Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Cookie bakeries in New Jersey

A bakery that prioritizes a proper cookie as much as their signature loaves and tarts.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bakehouse by Joe Murphy (New Providence) image 1
Bakehouse by Joe Murphy (New Providence) image 2
Bakehouse by Joe Murphy (New Providence) image 3
View all

Clean, easy-to-navigate bakery with a nice atmosphere for eating in. Offers exceptional cakes and cookies known for their moist, decadent layers and rich flavors. Regulars praise blackout cake, chocolate mousse cake, and oatmeal cookies as standout treats.

Cookies come in large sizes with a chewy center and crispy edges. The double chocolate cookie offers a grown-up chocolate flavor that is not overly sweet but satisfying.

Offers excellent bakery items with a reputation for quality that stands out in the area. Known for consistently delivering incredible baked goods that make it a must-visit bakery.

People are saying

"The cakes from this bakery are beyond delicious and made to perfection."

"I found the pastries here to be light, tasty, and not overly sweet."

"I would fight someone for another bite of this chocolate cake."

Good to know

1

Bakehouse offers a wide variety of pastries and cakes for all occasions.

2

Prices for cakes are reasonable considering their size and quality.

3

The bakery provides custom cakes for special events with advance notice.

02
Pabade Bakery NJ image 1

Small bakery with open kitchen and outdoor seating on a quiet street creates a cozy, relaxed vibe. Fresh pastries fill the air with a Parisian bakery feel. Regulars enjoy affordable, high-quality croissants and sandwiches in a friendly, neighborhood setting.

Caramel alfajor and chocolate cookies stand out with rich flavors. The cookies and pastries consistently taste delicious, and the staff often adds extra treats.

Offers oven-fresh savory and sweet baked goods alongside fantastic sandwiches. Provides latte options with almond and oat milk and delivers great customer service.

People are saying

"The almond croissants are incredible and have amazing texture."

"I thought this was the best bakery in the area."

"I thought the cookies were among the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Pabade Bakery NJ closes early, so visit early for breakfast.

2

Seating is limited, so plan for takeout if necessary.

3

Prices are reasonable, with sandwiches starting at $8.

03
Hey Peach Bakery image 1

Charming bakery with a storybook-like atmosphere and beautiful mosaic entrance creates a cozy, sophisticated vibe. Small interior space focuses attention on a delicious-looking display of freshly baked breads and pastries. Limited seating outside invites a quick, delightful stop for world-class baked goods.

Freshly baked cookies offer a rich, buttery flavor with exceptional texture. Unique options like the olive oil herb cookie stand out alongside classic chocolate chip varieties.

Bread and pastries stand out for their excellent quality and flavor. The crème puff pastry and chocolate croissants receive special mention for their taste and craftsmanship.

People are saying

"These pastries are the most delicious I've ever had."

"I thought the croissants at this bakery were the best I've ever had."

"I dreamt of their blueberry scones; I had to get more."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines outside most days, especially on weekends.

2

The bakery sells out quickly, especially in the morning for bread.

3

There are only two small tables outside for seating.

04
Jess Bakeshop image 1

Small bakery with a beautiful, cozy interior and aromatic sourdough fills the space with warmth. Atmosphere feels relaxing and fun with music and inviting design. Offers high-quality baked goods featuring Korean-inspired flavors and carefully crafted pastries.

Cookies feature a perfectly balanced flavor with chocolate that melts in your mouth. Options include vegan chocolate chip and triple chocolate brownie cookie, avoiding excessive sweetness.

Small and family-owned, this bakery specializes in sourdough and Korean-inspired flavors. It offers high-quality pastries and bread with a craft and care that make it stand out.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies were perfectly balanced and not too sweet."

"I loved their sourdough options and comforting aroma."

"I loved the sourdough bread at this bakery; it was super flavorful."

Good to know

1

Jess Bakeshop specializes in sourdough and Korean-inspired baked goods.

2

Daily specials showcase unique creations, so check them out.

3

Expect to pay a premium for high-quality baked goods.

