Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New Jersey

Pie shops

You want a full American meal that concludes with a slice of proper, house-made pie.

Based on 751 Opinions
+748
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 1
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 2
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 3
View all
Dessert restaurant

Cozy space with warm, welcoming energy creates a friendly, family-oriented vibe. Atmosphere feels like a comfortable home perfect for conversation and enjoying high-quality desserts. Clean, pretty environment enhances the inviting experience.

Desserts like Key Lime Pie and Pecan Pie stand out with fresh flavors and balanced sweetness. The menu also features Truffle Mac and Cheese and freshly made treats like Flan de Coco and Peach Almond Tart.

Key lime pie stands out with a fresh lime flavor balanced against a sweet topping. Desserts like Flan de Coco and Peach Almond Tart are freshly made by Chef Juan, keeping everything tasting vibrant and homemade.

People are saying

"I found the desserts here to be the most delicious I ever had."

"I found the desserts, especially the key lime pie, to be amazing."

"The pecan pie here is so delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

Everything is made fresh daily at Juan Dulce Desserts.

2

There are limited vegan dessert options available.

3

They offer catering services for events and parties.

02
Chief's Steak Shop image 1
American restaurant

Small, family-run restaurant with clean dining room and visible kitchen where the cook sings along with music. Atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed, with family photos creating a sense of connection. Known for best cheesesteaks in the area, offering a friendly and comfortable place to enjoy a meal.

Thinly sliced ribeye steak delivers perfect tenderness in a classic Philly cheesesteak. Buffalo wings and sandwiches like The Chief and Brisket Sandwich offer solid American flavors.

Peanut butter pie stands out as a signature dessert, often described as a dream come true. The menu also features a High PB pie that pairs well with savory dishes like cheesesteaks.

People are saying

"This family owned spot has the best, juicy cheesesteaks."

"I thought the cheesesteak was perfectly delicious, the best I ever had."

"I felt the cheesesteak sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The cheesesteaks are priced around $11.41, with extra charges for rolls or wraps.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

3

The establishment maintains a clean dining and food prep area.

03
Drew's Market image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store with a classic neighborhood market feel offers an excellent selection of fresh food including a prime butcher and deli. The atmosphere is reliable and inviting, attracting locals and visitors alike with quality products and fair prices.

Offers a fully cooked 8-10 lb. Thanksgiving turkey with gravy and a variety of sides. Meatloaf stands out as a notable dish, and apple pie is available for dessert.

Made-to-order pot pies include a chicken parm pot pie with pulled chicken and a holiday pot pie. The Thanksgiving Pie features turkey and sides, offering a hearty dinner option.

People are saying

"The market's prepared foods and sandwiches are delicious and fresh."

"I ordered the whole turkey and sides for Thanksgiving dinner."

"You have to try the chicken parm pot pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Drew's Market offers a wide selection of fresh food and Italian specialties.

2

Catering services are available for events, including graduation parties.

3

Prices at Drew's Market are affordable and competitive.

04
Brew Box Cafe NJ image 1

Small cafe offers a homey vibe with jazz music setting a relaxed tone. Positive energy fills the space, welcoming a diverse crowd seeking comfort food and unique sweet potato pie. It stands out as a hidden gem with generous portions and a clean, accessible environment.

Shrimp and grits stand out with rich flavors that impress many. The Cobb salad offers a fresh, satisfying option packed with chicken and crisp lettuce. Sweet potato cornbread adds a unique, tasty touch to the menu.

Sweet potato pie stands out with its rich flavor and large size that satisfies cravings. Bean pies also offer a notable taste experience.

People are saying

"I found the food to be fresh and delicious."

"I thought the sweet potato pie was the best I had ever tasted."

"I thought the American Food shrimp and grits were out of this world."

Good to know

1

There is lots of parking and the building is handicapped accessible.

2

They have a large variety of snacks and an easy-to-read menu.

3

The food didnโ€™t take long to prepare.

