Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New Jersey

Ice cream and milkshake shops

You want a thick, hand-spun milkshake from a shop that takes its ice cream seriously.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Jabal Creamery image 1
Jabal Creamery image 2
Jabal Creamery image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop features bright Middle Eastern murals and a comfortable seating area with TVs that creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. The vibe is calm and vibrant, making it a popular spot for enjoying unique homemade ice cream flavors. Free samples encourage trying innovative options like knafa and baklava ice cream.

Fresh homemade ice cream features unique flavors that add a fun twist. This spot stands out as a gem among ice cream shops in the area.

Milkshakes come in unique flavors like coffee and biscoff, knafah made from scratch, and S'mores. Options like cookies and cream and caramel offer classic tastes with a rich, creamy texture.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is amazing, fresh, creamy, and full of flavor."

"The ice cream here is so fresh, creamy, and full of flavor."

"The cookies and cream milkshake here is amazing."

Good to know

1

Jabal Creamery offers unique and exotic ice cream flavors not found elsewhere.

2

They are open late, making it a great spot for evening treats.

3

Reservations are not required, and walk-ins are welcome.

02
Callie's Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Bright, clean space with outdoor seating and an adorable, well-designed layout creates a fun, family-friendly vibe. Ice cream flights offer a unique way to sample flavors, while claw machines and a photo booth add playful energy. The atmosphere feels welcoming and lively, appealing to all ages.

Known for its delightful and impeccable ice cream, this shop offers a perfect spot for quick treats or family outings. It stands out as a favorite close to home with consistently great quality.

Biscoff milkshake stands out as a game changer and gets high praise. Chocolate, strawberry, and cookies and cream milkshakes also impress with their rich flavors.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is delicious and handcrafted."

"I thought the Biscoff milkshake was a game changer."

"This ice cream shop has amazing, handcrafted flavors you can't find elsewhere."

Good to know

1

Callie's Creamery hosts character events for kids, including visits from popular characters.

2

They offer a birthday package that includes a craft, ice cream, and character visits.

3

Expect a variety of unique ice cream flavors, with seasonal changes throughout the year.

03
Sweet Parlor Small Batch Ice Cream ๐Ÿฆ image 1

Ice cream shop offers unique handmade flavors like ube, pandan, and guava cheesecake in a modern, Instagram-worthy setting with plenty of seating. The atmosphere feels warm and welcoming with a trendy, clean vibe and bubble waffle cones add a distinctive touch.

Offers unique flavors that stand out from other local shops. Serves small batch ice cream with a fancy tea and ice cream vibe.

Milkshakes come with unique flavors like black sesame and banana ice cream. Options include toppings like whipped cream and graham crumbles for added texture.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream flavors to be uniquely delicious."

"This ice cream shop has so many unique and creative flavors."

"I thought the milkshake was good and yummy."

Good to know

1

Sweet Parlor offers unique flavors made from scratch, including Asian-inspired options.

2

The entire building is peanut safe, making it suitable for those with allergies.

3

They are open late until 11 pm, perfect for late-night ice cream cravings.

04
Park Ice Cream Company image 1

Ice cream shop with a homey atmosphere and friendly vibe offers an incredible variety of flavors, including vegan options. The environment feels fresh and clean, attracting families and locals looking for quality treats. Prices remain unbeatable, making it a popular spot for ice cream lovers.

Family-owned ice cream shop offers fun specials and a cute atmosphere. It serves some of the best ice cream in the area.

Milkshakes feature campfire s'mores and cookies and cream flavors. The fire milkshake stands out as a unique option.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is delicious and has amazing flavors."

"I thought all the ice cream flavors here were very good."

"I believed they had the best milkshakes in the area."

Good to know

1

Parking on the street is accessible.

2

The dine-in space is very limited.

3

They introduce new flavors regularly.

05
Dumbo Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers bright and airy space with fun sidewalk tables and spacious indoor seating. Atmosphere feels welcoming and cozy, inviting guests to relax inside or outdoors. The vibe stays clean and lively, making it a pleasant spot to enjoy a treat.

Offers affordable prices and maintains a clean, cute environment. Serves quality ice cream that stands out among local shops.

Chocolate and peanut butter milkshakes stand out with rich, creamy flavors. Vanilla milkshakes also taste really good, served alongside cones and special sundaes.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream to be the best I ever had."

"The ice cream here is so creamy and full of flavor."

"I found the milkshakes really delicious and creamy."

Good to know

1

Dumbo Ice Cream offers 32 flavors, including vegan options.

2

Prices are fair, and portions are generous.

3

Dumbo Ice Cream is open seven days a week year-round.