05
Kiersten's Creations image 1

Bakery offers gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan options with a focus on high-quality desserts. Atmosphere feels welcoming and accommodating, especially for dietary restrictions. Food truck service adds a casual, festive energy to events.

Oatmeal cookies stand out as a favorite, praised for their quality. The selection includes gluten-free cookies and sugar cookies, often paired with ice cream sandwiches from a cute ice cream cart.

Offers a wide variety of baked goods with reasonable prices. Ordering is easy and the treats consistently impress.

People are saying

"Their cakes are delicious and beautifully designed."

"These cookies are so delicious and taste fresh out of the oven."

"I found this bakery to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Kiersten's Creations offers gluten-free and vegan options for various dietary needs.

2

Desserts are reasonably priced, providing good value for the quality.

3

The bakery frequently sells out on weekends, so plan your visit accordingly.

06
Despina's Cream Bakery image 1

Bakery offers spectacular cakes and pastries with creamy cheesecakes and unique flavor twists like Brazilian-style carrot cake. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, attracting people who appreciate beautifully designed and delicious desserts. Open for retail sales on weekends and wholesales to restaurants during the week.

Cookies and cream cookies stand out with their recent addition. Recipes keep it simple with no more than 80 ingredients, making the cookies and brownies easy to enjoy.

Scones, biscuits, and muffins stand out as some of the most delicious baked goods here. Cakes and sweets are both beautiful and tasty, making this bakery a solid choice for special occasions.

People are saying

"The treats and cakes at this bakery are delicious and beautiful."

"This cheesecake literally melts in your mouth."

"I found the cookies here to be top tier."

Good to know

1

They are open for retail sales on weekends only.

2

They wholesale to many restaurants and other places during the week.

3

No order was too small or too large for Despina.

07
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 1
Dessert restaurant

Cozy space with warm, welcoming energy creates a friendly, family-oriented vibe. Atmosphere feels like a comfortable home perfect for conversation and enjoying high-quality desserts. Clean, pretty environment enhances the inviting experience.

Cookies come full of flavor and stay very fresh. The chocolate cookie and oatmeal raisin stand out for their rich taste and quality ingredients.

Top-notch bakery with a 4.9 rating offers a welcoming atmosphere and wonderful staff.

People are saying

"I found the desserts here to be the most delicious I ever had."

"The cookies here are huge, warm, and genuinely tasty."

"The owner is so friendly and attentive at this bakery."

Good to know

1

Everything is made fresh daily at Juan Dulce Desserts.

2

There are limited vegan dessert options available.

3

They offer catering services for events and parties.

08
Chic Sugars image 1
Cake shop

Cake shop offers custom designs with beautiful, detailed decorations and delicious flavors that impress at special occasions. The atmosphere is cute and visually appealing, creating a smooth and satisfying experience for ordering and delivery.

Cookies come out fresh and delicious with beautiful decorations. Customized orders match expectations and taste great.

Custom cakes stand out with detailed designs and quality. This bakery handles special orders with care and consistency, making it a go-to spot for celebrations.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful works of art."

"The cookies here are perfectly tasty and beautifully decorated."

"This bakery's custom cakes are beautifully designed and incredibly fresh."

Good to know

1

Custom cake orders require at least 48 hours notice.

2

Delivery is punctual and within the specified time window.

3

Pricing is fair for the quality of cakes and cupcakes offered.

09
Double Batch Bakery | Walk-Up Window • Online Bakery image 1

Walk-up window bakery with rotating menu offers fresh, scratch-made pastries and seasonal desserts. Atmosphere feels welcoming and lively, with curbside pickup and online ordering adding convenience. Family-run operation delivers high-quality baked goods that stand out in the neighborhood.

Napoleon cookie stands out with perfect texture and flavor, often described as a must-try. Freshly baked vegan cookies and a toffee and butter cookie also deliver rich taste and great texture.

Rotating menu offers a unique variety of seasonal pastries. Croissants and cakes stand out for their excellent quality. Service operates like a drive-through, making it quick and convenient.

People are saying

"I found everything from this bakery to be so delicious and homemade."

"This cookie is divine, with perfect texture and flavor."

"The dairy-free baked goods are so moist and delicious."

