Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Indianapolis

Jewelry stores

Made for those who treat jewelry as a permanent investment and prefer to browse collections in person rather than online.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Petite G Jewelers image 1
Petite G Jewelers image 2
Petite G Jewelers image 3
View all
Jewelry store

Boutique setting creates a warm, intimate vibe with a strong community feel. Jewelry selection includes phenomenal estate pieces and unique styles not found elsewhere. Skilled staff offer custom jewelry creation and attentive care, making every visit personal and relaxed.

Custom jewelry creation stands out here, with skilled work transforming family heirlooms into meaningful pieces. The store offers a phenomenal selection not found in big box stores and provides reliable jewelry repairs with attentive service.

People are saying

"This jewelry store turns your ideas into something extraordinary with true artistry."

"I love the custom jewelry design process here; it's truly extraordinary."

"The staff at this Watch Store are so kind and helpful."

Good to know

1

Petite G Jewelers offers custom jewelry services tailored to individual preferences.

2

The store has a unique selection of jewelry not found in big box stores.

3

Jewelry repairs are done with high-quality craftsmanship at reasonable prices.

02
Gold And Diamond USA image 1

Affordable prices meet fast repair services for jewelry, watches, and phones. Clean, professional space offers certified gemstones and a wide selection of gold jewelry. Flexible layaway with no interest or time limits makes quality craftsmanship accessible.

Offers a wide selection of gold jewelry at reasonable prices with professional repair services for both jewelry and phones.

People are saying

"I found the jewelry collection to be gorgeous and they fix it too."

"I got my watch battery repaired and the service was quick."

"I found the jewelry and gold here to be really cheap."

Good to know

1

Repairs are completed in less than 30 minutes for most items.

2

They offer a layaway option with no interest and no time limit.

3

All jewelry comes with certifications for gemstones, ensuring quality.

03
Windsor Jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store offers custom designs and expert repairs in a welcoming atmosphere filled with Erte prints. Unique, ethically sourced pieces come with competitive pricing and trusted long-term service. Customers enjoy heirloom restorations and on-the-spot care.

Expertise in repairs and servicing stands out with watch and jewelry maintenance handled carefully. Customers rely on this store for long-term trust and quality, returning for decades to buy, repair, and appraise pieces. Custom designs and heirloom restorations also feature prominently.

People are saying

"I got my ring repaired and resized the same day!"

"The staff at this Watch Store are so friendly and knowledgeable."

"The jewelry store staff is so nice and helpful."

Good to know

1

They can remove links from watches on the spot without an appointment.

2

The resizing service is completed within an hour.

3

They offer cleaning services for free, making jewelry look amazing.

04
Jewelry Lady image 1

Family-owned and women-operated jeweler offers custom designs with expert craftsmanship. Expect fine diamonds and wedding sets crafted with care. Friendly service ensures pieces arrive on time at fair prices.

Custom designs fit personal style with high quality and unique jewelry. The team offers professional, kind service and delivers pieces on time and at fair prices.

People are saying

"This jewelry store offers high-quality, custom pieces and unbeatable prices."

"I had a custom engagement ring designed and it was perfect."

"I love my custom necklace from this Necklace Store; they made it so quickly."

Good to know

1

Jewelry Lady offers custom design work for unique pieces.

2

Their jewelry is known for high quality and reasonable prices.

3

The shop is family-owned and operated, providing a personal touch.

05
Love Links by Rae Permanent Jewelry image 1

Jewelry booth offers quick custom designs with a great selection of chains and charms. Bracelets use high-quality metals that resist tarnishing. Staff provide flexible, knowledgeable service making permanent jewelry easy to choose.

Bracelets here use high-quality metals that resist tarnishing even after years of wear. Staff make choosing and customizing permanent jewelry easy and flexible, with a great selection and quick, knowledgeable service.

People are saying

"Working with Rae at this Jewelry Store was an absolute joy."

"I found the experience to be super fun and awesome."

"Rae made our party so special and was incredibly sweet."

Good to know

1

The jewelry is custom designed and made with high-quality metals.

2

The process to have the jewelry put on is quick and easy.

3

Rae offers a great selection of chains and charms to choose from.

06
Barrington Jewels image 1

Showroom shines with exquisite jewelry and a warm atmosphere that feels personal and family-owned. Repairs are quick and high-quality, handling complex fixes like a 33-year-old tricolor gold bracelet. Pricing stays reasonable, making it a trusted spot for custom and routine needs.

Jewelry repair happens quickly and effectively, including complex fixes like a 33-year-old tricolor gold bracelet. The store offers ring resizing, replating, cleaning, and reappraisal services with timely completion and strong customer support.

People are saying

"The salespeople at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and helpful."

"The Ring Store staff are so helpful and knowledgeable."

"The staff at this Watch Store are so nice and welcoming."

Good to know

1

The repair process takes less than 30 minutes for most items.

2

Pricing for repairs is very fair, with some services starting at $8.50.

