Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Sandwiches in Middletown

You want a quick, reliable lunch that doesn't compromise on the quality of the bread or fillings.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Slater's Deli & Caterers image 1
Slater's Deli & Caterers image 2
Slater's Deli & Caterers image 3
View all

Old-school deli offers a cozy vibe with generous portions and traditional Jersey Italian American feel. Breakfast sandwiches feature thick pork roll slices and fresh ingredients, often with extras like hash browns. Parking is easy and prices stay reasonable.

Breakfast sandwiches come stacked with thick pork roll slices and fresh ingredients. Sizes are huge, often with extras like hash browns, and prices stay reasonable compared to other shops.

People are saying

"This breakfast sandwich is huge and amazing."

"You have to try the pork roll, egg, and cheese sandwich at the Deli."

"I've never had such a stacked breakfast sandwich before!"

Good to know

1

Parking is available right in front of the deli for convenience.

2

I found it best to order ahead because the place can be quite busy.

3

The deli has been under the same ownership for over 40 years.

02
Sungate Deli & Dairy image 1

Hole-in-the-wall deli shines with friendly vibe and spotless cleanliness. Sandwiches, especially breakfast sandwiches, are consistently tasty and satisfying. Menu offers solid options for both sandwiches and breakfast.

Good sandwiches stand out here, including breakfast sandwiches that are solid and enjoyable. The offerings consistently deliver on taste and quality.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were really good."

"The breakfast staff here are super friendly and nice."

Good to know

1

The deli offers a variety of sandwiches and dairy products.

2

Cash and credit cards are accepted for payment.

3

Check for daily specials that may not be on the menu.

03
Jersey Mike's Subs image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers classic flavors with a clean dining environment and ample parking. Youthful staff create a lively atmosphere while carefully preparing tasty, filling sandwiches. Special orders get extra attention for quality and taste.

Sandwiches come with great selections and franchise favorites that are easy to eat and filling. Staff show care by thoroughly cleaning for special orders and sometimes make sandwiches themselves, ensuring tasty results.

People are saying

"The staff here are super nice and give great sandwiches."

"The food here is really nice and accommodating."

Good to know

1

The location has ample parking available in the strip mall.

2

The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness.

3

The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly.

04
Broadway Hot & Honey Chicken image 1

Nashville-themed spot offers bold flavors in chicken sandwiches like Nashville Hot and cowboy styles. Open kitchen and murals create a vibrant atmosphere with lively country music. Seating blends Southern charm and modern design for a cozy, welcoming feel.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with big pieces of tender chicken and bold flavors like Nashville Hot and cowboy styles. Options like the Nashville Chicken Caesar Wrap and boneless tenders offer crispy, flavorful choices.

People are saying

"I thought the chicken wrap was the best I've ever had."

"You have to try the milkshakes; they're great."

"I found the chicken in the sandwich to be incredibly fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $40 for two sandwiches and fries.

2

The restaurant offers generous portions for the price.

3

The food is made to order, ensuring freshness.

05
D'Alessio's Bagel Express image 1

Fresh hot bagels shine with quality but cream cheese stays plain. Breakfast sandwiches feature pork roll and eggs for a hearty start. Large parking and quick service make it perfect for a fast breakfast stop.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out here, especially with options like pork roll and eggs. The spot operates mainly as a deli with a full Bors Head selection, not just a bagel bakery.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels were really fresh and tasty."

"I enjoyed the great food here."

"I thought the breakfast sandwich was amazing."

Good to know

1

This place is mainly a deli with a full Boar's Head selection.

2

There are no cream cheese options other than plain.

3

The location is convenient for a quick breakfast stop.

06
Rosie's Pizza of Middletown image 1

Small space with few tables creates an intimate vibe. Pizza shines with sourdough crust and world-class dough, served whole only. Meatball sandwich stands out with homemade bread offering a perfect crunch and moistness, making it a tasty twist on the classic.

Meatball sandwich features homemade bread with a perfect crunch that keeps it moist and fresh. The sandwich offers an interesting twist on the typical meatball parm, making it very tasty.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza was one of the best I've had."

"The sourdough pizza crust is crispy, light, and airy."

"The meatball sandwich is super tasty and not your typical one."

Good to know

1

You cannot just walk in and grab a slice or pie; they only sell whole pizzas.

2

Reservations are recommended to ensure you get your pizza on busy nights.

3

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

07
Burger Kraze image 1
Restaurant

Enjoy juicy spicy chicken sandwiches and perfectly cooked burgers in a clean, modern spot with a lively K-pop vibe. Giant flatscreens play music videos, adding energy to the somewhat cramped seating. Unique onion rings complete the friendly, vibrant experience.

Spicy chicken sandwiches come out juicy and tender without being greasy. The buldak chicken sandwich offers a flavorful and crispy bite. Classic cheeseburgers and chicken sandwiches look and taste well-made and satisfying.

People are saying

"These burgers are big, juicy, and cooked perfectly."

"The onion rings are cooked perfectly, crunchy and not oily."

"The Buldak chicken sandwich is flavorful and crispy."

Good to know

1

The menu includes unique Korean-inspired burger options.

2

Vegetarian options are available on the menu.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

08
Sissy's Place image 1
American restaurant

Diner serves fantastic breakfast sandwiches in a cozy, hometown setting with friendly atmosphere. Quick, affordable meals attract locals for breakfast and lunch. Practical features include cash-only policy and ample parking.

