Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New Jersey

Birthday cakes

Made for those who believe a birthday is incomplete without a high-quality cheesecake to mark the occasion.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Julius Bakery image 1
Julius Bakery image 2
Julius Bakery image 3
View all

Small space fills with fresh bakery aroma and clean, airy atmosphere. Jazz music plays softly, creating a welcoming vibe. Open displays showcase high-quality pastries and cakes that attract a steady flow of dessert lovers.

Coconut flavor shines in the Biscoff cheesecake. Cheesecakes come in bite-size fruit clusters or plain with a good cheese taste. Sweetness stays balanced and not too rich.

Large multi-layer Baby Shark themed cakes come out detailed and well-matched to design requests. Non-dairy options taste good and avoid dryness common elsewhere.

People are saying

"The cakes at this bakery are delicious and beautifully made."

"The vegan cakes here are moist, fresh, and amazing."

"This birthday cake was perfectly balanced and tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

Julius Bakery stays open late, often until 8:30 pm.

2

Most items cost less than $4, making it very cost-effective.

3

Desserts are priced between $10 and $20 for 5 to 6 items.

02
GoodieBox Bakeshop image 1

Bright, clean space with beautifully decorated baked goods creates a charming atmosphere. Energy feels welcoming and consistent, attracting those seeking moist, flavorful cakes and cupcakes with fresh, real-ingredient frosting. Variety includes gluten-free options and specialty cakes, making it a reliable spot for sweet treats.

Mini cheesecakes and gluten-free cheesecakes stand out here. The cheesecake overall is phenomenal and pairs well with other sweets like cupcakes and brookies.

Birthday cakes come with custom designs and great taste. Communication happens easily over email with Carrie to finalize details.

People are saying

"This cake is so good, I'd eat it off the ground!"

"Their cheesecake was phenomenal; I enjoyed it."

"Carrie's birthday cakes look pretty and taste amazingly good."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of cupcakes, cookies, cakes, brownies, and rice krispie treats.

2

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

Full-size cakes can be ordered online for special occasions.

03
La Bon Bake Shoppes image 1

Bakery offers amazing cakes and phenomenal cheesecakes with beautiful designs and moist textures. Atmosphere feels delightful and the place stays clean and well run. Prices tend to be high but reflect quality, with a small selection at some locations.

Red velvet cheesecake stands out with a rich, smooth texture. Cherry cheesecake also offers a distinct, flavorful option among the amazing cheesecakes available.

Custom birthday cakes come with consistent quality and satisfaction. Long-term orders show reliability for special occasions like a 60th birthday.

People are saying

"The cakes here are always fresh and taste delicious."

"You have to try the chocolate covered strawberries; they were a massive hit."

"I found the red velvet cheesecake to be phenomenal."

Good to know

1

The online ordering and pickup process is easy and efficient.

2

Weekly and monthly specials are available at affordable prices.

3

Gluten-friendly options are offered for those with dietary restrictions.

04
Blue Dolfin Sweets image 1

Small bakery offers European-style pastries with fresh organic ingredients and no artificial colors. Atmosphere feels like a hidden gem with a focus on craftsmanship and detailed presentation. Customers find the cakes and scones especially notable for their balanced sweetness and quality.

Cheesecake here stands out for its excellent texture and rich flavor, especially the raspberry cheesecake. It often ranks higher than cheesecakes from other well-known places.

Cakes come out with beautiful designs and match exactly what you order. The flavor is consistently delicious and keeps people coming back for more.

People are saying

"This bakery's lemon cake and pastries are the best I've ever tasted."

"I gasped when I saw the gorgeous birthday cake."

"I found the cheesecake here to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Blue Dolfin Sweets is open year-round, six days a week.

2

Prices at Blue Dolfin Sweets are reasonable.

3

They have many different choices of fresh organic baked goods.

05
Vanilla Bakery & Cafe image 1

Bright, spacious bakery with modern decor and airy seating creates a clean, inviting atmosphere. Pastries and Turkish breakfast stand out as popular choices, drawing a steady flow of visitors. The environment balances chic design with a relaxed vibe.

Fresh cheesecake stands out with its incredible texture and flavor. Desserts include Fruit cheesecake alongside other sweets like Tiramisu and Tres leches.

Birthday cakes come with extra care and attention. Orders for kids' birthdays happen often, showing a focus on customized cakes.

People are saying

"Their desserts are delicious and beautifully presented."

"The cheesecake here is amazing, thanks to the staff's welcoming smile."

"The Birthday Cake here is beautiful and tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery is open 24 hours, allowing you to stop by anytime.

2

Everything at Vanilla Bakery & Cafe is freshly made.

3

Having parking available is a huge plus.

06
Red Rose Bakery image 1

Refrigerated cases display wide pastry selection including specialty cakes made to order with detailed designs. Atmosphere feels family-owned and welcoming, with many customers asking about cake origins. Pricing is generally fair with large portions, and ordering process is quick and easy.