05
Capt'n Chucky's Crab Cake Co. Ocean City, NJ image 1

Seafood market offers an immaculate setting with a phenomenal selection of fresh and prepared seafood. The atmosphere is straightforward and focused on quality, attracting those seeking fresh crab cakes and outstanding shrimp. Clear cooking instructions and reasonable prices support a reliable takeaway experience.

Crab cakes stand out as a signature item, known for their rich flavor. Other notable dishes include shrimp sliders and a shrimp/crab roll, all delivering solid American seafood flavors.

Key lime pie stands out with its bright, tangy flavor and creamy texture. It consistently impresses and complements the seafood-focused menu.

People are saying

"I thought the crab cakes were the best, with no fillers."

"I couldn't wait to get their crab cakes; they're some of the best I've ever had."

"I found the key lime pie to be fantastic."

Good to know

1

The prices for crab cakes are reasonable and competitive.

2

They offer a variety of fresh seafood options for takeaway.

3

Cooking instructions for prepared seafood are provided with purchases.

06
Ashley Farms image 1

Farm market combines cozy interior with family-run charm and a quiet, kid-friendly atmosphere. It offers fresh produce, homemade pies, and apple cider donuts alongside practical services like propane refills. The place feels welcoming without crowds, making it a calm spot for families.

Fresh Thanksgiving turkey is a key offering, with many traveling long distances to get it. Homemade salads like potato salad, turkey salad, macaroni salad, and coleslaw complement the main dishes.

Pies here taste rich and homemade with a consistently fantastic quality. Freshness stands out alongside breads and apple cider donuts.

People are saying

"This local spot is a great family-run farm."

"I thought the pies here were fantastic and tasted homemade."

"I always got my Thanksgiving turkey here; it was always great."

Good to know

1

Ashley Farms offers fresh produce and apple cider donuts.

2

Propane refills at Ashley Farms are inexpensive.

3

Great prices on a variety of local products.

07
ONE11 Bar & Kitchen image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant offers a lively and welcoming atmosphere with live music and big screens for sports. Outdoor patio provides a comfy space where dogs are welcome. The design is thoughtfully crafted with a fresh, clean feel throughout.

Key lime pie stands out with a flavor that rivals authentic versions from Key West. Dishes like the Philly cheesesteak special and smokey chicken wings deliver bold, well-cooked flavors.

Smooth and silky texture defines the key lime pie here. It delivers a perfect balance of flavors that rivals authentic versions from Key West.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always on point."

"The American Food here, especially the burgers, is juicy and excellent."

"I thought the key lime pie was amazing and silky."

Good to know

1

Live music and DJ performances happen every Friday and Saturday night.

2

Wine specials are available on Wednesdays.

3

Salsa lessons are offered on Thursdays.

08
Maia's Bakery image 1

Small bakery with cozy, inviting atmosphere and freshly baked viennoiseries that evoke a Parisian feel. Seating area is cute and charming, suitable for quick bites or relaxed visits. Pastries, especially croissants, stand out for their perfect texture and authentic taste.

Pecan pie stands out with its rich flavor and pairs well with drip coffee. Chocolate chip cookies and scones also feature as solid American treats.

Apple crumble pie stands out as exceptionally flavorful, praised for surpassing typical expectations. The pecan pie also delivers a rich, satisfying taste that pairs well with drip coffee.

People are saying

"I found the baguettes here to be fresh, proper, and so good."

"The pecan tart was everyone's favorite American Food."

"This apple crumble pie is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Maia's Bakery is closed on Sundays and Mondays.

2

The plain croissants sell out fast; arrive early to get one.

3

Maiaโ€™s Bakery has no chairs for seating.

09
Baked By The Ocean image 1

Small specialty patisserie offers custom cakes and savory items like chicken pot pie and mac and cheese. Atmosphere feels adorable and inviting with affordable cupcakes and a focus on fresh, well-crafted desserts. Ordering is quick, with additional hours available by appointment.

Chicken pot pie stands out with its creamy filling and buttery crust. Mac and cheese also features as a notable comfort food option.

