Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Indianapolis' best

Steak sandwich spots

A sandwich that features actual steak cuts instead of the thin, mystery-meat shavings found at most lunch counters.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Super Pollo Restaurant image 1
Super Pollo Restaurant image 2
Super Pollo Restaurant image 3
View all

Small space with beautiful decor and a relaxed, cozy vibe. Friendly atmosphere supports easy conversation with subtle background music. Clean and well-organized environment enhances the welcoming feel.

Ribeye steak stands out with excellent flavor and pairs well with dishes like nachos and pozole. The Alambre combines chicken and steak for a solid choice in steak dinners.

The Hawaiian torta stands out as a mammoth sandwich with a generous portion and comes with plenty of seasoned fries. The buffalo chicken sandwich offers a tasty option but could use a bit more sauce.

People are saying

"This lunch spot has fresh, delicious food like amazing chilaquiles."

"The sandwich portions are huge and come with seasoned fries."

"The steak here is amazing and a must-get."

Good to know

1

The menu includes a wide variety of options, from Mexican to American dishes.

2

Prices are very affordable, with meals averaging around $50 for a family.

3

The restaurant is known for its cleanliness and organized facilities.

02
Billy O'Neals Pub & Eatery image 1

Classic Irish pub design with multiple dart boards and a standard bar with TVs creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Mostly older patrons gather in a quiet setting that feels like a local spot for hearty, high-quality bar food. The space has potential for livelier energy with some updates and a fresh look.

Tenderloin stands out as exceptionally tender and flavorful. Steak tips also deliver a delicious and satisfying bite.

Fried pork tenderloin sandwiches come in nice-sized, thick, and crispy portions with lettuce, pickles, and red onions underneath. Other options include salmon BLT, fish with onion rings, spicy chicken, and fried mushroom sandwiches.

People are saying

"I found the tenderloin sandwich to be the best I had."

"You have to try the pork tenderloin sandwich; it's amazing."

"I found the tenderloin steak to be the best I had."

Good to know

1

Most meals cost around $12 and are better than fast food.

2

Billy O'Neals Pub & Eatery offers a large menu with many options.

3

Trivia and music bingo happen every Tuesday night.

03
IndyMeat Wrap and Over Rice image 1
Middle Eastern restaurant

Food truck serves halal Middle Eastern dishes with generous portions and a quiet atmosphere. It attracts people looking for authentic gyro and rice plates, especially late at night. The vibe is calm and satisfying, with a focus on quality and detail.

Juicy, perfectly seasoned steak sits atop tender, well-cooked rice. The combination delivers a satisfying, flavorful meal with perfect seasoning and tender texture.

Steak sandwiches stand out with rich flavor and a satisfying texture. Chicken wraps also offer a full flavor experience, making sandwiches here consistently tasty and well-prepared.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The steak and rice were juicy, tender, and seasoned perfectly."

"The steak sandwich was very good and juicy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but calling ahead is recommended as they may open later than 3PM.

2

The food truck serves halal and kosher options, including chicken, steak, gyro, falafel, fries, and rice.

3

Expect generous portions; one dish can often provide two meals.

04
Gaucho's Fire Express image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food spot inside a clean, lively food hall offers authentic Brazilian flavors with large portions and flavorful sandwiches and fries. The atmosphere is warm and family-friendly, with seating in a shared common area. Parking and finding a table can be challenging during busy times.

Steak comes out cooked perfectly with options like the Brazilian Steak Sandwich featuring grilled onions, mayo, provolone, and homemade vinaigrette. The Ultimate Brazilian Sandwich adds gaucho sauce, chimichurri, and tortilla strips for extra flavor, often paired with tasty fries.

Large sandwiches pack tender steak and sausage with chimichurri and gaucho sauces. Bread holds up well, and grilled onions add a fresh bite.

People are saying

"The Ultimate Brazilian sandwich is amazing and very flavorful."

"I loved the authentic Brazilian flavors and culture here."

"I found the steak delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging during peak hours at busy venues like this.

2

The menu features a variety of Brazilian street food options.

3

Portions are generous and provide good value for the price.