3

Barrington Jewels warranties their work, ensuring customer satisfaction.

07
Reis-Nichols Jewelers image 1

Luxury brands shine in an elegant showroom with a warm, inviting vibe. Staff like Nicole offer personalized service and expert help with diamond earrings and watches. Enjoy complimentary champagne while browsing timeless, quality pieces.

Personalized service stands out with knowledgeable staff like Nicole helping with both jewelry and watches. The store offers timeless jewelry and quality pieces including diamond earrings.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and helpful."

"Hannah helped me personalize my necklace with a new baby's initial."

"The sales associates are knowledgeable and attentive, making the luxurious experience seamless."

Good to know

1

The Tag / Indy 500 event is invite-only, so RSVP is necessary.

2

Expect a social atmosphere during jewelry buying events organized by the store.

3

Ask for Tim or Cheri Chappell for personalized service during your visit.

08
KAY Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store shines with personalized guidance from Adam and Danielle. Wide selection includes secure screwback earrings. Friendly vibe feels like help from friends, perfect for families with kids.

Sales representatives like Adam and Danielle provide personalized guidance for choosing rings and earrings. The store offers a variety of jewelry with details like screwback earrings for added security.

People are saying

"Danielle at the Ring Store made finding my engagement ring easy and exciting."

"The staff at this Watch Store are so friendly and determined to help."

"Adam at this Jewelry Store helped me find my dream rings."

Good to know

1

Ask for Danielle for personalized jewelry shopping assistance.

2

Request Adam for help with jewelry needs at this location.

3

A warranty inspection is required every six months to maintain coverage.

09
Sam's Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Showroom features natural diamonds and real gold in a calm, clean space. Custom pendants and diamond rings show detailed craftsmanship. Jewelry cleaning services keep pieces looking like new.

Great quality diamonds and fine jewelry stand out here. Custom pendants and natural diamond rings show detailed craftsmanship. Jewelry cleaning restores pieces to look like new.

People are saying

"The service at this jewelry store is so patient and knowledgeable."

"I found the Ring Store nice and friendly."

Good to know

1

Sam's Jewelers offers custom jewelry options for personalized gifts.

2

They provide free cleaning service for all jewelry purchases.

3

Expect a wide selection of natural diamonds and fine jewelry.

10
Diamonds Direct Indianapolis image 1

Jewelry store shines with wedding rings and expert care. Stu the jeweler offers personalized service and stays late for maintenance. Atmosphere feels welcoming and professional, making buying easy and exciting.

Wedding and engagement rings are a key focus here, with strong attention to detail and care. Staff like Stu the jeweler provide personalized service, staying late to assist with ring maintenance like rhodium plating.

People are saying

"The people at this Ring Store are knowledgeable and make the experience fun."

"I felt comfortable and welcomed during my visit."

"The staff at this jewelry store are patient and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

They offer fair pricing and quick turnaround times for repairs.

2

The quality of stones, pearls, and bands is top notch.

3

They ship repaired items to customers who live out of town.

11
MALiX Jewelry & Perfumes image 1

Jewelry store offers unique designs with options from affordable to 18kt gold and diamonds. Staff provides friendly service helping find great deals. Diverse clientele enjoys ethnic clothing and cell phone repair in a modern, welcoming space.

Jewelry features unique designs with a range from inexpensive to high-end pieces. Staff offers friendly, attentive service and helps find great deals on elegant rings, bracelets, and earrings.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store offered honest guidance and care."

"I found the Pakistani dresses and jewelry collection to be beautiful."

"I found unique jewelry with mind-blowing designs."

Good to know

1

Everything in the store is currently 50% off, making prices very reasonable.

2

They offer layaway plans for up to 2 years.

3

The jewelry selection includes both inexpensive and high-end pieces.

12
Rogers & Hollands Jewelers image 1

Offers first-class jewelry with hand-crafted designs and a great watch selection. Staff provides knowledgeable service and personalized care. Enjoy ring cleaning and exchanges with a welcoming atmosphere for thoughtful purchases.

Jewelry features first class quality and knowledgeable associates who take time to assemble and help with selections. Services include ring cleaning and exchanges, with staff going beyond to meet jewelry needs.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are patient, kind, and incredibly knowledgeable."

"Heather at this Jewelry Store was so helpful and kind."

"Heather at the Watch Store was amazing and so helpful."

Good to know

1

The store offers a healthcare responder discount for eligible customers.

2

Shipping is available for non-local customers, ensuring timely delivery.

3

Appointments are recommended for custom design consultations.

13
Rowan The Fashion Mall at Keystone image 1

Bright studio blends high-quality jewelry with a calming environment. Certified nurses ensure safe ear piercing with top-tier earrings. Space feels friendly and whimsical, perfect for all ages.

Earrings here are high-quality and cute. Certified nurses provide top-tier ear piercing jewelry.

People are saying

"They're so kind and patient with kids, making it feel Kid Friendly."

"The staff here is so nice and helps you pick out the perfect jewelry."