Chicken pot pies feature a buttery crust and a creamy, delicious filling that serves as perfect comfort food. Custom fruit pies with peaches, blueberries, and raspberries are also available.

People are saying

"The cake here is beautiful and delicious."

"The chicken pot pie here is creamy, delicious, and has a buttery crust."

"The American food, specifically the chicken pot pie, is creamy, delicious, and has a buttery crust."

Good to know

1

They offer additional hours by appointment for convenience.

2

The shop is closed until September 5, so plan accordingly.

3

The process of ordering takes about 10 minutes.

10
Jackson and Goodwin Soul Food image 1

Small, clean soul food restaurant with a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like a family kitchen. Owners share personal stories and show clear passion, creating a strong sense of community and love. Limited space means standing room only, but the environment remains friendly and welcoming.

Sweet potato pie stands out with a rich filling and moist texture. Cherry pie and peach cobbler offer classic fruit flavors, while pound cake often features a unique twist with sweet potato pie in the middle.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and great."

"The American food here is made with so much love."

"You have to try the sweet potato pie; it's top notch."

Good to know

1

Expect longer wait times due to the small size of the kitchen staff.

2

Bring extra time when ordering as the kitchen is very small.

3

The restaurant is located on the corner of Palisades and Grand.

11
The Oak House image 1
Restaurant

Wooden interior and homey, country atmosphere create a beautiful, intimate space with a large dining room and bar area. Music and acoustics are extremely loud, often requiring raised voices. Staff are attentive, and the place balances between a sports bar vibe and upscale dining.

Clam chowder serves as a hearty meal on its own with large portions. Steak sandwich features a perfectly cooked ribeye. Pulled pork quesadilla and meatballs offer solid flavors. Key lime pie tastes just right.

Key lime pie comes out just right with a bright, tangy flavor. Double-layer apple walnut pie features a perfect crumb topping and pairs well with ice cream served on the side.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and top-notch."

"The American food, like the burgers and ribs, was excellent."

"The pie here is delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are tough to get last minute, especially on weekends.

2

Valet parking is recommended due to limited street parking.

3

The menu is limited, with only two pasta dishes available.

12
Danaher's Pub image 1
Irish restaurant

Irish pub with free pool and darts in a dedicated space and professionally poured Guinness matching Dublin standards. Cozy booths and tables create a family-friendly atmosphere that can get loud near the bar. TVs show football matches, adding to the lively vibe.

Burgers stand out, especially the Rachael and classic hamburgers. The Philly Cheesesteak hits the mark, and the vodka penne with fried chicken offers a unique twist. Patty melts come with American cheese but the bread could be toasted more.

Shepherd's pie stands out with hearty fillings and rich flavors. The Chicken Pot Pie offers a classic, comforting taste with a flaky crust.

People are saying

"The pub grub here is fantastic, especially the bar pie."

"The American food here, especially the burgers and vodka penne, is really good."

"The shepherd's pie and chicken pot pie were excellent."

Good to know

1

Trivia night occurs every Wednesday and can get very crowded.

2

Reservations are recommended for larger groups, especially on trivia nights.

3

The pub is kid-friendly, making it suitable for family outings.

13
The Table image 1
Restaurant

Large, versatile space hosts multiple events with live Bossa Nova music and a tree slab table centerpiece. Atmosphere feels welcoming and charming, with excellent cocktails and a cozy vibe suited for romantic or social gatherings.

Dishes like eggs Benedict, challah French toast, and steak frites come out perfectly cooked and beautifully presented. The menu includes a variety of options from crispy bacon to Greek Caesar salad, all well prepared and delicious.

Pecan pie stands out as a highlight, noted for its rich flavor and texture. The key lime pie also appears frequently, praised for its balance of tartness and sweetness.

People are saying

"The food here is spectacular, especially the burgers and fries."

"The American Food, especially the brunch dishes, was delicious and perfectly cooked."

"I think the pecan pie here is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch, especially on weekends.