05
The Good Spot image 1
American restaurant

Cozy spot with board games and multiple TVs creates a welcoming, chill atmosphere. Interior feels clean and friendly despite a rough exterior. Energy stays warm and unbothered, making it easy to relax and enjoy food or sports.

Tenderloin stands out with its juicy and flavorful profile, offered fresh and at a reasonable price. Steak tips come out perfectly cooked, tender and tasty, especially during the Wednesday lunch special with fries.

Tenderloin sandwiches stand out with generous pickles and a tender, juicy texture. Other options include Philly cheese steak, beef Manhattan, Chicago dog, BLT, and grilled ham and cheese sandwiches.

People are saying

"The food here is really, really good."

"The tenderloin steak was juicy and flavorful."

"I found the tenderloin sandwich to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Karaoke starts at 10pm on Thursdays with a two-drink minimum.

3

The venue is cashless and only accepts card payments.

06
Harrison’s image 1
Restaurant

Renovated bank building with a preserved vault room creates a unique dining setting. Atmosphere stays relaxed and sophisticated with low noise and friendly energy. Spacious outdoor patio offers a quiet spot for food and drinks, featuring water served in upcycled liquor bottles.

Steaks arrive sizzling hot with beautiful medallions. The Filet stands out as perfectly cooked and a meal highlight.

Chicken parm sandwich stands out with its rich flavor. Italian panini comes with crispy fries on the side. Sandwiches pair well with soup for a simple meal.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is terrific, especially the chicken dishes."

"My steak was perfectly cooked and delicious."

"I found the Italian panini sandwich delicious and very good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially for larger groups.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Tuesday is steak night with special pricing on steak dishes.

07
Fire by the Monon image 1
American restaurant

Cozy restaurant with nice outdoor seating and intimate rooms offers a welcoming atmosphere that suits quiet dinners or small groups. The interior feels a bit worn, and air conditioning can be warm, but the patio with large umbrellas provides a pleasant alternative when weather permits.

Steaks come in good-sized cuts like the breaded tenderloin that folds perfectly to fit a bun. The NY strip steak offers a great flavor and the overall steak quality is consistently delicious.

Pork tenderloin sandwiches stand out for their size and flavor, often shared between two people. Other notable options include the Reuben sandwich and pulled pork sandwich, both praised for their taste.

People are saying

"I had the best tenderloin sandwich I’ve ever had."

"The onion rings on the sandwich were perfect."

"I thought the steak was fabulous and delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking can be tough to find, so arrive early.

2

The restaurant is dog-friendly and has outdoor seating.

3

Expect a brief wait of about 3 minutes for seating.

08
Pawn Shop Pub image 1
Restaurant

Old building with neon signs and a large outdoor patio creates a cozy, relaxed vibe. Busy and loud on weekends, it welcomes pets and allows smoking outside. Interior shows wear but maintains a traditional bar atmosphere.

Steak options include a juicy rare steak sandwich with cheese, onions, peppers, and mayo, plus a double bacon tenderloin sandwich. The tenderloin is good but thinner than some prefer, and a ribeye priced at $12 is available.

Tenderloin sandwich features salty breading and mayo that balances it well, with veggies adding a clean top note. Open face steak sandwich and chicken soft tacos also appear on the menu, offering variety.

People are saying

"The tenderloin sandwich was excellent, hanging over the bun on all sides."

"This tenderloin sandwich is huge and perfectly breaded."

"The tenderloin here is really good, with tender meat."

Good to know

1

Prices for bar food are very reasonable, typically under $10.

2

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

3

The pub is dog-friendly, allowing pets on the outdoor patio.

09
Almost Famous image 1
Cocktail bar

Swanky cocktail bar with eccentric decor and lively music sets a comfortable, classy vibe. Frequented for drag shows and tapas, it offers unique drinks like Martinez and exceptional espresso martinis. Seating includes outdoor options and unobstructed views for performances.

Steak comes with a homemade steak sauce that pairs well with breakfast. The steak and eggs dish offers a generous portion but the steak can be a little tough.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with killer flavor and creative twists like the queso asado option. Biscuits and gravy also appear alongside sandwiches, showing a varied menu.

People are saying

"I loved the coffee; the pistachio latte was perfect."

"The steak and eggs were delicious and plenty."