"It's a truly relaxing spot; the nurses made the piercing process easy."

Good to know

1

The minimum cost for a 5-minute piercing is $160.

2

The ear piercing process takes less than 4 minutes.

3

Piercings are performed by licensed nurses for safety.

14
House of Diamonds image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store shines with handcrafted pieces and real diamonds. Staff offers helpful advice and fast, clean service. Custom grillz and repairs add unique value at affordable prices.

Offers handcrafted jewelry with options like Cuban link bracelets and personalized rings. Staff provides helpful advice without pressure and ensures pieces are cleaned and waterproof. Prices are good for real jewelry, with deals on premium items.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and helpful."

"I found the jewelry and staff to be affordable."

"I found a pretty ring here."

Good to know

1

They offer a wide collection of real jewelry, including unique pieces.

2

Jewelry repairs are available on-site for customer convenience.

3

Prices are competitive, making it an affordable option for quality jewelry.

15
D & L Jewelry & Repair image 1

Bright, clean space offers high-quality jewelry with gold and VVS diamonds. Staff provide personalized attention and advice, making visits comfortable with refreshments. Efficient repair and resizing services ensure trust and satisfaction.

Offers high quality jewelry including gold and VVS diamonds with a great price. Provides excellent repair and resizing services with trustworthy and attentive staff.

People are saying

"They fixed my ring and it looks great after the repair."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store is so friendly and helpful."

"The Watch Store staff were so nice and professional."

Good to know

1

They completed the resizing one hour after I left the ring with them.

2

The owner completed the ring resizing within 20 minutes.

3

The repair was fairly priced.

16
Carmel Jewelry & Phones image 1

Store offers same-day repairs for jewelry and phones, blending gold expertise with quick fixes. Customers find affordable quality in gold teeth and perfumes. Efficient service meets diverse needs under one roof.

Same-day service handles jewelry repairs, watch battery replacements, and ring resizing in minutes. Selling gold and buying high-quality jewelry happens alongside quick repairs for watches and phones.

People are saying

"I got my jewelry and phones fixed the same day."

"I got quick repairs for my watch and phone here."

"I found their LCD repair service to be cheap."

Good to know

1

Same-day repairs are available for phones and jewelry.

2

Repair costs start at $30, making it affordable.

3

Expect quick turnaround times for jewelry repairs, often within minutes.

17
Jewelers Boutique Inc. image 1

Small, family owned boutique offers quick repairs and custom pieces with respectful service. Jewelry looks decades younger after care. Pricing is reasonable and service feels personal in a modest setting.

Workers show respectful service and handle jewelry with care. They offer ring resizing and create beautiful custom pieces.

People are saying

"I cried tears of happiness when they found my bracelet."

"This jewelry store's craftsmen are fantastic and provide great quality."

Good to know

1

Pricing is reasonable for custom jewelry services.

2

The resizing service is completed within one day.

3

Turnaround times for jewelry work are generally quick.

18
RINGMAKER, LLC - By Appointment image 1

Custom jewelry here features unique craftsmanship with creative designs like Howls Moving Castle rings. Patience is key due to unclear timelines, but results often exceed expectations. Professional cleaning services restore wedding rings to like-new condition.

Creative custom jewelry shines here with top tier talent crafting unique pieces like rings inspired by Howls Moving Castle. Regular services include professional cleaning that restores wedding rings to look like new.

People are saying

"This Ring Store brought my dream design to life with ease."

"This jewelry store creates custom, one-of-a-kind pieces with top-notch quality."

Good to know

1

Expect delays in communication; updates may not be provided regularly.

2

No clear timeline or completion date is given for custom orders.

3

Quality of custom jewelry is reported to be high and unique.

19
Cash America Pawn image 1

Pawn shop has a wide selection including power tools, guitars, and jewelry. Staff offer fair prices and help find jewelry pieces. Atmosphere supports buying, selling, and pawning with a community presence.

Staff help customers find jewelry pieces and offer fair prices. Selection includes jewelry alongside other items like power tools and guitars.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are friendly and amazing."

Good to know

1

Cash America Pawn accepts cash, credit cards, and debit cards for transactions.

2

Expect a wide variety of items, including electronics, jewelry, and tools.

3

Bring valid ID for transactions, especially for pawning items.

20
Midwest Jewelry and Bullion image 1

Jewelry cases show pieces from multiple angles with clear views and a well-curated estate collection. An on-site designer crafts custom pieces, adding a unique touch. Prices stay below average retail, often exceeding gold value for used items, offering great value.

Offers for used jewelry often exceed gold value by a significant margin. Jewelry cases provide clear views from multiple angles and feature a well-curated estate collection. Staff assist with custom pieces like sentimental rings and maintain fair pricing on quality items.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so nice and helpful."

Good to know

1

Payout for precious metals is based on spot price minus standard exchange fees.

2

The store offers cash or check payment options depending on the transaction amount.

3

Expect the selling process to take approximately 15 minutes.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...