, while absence of music keeps the atmosphere calm. Staff offer generous food samples, enhancing the relaxed, friendly energy.

Cakes here feature homemade-tasting textures with fillings like pudding and whipped cream. Varieties include chocolate, red velvet pistachio, and a notable Dubi cake.

Pistachio cheesecake stands out with a rich, creamy texture and unique flavor. Free slices sometimes come with meals, adding a nice surprise to the dessert options.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be authentic and delicious."

"I was so impressed by the amazing chocolate cake."

"I found the cheesecake here to be exceptional."

Good to know

1

The mix grill is 100 percent zabiha halal.

2

Expect about a 10-minute wait for fresh food.

3

Lunch specials offer good options during the hours.

09
Eddie Merlot's image 1
Steak house

Steak house offers a warm and cozy atmosphere with live music enhancing the dining experience. Decor blends classic sophistication and modern chic, creating a setting that suits relaxed conversations and reunions. Guests enjoy high-quality steaks paired with carefully selected wines in a friendly, intimate environment.

Carrot cake stands out with its huge size and incredible richness. It serves as a generous dessert option, enough for two people.

New York cheesecake stands out with a rich, creamy texture. The menu also features a unique turtle cheesecake and a popular carrot cake as dessert options.

People are saying

"The service at dinner spots was great and attentive."

"You have to try the carrot cake; it's incredible."

"Stephen made the night unforgettable; ask for him!"

Good to know

1

Happy Hour is available with special menu items from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Reservations are recommended for large parties to ensure seating.

3

Expect a 10-15 minute wait for dinner reservations during peak hours.

10
Mariam Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Coffee shop offers cozy vibes with calming Middle Eastern music and beautiful handmade goods. Seating is comfortable and well spaced, with outlets supporting various plug types. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, suited for relaxing, studying, or visiting with friends.

Many fresh pastries and cakes are available, including baklava and a Russian Honey Cake. The honey cake is light and delicious, often highlighted as a standout choice.

Dubai cheesecake stands out with its rich flavor and smooth texture. Options include cheesecake topped with fresh fruit, adding a sweet contrast.

People are saying

"The pastries here are so fresh and flavorful."

"I thought the honey cake was surprisingly light and very delicious."

"I bought Dubai cheesecake to take home; it was amazing."

Good to know

1

Mariam Coffee opens later than other coffee shops in the area.

2

They have just opened a new location in Broad Ripple.

3

The prices are on the high side.

11
Hazeables image 1
Bakery

Bakery with local artist murals and a pet friendly environment offers a variety of infused and gluten free treats. Atmosphere stays chill and welcoming, attracting families and dog owners alike. Pricing remains reasonable while maintaining a woman-owned business vibe.

Cakes come with creative designs and often include gluten free options like chocolate with strawberry filling. They are consistently moist and tasty, making them popular for birthdays and weddings.

Cheesecakes feature a graham cracker crust layer beneath the filling, offering a twist on the usual style. Mini cheesecakes and flavors like strawberry and Oreo stand out for their rich taste.

People are saying

"The strawberry Tres Leches cake is insanely delicious."

"They're so dog friendly and offer tasty treats for your pupper."

"The strawberry cheesecake was bomb and so satisfying."

Good to know

1

Hazeables is a dog-friendly shop.

2

Hazeables offers a variety of puppy treats and infused desserts.

3

The cake and desserts are very reasonably priced.

12
Café Babette image 1
Pastry shop

Pastry shop offers over 15 uniquely crafted baked goods with a simple, unadorned layout featuring old mismatched tables and no labels. Atmosphere feels laid-back and comforting with a bustling, positive energy especially on busy days. No eat-in service or coffee is available, and waiting or preordering is common due to high demand.

Cakes feature exceptional icing and artistic decoration that impress visually and in taste. Varieties like coconut and brown butter lemon curd offer balanced sweetness and elegant textures.

Basque cheesecake stands out with its dense and creamy filling and a pastry cream texture like a cloud. The menu also features a Basque-style cheesecake Danish alongside other baked treats.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and thoughtfully executed."

"This bakery is the best I've had outside of Europe."

"This Basque cheesecake is the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid long waits on weekends.

2

Expect long lines, especially on Saturdays and holidays.

3

Arrive early to secure pastries before they sell out.

13
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Warm baked cookie aroma fills a small space with simple aesthetic and pink gift boxes. Music plays softly, creating a nice atmosphere that feels inviting. Fresh cookies display prominently, drawing attention to variety and quality.

Mini cakes stand out with their moist texture and balanced flavors. Banana upside down and confetti cakes offer soft, delicious bites that pair well with softer cookies.

Cheesecake flavor cookies combine a rich topping with a soft cookie base. The Dubai cheesecake stands out as a favorite among the cheesecake options.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were the best I ever had."

