Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New Jersey's best

Cookie and pie

You want a place that masters both cookies and pies. You shouldn't have to visit two different shops to satisfy your cravings.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 1
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 2
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 3
View all
Dessert restaurant

Cozy space with warm, welcoming energy creates a friendly, family-oriented vibe. Atmosphere feels like a comfortable home perfect for conversation and enjoying high-quality desserts. Clean, pretty environment enhances the inviting experience.

Cookies come full of flavor and stay very fresh. The chocolate cookie and oatmeal raisin stand out for their rich taste and quality ingredients.

Key lime pie stands out with a fresh lime flavor balanced against a sweet topping. Desserts like Flan de Coco and Peach Almond Tart are freshly made by Chef Juan, keeping everything tasting vibrant and homemade.

People are saying

"I found the desserts here to be the most delicious I ever had."

"The cookies here are huge, warm, and genuinely tasty."

"I found the desserts, especially the key lime pie, to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Everything is made fresh daily at Juan Dulce Desserts.

2

There are limited vegan dessert options available.

3

They offer catering services for events and parties.

02
Hey Peach Bakery image 1

Charming bakery with a storybook-like atmosphere and beautiful mosaic entrance creates a cozy, sophisticated vibe. Small interior space focuses attention on a delicious-looking display of freshly baked breads and pastries. Limited seating outside invites a quick, delightful stop for world-class baked goods.

Freshly baked cookies offer a rich, buttery flavor with exceptional texture. Unique options like the olive oil herb cookie stand out alongside classic chocolate chip varieties.

Warm apple pies come fresh from the oven with a melting texture and rich flavor. Hand pies look beautiful and taste phenomenal, especially the apple and savory potato varieties.

People are saying

"These pastries are the most delicious I've ever had."

"These cream puffs are life-changing, even if you don't usually like them."

"I dreamt of their blueberry scones; I had to get more."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines outside most days, especially on weekends.

2

The bakery sells out quickly, especially in the morning for bread.

3

There are only two small tables outside for seating.

03
Double Batch Bakery | Walk-Up Window โ€ข Online Bakery image 1

Walk-up window bakery with rotating menu offers fresh, scratch-made pastries and seasonal desserts. Atmosphere feels welcoming and lively, with curbside pickup and online ordering adding convenience. Family-run operation delivers high-quality baked goods that stand out in the neighborhood.

Napoleon cookie stands out with perfect texture and flavor, often described as a must-try. Freshly baked vegan cookies and a toffee and butter cookie also deliver rich taste and great texture.

Pies come with beautiful presentation and delicious flavors. They appear alongside cakes, cookies, and cupcakes, making them a popular choice for gatherings.

People are saying

"I found everything from this bakery to be so delicious and homemade."

"This cookie is divine, with perfect texture and flavor."

"Their pies are beautiful and delicious."

Good to know

1

You need to order in advance for takeout and delivery.

2

The bakery releases a new menu each night, so order quickly to avoid missing out.

3

Most menu items can be ready within 5 minutes for last-minute needs.

04
Sasscer's Cheesecakes image 1

Bakery offers wide variety of creamy cheesecakes and fresh cookies with reasonable prices. Atmosphere is clean and inviting, with desserts often selling out by night. Special items like crabmeat quiche require advance order, adding unique options beyond typical pastries.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a very homemade taste and fresh daily baking. Cheesecake and key lime macaroon cookies add variety with rich, sweet flavors.

Key lime pie stands out with a strong, memorable flavor. The coconut pie also impresses with its rich, unique taste. Cakes and pies overall maintain a high level of quality.

People are saying

"I found the cheesecake here to be the most delicious and creamy I've ever had."

"I found the homemade chocolate chip cookies to be crazy delicious."

"I found the cakes and pies here to be excellent."

Good to know

1

The Crabmeat Quiche must be ordered in advance and is only made on Saturdays.

2

First-time visitors receive a complimentary chocolate cookie.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality of desserts offered.

05
Cafe Piecebook image 1

Small cafe with artistic urban decor blending Renaissance and graffiti styles creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Space welcomes dogs with Korean style pup cups and offers complimentary stickers. Large windows and open kitchen add to the unique, edgy vibe.

