Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Indianapolis' best

Sandwich cakes

A sandwich shop that actually takes its cake seriously instead of treating it like a generic afterthought.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Amberson Coffee & Grocer image 1
Amberson Coffee & Grocer image 2
Amberson Coffee & Grocer image 3
View all

Small coffee shop inside a repurposed old gas station offers a minimalist design with rustic architecture and vintage signage. Atmosphere feels cozy and cool, with a calm, friendly vibe and dog-friendly patio. Specialty coffee and espresso draw enthusiasts, served with attention to detail like reusable glass jars.

Rich and flavorful almond cake stands out alongside a large, frosted banana cake served in generous slices. The pistachio rose petal cake offers a unique, excellent option for variety.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with freshly made eggy fillings and a creamy sauce that adds rich flavor. These sandwiches consistently deliver a high-quality, satisfying bite.

People are saying

"The espresso here is always dialed in and delicious."

"I thought the breakfast sandwich was one of the best I've ever had."

"The banana cake here is delicious and larger than expected."

Good to know

1

Amberson Coffee & Grocer uses reusable jars for to-go coffee instead of paper cups.

2

The cafe has limited seating, so plan to visit during off-peak hours.

3

They charge $17 for two lattes, so budget accordingly.

02
The Groovy Cafe image 1

Cozy cafe with a 70's and cat theme offers comfy seating and a laid-back atmosphere. Quiet environment suits conversations while retro decorations and music create a welcoming vibe. Regulars enjoy a friendly, relaxed energy that feels like a home away from home.

Cakes here feature orange zest cream cheese and blood orange olive oil flavors. The Groovy Cat Cake stands out among the homemade options.

Breakfast sandwiches come on rosemary sea salt bagels or sourdough bread pressed to a golden brown. Toppings are generous and often include special dressings and tomato jam grilled cheese options.

People are saying

"The coffee and food at this cafe are delicious."

"I loved the fresh, generous breakfast sandwiches."

"I thought the homemade cake was delicious."

Good to know

1

Online ordering is available for convenient pickup.

2

The cafe offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

3

Happy hour features half-price coffee and ice cream.

03
Cheeky Bastards Restaurant image 1
Modern British restaurant

Modern British restaurant offers authentic English fare with standout fish and chips and classic English rock music setting a lively tone. Interior combines cozy, quaint decor with small, intimate rooms, creating a welcoming, family-like atmosphere. Space feels compact with tables designed for two but often seating four, emphasizing a popular, bustling vibe.

Victoria sponge layer cake stands out with its classic, light texture and balanced sweetness. The toffee Bundt cake offers a rich, moist alternative for dessert lovers.

Corned beef stands out in the Saint Michael sandwich, which is tasty and filling. Other sandwiches like the fish sandwich and cheesesteak offer solid options that hold up well for takeout.

People are saying

"The fish and chips here are huge and perfectly crispy."

"The fish sandwich here is huge and delicious."

"I found the fish and chips to be far above my expectations."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch due to limited seating.

2

Expect long wait times on Saturday nights without a reservation.

3

The restaurant offers a unique afternoon tea service on the first Sunday of each month.

04
Sahm's Place image 1
American restaurant

Classic pub-style interior with dark wood and a family-friendly atmosphere creates a quiet, pleasant vibe. Regulars enjoy quality food with diverse options like wraps and steak, paired with draft PBR. Patio seating offers a relaxed spot to wait or unwind.

Coffee cake features prominently with a notable sour cream variety and a crunchy texture. Cake portions tend to be small, sometimes prompting requests for larger slices.

Big tenderloin sandwiches stand out, especially on Mondays with a special deal. The meatloaf sandwich and steak sandwich also come highly recommended, with solid flavors and good preparation.

People are saying

"The American Food, especially the fried chicken and clam chowder, is always good."

"I found their salads to be awesome and filling enough for a meal."

"I enjoyed the sour cream coffee cake."

Good to know

1

Happy hour food specials are from 3 PM to 6 PM and 9 PM to close.

2

Late night happy hour after 8:30 PM offers fantastic prices.

3

Sahm's Place has a $10 pork tenderloin special on Mondays.

05
Pana Donuts image 1
Donut shop

Donut shop inside a former bank building offers a down-to-earth atmosphere with friendly staff and a drive-through. The space feels large but sparsely furnished, with a few tables and chairs. Donuts stand out as light, fluffy, and fresh, often considered the best in the area.

Crunchy tops and a flavor like yellow cake define the cake-like treats here. Cake donuts stand out with a really good flavor and a texture that feels like a classic cake.

Breakfast sandwiches come on bagels or croissants with fresh ingredients. Lunch sandwiches also use these breads and maintain the same quality.

People are saying

"I thought these donuts were the best I had ever tasted."

"These donuts are the best I've ever had."

