Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Indianapolis

Pizza and sandwich spots

You want a place that masters both the pizza oven and the sandwich press so you can get exactly what you are craving.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Barringers Tavern (re-established 2019) image 1
Barringers Tavern (re-established 2019) image 2
Barringers Tavern (re-established 2019) image 3
View all

Historic bar and grill with live music, classic games, and a large patio creates a friendly, relaxed atmosphere. Regulars enjoy affordable tap beer and world-class pork tenderloin sandwiches. The space blends old charm with modern updates and sports on big screens.

Chicken bacon ranch and all meat pizzas stand out for flavor. Pizzas sized 10 or 12 inches cook well and hold toppings nicely. The well done Brit's pizza offers a rich taste.

Pork tenderloin sandwiches stand out with a fried tenderloin that defines the Hoosier sandwich. Crispy chicken sandwiches also feature a crunchy texture that complements the meat well.

People are saying

"The breaded Tenderloin's breading is so crunchy and well-seasoned."

"I thought the pizza here was great and very flavorful."

"I thought the tenderloin sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Parking is available off-street and in the surrounding neighborhood.

2

Every item on the menu is reasonably priced.

3

Karaoke nights happen regularly, providing a fun atmosphere.

02
Marks Pub image 1
Restaurant

Neighborhood bar with a chill vibe and friendly atmosphere offers free pool tables and sports on TVs. Affordable prices and engaging activities create a comfortable spot for casual hangouts. Patio space adds to the relaxed setting.

Thin crust pizza features ample cheese, sausage, and pepperoni. The crust and toppings hold up well, making for a really good pizza.

Pulled pork sandwich stands out with its delicious flavor. Philly Cheese Steak sandwich offers an awesome taste. Variety of sandwiches available for different preferences.

People are saying

"The bar food here is pretty good and a great value."

"I thought the pulled pork sandwich was delicious."

"I believed that this pizza was the best."

Good to know

1

Half-priced appetizers are available on Tuesdays from 3 to 10 pm.

2

$3 burger and fries special on Thursdays.

3

Karaoke happens on Saturdays with a fun atmosphere.

03
Bert & Den's Grille image 1

Neighborhood bar with a cozy, dive-like atmosphere and a relaxed, friendly vibe. Regular crowd enjoys affordable, made-from-scratch bar food and a selection of drinks including an amazing IPA on draft. TVs, music, and games add to the casual, fun environment.

Hand-breaded chicken strips and seasoned fries complement the 3 topping pizza options. Pizza offers great carryout choices and pairs well with cheeseburgers and onion rings.

Chicken sandwiches and wings stand out with their incredible flavor. The club sandwich comes ridiculously huge and pairs with homemade chips that hit the mark.

People are saying

"It's a friendly neighborhood bar where everyone knows your name."

"I thought the pizza here was fire."

"The club sandwich was ridiculously huge and delicious."

Good to know

1

The kitchen stays open late for late-night diners.

2

They offer $4 long islands and margaritas on Wednesdays.

3

Karaoke is available on specific nights, attracting a lively crowd.

04
Kilroy's Bar N' Grill image 1

Large sports bar with numerous TVs showing multiple games simultaneously creates a lively, loud atmosphere filled mostly with energetic young adults. Indoor and outdoor seating options accommodate groups comfortably, while the bar area offers strong Long Island iced teas and a variety of food including highly rated burgers and unique wings.

Stuffed breadsticks and pizza stand out as favorites. The pizza tastes delicious and pairs well with wings and pickle chips during sports.

Brisket dip sandwich stands out with tender meat and dipping gravy. Reuben sandwiches come stacked high on dark rye. Cajun chicken sandwich offers moist, flavorful chicken with bacon and fried pickle slices.

People are saying

"The food at this bar is a standout, especially the jalapeรฑo breadsticks."

"I found the pizza to be delicious and the star of the show."

"The brisket sandwich with dipping gravy was tender and tasty."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers 50% off beer and select items on Wednesdays.

2

Seating is first come, first served; no reservations are accepted.

3

Two forms of ID are required for entry.

05
Twin Peaks image 1
Sports bar

Sports bar offers many TVs showing various games and a fire pit patio for outdoor viewing. Atmosphere is loud and energetic with scantily clad staff contributing to a distinctive vibe. Seating provides good views from most spots, creating a welcoming environment for sports fans.

Flatbread pizzas stand out with options like Italian Flatbread and hottie jalapeรฑo popper. The BBQ brisket pizza offers a rich, smoky flavor and a spicy kick with jalapeรฑos.

Cheesesteak and Philly Steak sandwiches stand out with authentic flavors that satisfy even tough critics. Spicy chicken and Nashville chicken sandwiches bring bold heat, while the meatball and chicken avocado sandwiches offer fresh, delicious options paired with crispy fries.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the bacon."

"I loved the spicy flatbread pizza here."

"I loved the cheesesteak sandwich here."

Good to know

1

There is a $5 cover charge for fight night events.

2

Bikini and beanie night is a popular themed event.