Freshly baked cheddar cookies and earl grey lemon cookies stand out here. Homemade cookies pair well with their refreshing boba tea options.

Pecan pie stands out with its rich, delicious flavor that pairs well with coffee. Freshly baked and highly recommended, it often accompanies other pastries like croissants.

People are saying

"Their lattes are amazing, maybe the best in town."

"You have to try the cookies; they're amazing and decadent."

"I found the pecan pie perfectly balanced and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Dogs are welcome at this cafe, making it dog-friendly.

2

Parking is easy to find and basically free here.

3

The owner creates unique drinks and baked goods.

06
TIME OUT COFFEE SHOP image 1

Small interior opens up with plenty of seating and a spotless, beautifully decorated space. Warm aroma of freshly brewed coffee and Greek pastries fills the air, creating a cozy, friendly atmosphere that feels like a community hub. Free Wi-Fi supports a relaxed vibe for working or catching up with friends.

Powdered sugar cookies pair well with cappuccinos and come highly recommended. Pastry cookies taste rich and fresh, with some offered on the house for extra enjoyment.

Spinach pie stands out with its perfect phyllo consistency, crunchy outside, and soft inside, featuring a familiar feta and spinach flavor. Orange pie offers a yummy and juicy taste.

People are saying

"The coffee here is amazing, delicious, and phenomenal."

"I loved the spinach pie; it was the best I've ever had."

"The cappuccino's espresso flavor is robust yet balanced."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop offers a variety of Greek pastries and fresh sandwiches.

2

They accept credit cards and mobile payments, but cash is preferred for small purchases.

3

Parking is available on the street, but it can be limited during busy hours.

07
From Scratch image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, intimate space with an open kitchen that feels like dining in Italy. Warm, inviting atmosphere balances cozy charm with joyful energy, ideal for quiet meals or dates. Offers authentic homemade pasta and cooking classes, emphasizing genuine Italian experience.

Complimentary butter cookies are sweet and pair well with espresso. The Nutella pie features a crispy top and a buttery cookie base that melts in your mouth.

Warm Nutella pies feature a crispy crunch on top and a buttery cookie bottom. Ricotta and Nutella pies also appear on the menu, with the Nutella pie available for special orders like birthdays.

People are saying

"The pasta here is incredible, fresh, and authentic."

"You have to try the Nutella pie, it's so good."

"Chef Claudia's cooking class was fun and taught us delicious recipes."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required, so planning ahead is necessary.

2

The restaurant offers a special Valentineโ€™s Day menu.

3

Bringing a bottle of wine is recommended when visiting.

08
Verrilli's image 1

Traditional bakery space with cozy atmosphere and lively energy from family owners. Small seating area encourages intimate conversation and community feel. Known for fresh made-to-order donuts and a variety of classic baked goods.

Cookies come with a hidden clove flavor that stands out. They often get offered for free and are a popular party item enjoyed by all ages.

Offers Greek specialties like gyro, cheese, and spinach pies alongside chicken pot pies. Pot pies stand out as amazing.

People are saying

"I found the donuts here to be amazing and made fresh."

"I grabbed some really good, freshly baked cookies."

"I found the pot pies to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Verrilli's is closed on Mondays.

2

Parking is available right out front.

3

Reservations are not required but calling ahead can save time.

09
Athens Bakery image 1

Small bakery with an unassuming storefront and limited seating focuses on authentic Greek pastries and homemade goods. Atmosphere feels friendly and spotless, catering mostly to pickup orders with cash-only payment. Pastries like spanakopita and cookies stand out for freshness and traditional flavors.

Cookies come fresh and warm, with sugar free options and flavors that evoke childhood memories. Some varieties like the triangle cookie may not appeal to everyone.

Spinach pie features mild feta that is not salty. Apple pies and cookies bring a nostalgic childhood feel. Pies become available for purchase late morning.

People are saying

"I loved the chocolate layer cake; it was an awesome dark chocolate experience."

