Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New Jersey

Cookie and cupcake spots

Made for those who refuse to settle for just one type of dessert and want a curated selection of cookies and cupcakes.

Based on 874 Opinions
+871
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Despina's Cream Bakery image 1
Despina's Cream Bakery image 2
Despina's Cream Bakery image 3
View all

Bakery offers spectacular cakes and pastries with creamy cheesecakes and unique flavor twists like Brazilian-style carrot cake. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, attracting people who appreciate beautifully designed and delicious desserts. Open for retail sales on weekends and wholesales to restaurants during the week.

Cookies and cream cookies stand out with their recent addition. Recipes keep it simple with no more than 80 ingredients, making the cookies and brownies easy to enjoy.

Cupcakes come out fresh and moist with strong, flavorful taste. Varieties like chocolate Oreo and blondie stand out for their rich flavors. They stay tasty even the next morning.

People are saying

"The treats and cakes at this bakery are delicious and beautiful."

"I found the cookies here to be top tier."

"The cupcakes here are so delicious and flavorful."

Good to know

1

They are open for retail sales on weekends only.

2

They wholesale to many restaurants and other places during the week.

3

No order was too small or too large for Despina.

02
The Modern Cakery image 1

Cozy shop with a clean, minimalistic design fills the air with freshly baked aromas. Light, moist cakes and treats offer high-quality ingredients and beautiful presentation. Regulars appreciate custom cakes suited for special occasions and dietary needs.

Cookies stay soft and fresh like they just came out of the oven. The chocolate chip cookies stand out as especially good, often described as perfect and amazing alongside other treats like cake pops.

Cupcakes have a good balance of sweetness and flavor. They come in customized designs for events like birthdays and engagements. The cupcakes are consistently delicious and well-made.

People are saying

"The cake here is so delicious and beautifully done."

"These custom cookies were exactly what I envisioned and turned out wonderfully."

"These cupcakes are genuinely delicious and beautifully made."

Good to know

1

The bakery is closed on Sundays, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Online ordering is straightforward and user-friendly.

3

They offer gluten and nut-free options for those with allergies.

03
Cakewalk @Candyland Crafts image 1
Baking supply store

Bright space filled with wide selection of molds, chocolates, and baking supplies. Warm, encouraging atmosphere supports fun, instructional classes for all skill levels. Known for top-quality chocolates and staying current with baking trends.

Classes focus on cookie decorating techniques like flooding and seasonal themes. Finished cookies look great and taste good.

Craft classes focus on cupcake decorating with hands-on instruction. Participants leave feeling inspired and proud of their decorated cupcakes.

People are saying

"I learned so many cookie decorating techniques in the class."

"The classes here are so much fun for kids."

"Michelle made sure everyone felt comfortable trying new techniques."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for classes, especially during peak seasons.

2

Classes cater to all skill levels, from beginner to expert.

3

Expect a variety of supplies, including molds, chocolates, and baking tools.

04
La Bon Bake Shoppes image 1

Bakery showcases colorful donuts with beautiful icing and sprinkles in a cute, welcoming space. Atmosphere stays calm with few customers, while staff provide friendly service. Known for fresh, buttery pastries and high-quality cakes that match detailed designs.

Rainbow Italian cookies stand out as a signature treat here. Cookies come with rich flavors and pair well with other baked goods like cheese strudel.

Cupcakes come in a variety of flavors like red velvet, carrot cake, and chocolate with strawberry filling. They are generally moist and delicious, with some freshness varying by flavor.

People are saying

"This king cake is so authentic, it reminded me of New Orleans."

"I thought the cookies here were the best I ever had."

"These cupcakes are so moist and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery accepts cash only; no ATM is available on-site.

2

Alternative payment methods like Cash App or Venmo are not accepted.

3

Quality of baked goods consistently exceeds expectations.

05
Turquoise Bakery & Cafe image 1

Bright, clean space with modern decor and plenty of windows creates an inviting atmosphere. Energy stays calm and serene, though seating can feel a bit cold and less cozy. Crowd tends to be steady, drawn by homemade baked goods and healthy lunch options.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a classy and delicious flavor. Variety includes key lime cookies, lemon almond cookies, and homemade treats like baklava and vanilla cupcakes with piped roses.

Cupcakes come out rich and moist with bursting flavor. They look adorable, often decorated with piped roses.

People are saying

"The banana bread latte was the best I ever tasted."

"The chocolate chip cookie here is classy and delicious."

"I found the baklava to be the best I've had in a long time."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

2

Parking can be busy, so plan to arrive early.

3

The bakery items are made fresh in-house daily.