Good to know

1

You need to order in advance for takeout and delivery.

2

The bakery releases a new menu each night, so order quickly to avoid missing out.

3

Most menu items can be ready within 5 minutes for last-minute needs.

10
Mo & Jay Pastry image 1

Cake shop offers wide selection of buttery croissants and flaky pastries with rich almond paste. Atmosphere feels inviting with a focus on quality and celebration. Pastries attract those seeking distinctive flavors and artisanal baked goods.

Cookies come in browned butter chocolate chunk and themed designs like summer swim. They arrive quickly and taste delicious with great feedback on flavor and appearance.

Small bakery offers same day custom cakes and serves the community with quality baked goods. Staff provide helpful, friendly service for various bakery needs.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be high-quality and delicious."

"Their almond croissant was unmatched, I searched everywhere for it."

"These cookies are amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Mo & Jay Pastry recently reopened for retail service.

2

Expect some items to be sold out due to high demand.

3

Prices for pastries are on the higher side.

11
Bakes by Izzy image 1

Cakes and treats showcase creative designs and rich flavors with standout items like Funfetti and chocolate chip cookies. The atmosphere feels artisanal and inviting, drawing those seeking special occasion desserts that combine taste and visual appeal.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a rich flavor that rivals those from New York City. Cookie cakes come soft and delicious, decorated with adorable themes and tasty icing.

Offers a delicious variety of baked goods that consistently impress. Recognized as a great local bakery with a strong reputation in the area.

People are saying

"The cookie cakes are so soft and delicious."

"I thought the chocolate chip cookie was better than any others."

"The cookie cakes are soft and delicious."

Good to know

1

Bakes by Izzy specializes in custom cakes for special occasions.

2

Expect to find seasonal treats that change throughout the year.

3

The bakery is located in a convenient downtown area.

12
Maxine’s Bakeshop image 1

Bright, airy space with skylights creates a cozy, welcoming atmosphere filled with heavenly smells. Quiet during midmorning, it draws those seeking top-tier French pastries made entirely in-house. The vibe is pleasant and relaxed, perfect for enjoying fresh, flaky croissants and other celebrated treats.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their heavenly flavor and a little bit of sea salt on top. Shortbread chocolate cookies come packaged for guests, adding a special touch.

French pastries strike a perfect sweet spot without causing a sugar crash. Everything is made in-house in a warm, welcoming space with a heavenly smell.

People are saying

"The pastries here are always fresh and delicious."

"I thought the chocolate chip cookie was divine."

"I found the almond croissant at this bakery to be crispy and flaky."

Good to know

1

Maxine’s Bakeshop offers a variety of fresh pastries and custom cakes.

2

All pastries are made in-house with authentic French techniques.

3

The bakery has plenty of seating available for customers.

13
Sweet & Flour image 1
Cake shop

Beautiful decoration creates an inviting atmosphere with show-stopping cake designs that become celebration centerpieces. The bakery offers custom cakes with fresh, high-quality ingredients, including eggless options for dietary needs. Guests often seek contact information due to the exceptional taste and presentation of desserts.

Custom cookies come in gorgeous designs and taste delicious. Irish soda cookies stand out as amazing and they offer themed treats like monster truck cake pops alongside cookies.

Cakes and custom desserts use high quality ingredients and show creative designs. Birthday cakes and cake pops are popular and consistently well received.

People are saying

"The cake here is so moist and beautifully decorated."

"Gina's custom desserts brought my ideas to life, even eggless options."

"Gina's bakery creations are show-stopping and taste delicious."

Good to know

1

Custom cake orders require at least one week's notice for preparation.

2

Cupcakes are priced at approximately $4 each, with a minimum order of 36.

3

The bakery uses high-quality ingredients in all their products.

14
Petite B Bakery image 1

Cozy, authentic French bakery with a homey atmosphere and a small seating area. The space feels tight but welcoming, with freshly baked pastries and breads that draw regulars seeking quality and comfort.

Chocolate chip cookies and pecan sticky buns stand out for their rich flavors. The Nutella cruffin and chocolate pecan cookie offer unique, indulgent twists.

