Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Indiana

Italian food

A plate of pasta or a wood-fired pizza offers the kind of simple, reliable comfort that only Italian food provides.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Tony's Italian Deli image 1
Tony's Italian Deli image 2
Tony's Italian Deli image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Italian deli offers authentic cannolis and fresh sandwiches with top-quality sausage. Warm, homey vibe creates a sense of community. Immaculate layout and cleanliness make it inviting and comfortable.

Cannolis stand out as authentic and better than many in major Italian neighborhoods. The Italian sausage and ricotta cheese are also top quality, making sandwiches and stuffed shells worth trying.

People are saying

"I loved the huge, flavorful Italian beef sandwich."

"This is a 5-star deli that I highly recommend."

"I thought the Italian food's cannoli were the freshest, crunchiest, and tastiest."

Good to know

1

Tony's Italian Deli opens at 11 am on weekdays.

2

Tony's Italian Deli opens at 10 am on weekends.

3

The restrooms and dining area are clean.

02
The NY Slice image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small spot offers authentic New York-style pizza with a friendly, homey atmosphere. Cannoli and garlic knots shine, with sliced Italian sausage adding flavor. Personalized service keeps prices reasonable and vibe welcoming.

Phenomenal cannoli stands out alongside pizza and garlic knots. Sliced Italian sausage adds a perfect touch to many dishes.

People are saying

"I found authentic New York style pizza here."

"You have to save room for the amazing cannolis."

"This Italian food is the best New York style pizza I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The NY Slice is primarily a carry-out restaurant with limited dine-in options.

2

Prices are very affordable, with family meals available for around $30.

3

The restaurant is usually not busy, allowing for quick service.

03
Velly Pizza & Indian street food image 1

Space blends clean design with a calming atmosphere and good music. Crowd loves authentic Indian-inspired pizza with halal options and customizable spice. Butter chicken pasta and Tandoori Chicken Pizza offer rich, unique twists on Italian classics.

Butter chicken pasta stands out with rich Indian flavors. The Tandoori Chicken Pizza and Velly style breadsticks add unique twists to classic Italian dishes.

People are saying

"I've never tasted pizza this good; it's the best I've ever had."

"I tasted authentic street food from Punjab, perfectly cooked."

"I ordered the butter chicken pasta and it was a 10/10."

Good to know

1

They offer halal options and allow you to customize the spice level.

2

The pricing is reasonable with a 2 large pizza, 3 toppings deal.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

04
INDY PIZZA PRO image 1
Pizza restaurant

Modern spot with fresh handmade dough and lively games. Offers great pizza and pasta bowls plus tasty pesto bread. Wings add a nice touch to the Italian menu. Atmosphere suits groups and couples alike.

Great pizza and pasta bowls stand out here. The pesto bread adds a tasty twist, and wings complement the Italian offerings well.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was really delicious and fresh."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, was great!"

"The Indian food here is loaded with amazing fresh flavor."

Good to know

1

They make their own fresh dough and sauce every day.

2

The prices are reasonable for the quality of food.

3

There is handicapped parking available.

05
Amore Mio Italian Subs and Espresso Bar image 1

Italian deli-themed cafe offers huge Milano ciabatta sandwiches and authentic tiramisu. Cozy, spotless decor with peaceful atmosphere invites relaxation. Quality espresso complements the friendly vibe perfectly.

Huge, delicious Milano ciabatta sandwiches stand out here. The Florence Ciabatta tastes authentic, like something from Italy. Tiramisu ranks among the best.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are huge and packed with fresh meat."

"I enjoyed the true Italian espresso and gelato."

"These Italian sandwiches are huge, fresh, and packed with flavor."

Good to know

1

The establishment offers authentic Italian beverages and desserts.

2

The portion sizes are very large, especially for sandwiches.

3

They have a loyalty program for frequent customers.

06
H Steakhouse image 1
Restaurant

Modern, spacious restaurant offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with upbeat music enhancing the lively vibe. Italian dishes like Veal Chop Saltimbocca and Scallops with risotto shine, with risotto being exceptionally good. Multiple seating options fit all group sizes.

Veal Chop Saltimbocca comes wonderfully seasoned and seared. Scallops served with risotto stand out, with risotto noted as exceptionally good. Chicken Parmigiana arrives in a generous portion.

People are saying

"I had the steak and it was great."

"The service at these dinner spots is outstanding and attentive."

"The Italian food's scallops and risotto are amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking is free for the first three hours in the nearby garage.