Breakfast sandwiches stand out with their fantastic flavor. The menu includes wraps and lunch sandwiches, offering variety beyond breakfast.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"The breakfast sandwiches here are fantastic."

"I enjoyed the great sandwiches they offered."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is cash only; bring cash for payment.

2

They offer daily specials that can save you money.

3

Parking is easy with ample space in the strip mall.

09
DeVito's Dogs & Grille image 1

Bright, spotless space offers a casual vibe with a view of grill and fryer. Chicken sandwiches come grilled or crispy with peppers and onions. Friendly atmosphere feels like a community hub where people relax and enjoy.

Chicken sandwiches come with grilled or crispy options and often include peppers, onions, and potatoes. Prices can be over $30 with fries, and sides like crispy onion rings with honey mustard are popular.

People are saying

"I thought the hot dogs here were the best I've had."

"The onion rings were perfectly fried and not greasy."

"I found the devito's burger sandwich to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is available right out front for easy access.

2

Prices for hot dogs are around $8 each, which some may find high.

3

Expect to pay over $60 for a family of four for hot dogs, fries, and drinks.

10
The Bagel Nook image 1
Bagel shop

Bright, colorful shop offers overstuffed bagels and a self-serve coffee bar with many options. Cozy seating inside and out invites you to enjoy a potato skin bagel biggie or classic breakfast sandwich. Variety and freshness make it a top spot.

Variety stands out with overstuffed bagels and classic breakfast sandwiches. The potato skin bagel biggie offers a filling, flavorful option among endless sandwich combinations.

People are saying

"The bagels here have so many unique and interesting flavors."

"The staff here is so friendly, it makes ordering a sandwich a great experience."

"I think this breakfast sandwich might be the best I've had."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a wide variety of bagels and cream cheeses.

2

Prices for bagels can be higher than average in the area.

3

The facilities are reported to be very clean and well-maintained.

11
Claudie's Chicken image 1
Chicken restaurant

Offers large chicken sandwiches with thick grilled chicken and unique sauces like BBQ and ranchero. Wings and fried chicken are fresh and moist with generous portions. Casual spot with neat packaging keeps food tasty and ready for grab-and-go.

Chicken sandwiches come in large sizes with many options. They feature thick grilled chicken and unique sauces like a special BBQ and ranchero style.

People are saying

"This American food is the best fried chicken I've ever eaten."

"You have to try the buffalo chicken wrap; it's perfect."

"The chicken sandwiches here are huge and have many options."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is located in the parking lot behind Dunkin' and the laundromat.

2

Claudie's Chicken has been enjoyed for over 50 years, known for quality chicken.

3

The menu includes wraps, handhelds, sides, full dinner options, and family-sized meals.

12
PAT'S MARKET PRIME "The Neighborhood Butcher Shop" image 1

Butcher shop serves American wagyu and prime beef with fresh ingredients in sandwiches. Family-friendly spot offers generous portions but prices can be high. Interior is immaculate and well-stocked, perfect for quality meat lovers.

Sandwiches come with high-quality meat and fresh ingredients. Prices run around $15 for a ham and Swiss on a roll, without extras like chips or drinks.

People are saying

"I thought the steaks here tasted much better than other stores."

"I got the best filet mignon and fresh, high-quality meat at this grocery store."

"I wish I could display this sandwich; it's the best."

Good to know

1

The market offers a variety of high-quality meats and Italian products.

2

Expect to pay around $14.93 for a sandwich without extras.

3

The butcher recommends the Spinalis dorsi ribeye for a premium cut.

13
Frozen Flavors Homemade Ice Cream & Italian Ice image 1

Cute corner spot offers freshly made ice cream with rich, smooth texture and unique flavors. Ice cream sandwiches shine with homemade quality and creative options like bubble waffles. Friendly vibe and strong family appeal make it inviting for all ages.

Ice cream sandwiches stand out with unique flavors and homemade quality. The menu also includes bubble waffles and cones alongside the sandwiches.

People are saying

"I thought the homemade ice cream was the best."

"It's so kid friendly; the owners make my children feel special."

"You have to try the homemade ice cream sandwiches; they're so popular."

Good to know

1

There is inadequate parking at the facility.

2

There is a 3.99% surcharge for credit card payments.

3

All products are freshly made in-house by Mr. Jordan and his wife Tatiana.

14
Atlantic Bagel Lincroft image 1

Bagel shop shines with delicious bagels and a clean dining area that includes outdoor seating. Sandwiches impress with thinly sliced turkey and tasty breakfast options like bacon, egg, and cheese. Busy on Sundays, expect some wait times due to its popularity.

Sandwiches feature thinly sliced turkey, chicken cutlet with roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella, and pork roll with cheese. Breakfast sandwiches like bacon, egg, and cheese are usually good and priced around $9.

People are saying

"These bagels are delicious; I've never had better."

"I had a warm, juicy, and well-seasoned sandwich."

"I couldn't imagine a bagel being any better than these."

Good to know

1

Prices for bagels start at $8.50, with some sandwiches costing $9.15.

2

Expect busy Sunday mornings, which may lead to longer wait times.

3

The shop often runs out of whole wheat bagels early on weekends.

Discover more

Middletown Township, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...