"I liked the cake donuts; they had a really good flavor."

Good to know

1

They offer one free donut per person for the rest of November.

2

They accept cards, which is better than most shops around here.

3

The prices at Pana Donuts are very reasonable.

06
Aberdeen Social House image 1

Upscale restaurant offers a mid-century modern vibe with curated artwork and thoughtful architectural details. Outdoor patio provides a comfortable, zen atmosphere ideal for leisurely dining. The space balances swanky and welcoming energy, attracting those who appreciate quality and style.

Pineapple upside down cake stands out as excellent, while the carrot cake is a solid choice for dessert. The banana cream pie and chocolate caramel cake are rich, but the ricotta cake tends to be dry and hard to enjoy.

Tonkatsu tenderloin stands out as a tender, flavorful sandwich. Waffle battered chicken offers a unique twist with the chicken and waffle sandwich. Lobster BLT pairs well with fresh salad options.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is phenomenal and packed with flavor."

"You have to try the carrot cake; it's excellent."

"The waffle battered chicken sandwich is amazing and unique."

Good to know

1

The menu changes frequently with local ingredients prepared by a creative culinary team.

2

Expect higher prices for unique dishes and elevated dining experiences.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekends and special occasions.

07
City Barbeque image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Smoke house barbecue setting fills the space with a warm, inviting vibe and blues music plays in the background. Small, immaculate dining area includes an outside patio that suits family gatherings. Atmosphere is loud and lively, creating a friendly but energetic environment.

Chocolate cake tastes homemade and delicious. The triple chocolate cake stands out as a rich dessert option.

Brisket sandwiches stand out with juicy, piled-on meat and a delicious, rich flavor. Pulled pork and Nashville hot chicken sandwiches also offer great taste and generous portions.

People are saying

"The food here tastes amazing, with a great smoke flavor profile that's excellent."

"I really enjoyed the delicious brisket sandwich."

"I found the chocolate cake to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Rib Tuesday offers special deals on ribs, making it a popular day to visit.

2

Curbside pick-up is available and recommended for quality food.

3

Dairy-free and soy-free options are offered for dietary restrictions.

08
Garrett's Smokehouse Barbeque image 1

Barbecue spot with fall-off-the-bone ribs, smoked flavor, and well-seasoned turkey ribs creates a hearty, casual vibe. Food ranges from crispy fried chicken to rich desserts like caramel and strawberry cakes. Atmosphere suits those seeking classic barbecue with some standout dishes.

Caramel cake stands out as extremely delicious and impressive. Other options include sweet potatoes and chocolate cake and strawberry cake, with lemon cake also available.

Chopped brisket and pulled chicken sandwiches come out well-prepared and flavorful. Pulled pork sandwich arrives cold and greasy, lacking warmth.

People are saying

"These smoked ribs are the best I've ever had."

"I was so glad I got the amazing brisket."

"I found the pulled chicken sandwich to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $30 for a full meal.

2

They charge an extra $0.50 for sauce.

09
His Place Eatery - Chicken & Waffles, Ribs & Soul food (30th & Shadeland) image 1

Cozy space with a Grandma's kitchen feel and southern soul food style creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere like a family reunion. Bright and clean but with a slightly dated, early 90s look. Busy and lively, it offers a genuine, homey vibe without any frills.

Carrot cake stands out with its awesome flavor and moist texture. It draws attention for a return visit.

Smoked BBQ bologna sandwich stands out with cole slaw on a toasted onion bun. Other notable options include the pork belly sandwich, buffalo chicken sandwich, and a collard green grilled cheese.

People are saying

"The American Food here is delicious, with tons of flavor."

"The service for my sandwich was friendly and attentive."

"I found the cake here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Meals cost at least $20, making it a pricier lunch option.

2

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but check for mobile payment options.

10
Portillo’s Indianapolis-IN image 1
Fast food restaurant

Nostalgic interior with old-time decorations and a vehicle strapped to the ceiling creates a unique and inviting atmosphere. Spacious dining area feels family-friendly and welcoming, with order ahead kiosks making ordering easy. Energy is warm and lively, appealing to both adults and children.

Chocolate cake stands out with its rich flavor and consistent quality. Lemon cake and chocolate eclair cake offer distinctive tastes, while cake shakes like the strawberry lemon add a creamy twist.

Italian beef sandwiches come huge and packed with peppers and onions. The dipped sandwiches taste rich and flavorful, matching Chicago-style quality.

People are saying

"I loved the Chicago style hot dogs; they were so satisfying."

"The Italian beef sandwiches here are huge and delicious."

"I enjoyed the chocolate cake; it was the best dessert."

Good to know

1

Portillo's Indianapolis does not accept cash at the drive-through.

2

Expect to pay over $30 for a meal for two, including drinks.

3

The drive-thru service is quick and efficient.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...