2

Valet parking is available for $5, saving you a walk in the cold.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekends and special occasions.

07
Von's Vittles image 1
Restaurant

Cozy, family-owned spot shines with phenomenal egg rolls and a diverse soul food-inspired menu. Italian dishes feature scratch-made Alfredo sauce and hearty portions like the 2-pound chicken Alfredo bake potato. Expect a busy vibe and long lines on weekends.

Alfredo sauce stands out as phenomenal and made from scratch. Dishes like the creamy and spicy Rasta Pasta and the 2-pound chicken Alfredo bake potato offer large, flavorful portions.

People are saying

"The shrimp Alfredo potatoe was flavorful and enough for two."

"You have to try the peach cobbler egg rolls; they're like peach cobbler with ice cream."

"The Rasta Pasta is creamy, spicy, and a great deal."

Good to know

1

Von's Vittles only opens on weekends.

2

Expect a 40-minute wait to place and receive your order.

3

The soul food bowl costs $27, which is higher than average.

08
Blossom Potatoes image 1

Restaurant shines with 67 stuffed potato varieties featuring soul food like braised oxtail and Cajun chicken. Italian dishes include Cajun Alfredo blending steak and chicken, plus kid-friendly carbonara. Vibrant, family-owned spot offers a friendly, clean space loved by diverse guests.

Chicken Fettuccine comes with a baked potato and broccoli. The Cajun Alfredo blends steak and chicken flavors. Kids enjoy the carbonara noodles.

People are saying

"I thought the food was really good and tasty."

"I loved the homemade lemon pound cake with caramel."

"I will definitely be going back for the jumbo potato."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is very clean and well-maintained.

2

The eatery is Black-owned and operated by a family.

3

You can drop your trailer at the Pilot or TA off Burr Street.

09
Amici Grill and Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza spot offers a quiet atmosphere with comfy booths and great playlists. Fried cheese wheel and garlic knots with two sauces highlight the Italian food menu. Friendly family vibe suits both dine-in and carry-out, perfect with wine or beer.

Fried cheese wheel replaces typical mozzarella sticks with a crispy, cheesy twist. Garlic knots come with both alfredo and marinara sauces. Pasta dishes like sausage and pepper and spaghetti with meatballs stand out for their flavor.

People are saying

"I loved my Italian beef sandwich; it was fantastic."

"I found the sausage and pepper pasta super delicious and spicy."

"You have to try the gyro pizza; it tastes just like a gyro."

Good to know

1

A credit card fee applies, so consider paying with cash for savings.

2

Expect generous portion sizes, making it a good value for the price.

3

The restaurant can get busy during lunchtime, so plan accordingly.

10
Frankie V's Bar & Grill image 1

Nostalgic interior creates a family-friendly atmosphere with lively, cozy vibes. Italian sausage made on site adds rich flavor to classic dishes like lasagne and pizza. Tavern-style pizza and hearty sandwiches offer consistent quality in food and drinks.

Italian sausage made on site stands out with rich flavor. The menu features Jalapeño Cheese Ravioli, seasoned pizza chips with marinara, and hearty sandwiches like the Ribeye and Meatball. Lasagne and pizza also deliver solid Italian classics.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious."

"The bar has a really friendly, family atmosphere."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and beef, is amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking is available on the side of the restaurant.

2

Prices are generally affordable, with meals and drinks under $170 for five people.

3

The restaurant offers catering services for events.

11
Cafe Noricha image 1
Brunch restaurant

Modern, trendy space offers a spacious atmosphere with live music and outdoor seating for a relaxed vibe. Italian dishes shine with Pasta Alla Carbonara featuring creamy sauce and tender noodles. Perfect for quiet moments or casual catch-ups.

Pasta Alla Carbonara stands out with rich, creamy sauce and perfectly cooked noodles. The steak is hearty and tender, while the Braised Oxtail offers deep, full flavor.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and delicious."

"The tea here is amazing, and the service is so nice."

"The Italian food, especially the lobster mac and cheese, is amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the public garage for free for the first 4 hours.

2

Brunch is served all day, making it a flexible dining option.

3

Karaoke nights are lively and popular, attracting many visitors.

12
Lo'Shell's Cajun and Creole Flavors image 1

Small, homey spot feels like Sunday dinner with warm, welcoming vibes. Authentic Cajun flavors shine in seafood gumbo and peach cobbler. Shrimp Alfredo blends a perfect kick and Creole flavor. Takeout with advance orders works best due to limited dine-in and inconsistent hours.