06
Jessica Sweets LLC image 1

Custom cakes showcase impeccable craftsmanship and use finest ingredients, combining beautiful design with delicious flavors. The space supports lively events where kids engage with a photo booth and games, creating a fun atmosphere. Personalized requests and creative ideas shape unique desserts that impress guests visually and tastefully.

Cookies come out stunning and delicious with beautiful designs. They suit all ages and pair well with other treats like cupcakes and cake pops.

Cupcakes come with custom designs like gender colors and edible photos. Kids enjoy decorating their own cupcakes. They taste as good as they look, with delicious flavors and beautiful presentation.

People are saying

"The cake was stunning, visually impressive, and exactly what I pictured."

"These custom cupcakes were the highlight of the party!"

"The cookies here are stunning and delicious."

Good to know

1

Booking is recommended well in advance due to high demand.

2

Parking can be challenging; plan to arrive early to find a spot.

3

Jessica Sweets accommodates custom requests for cakes, including unique flavors and designs.

07
AwesomeYo’s Kitchen image 1

Small cake shop with a cozy, vibrant atmosphere and a friendly, welcoming vibe. Space feels like a home kitchen filled with the smell of baked goods and decorated with gold accents on desserts. Popular for custom cakes and delicious pastries enjoyed by families and locals alike.

Rainbow cookies stand out for parties and gatherings, drawing lots of attention. Nastar pineapple cookie offers a unique, delicious flavor alongside freshly baked options for coffee breaks.

Ube and red velvet cupcakes stand out for their flavor and presentation. Staff accommodate last-minute requests and create matching cupcake designs for special occasions.

People are saying

"Their custom cakes are delicious and beautifully decorated."

"These cookies are ginormous, delicious, and a must-try."

"These cupcakes are so beautiful and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for custom cake orders, especially for events.

2

The average cost of a custom cake is around $270.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

08
We Knead the Dough image 1

Warm and inviting bakery known for custom cakes that serve as showstoppers at celebrations. Cakes and cupcakes consistently receive praise for being beautiful and delicious, with options including vegan pastries. The atmosphere supports special occasions with a focus on detailed decoration and taste.

Beautiful decorations and great attention to detail stand out on cookies like wedding dress and teacup shapes. The cookies and cream filling adds a special touch to the variety of cookies offered.

Cupcakes come out stunningly beautiful and uniquely decorated with themes like forests, trolls, and superheroes. They taste delicious and arrive in pristine condition, often prompting guests to ask for more.

People are saying

"This cake is so moist and delicious, I've never had better."

"The vegan cakes and pastries here are delicious and beautiful."

"The cupcakes here are so delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers delivery, so transportation is not a concern.

2

The cake order process is straightforward and user-friendly.

3

The desserts are fairly priced compared to other bakeries.

09
Chic Sugars image 1
Cake shop

Cake shop offers custom designs with beautiful, detailed decorations and delicious flavors that impress at special occasions. The atmosphere is cute and visually appealing, creating a smooth and satisfying experience for ordering and delivery.

Cookies come out fresh and delicious with beautiful decorations. Customized orders match expectations and taste great.

Cupcakes arrive moist and not too sweet, with custom designs like little books and photo prints. Delivery is reliable, keeping cupcakes in great shape and on time.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful works of art."

"The cookies here are perfectly tasty and beautifully decorated."

"The custom cupcakes here are amazing and perfect."

Good to know

1

Custom cake orders require at least 48 hours notice.

2

Delivery is punctual and within the specified time window.

3

Pricing is fair for the quality of cakes and cupcakes offered.

10
Natale's Summit Bakery image 1

Small bakery with original decor and an old school atmosphere offers a variety of fresh pastries and breads. The space feels cozy and welcoming, often busy with limited parking. Cakes and donuts stand out for quality and flavor.

Italian cookies come in a wonderful variety here, including butter cookies that people pick up regularly. The bakery also offers personalized cookies, adding a nostalgic touch.

Cupcakes offer a perfect blend of flavors and come fresh and delicious. Staff spend extra time helping with cake and cupcake concepts, making the desserts consistently great.

People are saying

"Their birthday cakes are delicious and beautifully decorated."

"The cupcakes here are a perfect blend of flavors."

"I've been getting my family's birthday cakes here for decades."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at least 48 hours in advance for custom cakes.

2

Parking is limited, especially on busy days like Mother's Day and Thanksgiving.

3

Expect a line during peak hours, particularly on weekends.