"I thought the breakfast sandwich was the best in the city."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

The drag show happens every Saturday night at 9pm.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends due to high demand.

10
Aberdeen Social House image 1

Upscale restaurant offers a mid-century modern vibe with curated artwork and thoughtful architectural details. Outdoor patio provides a comfortable, zen atmosphere ideal for leisurely dining. The space balances swanky and welcoming energy, attracting those who appreciate quality and style.

Steaks come dry-aged and cooked to perfection, with the ribeye and NY strip offering a deeply beefy and tender experience.

Tonkatsu tenderloin stands out as a tender, flavorful sandwich. Waffle battered chicken offers a unique twist with the chicken and waffle sandwich. Lobster BLT pairs well with fresh salad options.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is phenomenal and packed with flavor."

"The dry-aged ribeye steak was perfectly cooked and deeply beefy."

"The waffle battered chicken sandwich is amazing and unique."

Good to know

1

The menu changes frequently with local ingredients prepared by a creative culinary team.

2

Expect higher prices for unique dishes and elevated dining experiences.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekends and special occasions.

11
Friend’s Diner image 1
American restaurant

Small, clean restaurant with an open dining area that feels like a cafeteria. Atmosphere is laid back and friendly, offering a simple and inviting environment. Family-style setting includes plentiful free parking and amenities like books and crayons for children.

Grilled tenderloin appears often, served thin but with decent flavor. Steak comes with sides like mushrooms and onions, baked potato, and candied apples.

Sandwiches come in large portions with thick, well-cooked meat. Options include a fried tenderloin, steak, catfish, chicken, and breakfast sandwiches, all delivering solid flavor and size.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and always on point."

"The steak sandwich had a large, thick piece of meat cooked to perfection."

"The grilled tenderloin tasted decent, even if it was thin."

Good to know

1

Firearms are not allowed at the diner.

2

There is plentiful free parking available.

3

Restroom access is for customers only.

12
AJ'S Bar & Grill image 1
Bar & grill

Bar and grill offers live music with a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere that balances good lighting and sound for conversation. The space features a great bar area and draws a crowd that enjoys connection and community energy. Consistent food and drink quality complement the lively vibe.

Thick ribeye steak comes cooked perfectly with tarragon butter that enhances the flavor. The filet is very tender and nicely cooked, making steak night a solid value.

Italian beef sandwiches stand out with strong praise and high ratings. Other notable options include pork tenderloin and Reuben sandwiches, plus fresh and tasty fish sandwiches.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and made with pride."

"The Philly cheese steak sliders were delicious and perfect."

"The Italian beef sandwich with onion rings is a 10."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Thursday at 7pm with no entry fee.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Expect a 20-30 minute wait during peak dinner hours on weekends.

13
Mel's Drive In Restaurant image 1

Old school drive-in with car hop service and picnic table seating offers a nostalgic 50s vibe despite a worn building and parking lot. The atmosphere feels peaceful and retro, attracting a steady crowd. Known for affordable, homemade-style burgers and classic comfort food.

Grilled tenderloin features seasoned flavor and a tender texture. Opinions vary, with some finding it enjoyable and others not.

Tenderloin sandwiches come grilled to perfection and offer a tender texture. The 2 for 6 deal makes it a solid choice for a satisfying meal.

People are saying

"The food here is great and really affordable."

"I loved the tenderloin sandwich, it was grilled to perfection."

"You have to try the grilled tenderloin; it's the best steak I've had."

Good to know

1

The prices at Mel's Drive In Restaurant are very affordable, often under $5.

2

Expect busy parking lots during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Reservations are not required, but expect a wait during lunch and dinner rushes.

14
The Social View image 1

Bar occupies an upstairs space with a wrap-around patio offering a rooftop view of downtown. Atmosphere balances chill vibe with live music and tabletop games, creating a relaxed yet engaging environment. Outdoor seating draws those seeking a quiet spot or a fun night out with friends.

Steaks come out perfect and juicy, especially the New York strip and tenderloin. Fries arrive hot, and salads complement the meal well.

The sandwiches feature a signature grilled chicken with a bacon jam that adds a sweet touch. Options include a fried version and a fried fish sandwich, all served hot and paired well with fries.