Cheesecake comes out ready on request and tastes absolutely amazing. It pairs well with rum balls and suits special occasions like birthdays and holidays.

Chocolate and themed birthday cakes come with detailed designs like Winnie the Pooh. Cakes taste delicious and look amazing. Last-minute orders are accepted and fulfilled.

People are saying

"Their cookies and cupcakes always hit the mark."

"The cake looked stunning, just like the picture."

"This birthday cake looked amazing and tasted delicious."

Good to know

1

The process of ordering the cake is super easy and quick.

2

They have many cake options available.

3

The establishment is clean and easy to find.

07
Dโ€™era House image 1

Cozy bakery with a warm, inviting atmosphere and attention to detail in every corner. Quiet and relaxing vibe suits study or casual breaks. Known for fresh, light desserts and a homey feeling that blends comfort with a touch of luxury.

Cheesecake here is creamy and perfectly balanced, with a texture that literally melts in your mouth. It stands out as a top choice for anyone seeking rich, smooth cheesecake.

Custom birthday cakes include options like the Lotus Biscoff cake. Cakes come from a bakery known for fresh baked goods and amazing cheesecakes. This spot serves as a reliable choice for birthday celebrations.

People are saying

"The desserts here melt in your mouth and are made from scratch."

"This cheesecake literally melts in your mouth."

"Their creamy cheesecake melts in your mouth; it's unbelievable."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special desserts or cakes.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted for purchases.

3

Everything is made from scratch using real ingredients.

08
J & M Bakery image 1

Strong aroma fills the space, creating a pleasant atmosphere. Displays showcase an endless selection of desserts and pastries, including traditional Italian recipes and custom cakes. Guests often praise the fresh cookies and lobster tails for their quality and flavor.

Creamy texture and a crumb topping with balanced sweetness stand out. Cheesecake avoids dryness and pasty or overly sweet flavors common elsewhere.

Customized birthday cakes stand out here with detailed designs. Cakes consistently receive praise for being amazing and satisfying for special occasions.

People are saying

"This cake is moist, fresh, and tasted amazing."

"This birthday cake was amazing and so moist."

"I finally found the ultimate cheesecake after searching outside my area."

Good to know

1

Prices are reasonable considering the quality of the baked goods.

2

J&M Bakery offers a wide variety of handmade baked goods.

3

Credit card payments are accepted, but check for any additional fees.

09
Supreme Bakery image 1

Old style bakery with beautiful decorations and a pleasant atmosphere. Known for fresh, delicious cakes and consistent quality. Offers special occasion cakes with designs matching submitted photos.

Cheesecake here features a strawberry topping that many find scrumptious. Some consider it exceptional, while others find it just okay compared to other options.

Birthday cakes come with custom designs like flamingos and double hearts. Cakes taste scrumptious and arrive on time, even for same-day orders.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and flavorful."

"This birthday cake was beautifully made and tasted amazing."

"Their cheesecake topped with strawberries is my go-to."

Good to know

1

Supreme Bakery offers sugar-free cupcakes and cakes with a quick turnaround.

2

Online ordering at Supreme Bakery is easy and accurate.

3

Cakes can be customized for special occasions with advance notice.

10
La Dolce Bakery image 1

Bakery offers reasonably priced pastries and cakes with beautiful decoration and fresh, moist textures. Atmosphere feels cute and welcoming, with a variety of customized cakes that often become the highlight of celebrations.

New York cheesecake stands out with pure perfection in every bite, making it a favorite treat worth a 40-minute drive. The Italian cheesecake and pastries exist but lack freshness and flavor.

Birthday cakes come out delicious and beautifully decorated. They handle special occasions like a 91st birthday with care and quality.

People are saying

"This cake is delicious, moist, and beautifully decorated."

"The birthday cake here is delicious and beautifully decorated."

"This cheesecake is pure perfection, truly amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery charges a surcharge for using bank cards.

2

Prices for cookies are not displayed by weight.

3

The bakery can fulfill last-minute orders.

11
Calandra's Bakery image 1

Ample space with clean, well-lit interiors and an inviting aroma of fresh breads and pastries sets a lively atmosphere. A strong crew maintains order despite busy times, while displays showcase a sheer variety of baked goods including standout breads and cheesecakes.

Mini cheesecakes have a balanced taste, not too sweet or eggy, with a perfect texture. The cheesecakes are finger-licking good and come in small sizes alongside other desserts.

Fresh and delicious birthday cakes come from here, with orders placed well in advance. Staff greet you immediately when picking up cakes for all kinds of celebrations.

People are saying

"I thought their cakes were the best I've ever had."

"I thought the cheesecakes were delicious and creamy."

"I usually ordered birthday cakes from here; they always tasted very good."

Good to know

1

Calandra's Bakery offers a wide variety of fresh baked goods daily.

2

You can order custom cakes a day in advance for pickup.

3

Expect long lines on Saturdays, especially during peak hours.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...