3

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

06
Steer-In image 1
American restaurant

Classic diner with 1960's decor and a spacious dining area creates a cozy, small-town vibe in a city setting. Friendly regulars contribute to a welcoming atmosphere despite some wear and tear in furnishings. Known for generous portions and homestyle cooking, it feels like a neighborhood institution.

Pizza comes in deep dish and thin crust styles with a stuffed option that stands out. Meat pizza and classic diner varieties satisfy a range of tastes, making it a solid choice for families.

Pork tenderloin sandwiches stand out for being incredibly juicy, tender, and crispy. Other notable options include a Reuben sandwich praised for its quality and a Gourmet grilled cheese that delivers solid flavor.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the desserts and prime rib, is really good."

"You have to try the tenderloin sandwich; it's massive."

"I thought the pizza here was some of the best."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special menus like Valentine's Day.

2

Expect large portion sizes for the price you pay.

3

The restaurant is known for its reasonable prices compared to fast food.

07
Big Lug Canteen image 1

Brewpub with modern rustic decor and vibrant energy fills both upstairs and downstairs bars, often with loud music and sports on TVs. Outdoor patio welcomes dogs and offers a spacious dining area. Crowd varies from quiet early hours to lively evenings, creating a dynamic atmosphere.

Wood-fired pizzas come with unique toppings like mango and chorizo, offering a fresh twist on traditional flavors. The dough stays light and fresh, making the pizzas stand out among other local options.

Himmy Johns and Cuban sandwich stand out with strong flavors. Options include cranberry chicken salad, Nashville hot chicken sandwiches, and wraps, plus flexible half salad half sandwich combos.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the good beer."

"I tried the chorizo pizza and it was really something different."

"The sandwiches here are so good and the servings are generous."

Good to know

1

Happy hour menu is available from 3:30 PM to 5:00 PM.

2

Trivia night happens every Tuesday with drink specials.

3

Dogs are allowed in the outdoor patio area.

08
Keystone Sports Review image 1

Typical dive bar with lots of TVs and a friendly local crowd creates a cozy, welcoming vibe. The space balances bar and restaurant areas, though bar seating feels limited. Wings and pizza stand out as top food choices enjoyed in a relaxed atmosphere.

Pizza features a real good thin crust and a deluxe thin crust option. Wings often come paired with pizza, both noted for being consistently enjoyable.

Large portions stand out with sandwiches like the Stromboli and chicken parm offering hearty bar-style meals. The Philly Steak sandwich also pairs well with salad and soup for a filling option.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza and wings were great."

"The taco salad was huge and very tasty."

"I'll have to be back for this sandwich."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Parking can fill up fast, especially during busy events like the NFL Draft.

3

Reservations are recommended for game days due to high demand.

09
Bubba's 33 image 1
American restaurant

Small space with dad's garage decor and many TVs showing different games creates a fun, welcoming vibe. Music plays loudly, often at concert volume, making conversation difficult. Beer is served very cold, and the atmosphere feels lively and energetic.

Brick oven style pizzas stand out with a seriously underrated flavor. Pepperoni pizza ranks as one of the best, and the pizza overall stays consistently on point alongside their burgers and wings.

Chicken and avocado sandwiches stand out with grilled chicken, bacon, and pepper jack cheese adding strong flavors. The pork tenderloin sandwich is large and tasty but may not always be grilled as expected.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were very good and juicy."

"I thought the pizza here was seriously underrated and exceptionally good."

"The chicken avocado sandwich is to die for."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at the restaurant, making it a fun dining option.

2

The restaurant offers Burger Mondays with special pricing on burgers.

3

Kids meals are large enough to satisfy young tweens.

10
Upland Brewing 82nd Street image 1

Restaurant combines big open dining room with a park-like outdoor patio featuring plenty of greenery. Atmosphere is loud and lively, often with live music and multiple TVs showing sports. Beer selection stands out with homemade brews and strong local flavor.

Breakfast pizza stays available past brunch and really hits the spot. BBQ Chicken pizza draws praise and is a favorite for kids. Pizza margherita offers a classic choice with solid flavor. The place uses a pizza oven that adds to the quality.

Nashville hot chicken sandwich offers a subtle heat without being too spicy. Adding mayo or more lemon aioli enhances the flavor and balances the spice.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and great."

"I thought the Margherita pizza was fantastic."

"The pulled pork sandwich needed more seasoning and sauce."

Good to know

1

Reservations for large parties are easily accommodated.

2

Happy hour beer specials are offered on weekdays.

3

Live music occurs on Friday nights.

11
The Garage Food Hall image 1

Old warehouse space transformed into a historic food hall with a museum feel and revitalized industrial design. Atmosphere is lively and chaotic, filled with live music, pinball machines, and multiple bars offering tastings and mixed drinks. Crowds gather for a family-friendly vibe and diverse activities like sim racing, creating a bustling social hub.

Italian pizza comes with breadsticks that are generous enough to share or take home. The pizza pairs well with a variety of other food options available nearby.