People are saying

"You have to try their chicken wings; they're crispy and juicy."

"The Social Signature Sandwich with bacon jam is amazing."

"The steak here is perfect, juicy, and amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Monday to Friday with great deals.

2

Karaoke takes place on Wednesday nights starting at 8 PM.

3

Trivia night occurs every Tuesday at 7 PM with a $5 entry fee.

15
Twin Peaks image 1
Sports bar

Sports bar offers many TVs showing various games and a fire pit patio for outdoor viewing. Atmosphere is loud and energetic with scantily clad staff contributing to a distinctive vibe. Seating provides good views from most spots, creating a welcoming environment for sports fans.

Steaks come out well cooked with excellent flavor. Options like the New York strip, tenderloin, and sirloin all stand out for their taste and quality.

Cheesesteak and Philly Steak sandwiches stand out with authentic flavors that satisfy even tough critics. Spicy chicken and Nashville chicken sandwiches bring bold heat, while the meatball and chicken avocado sandwiches offer fresh, delicious options paired with crispy fries.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the bacon."

"The staff here are so friendly and took awesome care of us."

"I loved the cheesesteak sandwich here."

Good to know

1

There is a $5 cover charge for fight night events.

2

Bikini and beanie night is a popular themed event.

3

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

16
John's Famous Stew image 1

Hole-in-the-wall restaurant with vintage ambiance and old-school diner vibe. Atmosphere feels cozy and nostalgic, attracting mostly blue-collar workers during the day. Known for hearty, homemade meals served in a simple, unpretentious setting.

Tenderloin stands out for its size and tenderness, often enough to share. The Country Fried Steak comes with gravy that covers a perfectly cooked steak, tender enough to cut with a fork.

Massive, breaded pork tenderloin sandwiches stand out here, often described as iconic and as big as a manhole cover. The sandwiches pair well with hearty stews, making for a filling meal.

People are saying

"The pork tenderloin sandwich here is massive and delicious."

"The pork tenderloin sandwich is massive and delicious."

"You have to try their tenderloin; it's massive and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers free parking for customers.

2

Expect long wait times during peak lunch hours, especially around noon.

3

Daily specials are available, providing good value for meals.

17
Rock-Cola 50's Cafe image 1

Small diner with 50's retro decor and a nostalgic atmosphere that feels like stepping back in time. Lighting is dim and the space shows signs of wear, adding to its authentic, lived-in vibe. Regulars enjoy classic diner fare served with care in a cozy, unpretentious setting.

Grilled tenderloin stands out with its tender texture and perfect medium rare cooking. Options include New York strip and rib-eye, often served with eggs, hashbrowns, and Texas Toast.

Italian Beef and Reuben sandwiches stand out for their strong flavors and satisfying portions. The tenderloin sandwich is huge and filling, while the Fried Bologna and chicken sandwiches offer generous sizes and solid cooking.

People are saying

"I found the breakfast food to be really good."

"My steak and eggs were exceptionally good."

"I ate the best Reuben sandwich I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served all day at the cafe.

2

Most meals cost under $10, making it affordable.

3

Prices are not listed on the menu, so ask before ordering.

18
NYC Halal Eats (Greenwood) image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food restaurant with a bright, clean interior and NYC street urban vibe creates a welcoming, positive atmosphere. The space feels modern and spacious, decorated with cool wall art that adds character. It attracts people seeking authentic halal street food with generous portions and bold flavors.

Chicken cheese steak offers a solid balance but leans toward more bread than meat. Salito chicken sandwich stands out with its unique flavor and is worth ordering again.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the tender, well-seasoned lamb."

"I will definitely get the salito chicken sandwich again!"

"The steak platter had tender steak with top-tier flavor."

Good to know

1

The portion sizes are generous, often enough to share between two people.

2

Prices are reasonable for the quality and portion sizes offered.

3

The restaurant maintains a clean and welcoming environment.

19
Bubba's 33 image 1
American restaurant

Small space with dad's garage decor and many TVs showing different games creates a fun, welcoming vibe. Music plays loudly, often at concert volume, making conversation difficult. Beer is served very cold, and the atmosphere feels lively and energetic.