2

The cocktail class is hosted by Juan and is highly rated.

3

Private event space is available for gatherings of up to 40 people.

14
Stew Leonard's Farm Fresh Food & Wine image 1

Maze-like layout guides shoppers through every department, creating a unique flow. Animatronics like singing avocados and dancing cows add a playful, family-friendly vibe. Integrated wine and liquor section blends seamlessly with fresh food offerings, enhancing the lively atmosphere.

Fried chicken stands out with super crispy, huge pieces that are perfectly seasoned and not greasy. Lobster rolls and lobster salad offer tremendous flavor, while mac and cheese and ready-made ribs, wings, and brisket add variety to the American food options.

Fresh pies come in full or half sizes, with the clerk willing to split pies to offer different flavors. Pecan pie stands out as a consistent choice, paired often with cheese popcorn.

People are saying

"This grocery store felt like a theme park with lively animations."

"They listened and made the onion dip thick, creamy, and delicious again."

"I loved the delicious pies, especially the coconut custard."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide variety of fresh produce, meats, and baked goods.

2

Parking is ample and easily accessible for shoppers.

3

Prepared foods may not look fresh after 6pm.

15
Carribbean Pete's Island Grille image 1

Waterfront dining offers stunning bay views and Key West-inspired decor that create a relaxing, vacation-like atmosphere. Live music adds energy but can be loud enough to challenge conversation. Outdoor seating by the marina enhances the chill, friendly vibe.

Chicken wings feature non-traditional seasonings and a perfect crunch. Crab cakes contain all crab with distinctive spices. Key Lime pie offers a sweet yet crisp lime flavor that balances well.

Key lime pie stands out with its crisp lime flavor that balances sweetness without tartness. It leans a bit sweeter than some prefer but serves as a great ending to a meal.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and full of authentic Caribbean flair."

"The American Food chicken wings here are uniquely seasoned and delicious."

"The key lime pie is a delicious ending to a great meal."

Good to know

1

Live music is available every weekend.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your own drinks.

3

Expect limited menu options during your visit.

16
Jollibee image 1
Chicken restaurant

Cozy space with a welcoming atmosphere and vibrant environment. Music plays loudly, creating an energetic vibe. Offers drive-thru service and high chairs for children, accommodating various needs.

Fried chicken stands out with its savory crunch and consistent crispiness. The menu offers a split bucket option featuring both spicy and original flavors, alongside a tasty Angus cheeseburger.

Pies come crispy and warm, especially the Peach Mango Pie which is packed with flavor. The ube and Chickenjoy pies also stand out for their freshness and quality.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and fresh."

"I loved their peach mango pie; it was the perfect crispy dessert."

"This American food has the best fried chicken I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The wait time for food is often 30 to 45 minutes.

2

The store is clean, including the restroom.

3

There are ample parking spots available.

17
Grace O'Malley's Whiskey Chapel image 1

Classic Irish pub with cozy atmosphere and chill vibe offers big screens for sports and outdoor seating. Crowd enjoys watching football games while relaxing with well-poured Guinness and other drinks. Place feels welcoming and less loud than nearby spots.

Short rib grilled cheese stands out as a frequent choice. The New York strip comes with a notable brandy sauce. Other options include chicken pot pie, salmon, and burgers, with nachos offering a milder flavor.

Shepherd's Pie serves as a decent winter option but comes in a smaller portion than expected for the price. The Chicken Pot Pie stands out as a solid choice among the pies offered.

People are saying

"It's a classic Irish pub with a solid, welcoming atmosphere."

"They had a huge whiskey list, including a separate menu."

"The American Food here is great, thanks to Sean's upbeat service."

Good to know

1

The service and kitchen are open until late, allowing dining close to 11 PM.

2

Drink prices are great, especially for the area.

3

Outdoor dining is available, perfect for nice weather.

18
Dowling's Irish Pub & Restaurant image 1

Spacious Irish pub with a neighborhood pub feel and cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Live band plays soulful renditions of classic songs while multiple TVs cater to sports fans. Renovated space includes a banquet room, creating a comfortable spot for gatherings.