11
One The Cake image 1
Cake shop

Cozy shop offers unique custom cakes with phenomenal attention to detail and reasonable prices. Cakes feature fresh ingredients and balanced sweetness, creating a memorable experience for celebrations. Display cases showcase beautiful cupcakes and specialty items like bingsu and madeleines.

Icing cookies come in decorative shapes like flowers and complement cakes well. These cookies have a reputation for deliciousness among those who receive them as gifts.

Cupcakes feature buttercream frosting that looks beautiful and tastes light and airy. Designs include edible printed images like dinosaurs, and prices range from $6 to $10 depending on the design.

People are saying

"Ms. Yu Won's creativity made the cake a highlight."

"These flower cookies were a great addition to the cake decor."

"These cupcakes are beautiful and super delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for custom cake orders to ensure availability.

2

Cupcakes range from $6 to $10 depending on the design.

3

Custom cakes require advance notice; calling ahead is advised.

12
Kiersten's Creations image 1

Bakery offers gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan options with a focus on high-quality desserts. Atmosphere feels welcoming and accommodating, especially for dietary restrictions. Food truck service adds a casual, festive energy to events.

Oatmeal cookies stand out as a favorite, praised for their quality. The selection includes gluten-free cookies and sugar cookies, often paired with ice cream sandwiches from a cute ice cream cart.

Freshness stands out with cupcakes that taste good and stay moist. Flavors like red velvet and cinnamon bun get positive mentions, while a plain vanilla cupcake lacks interest.

People are saying

"Their cakes are delicious and beautifully designed."

"These cookies are so delicious and taste fresh out of the oven."

"These cupcakes are delicious, fresh, and a hit with guests."

Good to know

1

Kiersten's Creations offers gluten-free and vegan options for various dietary needs.

2

Desserts are reasonably priced, providing good value for the quality.

3

The bakery frequently sells out on weekends, so plan your visit accordingly.

13
GoodieBox Bakeshop image 1

Bright, clean space with beautifully decorated baked goods creates a charming atmosphere. Energy feels welcoming and consistent, attracting those seeking moist, flavorful cakes and cupcakes with fresh, real-ingredient frosting. Variety includes gluten-free options and specialty cakes, making it a reliable spot for sweet treats.

Cookies stay crispy on the edges and chewy in the middle even when not warmed. The Gingersnap and chocolate chip cookies stand out for their flavor and texture.

Cupcakes come out moist with a balanced icing that complements the flavor well. The strawberry champagne variety stands out as a classic and delicious choice.

People are saying

"This cake is so good, I'd eat it off the ground!"

"These cookies are moist, flavorful, and perfectly executed."

"These cupcakes are so moist and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a variety of cupcakes, cookies, cakes, brownies, and rice krispie treats.

2

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

Full-size cakes can be ordered online for special occasions.

14
Tinton Falls Pastry Chef image 1

Bakery offers homemade-style baked goods with fresh bread and pastries visible during afternoon hours. Atmosphere feels family-friendly with a focus on party-sized desserts and competitive pricing. Cakes and cookies stand out for their buttercream icing and variety of small desserts suitable for events.

Cookies have a fresh, homemade taste and come in varieties like pignoli and sprinkle that pair well with coffee. They work well for cookie platters at work events and stand out among other baked goods.

Cupcakes come out fresh and fluffy with a perfect texture. They disappear quickly, showing how well they are received.

People are saying

"The bakery's baked goods are always fresh and delicious."

"The wedding cake was beautifully done and absolutely delicious."

"These cookies taste so fresh and homemade."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide variety of cakes, cookies, and pastries.

2

Prices are competitive, with many items reasonably priced.

3

The bakery does not have sit-down service; it's takeout only.

15
Double Batch Bakery | Walk-Up Window • Online Bakery image 1

Walk-up window bakery with rotating menu offers fresh, scratch-made pastries and seasonal desserts. Atmosphere feels welcoming and lively, with curbside pickup and online ordering adding convenience. Family-run operation delivers high-quality baked goods that stand out in the neighborhood.

Napoleon cookie stands out with perfect texture and flavor, often described as a must-try. Freshly baked vegan cookies and a toffee and butter cookie also deliver rich taste and great texture.

Cupcakes here taste fresh and super moist, including vegan options that don't reveal they're plant-based. Varieties like carrot cake, lemon pistachio, and guava cream-cheese offer unique flavors enjoyed by many.

People are saying

"I found everything from this bakery to be so delicious and homemade."

"This cookie is divine, with perfect texture and flavor."

"I've never tasted such delicious, fresh cupcakes in my life."

Good to know

1

You need to order in advance for takeout and delivery.

2

The bakery releases a new menu each night, so order quickly to avoid missing out.