"The apple crumb pie is so refreshing and not too sweet."

"The spanakopita is fresh, homemade, and delicious."

Good to know

1

The bakery only accepts cash; no credit cards are accepted.

2

Seating is very limited, so plan to order to go.

3

The bakery mostly offers pickup service.

10
Red Horse Steakhouse by David Burke - Rumson, NJ image 1

Steakhouse offers a loud, energetic atmosphere with live music enhancing the experience. Decor features quaint, classy touches like blown glass artwork and candlelight. The space attracts those seeking a vibrant, upscale dining environment.

Sugar cookie ice cream sandwiches with toasted marshmallow stand out as a nostalgic treat elevated to gourmet levels. The cookies are delicious and pair well with creamy ice cream.

Key lime pie offers a light and fluffy finish to the meal. The coconut custard pie with roasted pineapple delivers a tropical flavor that stands out.

People are saying

"Dinner in the dark is an unforgettable sensory revelation."

"The sugar cookie ice cream sandwich was a nostalgic, gourmet treat."

"Nadine, our server, made our birthday celebration very special."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all day on Tuesdays with special promotions.

2

Trivia night features movie trivia every Tuesday at 8pm.

3

Steak night is on Wednesdays with special menu items.

11
Palmer's Bakehouse image 1

Bakery offers creative Asian flavors like Ube and pandan alongside rich buttercream and warm donut dough cake. Space feels calming and lovely despite occasional inconsistent hours. Known for excellent hand pies and scrumptious key lime pie.

Marshmallow filling stands out in the cookie sandwiches. Oatmeal cream cookies come in thin, delicate layers and classic oatmeal sandwich style. Some cookies and muffins tend to be dry, and cookie sizes vary from past visits.

Chicken spinach hand pies stand out with rich filling and flaky crust. BBQ chicken pies and oatmeal cream pies also deliver strong flavors and satisfying textures.

People are saying

"You have to try the scrumptious key lime pie here."

"You have to try the chocolate bundt cake; it's SO good!"

"I found the oatmeal cookie sandwich incredible."

Good to know

1

The price of the oatmeal cream pies increased from $3.75 to $4.

2

The bakery sells days-old items instead of fresh food.

3

Oatmeal cream pies have become much smaller recently.

12
Big Apple Bakery image 1

Bakery offers homemade soups, artisan breads, and decorative cakes with sugar-free options. Atmosphere carries a nostalgic, quality-focused vibe reminiscent of traditional bakeries. Regulars seek out fresh apple products and Italian cookies, appreciating consistent excellence in baked goods.

Cookies stay soft and fresh even after several days. Italian varieties and black/white cookies come out delicious and beautifully made. Large orders are handled with accommodation and care.

Keylime pie and cherry crumb pie stand out for their flavor. The selection includes pumpkin pie, chocolate/banana pudding pie, and holiday pies, all noted for being very good.

People are saying

"I found this bakery to be the absolute best."

"These Italian cookies are the best I've had in a long time."

"I thought the pie here was out of this world."

Good to know

1

They offer sugar-free options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

The bakery can accommodate last-minute cake orders with quick turnaround.

3

Donuts are priced at $2.00 each, which is relatively high.

13
David Burke's Dixie Lee Bakery image 1

Bakery offers classic sweets like black and white cookies and key lime tart with a homey atmosphere. Shelves often run low, creating a sense of scarcity during visits. No seating is available, and lines can extend outside when busy.

Black and white cookies here are light and soft with a chewy and crunchy texture and semisweet chocolate chunks. The cookies are huge and shareable, including Italian and rainbow varieties along with great chocolate chip options.

Key lime pie stands out as a classic favorite here, known for its delicious flavor. Black and white cookies and chocolate whoopie pies also feature as notable treats.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and delicious."

"I loved their Black and White cookies; they're the best around."

"I thought the key lime pie was amazing."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

Prices for baked goods range from $3 to $36 depending on the item.

3

Some popular items, like apple turnovers, may not always be available.