Shrimp Alfredo stands out with its perfect balance of kick and Louisiana Creole flavor. Seafood gumbo and chicken Alfredo also deliver phenomenal taste and rich flavors.

People are saying

"The seafood gumbo here is fiery, flavorful, and full of meat."

"The Shrimp Alfredo is phenomenal and I'd order it again."

"I found the peach cobbler to be exceptional."

Good to know

1

It's best to order ahead of your arrival to ensure you get your meal promptly.

2

The dine-in area appears to be closed during weekday lunch.

3

The restaurant's hours can be inconsistent, so calling ahead is recommended.

13
Macizo Restaurant image 1

Cozy space offers a warm, homey vibe with friendly energy from owners. Bright, fruity cocktails pair well with exquisite spaghetti and sweet spicy pasta. Fresh bread and focaccia with sauces complement rich dishes, blending casual charm with exceptional Mexican flavors.

Sweet and spicy pasta stands out alongside exquisite spaghetti served as an appetizer. Fresh bread and focaccia come with various sauces for dipping, complementing dishes rich in beef, potatoes, and pasta.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and some of the best."

"Their homemade sourdough bread is fantastic and memorable."

"The Italian food here is amazing, with a unique flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating.

2

The restaurant offers a unique blend of Mexican and Peruvian cuisine.

3

Tamales are made in-house, showcasing a commitment to quality.

14
Angie’s BREAKFAST & GRILL image 1

Small, quaint spot with soul & R&B music sets a warm vibe. Chicken Alfredo shines with a crispy, rich twist, blending Italian flavors with a spicy Cajun kick. Tight space feels cozy and family-friendly, plus drive-thru service adds easy convenience.

Chicken Alfredo stands out with a crispy twist and rich flavor. The Cajun chicken Alfredo offers a spicy take on classic pasta, paired well with other Italian-inspired dishes like shrimp and grits.

People are saying

"I found the breakfast here to be very delicious."

"I loved the chicken and waffles; the chicken was seasoned perfectly."

"I was excited to go back and get more Chicken Alfredo."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is a bit small, so large parties might find it challenging to dine there.

2

The restaurant was busy, but we were seated right away.

3

The portions were great for the price.

15
Sauce on the Side image 1
Italian restaurant

Calzone-focused eatery shines with unique calzones blending pizza and pasta flavors. Spacious seating offers stadium views and natural light, creating a laid-back vibe. Retro soda fountain and TVs add casual touches to the lively atmosphere.

Unique calzones combine pizza and pasta flavors, like the eggplant calzone with marinara. Salads feature Italian staples such as artichoke hearts and salami ribbons, while sauces like pesto queso and marinara serve as standout dips.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing."

"I'd never tasted a calzone so unique and full of flavor."

"The calzones here are large, crispy, and filled with greatness."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a gluten-free crust for an additional $4.

2

Dairy-free cheese is available for an extra $1.50.

3

Prices are reasonable, with a meal for six averaging around $100.

16
Amore! Italian Kitchen image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers a warm, relaxing atmosphere with Edison bulb lighting and old charm. Roast Pork Ragu delivers rich flavors while lasagna shines with a sweet sauce and homemade marinara. Live music adds a friendly vibe that fills the space without crowding.

Roast Pork Ragu stands out with rich flavors. Lasagna comes with a sweet sauce that pairs well with the homemade marinara, which is rich and flavorful.

People are saying

"The Italian food service here is fantastic and makes it an experience."

"The cannoli here are huge and delicious."

"Our server made sure we lacked nothing during dinner."

Good to know

1

On Tuesdays, wine is half price and there are specials on bolognese.

2

Wednesdays feature live music at the restaurant.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

17
Harrison’s image 1
Restaurant

Renovated bank building offers a preserved vault room for a unique dining vibe. Italian dishes shine with rich Fettuccine Alfredo and light chicken piccata. Relaxed, sophisticated atmosphere pairs well with a spacious outdoor patio serving water in upcycled bottles.

Fettuccine Alfredo stands out with its rich, creamy sauce. The menu also features chicken piccata that is light and flavorful, alongside a fresh burrata appetizer and salad.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is terrific, especially the chicken dishes."

"My steak was perfectly cooked and delicious."

"The patio space here is awesome and not right on the street."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially for larger groups.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Tuesday is steak night with special pricing on steak dishes.

18
Mia pizzaria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Family-owned spot serves New York style pizza with a cozy vibe and a huge TV for sports fans. Italian dishes shine with margarine-garlic crust and plant-based mozzarella in calzones. Friendly staff and clean space make it welcoming for all.