3

Most menu items can be ready within 5 minutes for last-minute needs.

16
Paulanto Bakery image 1

Classic bakery with freshly baked bread aroma and custom-designed cakes that impress with exceptional quality and artwork. Atmosphere feels welcoming despite some dusty decorations and sun-exposed displays. Known for consistent excellence in cakes and a variety of options including vegan choices.

Soft texture and fresh taste define the cookies here. Decorated sugar cookies and rainbow cookies stand out with their moist, thin cuts and rich chocolate layers that melt in your mouth.

Vegan cupcakes come in chocolate with whipped cream, cookies and cream, and vanilla filled with strawberries and whipped cream. They taste fresh, delicious, and cost less than many other options.

People are saying

"This bakery makes beautiful custom cakes that taste amazing."

"The decorated sugar cookies were a hit at our last event."

"I loved their delicious and fresh cupcakes."

Good to know

1

They provide custom-designed cakes for special occasions.

2

The bakery offers a variety of fasting cake options.

3

Prices at Paulanto Bakery are considered very good.

17
Sweet Roots Cakery image 1

Cake shop offers custom-designed cakes and themed cookies with precise attention to detail. Atmosphere feels personal and creative, reflecting unique ideas brought to life. Customers enjoy moist textures and balanced sweetness that often surpass appearance.

Cookies come in cute, themed designs that match party ideas perfectly. They taste delicious and look super adorable for birthdays and showers.

Red velvet and chocolate cupcakes come with rich, flavorful taste. Designs like Hello Kitty and bear shapes show detailed, creative baking.

People are saying

"Alicia made my cake so beautiful, exceeding my expectations."

"These cookies are super adorable and came out perfectly matching my theme."

"Alicia made adorable bear cupcakes with love and attention to detail."

Good to know

1

Payment and pick-up process is transparent and very easy.

2

Alicia knows the appropriate cake size based on the number of guests provided.

3

The price is right on par for what I expected to pay.

18
Giancarlo's Bakery image 1

Old school Italian bakery with crowded interior and outdoor seating offers a variety of baked breads, meat pastries, and entrees. Atmosphere feels nostalgic and no-nonsense, attracting those seeking authentic Italian flavors. The place is known for top-quality pastries and cakes with a neighborhood vibe.

Cookies by the pound stand out for their quality and variety. Butter cookies and other pastries consistently deliver excellent flavor and freshness.

Halloween cupcakes come in larger sizes with icing that stays firmly on. Gender reveal cupcakes are moist and can be ready within half an hour, though some cupcakes have icing that may not hold well.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be delicious and beautifully done."

"I found their cookies to be amazing and delicious."

"They made same-day gender reveal cupcakes with kindness and care."

Good to know

1

Giancarlo's Bakery offers a variety of baked goods, including cakes, pies, and pastries.

2

Most items are baked in-house, ensuring freshness and quality.

3

The bakery has a deli section with sandwiches, wraps, and breakfast options.

19
Pinho's Bakery image 1

Bakery offers a large covered patio and a few indoor tables with sunlit glass roof creating a calming atmosphere. Shelves display fresh-made breads and a wide variety of confectionery and desserts. The vibe feels like a warm, community-focused family joint with a sense of culture and comfort.

Italian leaf cookies and custom cookies for weddings, birthdays, and graduations stand out here. Sugar-free options and a large variety of beautiful, personalized cookies also fill the display.

Cupcakes come in simple buttercream and Oreo flavors with custom decorative options. Some orders arrive fresh, but pre-made cupcakes are not always available and presentation can vary from expectations.

People are saying

"I found this bakery to be the best I could go to."

"The peanut butter cookies here are huge and so good."

"I ordered amazing birthday cupcakes for a party."

Good to know

1

They make fresh egg tarts every hour, perfect for a quick treat.

2

Complimentary parking is available, but it is limited.

3

Pinho's Bakery offers a wide selection of baked goods, including pastries and sandwiches.

20
Red Rose Bakery image 1

Refrigerated cases display wide pastry selection including specialty cakes made to order with detailed designs. Atmosphere feels family-owned and welcoming, with many customers asking about cake origins. Pricing is generally fair with large portions, and ordering process is quick and easy.

Classic Italian rainbow cookies stand out with vibrant layers and fresh taste. Cookies come fresh daily and include unique options like Manicotti cookies alongside consistently good flavors.

Fresh daily batches of cupcakes and cookies always hit the mark. Assortments include bite-sized cakes alongside the cupcakes, all consistently delicious.

People are saying

"Their cookies and cupcakes always hit the mark."

"The cake looked stunning, just like the picture."