14
Peace Pie image 1
Ice cream shop

Colorful exterior and charming window setup create a welcoming scene. Atmosphere buzzes with anticipation and smiles as people enjoy handcrafted ice cream sandwiches featuring a huge variety of unique flavors. No seating or trash disposal on site, focusing on quick, flavorful treats.

Cookies come with a crispy, buttery crust that holds up well in ice cream sandwiches. They are simple but crisp and not stale, making them a solid base for the ice cream.

Peace pies come in many flavors like Elvis and Jersey Devil, each costing around $8. The selection includes peanut butter brownie and pecan pie, all packed well with dry ice for freshness.

People are saying

"These desserts are creative, delicious, and a true highlight."

"The cookie here is so crispy and holds up well."

"I found the peanut butter brownie and pecan pie delicious."

Good to know

1

Peace Pie is cash only, which may complicate purchases.

2

Ice cream sandwiches cost $8 each, which some may find pricey.

3

There is no seating available for customers.

15
Secor Farms image 1

Farm offers two corn mazes, a petting zoo, and hayrides decorated with Halloween themes. Grounds are well-maintained and provide many photo opportunities. Crowds gather for family-friendly activities and fresh apple cider donuts.

Fresh oatmeal cookies and apple cider donuts come straight from the farm bakery. Cookies cost around $7 each when bought with drinks, making them a sweet treat after time outdoors.

Fresh pies come with a tender, buttery crust and balanced sweetness. Options include apple pie and apple pie crumble, alongside other baked goods like cider donuts.

People are saying

"You have to try the cider donuts; they're to die for."

"You have to try the fresh cookies and delicious donuts here."

"The apple pie here has a tender, buttery crust."

Good to know

1

Starting September 15, the farm offers activities like a corn maze, hayrides, and pumpkin picking that require reservations.

2

The adult admission fee is $8.50, and kids' activities cost the same.

3

Secor offers timed, ticketed hayrides to avoid long waits.

16
Giancarlo's Bakery image 1

Old school Italian bakery with crowded interior and outdoor seating offers a variety of baked breads, meat pastries, and entrees. Atmosphere feels nostalgic and no-nonsense, attracting those seeking authentic Italian flavors. The place is known for top-quality pastries and cakes with a neighborhood vibe.

Cookies by the pound stand out for their quality and variety. Butter cookies and other pastries consistently deliver excellent flavor and freshness.

Lemon meringue pie stands out as a highlight. The bakery offers an excellent selection of pies including apple pie that surpasses typical grocery store versions.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be delicious and beautifully done."

"I found their cookies to be amazing and delicious."

"I found they had an excellent selection of pies and cakes."

Good to know

1

Giancarlo's Bakery offers a variety of baked goods, including cakes, pies, and pastries.

2

Most items are baked in-house, ensuring freshness and quality.

3

The bakery has a deli section with sandwiches, wraps, and breakfast options.

17
Waretown Bakery image 1

Small, crowded bakery with an old school feel and friendly locals creates a busy, clean atmosphere. Glass cases display a wide variety of fresh, soft donuts and pastries. Picnic tables outside offer a casual spot to enjoy coffee and treats.

Italian cookies stand out as very delicious. The bakery offers a wide variety of pastries, cakes, and cookies that are consistently outstanding and delicious.

Fruit pies like cherry and peach stand out for their flavor. Chocolate cream and crumb cakes also join a wide selection of pastries and baked goods.

People are saying

"I ordered a birthday cake that was delicious and beautifully decorated."

"The donuts and crumb cake at this bakery are moist and delicious."

"I thought their fruit pies were the best I had."

Good to know

1

Waretown Bakery is open every day of the year.

2

They make everything fresh every single morning.

3

Expect to run out of items very early, especially on weekends.

18
Pinho's Bakery image 1

Bakery offers a large covered patio and a few indoor tables with sunlit glass roof creating a calming atmosphere. Shelves display fresh-made breads and a wide variety of confectionery and desserts. The vibe feels like a warm, community-focused family joint with a sense of culture and comfort.

Italian leaf cookies and custom cookies for weddings, birthdays, and graduations stand out here. Sugar-free options and a large variety of beautiful, personalized cookies also fill the display.