Creative French pastries stand out with excellent quality and a cozy, homey atmosphere. Service is consistently top-notch, making it a truly special bakery experience.

People are saying

"I found their pastries to be delicious, especially the pecan sticky bun."

"You have to try the croissants and baguettes at this bakery; they're perfectly baked."

"I found the chocolate chip cookies to be amazing."

Good to know

1

The Canele costs 75 cents each, which is not something I normally see.

2

Petite B Bakery is a neighborhood favorite breakfast spot.

3

Expect a wide selection of baked goods compared to other bakeries.

15
Chocolatine image 1
Pastry shop

Small, bright pastry shop evokes Parisian street cafe with authentic French aromas and cozy, friendly atmosphere. Space is designed for takeout with no seating inside or out, emphasizing quick visits. Upscale presentation and world-class pastries define the experience.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their incredible flavor and texture. The selection also includes macarons and other pastries like croissants and lemon meringue tart.

Offers authentic French viennoiserie with a strong Parisian bakery vibe. The bakery features fresh baguettes and artisan pastries that bring a taste of Europe locally.

People are saying

"These flaky, buttery croissants are the best I've ever had."

"The croissants at this bakery are flaky, buttery, and delicious."

"I loved their chocolate chip cookie because it was incredible."

Good to know

1

There is no indoor seating available at Chocolatine.

2

Parking can be difficult; several lots are within walking distance.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but processing fees may apply for debit transactions.

16
Kuday Turkish Bakery image 1

Small bakery offers authentic Turkish pastries with a mom-and-pop vibe and fresh, handmade sweets. Atmosphere feels wholesome and unpretentious, reminiscent of traditional old-school bakeries. Limited variety changes daily, creating a sense of exclusivity and freshness.

Fresh cookies come warm and crispy outside with a buttery inside that melts in your mouth. Varieties include pistachio, blueberry, and apricot, with generous free samples offered by the friendly owner.

Baklava stands out with its fresh, flaky, and crispy texture, unlike others that sit for days. The bakery offers knafeh and fresh bread, all served with very kind and sincere staff.

People are saying

"The bakery owner is so kind and gives out generous samples."

"The baklava here is perfectly baked, flaky, and juicy."

"The owner gave us a delicious cookie sample without asking."

Good to know

1

Call two days in advance to place an order for baked goods.

2

The owner makes all sweets in small batches for freshness.

3

The bakery offers a limited variety of baklava, cookies, and breads.

17
The Simple Fare image 1
Restaurant

Cozy restaurant with bright, airy space and pleasant courtyard seating offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere ideal for casual dining or work. The sleek, minimalistic decor complements an Indian-inspired menu featuring well-portioned dishes and top-notch pastries.

Chocolate chip cookie and homemade Indian cookie stand out as delicious options. Cookies pair well with coffee and complement other items like the cheese kati roll.

High-end coffee shop and bakery vibe shapes the space. Bakery items pair well with tea, enjoyed right in the shop while the team tidies up.

People are saying

"This lunch spot's food is authentically Indian with a fun twist."

"You have to try the chocolate chip cookie; it's delicious."

"The owner welcomed us and offered to-go cups for our bakery items."

Good to know

1

They have plenty of parking, which is a huge plus because street parking is hard near them.

2

There’s both indoor and outdoor seating available, but seating is limited.

3

They just started serving dinner on Fridays and Saturdays.

18
Pierre's Bakery image 1

Bakery combines beautiful interior with an inviting atmosphere enhanced by an adjoining deli and restaurant. The space offers party hall and catering services, supporting a community-focused vibe. It features a wide variety of baked goods and cakes, known for their quality and affordability.

Soft texture and beautiful presentation define the cookies here. An assortment offers freshness alongside pastries and cakes.

Fresh bakery items fill the air with an amazing aroma. The variety includes mocha cake that impresses many, showing the bakery's community embrace and quality.

People are saying

"The cake here is always moist and delicious."

"The cookies here are soft and amazing."

"Their cakes are delicious and moist."

Good to know

1

Pierre's Bakery offers a nice selection of assorted breads and pastries.