"I loved their delicious cupcakes and bakery goods."

Good to know

1

The process of ordering the cake is super easy and quick.

2

They have many cake options available.

3

The establishment is clean and easy to find.

21
Julius Bakery image 1

Small space fills with fresh bakery aroma and clean, airy atmosphere. Jazz music plays softly, creating a welcoming vibe. Open displays showcase high-quality pastries and cakes that attract a steady flow of dessert lovers.

Cookies come out fresh and soft, especially the Macadamia white chocolate variety. Butter cookies offer great flavor and value, with raspberry-filled options adding variety.

Cupcakes come with dry texture and icing that tastes worse than typical store-bought versions. They lack a homemade feel and seem similar to mass-produced options.

People are saying

"The cakes at this bakery are delicious and beautifully made."

"The butter cookies were superb and well priced."

"I loved the fresh and delicious cupcakes."

Good to know

1

Julius Bakery stays open late, often until 8:30 pm.

2

Most items cost less than $4, making it very cost-effective.

3

Desserts are priced between $10 and $20 for 5 to 6 items.

22
Simona's Bakery image 1

Small, family-owned bakery with aromatic butter and sugar scent fills the air. Displays feature tempting, beautifully arranged pastries and cakes with moist cupcakes and custom decorated cakes that impress at celebrations. Atmosphere feels cute yet unwelcoming, with some items like cinnamon buns rarely available.

Endless trays of Italian cookies come out perfect every time. The rainbow cookies stand out, alongside a great assortment of biscotti and pastries.

Mini cupcakes come with 1-2 fillings inside, which is unique. They stay moist and fresh even after two days and look like beautiful creations.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are the most beautiful creations I've ever seen."

"These cookies are tender, flavorful, and truly excellent."

"They had an amazing assortment of bread and pastries."

Good to know

1

The bakery is open until 8pm on Saturdays.

2

Cinnamon buns must be special ordered as they are rarely available.

3

Prices are higher than some other bakeries but comparable to similar establishments.

23
L'Affaire II Bake Shoppe image 1

Small bakery offers wide variety of freshly baked cakes and pastries with exceptional attention to detail. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, drawing people who appreciate custom cakes and classic breads like rye and challah.

Butter cookies and black and white cookies stand out for their freshness and flavor. A wide variety includes filled cookies with jam, fudge, or buttercream, along with fig cookies, almond crescents, and linzer tarts.

Cupcakes come with beautiful decorating and a heavenly taste. Orders can include half dozens, and kids tend to love them, though sometimes the order may be incorrect.

People are saying

"The cake here is so tasty and beautifully decorated."

"The staff here is so friendly and welcoming."

"The cupcakes here are heavenly and the kids loved them."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide variety of baked goods, including rye bread, challah, donuts, and cakes.

2

Reservations are recommended for custom cakes, especially around holidays.

3

The shop is takeout only and does not have sit-down tables.

24
Cake Artist Cafe image 1

Bakery offers a chic, adorable interior with available seating for quick bites or coffee breaks. Atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxing, attracting people for custom-made cakes and beautifully crafted desserts. Cake pops and decorated cookies stand out as delicious and visually appealing treats.

Decorated cookies come with beautiful designs and personalized themes like Teddy bears. They taste delicious and work well as place cards or party treats.

Custom cupcake cakes come in detailed themes like car/truck and penguin designs. Cupcakes offer many unique flavors such as strawberry shortcake, though some can be dry.

People are saying

"The custom cakes here are beautiful and delicious."

"The decorated cookies here are beautiful and delicious."

"I got a gorgeous masterpiece cupcake cake that tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking can be found all around the shop and is easily accessible.

2

The price is very affordable for desserts.

3

The pickup process for orders is easy and efficient.

25
Supreme Bakery image 1

Old style bakery with beautiful decorations and a pleasant atmosphere. Known for fresh, delicious cakes and consistent quality. Offers special occasion cakes with designs matching submitted photos.

Lace cookies stand out as a magnificent and delicious option here. The variety includes chocolate chip and other cookies, all consistently good and often paired with cakes and cupcakes.

Cupcakes come in custom designs like characters from Trolls and match specific themes for birthdays. Options include sugar-free varieties and flavors like red velvet, all fresh and moist.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and flavorful."

"These cupcakes are so delicious, I loved the moistness."

"I was addicted to their magnificent lace cookies."

Good to know

1

Supreme Bakery offers sugar-free cupcakes and cakes with a quick turnaround.

2

Online ordering at Supreme Bakery is easy and accurate.

3

Cakes can be customized for special occasions with advance notice.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...