Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Cookie spots in Indianapolis

A cookie that is baked to be a standalone dessert rather than a dry afterthought.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Hazeables image 1
Hazeables image 2
Hazeables image 3
View all
Bakery

Bakery with local artist murals and a pet friendly environment offers a variety of infused and gluten free treats. Atmosphere stays chill and welcoming, attracting families and dog owners alike. Pricing remains reasonable while maintaining a woman-owned business vibe.

Baked goods stand out with incredible flavor and a vast variety including puppy treats and infused desserts. Prices stay incredibly reasonable while maintaining delicious quality.

Little pig cookies stand out for their charm and flavor, often disappearing quickly. Red Velvet giant cookies attract a lot of attention and satisfy cookie cravings with their size and taste.

People are saying

"The strawberry Tres Leches cake is insanely delicious."

"I could eat the little pig cookies every day."

"I found the desserts here to be absolutely amazing."

Good to know

1

Hazeables is a dog-friendly shop.

2

Hazeables offers a variety of puppy treats and infused desserts.

3

The cake and desserts are very reasonably priced.

02
Cafรฉ Babette image 1

Pastry shop offers over 15 uniquely crafted baked goods with a simple, unadorned layout featuring old mismatched tables and no labels. Atmosphere feels laid-back and comforting with a bustling, positive energy especially on busy days. No eat-in service or coffee is available, and waiting or preordering is common due to high demand.

An incredible selection of pies, croissants, and brownies makes choosing tough. Desserts come out gorgeous and worth arriving early for.

Cookies here stand out for their incredible taste and quality. Varieties like the sea salt chocolate chip and s'mores cookie offer rich, memorable flavors that keep people coming back.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and thoughtfully executed."

"I thought the cookies here were the best I have ever had."

"The baked goods here are beautiful and delicious."

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid long waits on weekends.

2

Expect long lines, especially on Saturdays and holidays.

3

Arrive early to secure pastries before they sell out.

03
The Cavity Factory image 1

Small cookie shop with a trendy vibe and friendly atmosphere that fills up quickly. Energy stays chill but lively, attracting people who appreciate fresh, highly praised cookies. Operations are flexible, often selling out early, so arriving early is common.

Crookies stand out as a unique dessert here. Desserts often feel worth the wait and deliver an incredible taste.

Cookies have a perfect texture, are super soft, and come in unique flavors like s'mores. They are sweet and just the right size, consistently delivering a satisfying treat.

People are saying

"I thought these cookies tasted so much better than Crumbl."

"These cinnamon rolls taste like a spiritual journey or a beach vacation."

"I found the desserts here to be the most incredible of all time."

Good to know

1

The Cavity Factory does not have set operating hours and operates based on the owner's mood.

2

Get there early because she almost always sells out.

3

The shop is open until they sell out.

04
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop offers bright, welcoming space with a sweet aroma and clean environment. Weekly rotation of creative cookie flavors draws consistent crowds, making it a popular spot for fresh, high-quality treats. Setup feels antisocial, with minimal interaction from staff.

Cookies have a strong aroma that can tempt even those not wanting dessert. Warming them in the microwave turns them into a unique dessert experience. They look and smell appealing and are consistently delicious.

Soft, gooey cookies stand out with consistently high quality and rich flavor. Mini and waffle cookies offer unique, addictive options that many find exceptional.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were the best I've ever had."

"The desserts here are surprisingly not too sweet, especially the Oreo cheesecake."

"It's so Kid Friendly; my kids loved the cookies."

Good to know

1

Crumbl offers a new cookie flavor each week.

2

Crumbl gives away free cookies on customers' birthdays.

3

Crumbl does not accept cash payments.

05
Heidelberg Haus image 1
German restaurant

German restaurant combines cozy, authentic atmosphere with a quirky gift shop filled with knickknacks and gnomes. Space feels tight and lively, with staff in fun outfits enhancing the energy. Offers unique German groceries and pastries alongside dining tables scattered through the store.

Authentic German desserts fill the case with options you won't find elsewhere. Chocolate cake and German chocolate cake stand out among the incredible cookies and pastries.

Cookies here are authentic German treats, often paired with affordable prices. Seasonal options like Christmas cookies stand out alongside classic favorites.

People are saying

"It's a unique place packed with quirky trinkets and German imports."

"I found the cookies here to be soft and delicious."

"The desserts here are amazing and beautiful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended to avoid sold-out baked goods.

2

Heidelberg Haus has about eight tables, so expect limited seating.

3

The bakery offers a variety of German pastries and desserts that are popular among locals.

06
Cookie Plug image 1

Cute space with a retro-friendly vibe and clever, cool atmosphere. The setup showcases a great choice of cookie flavors with options for tasting and larger sizes. Friendly energy makes it an inviting spot for those seeking a unique cookie experience.

Unique, dessert-style cookies stand out here. Quick, delicious options make it easy to grab a sweet treat before a show.

Soft, dessert-style cookies melt in your mouth with flavors like strawberry and red velvet. The cookies taste homemade but elevated, with a well balanced flavor that is not too sweet.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were the best I've ever tasted."

"The strawberry cheesecake cookie's flavor was unreal and well balanced."

"The theme here is humorous and makes for a great Late Night Spot."

Good to know

1

Prices for cookies start at $5 each.

