Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New Jersey

Cookie and chocolate cake

A bakery that masters both the cookie and the chocolate cake instead of doing one well and the other as an afterthought.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bakehouse by Joe Murphy (New Providence) image 1
Bakehouse by Joe Murphy (New Providence) image 2
Bakehouse by Joe Murphy (New Providence) image 3
View all

Clean, easy-to-navigate bakery with a nice atmosphere for eating in. Offers exceptional cakes and cookies known for their moist, decadent layers and rich flavors. Regulars praise blackout cake, chocolate mousse cake, and oatmeal cookies as standout treats.

Cookies come in large sizes with a chewy center and crispy edges. The double chocolate cookie offers a grown-up chocolate flavor that is not overly sweet but satisfying.

Chocolate cake stands out with its moist texture and decadent layers of thicker chocolate pudding. Topped with chocolate crumbles, it offers a rich, flavorful experience and a good size for the price.

People are saying

"The cakes from this bakery are beyond delicious and made to perfection."

"I thought the chocolate cake was the best I ever tasted."

"I would fight someone for another bite of this chocolate cake."

Good to know

1

Bakehouse offers a wide variety of pastries and cakes for all occasions.

2

Prices for cakes are reasonable considering their size and quality.

3

The bakery provides custom cakes for special events with advance notice.

02
Cleopatra Sweets image 1

Bakery offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere with Egyptian-style decor and fresh-baked aromas filling the space. Friendly staff create a family-run vibe that invites guests to enjoy authentic Middle Eastern pastries. Clean, comfortable seating complements the high-quality, carefully crafted desserts.

Cookies use 100% real butter, giving a rich, noticeable flavor. Varieties like black and white and pistachio raspberry chocolate stand out for freshness and taste.

Smooth and rich texture defines the chocolate cake, offering a balanced flavor that is not overwhelming. It suits celebrations well with its consistent quality and creamy finish.

People are saying

"I found the homemade desserts to be unbelievable and fantastic."

"These bakery cookies are amazing and delicious."

"The Chocolate Cake is moist, rich, and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery opens at 6:30 am and closes at 8 pm every day except Sunday.

2

There is plenty of street parking and a large parking lot available.

3

Prices at Cleopatra Sweets are fair for a bakery, though some items may be pricey.

03
Paulanto Bakery image 1

Classic bakery with freshly baked bread aroma and custom-designed cakes that impress with exceptional quality and artwork. Atmosphere feels welcoming despite some dusty decorations and sun-exposed displays. Known for consistent excellence in cakes and a variety of options including vegan choices.

Soft texture and fresh taste define the cookies here. Decorated sugar cookies and rainbow cookies stand out with their moist, thin cuts and rich chocolate layers that melt in your mouth.

People are saying

"This bakery makes beautiful custom cakes that taste amazing."

"The decorated sugar cookies were a hit at our last event."

"This chocolate cake was exactly what I envisioned, delicious and beautiful."

Good to know

1

They provide custom-designed cakes for special occasions.

2

The bakery offers a variety of fasting cake options.

3

Prices at Paulanto Bakery are considered very good.

04
Verity Chocolate image 1
Chocolate cafe

Chocolate cafe offers a calm atmosphere with a gorgeous, clean space filled with a welcoming chocolate aroma. It serves homemade, nut-free chocolates and treats, including unique cookies and drinks made on site from bean to bar.

Double chocolate and chocolate chip cookies stand out with intense flavor and perfect texture. A touch of flaky salt on top adds a rich, decadent finish.

Dark chocolate cake stands out with rich flavor and moist texture. The chocolate cake dessert pairs well with other chocolate items like bars and bon-bons.

People are saying

"The owner makes excellent chocolate and clearly loves her craft."

"I found the cookies here to be the best I've ever eaten."

"The owner here is so sweet and lovely."

Good to know

1

The shop is 100% peanut and tree-nut free, making it safe for those with nut allergies.

2

All chocolates are made in-house by the owner.

3

Cookies are baked daily, ensuring fresh offerings.

05
AwesomeYoโ€™s Kitchen image 1

Small cake shop with a cozy, vibrant atmosphere and a friendly, welcoming vibe. Space feels like a home kitchen filled with the smell of baked goods and decorated with gold accents on desserts. Popular for custom cakes and delicious pastries enjoyed by families and locals alike.

Rainbow cookies stand out for parties and gatherings, drawing lots of attention. Nastar pineapple cookie offers a unique, delicious flavor alongside freshly baked options for coffee breaks.

Rich and indulgent, the chocolate cake stands out for its moist texture and fantastic flavor. The chocolate cake pop shares the same delicious quality and is a popular choice alongside other desserts.

People are saying

"Their custom cakes are delicious and beautifully decorated."

"These cookies are ginormous, delicious, and a must-try."

"This chocolate cake is so rich and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for custom cake orders, especially for events.

2

The average cost of a custom cake is around $270.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

06
Calandra's Italian & French Bakery image 1

Classic Italian bakery atmosphere fills the space with the smell of fresh baked bread and beautiful, elegant decor. Cozy seating is limited, encouraging takeout of a wide selection of authentic baked goods. Cakes stand out as delicious and visually stunning centerpieces that draw consistent praise.

Italian cookies stand out with Pinole cookies leading the pack. Rainbow sprinkle cookies with chocolate centers and cookies topped with sprinkles add variety and color.

Dark and moist chocolate cake stands out with dulce de leche filling and layers paired with whipped cream or custard. Fresh strawberries and Italian custard add variety to the rich chocolate flavors.

People are saying

"The cakes here are always beautiful and delicious."

"I thought the cookies here were the best I tried."

"This chocolate cake is beyond amazing and moist."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-price appetizers from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

Dinner and a show events are regularly scheduled, providing entertainment with meals.

3

Reservations are recommended for special events to secure a spot.

07
J & M Bakery image 1

Strong aroma fills the space, creating a pleasant atmosphere. Displays showcase an endless selection of desserts and pastries, including traditional Italian recipes and custom cakes. Guests often praise the fresh cookies and lobster tails for their quality and flavor.

Cookies here stay fresh and avoid heavy sweetness or processing. The Pignoli cookie stands out for quality and price, alongside seeded twist and rainbow cookies that impress.

Chocolate cakes come with chocolate fudge icing and often include raspberry filling. The flavor matches a double chocolate cake profile, though quality varies across types like the 7 layer chocolate cake.

People are saying

"This cake is moist, fresh, and tasted amazing."

"I considered this bakery the very best I've ever had."

"I got the chocolate cake for my mom's birthday and it was perfect."

Good to know

1

Prices are reasonable considering the quality of the baked goods.

2

J&M Bakery offers a wide variety of handmade baked goods.

3

Credit card payments are accepted, but check for any additional fees.

08
Supreme Bakery image 1

Old style bakery with beautiful decorations and a pleasant atmosphere. Known for fresh, delicious cakes and consistent quality. Offers special occasion cakes with designs matching submitted photos.

Lace cookies stand out as a magnificent and delicious option here. The variety includes chocolate chip and other cookies, all consistently good and often paired with cakes and cupcakes.

Chocolate cakes feature cannoli cream filling and buttercream frosting. The German chocolate cake stands out for its rich flavor. Birthday cakes often come with inscriptions.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and flavorful."

"I was addicted to their magnificent lace cookies."

"I've never had a German chocolate cake this amazing."

Good to know

1

Supreme Bakery offers sugar-free cupcakes and cakes with a quick turnaround.

2

Online ordering at Supreme Bakery is easy and accurate.

3

Cakes can be customized for special occasions with advance notice.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...