Tenderloins come out consistently great and the ribeye hits the mark every time. Steaks like the marinated and coffee cuts arrive cooked just right with excellent flavor and perfect temperature.

Chicken and avocado sandwiches stand out with grilled chicken, bacon, and pepper jack cheese adding strong flavors. The pork tenderloin sandwich is large and tasty but may not always be grilled as expected.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were very good and juicy."

"The ribeye steak with espresso rub and dip was amazing."

"The chicken avocado sandwich is to die for."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at the restaurant, making it a fun dining option.

2

The restaurant offers Burger Mondays with special pricing on burgers.

3

Kids meals are large enough to satisfy young tweens.

20
Sahm's Tavern & Sports Bar image 1

Sports bar with 19 TVs and three dart lanes creates a lively, noisy atmosphere filled with a strong community vibe. Wooden paneling and cushy seats add warmth and comfort amid the bustling energy. Spaces include small dining cubbies and an upstairs speakeasy for groups seeking privacy.

Steak options include a fillet steak and a New Orleans style cut, both cooked well. The menu also offers steak in a stir fry with chicken or shrimp, alongside other entrees and sandwiches.

Huge portions stand out, especially the fried grouper fish sandwich. The beer-battered Cod sandwich offers a solid option, while the chicken sandwich hits the mark with its perfect preparation.

People are saying

"It's a great spot to catch a game with TVs everywhere."

"The beer-battered fish sandwich was tender and not greasy."

"The steak was cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

Happy hour specials run from 3-5pm and 9pm to close.

2

Expect a wait during busy hours, especially for dinner.

3

The menu includes one vegan option, which may require modifications.

21
Rookies Sports Pub image 1

Neighborhood bar with multiple pool tables and dart boards offers a laid-back atmosphere where a diverse crowd gathers to watch sports on many TVs. The vibe stays chill and comfortable, making it a fun spot to hang out and play games.

Steak specials include melt-in-your-mouth options like filet mignon priced around $15. Tenderloin dishes appear frequently, though some servings come with cold fries.

Grilled pork tenderloin sandwich offers huge size and strong flavor. Buffalo chicken sandwich comes with waffle fries and tastes very good, though some sandwiches can be burnt.

People are saying

"The food here is awesome and in a league of its own."

"The service for steak was excellent from the bartenders and waitstaff."

"I found the buffalo chicken sandwich with waffle fries to be sooo good."

Good to know

1

Karaoke happens every Saturday night, starting at 10pm.

2

Trivia night is on Sundays from 6 to 8pm.

3

The kitchen closes at 11pm, but food may still be served later.

22
Gaucho’s Fire at 82nd image 1
Brazilian restaurant

Small, cozy Brazilian restaurant with authentic food and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Brazilian music and TV screens showing soccer add to the relaxed, family-friendly vibe. Seating includes metal stools and wood booths, reflecting a casual, unpretentious setup.

Steak comes well seasoned and cooked as ordered, delivering a very tender texture. Large servings accompany tasty side dishes like fries and sausage.

The sandwich features perfectly seasoned meat and gooey warm cheese on good bread. It is large, full of grilled perfection, and easy to eat quickly.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and plentiful."

"The steak was tender, juicy, and cooked just right."

"I loved the Brazilian steak sandwich and fries."

Good to know

1

Prices are in the $10-20 range per person, which is reasonable.

2

The restaurant offers big portions at fair prices.

3

They charge $2 for extra sauce and Yuca dust.

23
The Dining Room at RH Indianapolis image 1

Upscale dining space combines museum-like design with impeccable decor and breathtaking grounds. Atmosphere feels elegant and intimate, suited for special occasions with attentive service and calming outdoor areas. Guests often enjoy the wine bar and art exhibits while waiting or relaxing.

Steak comes in filet cuts cooked to order, with attention to doneness despite occasional mix-ups. The menu includes caviar and a prosciutto and delice board alongside the steak options.

People are saying

"The food here is beautiful, with stunning scenery."

"The steak here is great, just like the beautiful scenery."

"Our waiter Jason was amazing and made our night special."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for dining, so book ahead.

2

Valet parking is available for $10.

3

All dishes are served à la carte, with no sides included.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...