Cuban and Brazilian steak sandwiches stand out with rich, bold flavors. Other options include a Honey Spice Chicken sandwich, a BLT lobster sandwich, and a flavorful chicken salad sandwich.

People are saying

"It's a cool spot with great vibes."

"You can get pizza and other international foods all in one spot."

"I loved the variety of international sandwich options here."

Good to know

1

Parking at The Garage Food Hall is difficult, especially on weekends.

2

The Garage Food Hall closes at 10 pm.

3

It is best to grab a table first before ordering food.

12
Jay Bhavani (Indian Vegetarian Street Food) - Indianapolis image 1

Indian vegetarian street food spot offers a clean, polished interior with a modern touch and a family-friendly atmosphere. The vibe is vibrant and welcoming, capturing the energy of India's street food culture with a casual dining pace. A selfie corner adds a creative, playful element to the space.

Bhakri pizza with cheese stands out with its street style vibe. Flavors like vada pav and Indo Chinese dishes taste just like back home.

Special Club sandwich and vegetarian grilled sandwich stand out with rich flavors. Options like CTC sandwich and exotic varieties offer a unique twist on classic Indian street food.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"This bhakri pizza tastes just like Mumbai street style pizza."

"I thought the vegetarian grilled sandwich and vada pav were extraordinary."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a wide variety of vegetarian options.

2

Prices are very reasonable, making it budget-friendly.

3

The menu includes south Indian, fast food, and Indo-Chinese cuisine.

13
Joe's Grille image 1
Bar & grill

Bar and grill with laid-back atmosphere and friendly, diverse crowd. Features pool tables and an outdoor fire pit for a relaxed social vibe. Offers great food and drink specials with a focus on tasty wings and burgers.

Huge personal pizzas come with a sauce that some find off. Wings and Philly cheesesteak often accompany the pizza.

Dagwood sandwich stands out with its impressive size and layers. Both the burger and chicken sandwich offer solid, satisfying flavors.

People are saying

"You can grab a great sandwich while watching live sports here."

"I thought the chicken sandwich I ordered was very good."

"I thought the pizza was huge and amazing."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Wednesday at 8pm with a competitive atmosphere.

2

Monday is free pool night, making it a great time to visit.

3

Karaoke takes place on Saturdays, adding to the weekend fun.

14
Pasquale's Pizza & Pasta image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers homey atmosphere with a family-friendly vibe and fresh, made-to-order toppings. The space feels busy and warm, suited more for takeout or delivery than dining in. Toppings are priced fairly, and pizzas come loaded with cheese and meat.

Pizzas come with loaded toppings, perfect sauce balance, and high-quality cheese. Options include meat-heavy pies and a notable dessert pizza that stands out.

Sandwiches come in small sizes, about 4 inches long, with skimpy fillings. The Stromboli sandwich gets strong praise from some for its flavor, though sandwiches generally take about 15 minutes to prepare.

People are saying

"This local spot has great pizza with a nice sauce and chewy crust."

"I found the pizza here to be excellent."

"I ate the whole Stromboli sandwich because it's so good."

Good to know

1

Almost all toppings, except one, cost $1.03 to add.

2

Everything is made to order, ensuring freshness.

3

Expect a messy hallway with construction supplies leading to the restrooms.

15
Aunt Polly's Pizza, Ribs & Chicken image 1

Family-oriented setting creates a wholesome atmosphere with a welcoming, positive vibe. Busy but well-managed, it stays open late to serve consistently fresh, traditional hometown-style pizza and other dishes. The building shows signs of wear but adds to the authentic, no-frills experience.

Pizza here has a traditional, hometown taste with consistent quality. The BBQ pizza stands out as a unique option, and the ordering process is straightforward with friendly staff.

Sandwiches here stand out for their awesome flavor and variety, including options like the CPL sandwich. They pair well with other menu items like ribs and pizza, making for a satisfying meal.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was excellent and perfectly cooked."

"I thought the pizza and wings here were the best I'd ever tasted."

"I've loved the Hot Italian Sub since I was a kid."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open past midnight, which is later than most take-out places.

2

Reservations are not required, but calling ahead for pickup is recommended.

3

Expect potential communication issues regarding closing days; check before visiting.

16
Honest Indianapolis Restaurant image 1

Bright, clean space offers a cozy, authentic vibe with a welcoming atmosphere. The energy ranges from relaxed to lively when crowded. Families find it accommodating with thoughtful touches like a top-screen TV for children.

Bakhri pizza stands out with great taste and fresh toppings. Other pizzas like cheese can be bland or overbaked, and sizes vary with some feeling small for the price.

Bold, loaded Bahubali/Kattapa sandwiches stand out with authentic flavors like the Kattappa sandwich tasting just like in Ahmedabad. Other options include Punjabi shaak sandwiches and the popular Vada Pav.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic, flavorful, and delicious vegetarian Indian street food."

"The Katappa sandwich tasted just like Ahmedabad."

"I definitely recommend ordering the bakhri pizza."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dosa night events to ensure seating.

2

The restaurant offers customizable dishes for dietary restrictions.

3

Takeout is preferred for a better food experience than dining in.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...