Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New Jersey

Authentic margherita pizza

Made for those who refuse to eat a margherita pizza unless it adheres to strict, traditional preparation standards.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza image 1
Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza image 2
Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza image 3
View all

Small, family-owned pizzeria with wood fire oven on display creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere blending modern decor and rustic charm. The space feels warm and welcoming, with a family-friendly vibe and Italian music enhancing the experience. Outdoor seating adds flexibility while maintaining an intimate setting.

Pizzas here capture the authentic Napoli style with a Margherita that tastes very close to the original. The crust and sauce balance well, making the pizza beyond delicious and consistently great.

Pizza here matches the authentic Napoli style closely, with fresh ingredients and a wood-fired crust. It captures the heart and soul of traditional Italian pizza, making it stand out outside Italy.

People are saying

"This pizza is so delicious, it's beyond words."

"I thought the pizza was as authentic as you can get."

"The Margherita Pizza here is simple perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your own drinks.

3

On Wednesdays, buy a pizza and get $1 wings.

02
O’ Sole Mio Pizzeria Ristorante image 1

Italian restaurant offers family-oriented atmosphere with old-world charm and outdoor patio dining. The space feels like home, featuring authentic decor with paintings and background music. It hosts friendly interactions, including owner-organized games and thoughtful gestures.

Slices deliver a perfect balance of cheese and sauce. The Margherita pizza stands out with its exquisite flavor and quality that feels fit for a king.

Italian food features fresh pasta cooked to perfection with rich, delicious sauce. Every dish offers an authentic taste made from good ingredients, whether it's a casual slice or a full dinner.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was phenomenal, especially the crispy thin crust."

"The Italian food here is so authentic and fresh."

"This Margherita Pizza is spot on, a taste of heaven."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYO, so bring your own drinks.

2

Expect higher prices than what's listed on the menu.

3

There is no air conditioning in the restaurant.

03
Culto Italiano Pizzeria image 1

Outdoor tables surround a small patio with a walk-up counter and a pizza food truck featuring a portable oven. Warm, cozy atmosphere evokes authentic Neapolitan Italy, with a focus on takeout and outdoor dining. The vibe is casual and inviting, centered on traditional Italian pizza made with high-quality ingredients.

Crispy, Neapolitan-style crust defines the Margherita pizza here, topped with quality ingredients. The pizza stands out as a special pie alongside other dishes.

Pizza features a light as a cloud crust with an authentic Neapolitan style. Ingredients stay fresh and simple, delivering genuine Italian flavors in every bite.

People are saying

"This authentic Neapolitan pizza tastes just like Naples."

"The calamari here is so crispy and delicious."

"I found the Margherita pizza to be amazing and one of the best."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only offers outdoor seating and takeout options.

2

Culto Italiano uses high-quality imported ingredients for authentic Italian flavors.

3

Expect small portion sizes, which may not justify the higher prices.

04
Bivio Pizza Napoletana image 1
Pizza restaurant

Wood-fired oven dominates a small, cozy space with closely set tables and a lively, intimate vibe. Music complements the warm atmosphere, creating a feeling of being in Italy. The energy is high, especially around the bar seats facing the oven, making it a popular spot that fills quickly.

Neapolitan style shines in the Margherita pizza, delivering a taste that feels authentically Italian. The pizza stands out for its delicious simplicity and classic flavors.

Wood-fired crust delivers authentic Neapolitan pizza with a perfect balance of char, chew, and lightness. Air bubbles and wooden char add a distinct authentic flavor true to Italian tradition.

People are saying

"This pizza's authentic Neapolitan flavors are simply outstanding."

"I loved the authentic Neapolitan pizza with its wood-fired char."

"I felt like I was in Italy eating this Margherita pizza."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must as the restaurant gets full quickly.

2

The restaurant is only open on Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays.

3

They do not accept walk-in customers; all reservations are made through OpenTable.

05
IL Forno a Legna - Raritan image 1
Italian restaurant

Wood-fired oven creates smoky, crispy pizza in a cozy, inviting space with modern decor and authentic Italian music. The atmosphere balances warmth with occasional noise from hard walls, making it suitable for relaxed meals with friends or family. Semi-private corners offer separation for larger groups.

Margherita pizza stays consistent and on point. It pairs well with simple sides like spinach salad and Burrata.

Pizza features a wood-fired crust and toppings like those in Campania. Marinara sauce stands out as excellent and authentic. Italian dishes use fresh, rich flavors and good ingredients throughout.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic and packed with fresh, rich flavors."

"The pizza has that authentic wood-fired taste and amazing crust."

"Their Margherita Pizza is always good and on point."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to ensure a table.

2

The restaurant has a BYOB policy, allowing guests to bring their own alcohol.

3

Weekday lunch specials offer great value and quality for diners.

