Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New Jersey

Vintage jewelry shops

Made for those who exclusively hunt for vintage jewelry and unique, storied pieces.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Braunschweiger Jewelers image 1
Braunschweiger Jewelers image 2
Braunschweiger Jewelers image 3
View all

Jewelry store offers a stunning selection of high-quality pieces with exceptional attention to detail. Family-run atmosphere feels personal and professional, combining sales with repair and cleaning services for a full-service experience.

5-star service and attention to detail stand out when buying jewelry, repairing pieces, or replacing watch batteries. Custom pieces get special care, vintage rings are expertly sized, and old jewelry can be repurposed with thoughtful suggestions.

Offers a mix of custom, new, and vintage pieces with a steady selection of vintage items like a gold pendant. Staff at the location are familiar with frequent visits for redesigns and vintage finds.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store were so helpful and friendly."

"The staff at this Ring Store made finding my fiancΓ©e's ring feel easy and special."

"I've been a customer my whole life and will always give my business here."

Good to know

1

Braunschweiger Jewelers offers jewelry repair services, making it a one-stop shop.

2

They have a 'wish list' feature for future purchases or gifts.

3

Replacing a watch battery costs $25.

02
Queen May image 1
Jewelry store

Beautiful shop filled with unique jewelry and luxury pre-owned items creates a relaxed atmosphere where passionate people share their love for fine pieces. The selection includes vintage watches, handbags, and timeless treasures for various budgets.

Offers a stunning selection of high-end jewelry, watches, and luxury bags with top-notch quality. Staff provides knowledgeable help to find perfect pieces and handles repairs with care.

Offers gorgeous jewelry and vintage bags including pieces like a vintage Louis Vuitton purse. Both vintage and new jewelry selections are available.

People are saying

"I found this jewelry store's selection of unique treasures to be amazing."

"The staff at this vintage shop felt like family, always friendly and helpful."

"I found a beautiful selection of luxurious jewelry and bags here."

Good to know

1

Queen May offers a wide selection of unique and high-quality jewelry.

2

Online shopping is available, allowing out-of-state customers to browse inventory.

3

Delivery is prompt, with items beautifully packaged upon arrival.

03
Revive Consignment / Somerville, NJ image 1

Bright, open space with beautifully curated selections creates an inviting, friendly atmosphere. Clean, organized layout features high-quality designer items and affordable prices. Frequent new inventory and comfortable seating make shopping easy and enjoyable.

Unique and eclectic jewelry pieces stand out in a collection that also includes scarves, bags, and shoes. Affordable prices and attentive service like sterling silver polishing add to the appeal.

Many unique vintage handbags and eclectic jewelry pieces stand out here. The selection blends vintage and modern items well, including some great vintage bags and modern clothing.

People are saying

"The staff here are the sweetest people ever when helping with women's clothing."

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so kind and helpful."

"I found so many unique vintage items, like jewelry and bags."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $10-20 for most jeans and tops.

2

New merchandise is displayed frequently, ensuring variety.

3

All items are posted online for easy browsing and purchasing.

04
Gift To Earth Thrift Store image 1

Small, cozy thrift store with tight aisles and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Offers a large, well-organized selection of clothes, shoes, accessories, and household goods at affordable prices. Includes a food pantry and donates proceeds to environmental causes.

Many cool rings and lovely jewelry pieces stand out here. The selection includes a variety of styles suitable for different tastes.

Selection includes a large variety of vintage shoes and many antique items. Mix of modern clothes and vintage brands appears, but some items blur the line between outdated and true vintage.

People are saying

"This thrift store has a beautiful mission supporting environmental conservation."

"The customer service at this Jewelry Store was so friendly and good."

"The Vintage Shop cashier was super friendly and nice."

Good to know

1

The store runs weekly color tag discounts of 75%, 50%, and 25%.

2

They offer a student discount for more affordable shopping.

3

All proceeds go to environmental causes.

05
West End Garage image 1
Shopping mall

Large space with eclectic booths offers unique antiques and handmade local goods. Atmosphere feels artsy and nostalgic, inviting slow browsing and discovery. Cozy cafe with excellent pastries complements the shopping experience.

Offers a wide range of vintage fine jewelry and handcrafted pieces alongside indie brand accessories. Staff provide personalized assistance to help find unique gifts.

A mix of antiques, handmade pottery, and vintage fine jewelry fills the space. Small booths offer local art, vintage clothing, and unique collectibles like 60s items and Pyrex pieces.

People are saying

"I found so many unique treasures and cool items here."

"I found this vintage shop to be a treasure trove of unique finds."

"I found vintage fine jewelry and unique finds at the jewelry stalls."

Good to know

1

All sales are final at West End Garage.

2

Expect a variety of unique items from local artisans and vendors.

3

Bring cash for some vendors as not all accept credit cards.

06
Vintage Anchor image 1

Boutique offers unique retro clothing and exclusive Italian pieces that are light and comfortable. Atmosphere feels casual yet chic, with a selection that stands apart from typical boardwalk stores. Items include beautifully curated jewelry and accessories at reasonable prices.

Beautifully curated jewelry and accessories offer a variety of styles. Options include cute pieces suitable for kids and items that can elevate any look.

Retro clothing and fun items stand out here. A friendly owner adds to the vibe, making it feel different from typical boardwalk shops.

People are saying

"I found such unique and special jewelry pieces here."

"Valerie picked out gorgeous unique pieces just for me."

"The Vintage Shop owner and staff are so nice and friendly."

Good to know

1

The boutique offers unique, one-of-a-kind pieces not found in typical stores.

2

Prices are reasonable for the quality of items available.

3

Expect a friendly atmosphere with personalized service from the owner.

07
Days Of Olde Antique Center image 1

A vast antique store spans over 20,000 square feet with many individual booths and themed sections. The atmosphere feels like a nostalgic walk down memory lane with 50s and 60s music playing softly. Clean, spacious, and wheelchair accessible, it invites long browsing sessions through a wide variety of vintage items.

Many vintage and antique jewelry pieces stand out here, alongside unique collectibles. The selection includes a mix of pretty items that catch the eye.

Booths filled with a wide variety of vintage items like sterling silver, oriental rugs, and 1930s-1950s accessories create a nostalgic vibe. The shop offers tons of collectibles including jewelry, furniture, and kitchenware, all at reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I found so many neat vintage items separated into booths."

"I found a huge selection and great variety of vintage items here."

"This jewelry store is huge, with tons of cool vintage items and collectibles."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of free parking available.

2

Handicap parking is accessible.

3

The store is over 21,000 square feet, making it one of the largest in Southern New Jersey.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...