Meatloaf stands out with brown gravy that many find top notch. Other solid choices include the prime rib sandwich and pot pie, both noted for their tasty flavors.

Shepherd's pie comes with a rich filling and pairs well with an ice cold Kilkenny beer. Irish cream pie serves as a sweet finish, especially with Baileys Irish cream coffee.

People are saying

"The pub food, like the fish and chips, was off the charts."

"I loved the Shepherd's Pie; it had the right ratio of meat and potato."

"I thought the American Food, especially the meatloaf, was fantastic."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a $5 entry fee.

2

Bingo night is hosted weekly, providing a fun social atmosphere.

3

The pub offers gluten-free beer and food options for dietary needs.

19
RP Prime Steakhouse Fair Lawn image 1

Upscale steakhouse with beautiful renovations and a magnificent bar offers a warm, romantic atmosphere with an elegant touch. The space tends to be loud, making conversation challenging even when not full. The vibe suits special dinners but remains family friendly.

Prime rib and porterhouse steak stand out with great seasoning and perfect cooking, especially the medium rare option. Fried calamari and mashed potatoes add to the delicious American food offerings.

Blueberry pie comes with vanilla ice cream and serves as a common dessert option. Fruit pies and cobblers appear, sometimes served cold, which is unusual. Apple pie also features alongside other desserts like tiramisu.

People are saying

"The food and service were outstanding."

"The American Food here, especially the steaks, is juicy and cooked perfectly."

"The service here is stellar, with genuine kindness and attention."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for large groups to ensure seating.

2

Lobster night special occurs every Wednesday, featuring unique menu items.

3

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

20
Crockett's Fish Fry image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small dining area with soulful decor featuring African American interpretations of saints and Biblical scenes creates a homely atmosphere. Jazz music and videos play, adding to the pleasant vibe while enjoying crispy fried fish and classic sides.

Fried fish dishes like catfish, whiting, and scallops come with crispy, well-seasoned hush puppies. Sides include tasty mac and cheese, collard greens, and potato salad.

Sweet potato pie stands out as the only dessert option and comes in a large portion suitable for sharing. It pairs well with cold drinks and complements classic sides like mac & cheese and potato salad.

People are saying

"The fried fish here is so crispy and tasty."

"The American Food here is perfectly fried and crispy."

"You've got to try the sweet potato pie; it's so good."

Good to know

1

Crockett's Fish Fry only accepts cash payments, no credit cards.

2

Parking requires a little patience; spaces can be hard to find.

3

The restaurant has been in business for over 35 years.

21
Red Horse Steakhouse by David Burke - Rumson, NJ image 1

Steakhouse offers a loud, energetic atmosphere with live music enhancing the experience. Decor features quaint, classy touches like blown glass artwork and candlelight. The space attracts those seeking a vibrant, upscale dining environment.

Key lime pie stands out with a light and fluffy texture that finishes the meal well. The Porterhouse for two comes without sauce, highlighting the meat's natural flavor.

Key lime pie offers a light and fluffy finish to the meal. The coconut custard pie with roasted pineapple delivers a tropical flavor that stands out.

People are saying

"Dinner in the dark is an unforgettable sensory revelation."

"The American food here is great, especially when Nadine is your server."

"Nadine, our server, made our birthday celebration very special."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all day on Tuesdays with special promotions.

2

Trivia night features movie trivia every Tuesday at 8pm.

3

Steak night is on Wednesdays with special menu items.

22
Dino's Seaville Diner image 1

Diner with old-school atmosphere and homey, cozy vibe offers a quiet, family-friendly setting. Interior feels dated but clean, featuring an old-style bar and counter seating. Regulars enjoy consistent quality and generous portions, especially for breakfast and seafood.

Chicken Pot Pie stands out with its flaky crust, generous chicken, and well-cut vegetables. Other notable dishes include prime rib, biscuits and gravy, fried shrimp, broiled scallops, crab cakes, and meatloaf.