2

Cookies are packaged in resealable bags for easy transport.

3

Expect a variety of unique flavors that change regularly.

07
Taylor's Bakery image 1

Bakery filled with beautiful cake creations and delicious baked goods creates a fun, clean atmosphere packed with people. Known for best cakes and donuts in the area, it draws families and special occasions consistently.

Chocolate ganache dessert cake stands out for special occasions. Cupcakes, donuts, cookies, and coffee cakes offer variety. Birthday cakes and holiday desserts come with options for preordering through an account system.

Cookies come with iced sugar decorations and custom designs for events. The chocolate chip cookie with icing in the middle stands out among the selection. Seasonal decorated cookies add variety and visual appeal.

People are saying

"I drive 1.5 hours for their Mardi Gras King Cakes."

"These cookies and cupcakes are delicious!"

"The desserts here are delicious and moist."

Good to know

1

The parking situation at the 116th Street location can be problematic.

2

Expect limited stock later in the day; arrive early for best selection.

3

Taylor's Bakery does not offer gluten-free cookies.

08
Pots & Pans Pie Co. image 1

Small bakery with open kitchen view and minimal seating offers a clean, cozy atmosphere highlighted by the smell of flaky pie crusts. Energy stays easygoing and welcoming, with a focus on homestyle pies sold by the slice and rotating flavors that invite frequent visits.

Dessert pies stand out with a rotating selection and mini pies often chosen for events. Catering services include take-and-bakes and savory pies alongside sweet options.

Shortbread chocolate chip cookies have a heavenly crust and a rich buttery flavor. Oatmeal cream pies taste like oatmeal cookies with a buttery center but lack sweetness.

People are saying

"I found Bruce's Lemon Pie to be the best pie I had ever had."

"I found the pastry here to be fresh and delightful."

"These cookies are the best I have ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Pie slices are available for $7 each, with whole pies starting at $13.

2

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

They offer unique pie flavors that change frequently.

09
Greiner's SubShop image 1
Sandwich shop

Rustic design and old car decorations create a charming, welcoming space with a friendly atmosphere. Strong, independent women work with warmth, giving the place a unique energy. Outdoor seating is dog friendly, adding to the relaxed vibe.

Homemade desserts stand out here with incredible flavors. They complement the menu well and are worth trying.

Double chocolate chip and strawberry cheesecake cookies stand out here. Cookies are homemade and come with extras if a batch gets messed up.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwich I had was the best I ever ate."

"The homemade desserts here are incredible."

"I tried a strawberry cheesecake cookie that was amazing."

Good to know

1

Greiner's SubShop closes at 7:00 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Expect high prices for sandwiches, which may not match the quality.

3

The shop offers gluten-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

10
The Cheesecake Lady image 1

Small, colorful bakery with a bright, welcoming atmosphere and cheerful decor. The space feels quaint and charming, inviting visitors to enjoy a relaxed, picture-worthy setting. Known for offering a wide variety of cheesecake options with excellent value for the portion sizes.

Cheesecake cups, slices, and stuffed cookies stand out as amazing desserts here. The dessert table service shows exceptional professionalism.

Biscoff cookies come with cheesecake and caramel, offering a rich combo. Chocolate chip cookie slices sometimes lack flavor, but options like the cinnamon roll cookie and cheesecake cookies stand out.

People are saying

"I thought the cheesecake was great."

"I love the make-your-own cheesecake cups, they overflow with goodness."

"I thought the cookies were very good."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $5 for small cups to nearly $10 for large cups.

2

A special promotion allows you to buy three cheesecakes and get one free.

3

The shop has a reward card program for repeat customers.

11
Prime 47- Indy's Steakhouse image 1

Steakhouse occupies an old bank building with beautiful architecture and an old vault wine locker. Atmosphere ranges from intimate and relaxing to lively and noisy, with seating arranged for both privacy and groups. Drinks include well-crafted cocktails and a notable wine selection, complementing high-quality steaks and seafood dishes.

Complimentary desserts come with whipped cream and candles for celebrations. Servers sometimes offer a gift card along with dessert.

Fresh baked chocolate chip cookies come with vanilla ice cream and chocolate sauce. Complimentary soft baked cookies appear on special occasions.

People are saying

"The filet mignon at these date spots was cooked perfectly."

"The Japanese wagyu was cooked to perfection and seasoned so well."

"The Japanese wagyu was cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special events like birthdays or anniversaries.

2

Parking can be difficult to find in the downtown area.

3

The restaurant offers a gluten-free menu for those with dietary restrictions.

12
Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers homey atmosphere with a family-friendly vibe and fresh, made-to-order toppings. The space feels busy and warm, suited more for takeout or delivery than dining in. Toppings are priced fairly, and pizzas come loaded with cheese and meat.

Desserts include an incredible dessert pizza and an excellent cinnamon dessert. Both come after a quick sit-down meal within an hour.

Fresh chocolate chip cookies come out of the oven warm. Some batches are buttery and tasty, while others miss the mark.

People are saying

"This local spot has great pizza with a nice sauce and chewy crust."

"The Calzone here is great; the staff is so nice and accommodating."

"I found the pizza here to be incredible."

Good to know

1

Almost all toppings, except one, cost $1.03 to add.

2

Everything is made to order, ensuring freshness.

3

Expect a messy hallway with construction supplies leading to the restrooms.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...