Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Footwear thrift stores in New Jersey

A thrift store for shoes that is organized enough to actually find a matching pair.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The Connect Clothing Store image 1
The Connect Clothing Store image 2
The Connect Clothing Store image 3
View all

Store offers a wide selection of vintage and streetwear clothing alongside sneakers. Atmosphere feels organized and clean, welcoming families and casual shoppers. Prices remain affordable, with many items under $50, making it accessible for expanding collections without high cost.

Offers a wide selection of sneakers and related apparel with good quality. Staff provide expert legit checks and helpful advice on footwear and streetwear.

Offers a solid mix of vintage wrestling t-shirts, sneakers, and streetwear. The hype case adds a unique touch to the selection.

People are saying

"This footwear store has an amazing selection of sneakers and apparel."

"I found great deals and a wide selection of women's clothing."

"This thrift store has the best vintage and streetwear finds."

Good to know

1

The store has a wide selection of sneakers and streetwear.

2

Prices for items are generally affordable, with many under $50.

3

All items are confirmed to be authentic and in good condition.

02
conSHINEment image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop offers a curated selection of high-quality, vintage and aesthetic clothing with affordable prices. The atmosphere is chill and comforting with loud, good music and friendly management. Fitting rooms are functional but simple, supporting a relaxed shopping experience.

A wide range of shoes exists, from affordable work shoes to luxury footwear. The collection also includes boots and pairs that stand out for their style and quality.

Vintage clothing options stand out with a mix of aesthetic and designer pieces. The store feels clean without the typical thrift smell and often has sales with discounts.

People are saying

"I found a large variety of quality women's clothing in great condition."

"I found amazing shoes and great deals at this footwear store."

"The Thrift Store staff were super friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

Expect a good assortment of items with a nice array of brands and prices.

2

Prices are generally affordable, but some items may be priced high for thrift.

3

There is no fitting room or return policy, so check sizes carefully.

03
Bin Stop USA image 1
Outlet store

Outlet store offers Amazon returns and mystery boxes alongside bins of clothes and shoes priced at $3 to $5. Energy stays upbeat with a friendly environment despite crowds. New items arrive daily, creating a wide selection of bargains and hidden gems.

Shoes include Michael Kors styles, though prices like $5 or $2 advertised online do not appear on tags. The store offers a wide variety of footwear alongside clothes and other products.

This thrift store offers a great selection of bargains with prices that feel like a steal. Discounts are too good to pass on, making it a spot for fun bargain finds.

People are saying

"I found so many great bargains at this thrift store."

"I scored amazing stuff for next to nothing here."

"The staff at this Footwear Store were so helpful!"

Good to know

1

The $3 clothing bins and $5 shoe bins offer excellent value.

2

New products arrive every day at Bin Stop USA.

3

Fridays are the best day to shop for new deals.

04
Gift To Earth Thrift Store image 1

Small, cozy thrift store with tight aisles and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Offers a large, well-organized selection of clothes, shoes, accessories, and household goods at affordable prices. Includes a food pantry and donates proceeds to environmental causes.

Offers a large selection of shoes for women, men, and children alongside clothes and accessories. Includes a surplus of vintage finds and options for kids' footwear.

Quality items stand out with many gems and vases offered at bargain prices. Discounts vary by tag color, making it easy to find good deals on unique finds.

People are saying

"This thrift store has a beautiful mission supporting environmental conservation."

"I found a ton of women's clothing to look through and discovered gems."

"I found a huge selection of shoes and vintage finds here."

Good to know

1

The store runs weekly color tag discounts of 75%, 50%, and 25%.

2

They offer a student discount for more affordable shopping.

3

All proceeds go to environmental causes.

05
Revive Consignment / Somerville, NJ image 1

Bright, open space with beautifully curated selections creates an inviting, friendly atmosphere. Clean, organized layout features high-quality designer items and affordable prices. Frequent new inventory and comfortable seating make shopping easy and enjoyable.

Many shoes come in both high-end and casual styles. Shoes are neatly organized by size, making browsing easy. The store offers a mix of designer and discounted footwear options.

Unique eclectic jewelry and vintage handbags stand out here. The 50% room features a mix of vintage bags and modern clothing.

People are saying

"The staff here are the sweetest people ever when helping with women's clothing."

"The staff at this Footwear Store are so friendly and helpful."

"I found so many unique vintage bags and jewelry at this thrift store."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $10-20 for most jeans and tops.

2

New merchandise is displayed frequently, ensuring variety.

3

All items are posted online for easy browsing and purchasing.