Rich lemon flavor and light, scrumptious meringue define the Lemon Meringue pie. The Chicken Pot Pie features a flaky crust, large amounts of chicken, and nicely cut vegetables, available only on Sundays.

People are saying

"I had a great breakfast with perfectly cooked omelets and hash browns."

"This American food, the chicken pot pie, has the best crust and chicken."

"The lemon meringue pie is rich and to die for."

Good to know

1

Dino's offers the Chicken Pot Pie only on Sundays.

2

Coffee or tea is free for veterans.

3

There is lots of parking available.

23
Pitney Pub image 1

Pub offers indoor and outdoor seating with live music and multiple TVs for sports coverage. Atmosphere stays friendly and inviting with background music that keeps noise moderate. Menu features large portions and affordable prices, with standout items like wings, pizza, and unique specials.

Nachos stand out as a meal for two with plenty to share. The menu also features chicken pot pie, Reuben sandwich, crab cakes, curried chicken, and desserts like peanut butter bomb, cheesecake, and key lime pie.

Chicken pot pie stands out with rich, savory filling. Specials include a lobster pot pie. Dessert options feature key lime pie and peanut butter cheesecake.

People are saying

"The bar food here is really good, especially the wings."

"The American food here is always fresh and delicious."

"I found the pot pie absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a busy atmosphere during major events like the Kentucky Derby.

2

The parking lot is often full, so arrive early to find a spot.

3

Happy hour specials are available, making drinks more affordable.

24
O'Donnell's Pour House image 1

Irish pub offers lively atmosphere with live bands and outdoor seating under a big pavilion. The space feels welcoming and casual, with patrons often joining in sing-alongs and cheering during sports events. Decor includes county flags that add a cultural touch.

Pork chop, shepherdโ€™s pie, and crab cakes stand out with solid flavors. The crab cakes taste sweet and buttery. Prime rib tends to be tough and overcooked.

Peanut butter pie stands out with its fabulous flavor. Shepherd's pie features braised short rib under mashed potatoes, offering a twist on the traditional version.

People are saying

"The food here is really fresh and perfectly prepared."

"I thought the pie here was great."

"The wait for American food here can be really long."

Good to know

1

Outdoor seating is available at O'Donnell's Pour House.

2

The establishment is 21+ after 5pm, so no children allowed.

3

Expect a 45-minute wait if the kitchen is backed up.

25
Palisades Park Bakery image 1

Spacious, modern bakery blends American and Korean styles with bright, clean decor and painted murals. Atmosphere stays calm and cozy, avoiding crowded cafe vibes. Self-serve setup lets people choose pastries at their own pace.

Pecan pie stands out with a subtle but notable twist after the owner took over, returning to its original taste. Brunch features eggs Benedict that many find very good, often paired with fresh salads and creme French toast.

Pecan pie stands out with its traditional recipe kept alive for decades and a subtle but huge difference after new ownership. It sells fast from the kitchen and suits parties and family desserts well.

People are saying

"The desserts here are some of the best I've had."

"The pecan pie tastes just like the original recipe."

"Their American Food, especially the pecan pie, is back to its original taste."

Good to know

1

Donuts are priced at $2.75 each, significantly higher than before.

2

Expect long lines during weekends due to popularity.

3

The bakery uses dairy whipped cream for a better texture.

26
Cattle 'n Clover image 1

Huge bar space combines live music and multiple pool tables to create a lively, energetic atmosphere. Booths and tables offer seating, though some are tight and small. Outdoor areas add a comfortable energy for relaxed socializing.

Chicken pot pie stands out as especially delicious and a frequent order. The meatloaf and corned beef and cabbage also deliver strong, classic American flavors.

Chicken pot pie stands out with rich, savory filling and flaky crust. The shepherd's pie impresses with hearty layers and robust flavor, often called one of the best dishes here.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the authentic Irish fare."

"This chicken pot pie is fresh and filled with chicken and vegetables."