2

The food is reasonably priced and affordable for breakfast.

3

They have a fabulous deli menu and catering options.

19
Turquoise Bakery & Cafe image 1

Bright, clean space with modern decor and plenty of windows creates an inviting atmosphere. Energy stays calm and serene, though seating can feel a bit cold and less cozy. Crowd tends to be steady, drawn by homemade baked goods and healthy lunch options.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a classy and delicious flavor. Variety includes key lime cookies, lemon almond cookies, and homemade treats like baklava and vanilla cupcakes with piped roses.

Offers homemade bakery items with fantastic quality. The lemon blueberry scone stands out among the selection.

People are saying

"The banana bread latte was the best I ever tasted."

"The bakery staff were super friendly and kind."

"The chocolate chip cookie here is classy and delicious."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

2

Parking can be busy, so plan to arrive early.

3

The bakery items are made fresh in-house daily.

20
Lonestar Bakeshop & Bagels image 1

Family-owned bakery offers a cozy atmosphere with limited seating mainly for take-out. Early visits are essential as fresh kolaches and bagels sell out quickly. Friendly vibe welcomes families and kids, making it a popular local breakfast spot with exceptional pastries and sandwiches.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their rich flavor. The chocolate toffee cookie offers a sweet, crunchy bite that disappears fast.

Family-owned bakery offers a variety of breads, sweets, and savory foods with great taste. Friendly staff greet customers with a smile, creating a warm, welcoming vibe.

People are saying

"I found the breakfast sandwich to be amazing."

"You have to try the kolaches at this bakery; they're delicious."

"The chocolate cookies here are bursting with flavor."

Good to know

1

Arrive early in the morning to ensure bagels are available.

2

Expect limited bagel options after 9am due to high demand.

3

Kolaches are a must-try item for first-time visitors.

21
The Modern Cakery image 1

Cozy shop with a clean, minimalistic design fills the air with freshly baked aromas. Light, moist cakes and treats offer high-quality ingredients and beautiful presentation. Regulars appreciate custom cakes suited for special occasions and dietary needs.

Cookies stay soft and fresh like they just came out of the oven. The chocolate chip cookies stand out as especially good, often described as perfect and amazing alongside other treats like cake pops.

High-quality ingredients create delicious baked goods that impress many. The bakery offers a wide variety of items, with cakes that attract repeat orders and strong recommendations.

People are saying

"The cake here is so delicious and beautifully done."

"These custom cookies were exactly what I envisioned and turned out wonderfully."

"This bakery makes beautiful and delicious custom cakes."

Good to know

1

The bakery is closed on Sundays, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Online ordering is straightforward and user-friendly.

3

They offer gluten and nut-free options for those with allergies.

22
Sasscer's Cheesecakes image 1

Bakery offers wide variety of creamy cheesecakes and fresh cookies with reasonable prices. Atmosphere is clean and inviting, with desserts often selling out by night. Special items like crabmeat quiche require advance order, adding unique options beyond typical pastries.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a very homemade taste and fresh daily baking. Cheesecake and key lime macaroon cookies add variety with rich, sweet flavors.

Clean environment and top tier employees create a welcoming bakery experience. Cheesecakes stand out as a top notch offering here.

People are saying

"I found the cheesecake here to be the most delicious and creamy I've ever had."

"I found the cheesecakes here to be the most delicious and creamy."

"I found the homemade chocolate chip cookies to be crazy delicious."

Good to know

1

The Crabmeat Quiche must be ordered in advance and is only made on Saturdays.

2

First-time visitors receive a complimentary chocolate cookie.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality of desserts offered.

23
Boba Works image 1

Spacious bakery with an open kitchen and clean, tidy environment offers a warm and lively atmosphere that suits relaxing or working remotely. Unique pastries and authentic high-quality boba tea attract a diverse crowd, while games and seating options create an inviting, fun space.

Soft, hearty oatmeal raisin cookies stand out with full flavor. Sugar cookies and holiday-themed cookies show careful decoration and variety among custard-filled cruffins and matcha blondies.

Amazing bakery options stand out with items that could rival those from upscale bakeries. The bakery pairs well with super good coffee in a cute little coffee shop setting.