06
It's Delicious Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop offers clean, bright space with indoor and outdoor seating featuring board games and outdoor activities for families. Atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, suitable for relaxed hangouts or quick treats. Friendly environment includes generous samples and supports community causes.

Bright and clean space welcomes families and anyone craving a treat. Staff stays lovely and the ice cream is consistently delicious and highly recommended for events or casual stops.

Milkshakes here are consistently excellent and come alongside cakes that complement them well.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I ever had."

"The ice cream here is rich, creamy, and packed with amazing flavors."

"The milkshakes here are awesome."

Good to know

1

Every Friday night during summer, they host live music and a food truck.

2

They offer a variety of homemade ice cream flavors, including dairy-free options.

3

The location has plenty of parking available for visitors.

07
Mooโ€™s Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers wide selection of unique flavors with homemade options and huge portion sizes. Atmosphere feels friendly and welcoming, with family-friendly seating inside. Energy stays relaxed, making it a good spot to hang out.

Handmade ice cream pairs with fresh baked goods made on site. Staff offers the friendliest service found in any ice cream shop.

Milkshakes come in black and white and cappuccino chocolate flavors. They pair well with the cinnamon ninja Belgium waffle and use in-house made ice cream.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is amazing and so creamy."

"The staff at this ice cream shop are the friendliest I've ever encountered."

"The staff here is super friendly and sweet when you get your milkshake."

Good to know

1

Mooโ€™s Creamery offers a wide selection of unique ice cream flavors.

2

Prices for ice cream cones are around $12 for two large cones.

3

The menu features fresh baked goods and smoothie bowls.

08
Trina's Treats image 1
Chocolate shop

Small chocolate shop with cute pink princess decor and an old-fashioned ice cream parlor vibe. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, popular with families and friends after school. Known for wide variety of ice cream flavors and beautifully designed chocolates.

Decor resembles an old-fashioned ice cream parlor with a super cute vibe. The shop offers a very good selection of ice cream.

Milkshakes come extremely large and decadent with a thick texture. Coffee milkshakes balance flavor and creaminess well.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is delicious, creamy, and flavorful."

"It's a super cute ice cream shop, nicely decorated like an old-fashioned parlor."

"I found their milkshakes to be to die for."

Good to know

1

Parking is difficult, so plan accordingly.

2

Credit cards are accepted, but they do not carry change for large bills.

3

Prices are affordable, and portions are generous.

09
Avery & Jay's Handcrafted Ice Cream image 1

Bright, clean space with outdoor seating under trees creates a cozy atmosphere. Wide variety of unique ice cream flavors including homemade soft serve draws a diverse crowd. Prices lean toward the higher side but quality and selection stand out.

Handcrafted ice cream stands out with a beautiful shop design that creates a happy vibe. The experience feels positive and welcoming throughout.

Vanilla milkshake offers a perfect blend and texture. Large size contains mostly milk with only two half scoops of ice cream.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is delicious, especially the cappuccino flavor."

"This is the best ice cream shop I've ever been to."

"The milkshake has a perfect blend and texture."

Good to know

1

The shop offers free taste samples to help you decide on flavors.

2

Expect to pay around $10 for two scoops of ice cream.

3

The store is a kosher ice cream shop.

10
Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice image 1

Cute corner spot with a clean, inviting atmosphere and a strong family appeal. Offers freshly made ice cream and Italian ice with unique, rich flavors and smooth, creamy texture. The vibe is friendly and welcoming, with a focus on quality and variety.

Small shop offers Italian ices alongside a few choices of hard ice cream and pre-packaged containers. Premium quality stands out despite limited selection.

Milkshakes here stand out for their homemade flavors like strawberry and apple pie. The chocolate peanut butter option offers a rich taste, and sizes like the medium vanilla come at around $8.80.

People are saying

"I thought the homemade ice cream was the best."

"This ice cream shop has the best ice cream I've ever tasted."

"I thought their apple pie milkshake was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

There is inadequate parking at the facility.

2

There is a 3.99% surcharge for credit card payments.

3

All products are freshly made in-house by Mr. Jordan and his wife Tatiana.

11
Harvy's image 1
Ice cream shop

Small ice cream shop blends old-school charm with modern indulgence and features comfortable seating including outdoor options. Atmosphere is cozy and relaxing with South Indian and Bollywood music creating a unique cultural vibe. Offers unique Indian-inspired flavors not commonly found elsewhere.

Offers a large menu of exotic and traditional flavors with options not found elsewhere. Provides comfortable seating and exceptional customer service that stands out from typical ice cream shops.

Milkshakes use premium Belgian chocolate and come in a portion size similar to Shake Shack or Five Guys. They taste very tasty and amazing, though tap water is added during preparation.