"I loved the fast and easy curbside pickup for takeout."

"The cheesecake topping on these cookies is amazing."

Good to know

1

Online ordering makes cookie pickups quick and easy.

2

Curbside pickup is fast and convenient every time.

3

The store is consistently clean and well-maintained.

14
Mi Sueño Upscale Mexican Cuisine & Cocktails image 1

Upscale Mexican restaurant with stylish decor and a well-stocked bar creates a cozy, lively atmosphere. Live music and DJs keep energy high while offering a friendly, welcoming vibe. Bold, refined flavors complement the vibrant setting.

Tres leches cake stands out with rich, moist layers. Variations like Piña Colada tres leches and Flan de Cajeta add unique flavors to the cake selection.

Mango cheesecake stands out with its amazing flavor and likely house-made quality. Dessert options also include a tres leches cake that complements the cheesecake well.

People are saying

"The Mexican food service was excellent, attentive, and inviting."

"The tres leches cake was a delicious delight."

"The mango cheesecake here is amazing and mouthwatering."

Good to know

1

Happy hour starts at 3 pm with discounted appetizers.

2

Taco Tuesday offers half-off discounts on most tacos.

3

The venue hosts a popular sip and paint experience.

15
Marilyn's Bakery image 1

Warm aroma fills a clean, inviting space with freshly baked treats and detailed custom cakes that impress visually and in taste. The atmosphere balances consistent quality with special occasion craftsmanship, attracting those seeking memorable desserts.

Custom cakes feature detailed character designs like Buzz Lightyear and SpongeBob. Cakes are moist and rich, with flavors like chocolate and pineapple upside-down that get great feedback.

Cheesecakes come with beautiful presentation and rich flavors. The turtle cheesecake bar stands out as particularly decadent.

People are saying

"They brought my vision to life with an incredible custom cake."

"I found the pies here to be fresh and tasty."

"The cheesecake here is excellent and decadent."

Good to know

1

Prices at the bakery are generally high, costing $$$$.

2

The bakery often runs out of popular items like brisket, soup, and quiche.

3

Custom cake orders require clear specifications to avoid mistakes.

16
Kick Starrt Cafe image 1
Halal restaurant

Spacious halal restaurant with modern decor and comfortable seating creates a laid-back, inviting atmosphere ideal for relaxing or working. Live music nights and a massive pool table add to the lively yet chill vibe. The space suits both intimate gatherings and larger meetups.

Chocolate lava cake comes warm and gooey, often paired with ice cream. The carrot cake offers a rich, moist texture, while the cheesecake provides a creamy finish.

Cheesecake comes as a good dessert option here. It appears alongside frozen yogurt and other sweets like lava cake with ice cream.

People are saying

"You have to try their smash burgers; they're the best we've ever had."

"I loved the warm chocolate lava cake with ice cream."

"I thought the cheesecake was good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for catering services to ensure availability.

2

The cafe offers a variety of halal options on the menu.

3

Expect a unique selection of dishes made with fresh ingredients.

17
Melt N Dip image 1
Creperie

Creperie offers a modern decor with cozy seating including cuddle couches and comfy chairs. Atmosphere stays calm and cozy with a lounge-like area, outdoor patio, and a fireplace. Chocolate fountains and luxurious desserts create a distinctive indulgent vibe.

Chocolate cakes stand out with rich, chocolatey flavors and a noticeable Biscoff cookie taste in each bite. Options include a lava cake and an ice cream cake, both well-liked for their texture and flavor.

Lotus cheesecake and Brownies magic come beautifully arranged and draw attention. The strawberry cheesecake stands out as a notable option. Some orders may have quality issues like foreign objects, affecting value.

People are saying

"The chocolate here is heavenly good and delicious."

"The lava cake is warm, chocolaty, and served with vanilla gelato."

"I was fighting over bigger bites of the Lotus cheesecake."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Prices for desserts can be high; expect around $60 for three people.

3

Sliced strawberries cost $15, which is significantly higher than grocery prices.

18
The Cheesecake Lady image 1

Small, colorful bakery with a bright, welcoming atmosphere and cheerful decor. The space feels quaint and charming, inviting visitors to enjoy a relaxed, picture-worthy setting. Known for offering a wide variety of cheesecake options with excellent value for the portion sizes.

Cheesecakes come in light and airy no-bake fillings and rich baked varieties. Options include cheesecake cups with flavors like strawberry and pumpkin caramel, priced reasonably for their size.

People are saying

"I thought the cheesecake was great."

"This Woman Owned spot has the freshest, most delicious cheesecake ever."

"I tried the cheesecake and it was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $5 for small cups to nearly $10 for large cups.

2

A special promotion allows you to buy three cheesecakes and get one free.

3

The shop has a reward card program for repeat customers.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...