06
Bella Trattoria E Pizzeria image 1
Italian restaurant

Elegant space with unique decor and great curb appeal creates a cozy, family-oriented atmosphere. Relaxing background music enhances the inviting vibe, while BYOB service adds a personal touch. Known for authentic Italian dishes and standout pizza, it offers a warm, intimate dining experience.

Thin crust has a good bite and tastes great. Fresh mozzarella stands out as the best on Bergenline. The pizza is consistently mouthwatering and delicious.

Every dish bursts with authentic Italian flavor crafted using traditional techniques. The classic NY Style pizza and homemade tiramisu stand out for their genuine taste and texture.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and flavorful."

"The food here is authentic Italian, bursting with flavor."

"I thought the Margherita Pizza was superb and tasty."

Good to know

1

Brunch is available on weekends.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, allowing you to bring your own drink.

3

All desserts are homemade, ensuring freshness.

07
IL FORNO A LEGNA- DUNELLEN image 1

Small rustic pizza restaurant with wood pizza oven and intimate lighting creates a cozy, authentic Italian vibe. Atmosphere stays calm and relaxing, welcoming for families and dates. Local touches include a photo collage and occasional live music.

Fresh tomatoes give the pizza a fragrant, authentic taste. The crust and toppings stay on point, offering a clear, classic flavor.

An authentic Italian vibe fills the space, making the atmosphere feel genuine. The margherita pizza stands out with its fresh tomatoes, capturing true Italian flavors.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, tastes so fresh and authentic."

"The margherita pizza felt truly authentic with its fresh tomatoes."

"The Margherita Pizza here is on point, tasting of fresh tomatoes."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your own drinks.

2

There is a discount if you pay cash.

3

Expect a 4% credit card fee at the end of your meal.

08
Porto By Antonio image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space with artisanal pizza oven and eye-catching artwork creates a trendy, international vibe. Outdoor seating is dog-friendly and lively, while inside stays full but not crowded. Bar serves excellent cocktails, adding to the energetic atmosphere.

Hot Margherita pizza comes with a crispy crust and a classic style. Sauce quality varies, sometimes lacking flavor.

Pizza features a light, crisp crust with perfect chew and char, reflecting authentic Napoli style. Mediterranean dishes showcase rich, authentic flavors using genuine Italian ingredients.

People are saying

"The food here is flavorful and prepared with so much love."

"I loved the authentic Italian flavors and homemade pasta here."

"I found the Margherita pizza to be out of this world."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups.

2

Expect long wait times during peak dining hours.

3

Limited street parking is available near the restaurant.

09
CapoStrada image 1
Italian restaurant

Small Italian restaurant with cozy indoor seating and outdoor tables offers a casual, inviting atmosphere. Mostly focused on take-out service, it features large portions and a menu with fresh, quality ingredients. The vibe feels authentic, with a hint of Italy in the air.

Large size and a price of $25.00 stand out for the Margherita pizza. It resembles a tomato pie more than a traditional Margherita and generally rates around 4 stars.

Food features imported meats from Italy and authentic toppings that capture the Italian vibe. Portions come large and prices stay reasonable for the fresh, made-to-order quality.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the pasta dishes."

"The food here is amazing, truly authentic Italian."

"The Margherita Pizza's crust was excellent, and the sauce and basil were delicious."

Good to know

1

CapoStrada specializes in take-out service and has limited seating available.

2

Pizzas are approximately 18 inches and pastas can easily feed two people.

3

Reservations are not required, and there is usually no wait time.

10
Fratelli's Wood-Fired Pizzeria - Sea Isle City image 1

Wood-fired pizza oven creates authentic flatbread-style pizza with a chewy crust and quality ingredients. Seating includes outdoor options that invite people watching in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. BYOB policy adds a casual, family-oriented vibe despite occasional heat and insect presence inside.

Thin crust and well done characterize the Margherita pizza here. Prices sit around $19, but quality varies with some pizzas not meeting expectations.

Pizza features a perfectly crisp crust, fresh ingredients, and generous toppings with authentic Italian and Mediterranean flavors. The atmosphere feels authentic too.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here reminded me of Italy."

"I loved the authentic Italian pizza with its crisp crust."

"I found the Margherita pizza to be the best I had."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB, allowing customers to bring their own beverages.

2

Expect long wait times, especially on busy weekends.

3

Prices for pizzas are around $24 each.

11
Trattoria Napoli image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space with warm lighting and soft music creates a cozy, family-friendly vibe. Atmosphere blends rustic charm and modern comfort, making it inviting and calm. Outdoor seating adds reasonable comfort to the experience.

Margherita pizza stands out for its delightful flavor and memorable taste. It consistently delivers a phenomenal experience.

Offers authentic Italian cuisine with dishes that taste truly delicious and made with heart. Food consistently delivers a genuine taste of Italy.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pizza and pasta, is delicious."

"I found the food here to be truly authentic Italian cuisine."

"I thought the Margherita Pizza was quite delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your own drinks.

2

After 10 PM, only takeaway service is available.

3

Parking in the area can be challenging.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...