Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Deli sandwiches in Indiana

Made for those who prefer their sandwiches sliced and assembled by a traditional deli counter.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
New York Gourmet deli image 1
New York Gourmet deli image 2
New York Gourmet deli image 3
View all

Traditional New York style deli with authentic atmosphere and clean, organized interior. The vibe is chill and welcoming, reflecting classic deli culture. Offers unique meats and sandwiches not commonly found elsewhere.

Large selection of sandwiches and wraps includes standout options like the chopped cheese and roast beef sandwiches. Sandwiches come fast, fresh, and consistently deliver great flavor.

Authentic New York style shines through in the deli sandwiches, especially the Philly Cheesesteaks. Staff provide excellent service and remember orders, making the experience fast and fresh every time.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches here to be amazing and affordable."

"This deli's New York style made me feel like I was back in NYC."

"I found the Philly Cheesesteak flavorful and satisfying."

Good to know

1

The deli is takeout only, with no seating available.

2

Breakfast dishes are served all day, a unique feature of the deli.

3

Platters are only available during breakfast hours.

02
Tony's Italian Deli image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian deli with an immaculate layout and a warm, homey atmosphere creates a sense of community. Family-owned vibe welcomes guests with authentic Italian offerings and fresh sandwiches. Cleanliness and attention to detail stand out throughout the space.

Meatball sandwiches stand out for their authentic flavor reminiscent of homemade recipes. Italian subs feature top-quality Italian meats and a delicious Italian Beef and Sausage Combo with hot giardinara.

A full deli of authentic Italian items offers a warm atmosphere with fantastic deli help and a clean, well-maintained space. Meatball sandwiches and various salads stand out for their homemade quality and authentic flavors.

People are saying

"I loved the huge, flavorful Italian beef sandwich."

"This is a 5-star deli that I highly recommend."

"I thought the cannoli here was the freshest, crunchiest, and tastiest I ever had."

Good to know

1

Tony's Italian Deli opens at 11 am on weekdays.

2

Tony's Italian Deli opens at 10 am on weekends.

3

The restrooms and dining area are clean.

03
M J's Polish Deli image 1

Old World style deli with sausage hanging on the wall creates an ethnic and inviting atmosphere. Small store offers a large selection of Polish essentials including fresh and smoked sausages, pierogis, and soups. Clean and well-maintained space serves as a local gem for authentic Polish food.

Deli sandwiches come with a satisfying mix of flavors and pair well with chips and pop. The sandwiches stand out for their delicious taste and solid quality.

Offers authentic home-cooked Polish food with a wide variety of traditional items. Known for excellent potato cakes, cabbage rolls, and must-have sausage served consistently over the years.

People are saying

"This Polish sausage is a holiday tradition, just like Grandpa's borscht."

"The mushroom soup and red borscht are exceptional."

"You have to try the Polish deli sausages; they're phenomenal."

Good to know

1

The deli offers a large selection of cooked, baked, and frozen Polish delicacies.

2

Imported items from Poland are available for purchase.

3

The store maintains a clean and organized environment.

04
Midday Deli & Catering image 1

Small sandwich shop with a small town feel and basic interior offers quick, reasonably priced lunches. The atmosphere is packed with deliciousness, attracting those seeking homemade sandwiches and daily specials. Energy stays steady during lunch hours with a focus on fresh, in-house made food.

Sandwiches come with bold flavors and are quite filling. Options like the brisket sandwich and Midday Melt stand out, with lunch specials bundling a sandwich, soup, and drink for about $15.

Small deli packs a big punch of deliciousness with its sandwiches. Offers an amazing lunch that draws people from other towns.

People are saying

"Their sandwiches are flavorful and filling."

"The chicken chili soup was just okay, kind of meh."

"I found the deli food to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Daily specials are offered, providing a unique meal option each day.

2

Lunch specials are around $15, including a soup, sandwich, and drink.

3

Most items are made in-house, ensuring freshness and quality.

05
Joe's Butcher Shop and Fish Market image 1

Traditional butcher shop setup combines with European charm and a cozy, colorful atmosphere. Big dining area hosts a steady flow of people drawn by top-quality meats and seafood and unique, highly praised sandwiches. The shop balances a clean, classic feel with a friendly, local vibe.

Hot sandwiches stand out with unique flavors like the Aji Amarillo Flank Steak and Hot Capicola. The BLT and meatloaf sandwiches also deliver phenomenal taste with fresh, curated meats and cheeses.

Deli sandwiches stand out with unique flavors and generous portions like the flank steak with extra meat. Hot sandwiches offer a phenomenal taste that makes this deli a favorite spot for quality sandwiches.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best I ever had."

"I found the seafood here to be always good quality."

"I found the deli sandwiches to be phenomenal and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the back of the shop.

2

Joe's offers a variety of cheeses, curated meats, and daily fresh sandwiches.

3

Expect high-quality meats and seafood at Joe's.

06
Richie’s Corner Deli image 1

Old school deli with a warm, Brooklyn-Bronx vibe offers high quality sandwiches and BBQ ribs on Saturdays. Food is made with care, creating a relaxed pace and loyal following. Limited daily availability of some items adds a sense of exclusivity to the experience.

Sandwiches feature upscale meats, cheeses, and breads with fresh, top notch ingredients. Options like the smoked pork belly and moist meatball sandwich offer rich, flavorful bites packed with plenty of meat.

Sandwiches feature upscale meats, cheeses, and breads wrapped neatly. The deli offers high quality cold cut subs alongside exceptional BBQ options with attentive staff service.

People are saying

"I tried their cheesesteak sandwiches and they were amazing."

"I think their BBQ sauces and flavors are some of the best around."

"The deli and BBQ options here are exceptional."