06
2nd STREET Westfield image 1
Second hand store

Second hand store offers a huge selection of vintage and designer clothing with fair prices and a clean, trendy layout. The atmosphere stays chill despite some inconsistencies in item condition and pricing. Both men and women find unique pieces ranging from affordable vintage to high-end brands.

A wide variety of vintage and gently used shoes fills the store, with many styles out of date. Some shoes show mixed quality, but YSL sneakers and cowboy boots stand out among the selection.

Affordable vintage and high-end items mix well here. The store offers vintage leather jackets, embroidered sweaters, and designer bags like Coach and MCM at great prices.

People are saying

"The staff here are so helpful finding vintage treasures."

"The thrift store staff are so helpful and kind."

"The staff at this Footwear Store were so pleasant and helpful."

Good to know

1

The store has a huge selection of vintage and gently used clothing.

2

Expect to find high-quality jeans for under $30 in the women's section.

3

Sundays late afternoon offer free public parking nearby.

07
Once Upon a Child Edison image 1
Children's clothing store

Store offers a wide and varied selection of second-hand kids' clothes, toys, and baby gear at affordable prices. Atmosphere feels welcoming and fun, making shopping comfortable for families. Space varies from spacious and organized to sometimes crowded with overflowing items.

Shoes and boots come sorted by size from newborn up, making it easy to find the right fit. The selection includes affordable, great-condition footwear alongside clothes and toys.

Clothing often costs under $3 with regular sales and discounts. Second-hand children's clothes are available, mostly barely used and inexpensive. Selling clothes earns a discount toward purchases.

People are saying

"It's a great spot for Kid Friendly finds, with tons of well-kept clothes and toys."

"I found great items at this thrift store for a fraction of the price."

"I found amazing deals on kids' shoes and apparel for a low price."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide selection of second-hand baby and children's clothes.

2

Prices are generally very affordable, with many items at unbeatable prices.

3

Clearance events provide additional opportunities for great deals on clothing.

08
Plato's Closet Middletown image 1
Used clothing store

Used clothing store offers a spacious, well-organized layout with clothes sorted by color, size, and style. Atmosphere stays friendly and welcoming with good music and a steady flow of customers. Shoppers find affordable, trendy clothes in clean, great condition with many items still tagged.

Offers a large selection of men's shoes including brand new Michael Kors boots priced around $16. Stock ranges from classic professional to comfy sporty styles for all genders and seasons.

More organized than most thrift stores, it offers a stress-free shopping experience. Good finds come with great discounts, making it easy to browse without feeling overwhelmed.

People are saying

"I found the women's clothing to be trendy and affordable."

"I found great deals on shoes and bags at this footwear store."

"This thrift store is super organized by size and color."

Good to know

1

The store offers a huge selection of trendy styles at affordable prices.

2

Everything is clean and in great condition, with many items still having tags.

3

The store is always organized, with clothes sorted by color and size.

09
Market Street Mission Thrift Store - Morristown image 1

Large thrift store spreads over two floors with a bright, clean atmosphere and vintage section upstairs. Music plays lively, creating a sing-along vibe among staff and shoppers. Items range from luxury designer clothing to antiques, with prices reflecting brand and rarity rather than typical thrift affordability.

Staff often go out of their way to find shoes in specific sizes. The footwear selection sits alongside a variety of clothes, jewelry, and bags.

Shelves overflow with amazing second-hand goods and a vintage section upstairs offers beautiful items. The store blends a consignment shop feel with thrift store variety in a clean, bright space.

People are saying

"I found designer clothing and vintage items at great prices in this thrift store."

"I found so many unique vintage items and antiques here."

"I found designer footwear at excellent prices."

Good to know

1

The store has a large selection of clothes, shoes, and housewares.

2

Expect to find a variety of antiques and unique second-hand goods.

3

The store supports a good cause with proceeds from sales.

10
Going, Going, Gone! image 1
Sporting goods store

Climbing wall stands in the middle with staff assisting kids, creating an active atmosphere. Sections for kids' sports gear and well-organized clothing by size make browsing easy. Offers discounted brand-name clothing, rotating stock, and a large fishing section, all in a spacious, clean layout.

A huge selection of shoes, boots, and sports gear comes at discount prices. Shoes and clothes are organized by size, making it easier to find hiking shoes or sneakers. Staff like Amanda and Carol offer helpful advice when picking out footwear.

Offers bargain clothing and shoes with some decent discounts. Prices lean toward being a bit overpriced for a discount store.

People are saying

"I found brand name footwear and sports gear at a discount."

Good to know

1

The store offers many clothing options for all sizes, including name brands at lower prices.

2

Look for a special deal where items marked with an eight grant an additional 50% off.

3

Expect rotating stock; the selection can vary greatly from visit to visit.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...