People are saying

"The jasmine tea with lychee jelly is always refreshing."

"The bakery items here are amazing, especially the matcha croissant."

"I found this cookie pop-up to be a great find."

Good to know

1

Afternoon tea is available, but reservations are recommended.

2

Baking classes are offered on weekends; check the schedule in advance.

3

The pastries are baked fresh daily and are unique to the shop.

24
Honey Bakery image 1

Small bakery with an open-kitchen setup and warm, welcoming atmosphere filled with the aroma of freshly baked Persian pastries. The space feels cozy and cute, attracting those who appreciate authentic Persian sweets and a relaxed vibe.

Persian cookies like zolbia and rollet stand out with their fresh, exquisite taste. Samples include gingerbread cookies and almond varieties that are not overly sweet, perfect with tea.

Offers authentic Persian sweets that are fresh and delicious. The bakery is clean and beautiful, with cakes and baked goods that stand out for their quality.

People are saying

"The pastries here are fresh and unbelievably delicious."

"The staff here are so kind and let you try samples."

"The bakery's pastries are so fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Honey Bakery offers a wide selection of authentic Persian pastries and cookies.

2

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

The bakery provides generous samples of their sweets to try before buying.

25
Amici Bakery & Pastry Shop image 1

Bakery offers a heavenly aroma of baked goods with a wide selection of cookies, breads, pastries, and cakes. Atmosphere feels like a family-run Italian bakery with Brooklyn-style influences. Cakes and pastries receive consistent praise for quality and presentation.

Freshly baked cookies come in a wide selection of soft and hard textures. Jellied cookies and Italian sprinkled cookies stand out among the choices, with cookie cakes and cheesecakes also available.

Fresh Italian-style pastries, cookies, and cakes come out daily. The bakery offers Brooklyn-style quality that matches what you'd find in New York, especially for Italian baked goods.

People are saying

"This bakery is comparable to the ones I remember from Brooklyn."

"The cake here is stunning and delicious."

"I thought the cookies here were the best I had ever eaten."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide selection of cookies, breads, pastries, and cakes.

2

Prices are fair and affordable, with cakes starting around $35.

3

Amici Bakery is a family business, contributing to its charm.

26
Rispoli Pastry Shop image 1

Clean, welcoming bakery known for exceptional Italian pastries and extraordinary lobster tails. Atmosphere stays calm with steady demand, especially during holidays when waits extend. Regulars seek out authentic cakes and cookies, appreciating consistent quality and triple-A cannoli cream.

Italian bakery cookies come fresh and well made with a fantastic taste. Lobster tails and cannolis stand out alongside the ready-made cookies offered.

Italian pastries stand out with fresh, well-made treats. Lobster tails and bakery cookies are notable specialties enjoyed over decades.

People are saying

"This cake was so delicious, guests were going back for seconds."

"You have to try their famous lobster tails; they're heavenly."

"The bakery's lobster tails are incredible, filled with chantilly cream."

Good to know

1

The shop closes at 6pm daily.

2

During holidays, expect at least a 2-hour wait for pastries.

3

A pop-up shop is available for Thanksgiving 2025.

27
Sourdough Society Storefront image 1

Sourdough bread made with organic ingredients and a Greek starter defines the bakery's offerings. The atmosphere feels warm and inviting, with bread arriving fresh and hand-delivered. The place stands out for its high-quality craftsmanship and distinctive sourdough flavors.

Sourdough cookies use organic ingredients and have a handmade quality. They taste amazing and feel guilt free.

Micro bakery focuses on sourdough with a unique approach that stands out. It elevates the local bakery scene with fresh, artisanal bread and a strong reputation for quality.

People are saying

"This bread is the best I've ever had."

"I found the cookies and cookie dough to be incredible."

"This bakery's feta and oregano bread transports you to Greece."

Good to know

1

Sourdough Society offers home delivery services for their bread.

2

All bread is made with organic ingredients and a 100-year-old starter from Greece.

3

The bakery sells sourdough at the farmers market on Cole Street and in Weehawken Lincoln Harbor.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...