Many pies like apple crumble, peach tart, and custard are available. The selection includes mini desserts and other baked goods.

People are saying

"I found this bakery to be the best I could go to."

"The peanut butter cookies here are huge and so good."

"I loved their peach tart pies and other sweet treats."

Good to know

1

They make fresh egg tarts every hour, perfect for a quick treat.

2

Complimentary parking is available, but it is limited.

3

Pinho's Bakery offers a wide selection of baked goods, including pastries and sandwiches.

19
B&W Bakery image 1

Classic bakery with an old-school layout and friendly atmosphere feels like stepping back in time. Long lines form for best-in-region crumb cake and other standout pastries. Only cash payments accepted, adding to its authentic, traditional vibe.

Fresh fruit pockets, apricot cookies, and black and white cookies stand out. Cookie trays and seasonal treats like Halloween-themed cookies add variety.

Pies feature buttery crusts and toasty meringue that stand out. Options include pecan pie, lemon meringue, chocolate silk, apple crumb, and pumpkin, with the pumpkin pie being notably sweet and rich.

People are saying

"This crumb cake is scrumptious and not too sweet."

"The crumb cake here is the best I ever had."

"I thought the pecan pie was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

B&W Bakery only accepts cash payments.

2

Parking is available on the street.

3

It operates mainly as a take-out bakery with no seating available.

20
Palisades Park Bakery image 1

Spacious, modern bakery blends American and Korean styles with bright, clean decor and painted murals. Atmosphere stays calm and cozy, avoiding crowded cafe vibes. Self-serve setup lets people choose pastries at their own pace.

Cookies come soft and tasty, often dipped in chocolate with sprinkles. Varieties include double chocolate and Oreo, both rich and flavorful.

Pecan pie stands out with its traditional recipe kept alive for decades and a subtle but huge difference after new ownership. It sells fast from the kitchen and suits parties and family desserts well.

People are saying

"I found the best Korean bakery with great pastry and coffee."

"The pecan pie tastes just like the original recipe."

"The Pecan Custard cookie tastes just like I remember from childhood."

Good to know

1

Donuts are priced at $2.75 each, significantly higher than before.

2

Expect long lines during weekends due to popularity.

3

The bakery uses dairy whipped cream for a better texture.

21
Supreme Bakery image 1

Old style bakery with beautiful decorations and a pleasant atmosphere. Known for fresh, delicious cakes and consistent quality. Offers special occasion cakes with designs matching submitted photos.

Lace cookies stand out as a magnificent and delicious option here. The variety includes chocolate chip and other cookies, all consistently good and often paired with cakes and cupcakes.

Key lime pie stands out as a favorite, noted for its amazing flavor. Other pies like peach and apple also deliver delicious, memorable tastes.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was beautiful and flavorful."

"I've been going to this Bakery for over 20 years."

"I was addicted to their magnificent lace cookies."

Good to know

1

Supreme Bakery offers sugar-free cupcakes and cakes with a quick turnaround.

2

Online ordering at Supreme Bakery is easy and accurate.

3

Cakes can be customized for special occasions with advance notice.

22
Miller's Bakery image 1

Bakery offers fresh pastries with a clean atmosphere and traditional baked goods like buttered bread and apple pie. It serves a long-standing community role with a history dating back to the 1940s. Prices for some items are notably high, reflecting a focus on specialty and quality ingredients.

Cookies come in affordable prices and include options like hamantaschen pastries. Some rainbow cookies show layer separation and jam leakage, and fresh cookie selection can be preferred over ready-made ones.

Traditional apple pie offers a classic taste with a buttery crust. The pecan pie balances sweetness well and highlights the nuts. Pumpkin pie has a mousse-like consistency.

People are saying

"I loved their delicious pastries and specialty baked goods."

"I thought the pecan pie was the best I had ever tasted."

"I came back for the cookies and they were even better than I remembered."

Good to know

1

Miller's Bakery has been a town staple since the 1940s.

2

They can prepare cakes in 1 day for last-minute orders.

3

Miller's Bakery is open on Thanksgiving for holiday treats.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...