People are saying

"You have to try the Indian-inspired ice cream flavors here."

"I thought the milkshake here was amazing and the best."

"I thought this was a great ice cream shop."

Good to know

1

Harvy's kitchen for hot foods closes around 10:30 pm.

2

Harvy's is open until 3am on weekends.

3

The prices are very affordable, with meals for three costing just over $30.

12
Boza Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Small, clean space with modern design and a fresh baked cookie scent creates a zen vibe. Coffee bar sits to one side, ice cream service to the other, with a tasting station speeding up busy times. Outdoor seating is limited but peaceful, and the shop stays lively late into the night.

Homemade ice cream stands out here, with flavors that surpass mainstream shops. The shop stays open late, offering a rare late-night ice cream option.

Milkshakes feature top notch quality and freshness in both ice cream and milk. The birthday cake milkshake comes with whipped cream on top.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so fresh and delicious."

"I loved their homemade ice cream and milkshakes."

"I'd never experienced homemade ice cream this good."

Good to know

1

Boza Creamery is open until 11PM, making it a late-night option.

2

There is plenty of parking available near the shop.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but check for any promotions before visiting.

13
Mister Softee Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop offers amazing homemade ice cream with many unique flavors like cannoli cream and Bananas Foster. Atmosphere varies from clean and calm to occasionally unprofessional and unsupervised. Prices tend to be high compared to portion sizes.

Delightful flavors and a solid selection make this ice cream shop stand out. Some visits bring a great experience, while others lead to deciding not to return.

Milkshakes come with rich ice cream and a smooth texture. A vanilla milkshake costs around $11.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best I had."

"The staff here is so patient and pleasant with kids."

"I thought the ice cream here was delicious with so many flavors."

Good to know

1

Expect high prices, with $15 for two small cones and $35 for three sundaes.

2

Lactose-free options are not available, which may disappoint lactose intolerant visitors.

3

The establishment has been noted for its cleanliness, but some reviews suggest otherwise.

14
Carvel image 1
Ice cream shop

Bright, clean space offers a cozy vibe with well-organized layout and spotless counters. Energy feels welcoming and positive, attracting families and kids who enjoy the atmosphere. Ice cream cakes stand out for their colorful, creative designs and quick preparation.

Local spot offers classic ice cream flavors with a straightforward menu. Visits show it as a reliable choice for casual ice cream cravings.

Milkshakes come with custom toppings and are well made. Options include unique flavors like cold brew coffee ice cream.

People are saying

"The ice cream cakes here taste amazing and are better than store-bought."

"I loved the ice cream, especially the marshmallow pops!"

"They made awesome milkshakes, really well made."

Good to know

1

The ice cream cakes are made fresh every 10 to 14 days.

2

Reservations for cakes are recommended for special occasions.

3

The store maintains high cleanliness standards with spotless counters.

15
Maroons Creamery - Hand Crafted Ice Cream image 1

Ice cream shop offers wide variety of flavors with options for sampling and includes sugar-free and eggless choices. Interior is modern and clean with limited indoor seating and some outdoor options. Atmosphere feels welcoming and cozy despite occasional heat and lack of music.

Offers extraordinary ice cream with a strong reputation. Faces competition from a nearby shop with a better location. Fulfills demand for an uptown ice cream spot after a previous closure.

The Tuscan Truffle Milkshake with Oreo Cookies stands out as a unique option. Milkshakes tend to be small in quantity, and some lack strong flavor or quality.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is rich, creamy, and full of flavor."

"The ice cream flavors here are mind-blowing and unique."

"The Tuscan Truffle Milkshake with Oreo Cookies is delicious."

Good to know

1

Seating is limited, so plan accordingly during busy hours.

2

Expect to find unique flavors like strawberry lychee and black sesame.

3

There was a $1.25 charge for the cone that was not disclosed beforehand.

16
Custard Hut image 1
Ice cream shop

Outdoor seating with shaded benches creates a clean, relaxed space to enjoy ice cream. The shop offers classic American flavors with some unique combinations and packed cones. Lines can form, reflecting steady local popularity.

Classic American custard stands out here with simple, traditional flavors. The shop offers a straightforward, nostalgic ice cream experience.

Milkshakes start thin and taste like chocolate milk but thicken after several sips to a more classic texture. Prices are high for the size, and quality varies from just okay to really creamy.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was phenomenal and delicious."

"The milkshake tasted like chocolate milk at first."

"The ice cream here is really good."

Good to know

1

A small cone with chocolate Jimmies costs $6.

2

Parking was limited, but the neighborhood was walkable.

3

Custard Hut had outdoor seating only.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...