"The chicken pot pie is one of the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The bar is open until 3:00 a.m. on weekends.

2

The kitchen is open until at least midnight for late-night diners.

3

Some items on the online menu may not be available at the restaurant.

27
Crest Tavern image 1
Bar & grill

Lively bar and grill with indoor and outdoor bars and a sports-themed atmosphere filled with eclectic patrons. The space is often crowded and loud, featuring multiple TVs and live music. Food and drink selections include craft beers and well-regarded seafood dishes.

Chicken pot pie stands out, available only on Wednesdays and drawing regulars for its awesome flavor. The crab cakes also get consistent praise for their quality.

Chicken pot pie comes out hot and super tasty on Wednesdays only. It draws regulars for its Wednesday pot pie night and gets mixed reviews but mostly positive.

People are saying

"The bar food here is good, especially the chicken sandwich."

"You have to try the chicken pot pie on Wednesday."

"I always came on Wednesday for the chicken pot pie."

Good to know

1

Happy hour deals are available, offering great discounts on drinks.

2

Wednesday is chicken pot pie night, a popular event.

3

Expect a 30-minute wait for a table during off-peak times.

28
Thatcher McGhee's Denville image 1

Irish pub offers a large interior with two dining areas and outdoor seating. Atmosphere ranges from loud, energetic music to quieter rooms with tables for relaxed conversation. Crowd enjoys classic Irish drinks like Guinness and Irish cider alongside hearty food options.

Prime rib sandwiches come with au jus and can be fatty. Chicken pot pie and crock of chili are popular hearty options. Appetizers include potato skins, pretzels, and loaded chicken nachos.

Shepherd's Pie stands out with a portion size that satisfies and a taste reminiscent of England. The Chicken Pot Pie also earns praise for its flavor and is a favorite among diners.

People are saying

"The bar has a great beer selection and authentic Irish food."

"The American food here is delicious, especially the loaded chicken nachos."

"The Shepherd's Pie was excellent, with a great meat and potato topping."

Good to know

1

Trivia night happens every Wednesday at 8pm.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Parking can be difficult to find during busy afternoons.

29
The Auld Shebeen Pub image 1

Irish pub with authentic imported decor creates a cozy, homey atmosphere that feels like stepping into Ireland. Quiet spaces like the snug in the back corner offer privacy and comfort for lunch or reading. Fresh Guinness and well-crafted cocktails complement the warm, inviting vibe.

Irish nachos come loaded with crumbled corned beef. The chicken pot pie features a flaky, light crust and is a common favorite. The Guinness cheeseburger offers a very flavorful bite.

Cottage pie and chicken pot pie stand out here. The pot pie has a flaky, light crust and tastes great, while the cottage pie gets consistent praise.

People are saying

"The pub staff here is so friendly and professional."

"The chicken pot pie has an awesome flaky crust."

"The chicken pot pie's crust was flaky and light."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on busy nights like St. Patrickโ€™s Day due to long wait times.

2

The pub offers a variety of vegan and vegetarian options on the menu.

3

The restaurant is conveniently located inside the Marriott hotel for easy access.

30
Spike's Fish Market & Restaurant image 1

Small seafood market restaurant with a cozy, retro vibe and a laidback shore atmosphere. Guests pick meals from a refrigerated case featuring the freshest catch, reflecting a nearly 100-year-old fishing shack style. The space feels quaint and bustling, offering a friendly, family-like setting.

Seafood shines with lobster rolls served alongside home fries or coleslaw, and New England clam chowder offered in pints. Options include clam chowder varieties, crabcakes, shrimp salad sandwiches, and clams on the half shell.

Homemade pies stand out with the coconut mousse pie being especially incredible and delicious. The pies serve as a strong dessert option after dinner.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and so fresh."

"Their New England clam chowder is really good."

"I believed the pie I tried was the best pie I had ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to ensure seating, especially during busy times.

2

The restaurant is a bring-your-own-bottle establishment; no alcohol is served.

3

Expect the place to be packed at times, especially during peak hours.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...