New York style pizza and breadsticks come with a margarine-garlic glaze on the crust and sticks. The calzone features plant-based mozzarella with a cheese pull, though the Italian sausage could be better.

People are saying

"This New York Style Pizza has a perfectly thin, flavorful crust."

"The lunch special here is a great value for the price."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, is massive and delicious."

Good to know

1

They currently have a $10 lunch special that includes a slice of NY pizza, 3 breadsticks, and a 20 oz drink.

2

The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

3

Mia Pizzaria is a family-owned local business with a focus on quality.

19
BlackSheep Pizza & Cocktails - Westfield image 1

Open kitchen with bar seating offers a lively dining vibe. Italian dishes shine with garlic bread trio and fresh Caprese salad starters. Cozy, heated patio and excellent cocktails make it great for dates or family meals.

Warm, soft breadsticks start the meal with full flavor. Garlic bread comes with a combo of pesto, whipped feta, and marinara. Caprese salad serves as a wonderful starter.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was one of the very best I've had."

"The cocktails here are tasty and perfectly prepared."

"You have to try the award-winning Neapolitan pizza here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to limited seating capacity.

2

Parking is limited due to ongoing construction around the restaurant.

3

Expect a wait time of about 1 hour 45 minutes to 2 hours during peak hours.

20
Nyla's image 1
Restaurant

Barn-like setting offers intimate seating with cozy tables close together. Italian dishes shine with zucchini pasta and rich risotto. Outdoor dining under string lights adds to the romantic vibe, perfect for an adult crowd.

Zucchini pasta appears in multiple dishes, paired with shrimp or served as spaghetti. The menu features rich items like port reduction risotto with duck and crab stuffed mushrooms. Sides like au gratin potatoes and cornbread complement the main courses.

People are saying

"The food here was terrific and tasty."

"The sea bass here is perfectly prepared, unlike any other I've had."

"The chicken milanese is generously portioned and flavorful Italian food."

Good to know

1

Nyla's only allows guests aged 21 and older.

2

Valet parking is available for convenience, costing $10.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

21
Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza spot shines with fresh toppings and a family-friendly vibe. Italian dishes like baked spaghetti and steak strombolis bring solid flavor. Space feels warm but busy, best for takeout or delivery.

Baked spaghetti and meatballs stand out with excellent flavor. Dishes like spaghetti with meat sauce, steak strombolis, and BBQ pizza offer a varied Italian menu. Pasta and pizza are acceptable, with calzones being fairly delicious and lasagna served a bit sloppily.

People are saying

"This local spot has great pizza with a nice sauce and chewy crust."

"The Calzone here is great; the staff is so nice and accommodating."

"The Italian food here is always hot and delicious."

Good to know

1

Almost all toppings, except one, cost $1.03 to add.

2

Everything is made to order, ensuring freshness.

3

Expect a messy hallway with construction supplies leading to the restrooms.

22
Bocca image 1
Restaurant

Cozy spot with a gorgeous outdoor patio and live local music sets a romantic mood. Italian dishes shine with truffle arancini and rich mushroom ravioli. A chic basement speakeasy adds unique charm for intimate nights.

Mushroom ravioli comes with a rich, flavorful sauce that balances well. Truffle arancini and pasta dishes like bolognese, carbonara, and della casa stand out alongside perfectly seasoned risotto and fresh appetizers like beef carpaccio and raw oysters.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the Tortellacci, is outstanding."

"The outdoor seating has a gorgeous vibe."

"It's a perfect spot for a romantic date night."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $1 oysters and discounted drinks from 4-5pm daily.

2

Live jazz performances occur every Tuesday evening on the patio.

3

Bocca has a one-hour happy hour with special liquor pours.

23
Rosemary & Olive Italian Restaurant image 1

Small interior with chic modern design and an art deco twist creates an intimate setting. Rigatoni Bolognese and pesto gnocchi with chicken offer fantastic Italian flavors. Outdoor seating provides a quieter dining option amid a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Rigatoni Bolognese has a scrumptious look and is described as fantastic by those who tried it. Pesto gnocchi with chicken delivers impactful flavor and stands out on the menu.

People are saying

"The Dinner Spots here are authentic Italian with huge portions."

"I could have eaten only the beet salad and been happy."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, was perfectly tender and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during busy hours.

2

Expect a wait if visiting during peak dining times.

3

The restaurant participates in Devour Downtown with special menus.

