Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Bagel spots in Indianapolis

A bagel is only worth your time if it is made with the right texture and care.

Based on 530 Opinions
+527
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bagel Fair image 1
Bagel Fair image 2
Bagel Fair image 3
View all
Bagel shop

Freshly baked bagels fill the air with an authentic New York style aroma in a welcoming atmosphere. The shop blends modern and classic styles after renovations, creating an updated yet unassuming space. Long waits show how top-tier bagels keep customers coming back.

Freshly baked bagels fill the air with an authentic New York style aroma. A wide variety of flavors includes a jalapeño bagel with jalapeño cream cheese that stands out as a fantastic combo.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be the best I'd ever had."

"The breakfast bagels here are always fresh and sometimes still warm."

"It's a timeless, not-too-fancy spot that's great for kids."

Good to know

1

Bagel Fair closes early, at 1 o'clock on Sundays and 2 o'clock the rest of the week.

2

The store accepts cards and is not cash-only, contrary to the Google description.

3

There was no seating area, only counter service for takeout.

02
chronic coffee & smoothies image 1

Tiny coffee shop with a witchy aesthetic offers strong espresso and fresh bagels like blueberry with cream cheese. Local art and plants create a relaxed vibe, while games and stickers add charm. Seating is limited, perfect for quick visits.

Bagels come super fresh with options like blueberry bagel with cream cheese and bagels served with vegan butter. The cream cheese is well balanced, especially on the blueberry bagel.

People are saying

"The coffee here is smooth and delicious."

"You have to try the empanadas; they're so delicious."

"I found the bagels here to be really cute and amazing."

Good to know

1

Seating is limited, so plan to visit during off-peak hours.

2

The café is dog-friendly, making it a great stop for pet owners.

3

They use coffee ice cubes to prevent drinks from getting watered down.

03
The Groovy Cafe image 1

Cozy cafe blends a laid-back atmosphere with rosemary sea salt bagels that are crisp outside and soft inside. Retro decorations and quiet vibes make it perfect for chats. Friendly energy feels like a home away from home.

Bagels come with a crisp outside and soft inside, often paired with velvety cream cheese. The rosemary sea salt variety stands out, especially in breakfast sandwiches.

People are saying

"The coffee and food at this cafe are delicious."

"The breakfast staff here is so kind and welcoming."

"These bagels are a little slice of heaven."

Good to know

1

Online ordering is available for convenient pickup.

2

The cafe offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

3

Happy hour features half-price coffee and ice cream.

04
Perk Up image 1

Small cafe offers crispy everything bagels with egg and bacon, perfect for breakfast. Enjoy a peaceful atmosphere with 50s and 60s music and pet-friendly outdoor seating near a popular trail. Limited seating keeps the vibe quiet and relaxed.

Breakfast sandwiches on everything bagels come with crispy texture, large folded egg, cheese, and bacon. The bagels taste very fresh and pair well with matcha.

People are saying

"Their lattes are excellent, smooth, and creamy."

"The outdoor seating is great for enjoying their fresh baked goods."

"The bagel breakfast sandwich here is unbelievable."

Good to know

1

There is no indoor seating available; all dining is outside.

2

Prices are not listed on the menu or online, making it hard to budget.

3

Expect long wait times for food and drinks during busy hours.

05
Sidedoor Bagel image 1
Bagel shop

Small corner shop offers a cozy vibe with dog-friendly space and outdoor seating. Fresh bagels boast a crispy crust and bold flavors like rosemary. Popular spot often has lines but stays lively and welcoming.

Bagels come out fresh and warm with a perfectly crisp exterior and a generously spiced crust. The flavor profile and consistency hit just right, making sandwiches like the rosemary bagel stand out.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were great and a must-try."

"I had the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had."

"I found free parking right in front, it was easy."

Good to know

1

There is no seating indoors at Sidedoor Bagel; takeout only.

2

Mobile ordering is recommended to avoid long lines on weekends.

3

Expect to wait 10-20 minutes for your order during busy times.

06
Bearded Bagel image 1
Bagel shop

Bagel shop serves fresh bagels in over 10 flavors like jalapeño cheddar with soft texture and tasty sandwiches. Espresso coffee pairs well in a quiet, chill spot with friendly staff and simple seating for quick meals.

Bagels come in over 10 different flavors daily with freshness and softness that stand out. The texture and flavor combinations like jalapeño cheddar and asiago cheese are notable, and the bagel sandwiches are consistently top notch and well worth the price.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the best I've ever eaten."

"The coffee here is top-notch, especially the handcrafted lattes."

"I found the biscuits and gravy to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a 25-minute wait for sandwiches around 11:30 AM on Saturdays.

2

Online orders may not process correctly, so check your card charges.

3

The food truck is popular at local events and offers a great selection.

07
Tam's Sweet & Savory Café image 1

Cozy, eclectic vibe shines with vintage mix-and-match plates and a peaceful back patio. Classic Lox and Bagel sandwich offers a traditional taste, though dill may not suit all. Intimate setting feels like breakfast at a friend's home with locally sourced food.

The Lox and Bagel sandwich stands out with its classic preparation. Dill appears on the lox bagel but may not suit everyone's taste.

People are saying

"The quiche crust is flaky and buttery, just like the eggs are fluffy."

"The strawberry salad with lemon vinaigrette is fantastic."

"The lox bagel sandwich was fantastic."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in an adjacent lot for visitors.

2

The café is open Wednesday through Sunday from 8am to 2pm.

3

The café accommodates dietary restrictions and offers a variety of options.

08
Foundry Provisions image 1

Bright, airy cafe buzzes with lively energy from high school groups. Handmade bagels shine, especially the jalapeño bagel with bacon. Colorful murals and a dog-friendly patio add to the welcoming, homey vibe.

Toasted bagels come handmade, perfectly soft and chewy. The jalapeño bagel stands out, and adding bacon boosts the flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was great."

"This cafe is a cute, lively spot that's great for conversations."

"These bagels are handmade, perfectly soft and chewy."

Good to know

1

Parking is only available on the street, and it can be hard to find.

2

Expect long wait times, especially during busy hours with students.

3

The breakfast sandwich costs $9.50, and the menu is small but decadent.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...