Good to know

1

The BBQ Ribs are only available on Saturday.

2

Prices are high, but the food is substantial.

3

They display what is and isn't available on their site.

07
Cousin Vinny's Deli & The Sub Hub image 1

Deli resembles a clean gas station market with a friendly atmosphere and affordable prices. Sandwiches are fresh and filling, featuring standout options like chicken cordon bleu and grilled chicken Philly. The vibe is casual and unpretentious, with quick service and a focus on value.

Chicken cordon bleu stands out as a top sandwich here, with others like corned beef also highly praised. Sandwiches stay fresh and not soggy, offer great value, and come in a solid variety.

Sandwiches come out fresh, filling, and delicious. This deli offers some of the best deli sandwiches around, making it a regular stop for quality subs.

People are saying

"The Cousin Vinny sandwich was the obvious standout."

"The deli sandwiches here are delicious and so fresh."

"Their homemade ice cream is always a treat."

Good to know

1

The sandwiches are reasonably priced, making them a good value.

2

Orders typically arrive within 10 minutes, ensuring quick service.

3

The belly buster deal offers three meats and a choice of cheese for $8.

08
Rob's Meat Chop & Deli image 1
Butcher shop deli

Butcher shop deli offers clean interior and wonderful floors with a large selection of meats and foods. Atmosphere feels friendly despite some mixed vibes, with a pub serving warm sandwiches and soups. Known for great prices and high-quality cuts, it stands out as a local favorite for meat and deli products.

Daily sandwiches feature generous portions and come with well-cooked steak options. Subs offer good value and the pub serves warm sandwiches alongside soups.

Huge selection of meats and deli items fills the counter, which stays immaculate. Prices stay very reasonable, with excellent options in meats, salads, and pastas.

People are saying

"I found the deli here has a huge selection of meats and prepared foods."

"The steaks here are unbelievably good and tender."

"These sandwiches are killer and totally awesome."

Good to know

1

Rob's Meat Chop & Deli offers a wide selection of meats, deli items, and seafood.

2

Prices on beef, seafood, and pork products are very reasonable.

3

Locally sourced meat is available, with bulk purchases offering great deals.

09
Titus Bakery and Deli image 1

Bakery offers a cozy, unpretentious atmosphere with an enticing aroma and a wide selection of donuts and pastries. Drive-thru service and a soda fountain add convenience and variety. The place draws a busy crowd during peak hours and stands out for its top-notch treats without unnecessary fuss.

Sandwiches come with reasonable prices and often include horseradish sauce as a recommended addition. Meat can be heated on request, and the sandwiches consistently taste very tasty and satisfying.

Donuts and deli sandwiches stand out with fantastic donuts and solid deli items. Bagels come from Lebanon, Indiana, but common flavors like everything and onion are not available.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts were the best I had ever tasted."

"I found the sandwiches to be very tasty."

"The Deli staff are so sweet and friendly, even when busy."

Good to know

1

Titus Bakery and Deli is closed on Sundays.

2

The place can get busy during peak hours.

3

There was no restroom available for customers.

10
AlBasha of Fishers – Mediterranean Kitchen image 1

Small Mediterranean restaurant connects directly to a grocery store, creating a simple yet tasteful setting with homey atmosphere and welcoming vibe. Lighting tends to be somewhat dark, and noise levels can rise when busy. Known for authentic halal dishes and fresh, flavorful food, it attracts those seeking genuine Mediterranean flavors.

Falafel and shawarma sandwiches stand out as the best here. The menu also features a Philly steak sandwich and a Chicken Souvlaki Pita Sandwich, all well made.

A deli offers a mix of fresh meats and foreign treats. Some deli meats can be found past their sell by date by a few days.

People are saying

"I found the food to be absolutely delicious."

"I found the falafel and shawarma sandwiches to be the best."

"The Deli meats and items I got were so fresh."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a variety of halal options for diners.

2

Expect fresh ingredients and authentic Middle Eastern flavors.

3

Prices are reasonable, but some items may have increased recently.

11
Big Frank's Sausage image 1
Polish restaurant

Cozy Polish restaurant with an old-school vibe and comfortable bar seating creates a welcoming, relaxed atmosphere. Multiple TVs stream sports, including football, enhancing the friendly neighborhood feel. Outdoor patio allows service animals, adding to the inclusive environment.

Real off-the-bone Polish ham stars in the BIG sandwich. Toasted bread, warm turkey, and melted cheese create a flavorful first bite. The Reuben and belly buster sandwiches also stand out.

A small deli counter offers a selection of sausages and other deli products. Smoked sausage sticks are a common item to grab from the deli section.

People are saying

"I loved the fresh Polish sausage with lots of garlic."

"I loved the pierogies, especially the mushroom kraut."

"I loved the Polish sausage and pierogis here."

Good to know

1

Pizza is available on weekends.

2

The restaurant offers a Friday Fish Fry.

3

Kids under 21 are welcome in the family reserved area.

12
McAlister's Deli image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers a cozy, laid-back atmosphere with soft music playing through ceiling speakers. Staff interactions include casual, joking exchanges that add to the informal vibe. Large groups fit comfortably, and a private room is available for gatherings.

Sandwiches come made to order with options like the fresh picked garden turkey and the New Yorker. Half sandwich and half salad combos offer good size and value, with wraps and grilled chicken club also available.

Small fast food spots serve consistent deli sandwiches across locations. Atmosphere suits eating with family or friends or solo.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

"I thought the sandwiches here were great and a good size for the money."

"I thought the deli sandwiches here were top-notch."

Good to know

1

Expect a long wait time during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant maintains a clean environment with freshly cleaned tables.

3

Prices for meals can be on the higher side, especially for lunch.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...