24
Vinny's Drive Bar image 1

Dive bar buzzes with live music and outdoor seating, perfect for dog lovers. XL pizzas boast custom toppings and crispy sides like mozzarella sticks. Games like corn hole keep the vibe casual while prices stay affordable.

Pizza comes in an XL size with customizable meat and veggie toppings. Breadsticks arrive hot, garlic-infused, or with cheese dip, and mozzarella sticks and fried green tomatoes offer crisp textures with flavorful sauces.

People are saying

"The bar food here is great, especially the pizza and wings."

"The hand-pounded, breaded tenderloin is fried to perfection."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and breadsticks, is extra cheesy and piping hot."

Good to know

1

Vinny's Drive Bar offers a drive-up service for convenient takeout.

2

The outdoor seating area is dog-friendly, perfect for pet owners.

3

Expect reasonable prices for food and drinks, with good portion sizes.

25
Bronko's Pizza Schererville image 1

Spacious spot blends bar atmosphere with indoor golf and simulators for fun. Pizza shines with fluffy breadsticks and sweet marinara. Comfortable high tops invite families and adults to relax and enjoy.

Pizza and breadsticks stand out with fluffy, warm breadsticks and a sweet marinara sauce for dipping. Portions match the cost, though some items come out a bit overdone.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was delicious and tasted great."

"It's a kid-friendly place with fun simulators and batting cages."

"The Italian food's breadsticks were pretty good with sweet sauce."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Wednesday at 7pm with no entry fee.

2

The restaurant offers takeout options for lunch and dinner.

3

Delivery service is available and typically fast.

26
Enzo Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza spot offers drive-thru convenience and a cozy atmosphere with outdoor seating. Italian dishes shine with marinara sauce and classics like calzones and spaghetti aglio e olio. Fresh, customizable pies keep flavors straightforward and satisfying.

Marinara sauce stands out as a key highlight. The menu features pepperoni breadsticks, calzones, and house pasta, along with spinach roll and spaghetti aglio e olio.

People are saying

"I thought Enzo Pizza served the best pizza in town."

"The Drive Thru pizza here is huge and delicious, with monstrous slices."

"Their pizza is huge and delicious, a perfect comfort slice."

Good to know

1

Enzo Pizza offers a drive-thru for convenient takeout.

2

Expect an average wait time of about 20 minutes during peak hours.

3

You can dine in or take out at Enzo Pizza.

27
Nino's Pizza Noblesville image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza spot inside a VFW hall serves thin crust pizza with a friendly atmosphere. Italian sausage pizza shines with rich flavor, paired with airy breadsticks and classic desserts like cannoli. Seating at barstools invites casual chats and smiles.

Italian sausage pizza stands out with its rich flavor. Breadsticks come airy and soft with perfect seasoning. Desserts include cannoli and tiramisu that offer classic Italian sweetness.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be very good."

"I thought the sandwiches here were fantastic."

"You should save room for the wonderful desserts, especially the gelato."

Good to know

1

Bingo night happens every Friday evening, attracting a large crowd.

2

Expect unpredictable wait times due to the restaurant's location inside the VFW.

3

Orders are typically ready for pickup within 30 minutes after ordering.

28
Jack's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Thin crust pizzas shine with fresh crispness and buttery breadsticks add rich flavor. Busy seating shows popularity while delivery is usually on time. Prices feel high but Italian food lovers enjoy the consistent taste when eaten fresh.

Pizza and breadsticks stand out with fresh, crisp, and buttery qualities. Both deliver consistent satisfaction without disappointment.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, is amazing."

"I thought the pizza was the best I had ever tasted."

"The delivery staff here are always very nice and pleasant."

Good to know

1

Pizza prices start at $30 for a medium with four toppings.

2

Delivery service is consistently on time.

3

The pizza is best eaten the same day for optimal taste.

29
Bugambilias Mexican Cuisine image 1
Mexican restaurant

Cozy dining room with festive decor sets a warm, family-friendly mood. Spaghetti con pollo offers rich flavors while tacos add a tasty twist. Quiet Spanish music and sports on TV create a lively but comfortable vibe.

Spaghetti con pollo stands out with rich flavors, while the Mexican spaghetti offers a unique twist on classic pasta. The menu also features tacos that complement the Italian dishes well.

People are saying

"I thought their Mexican food was the best I've ever had."

"The food here is authentic, delicious, and full of flavor."

"You have to try the spaghetti; it's the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Bugambilias is closed on Tuesdays.

2

There was hardly any parking at Bugambilias.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is preferred for tips.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...