Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New Jersey

Reuben sandwiches

A proper Reuben is a non-negotiable standard that defines your entire lunch hour.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Brick City Market image 1
Brick City Market image 2
Brick City Market image 3
View all

Cozy cafe buzzes with a friendly crowd and clean design. Known for healthy food and excellent sandwiches, it handles large orders with ease. The Reuben sandwich is a standout, ranked among the best in Newark and the US.

Offers a Reuben sandwich that stands out for its consistent quality and is considered among the best in Newark and even the US.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was great and always cooked fresh."

"I loved their breakfast; it was my go-to spot."

"I found the Reuben sandwich to be the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Brick City Market offers a diverse menu with salads, pressed juices, wraps, and hot dishes.

2

The restaurant is known for its cleanliness and welcoming atmosphere.

3

There are many vegan options available on the menu.

02
Flemington Deli image 1

Small deli offers a warm atmosphere and friendly staff. Reuben sandwiches shine with perfect proportions and well-balanced flavors. Fresh breakfast items add to the cozy, inviting vibe.

Corned beef and pastrami versions come with perfect proportions of ingredients. The Reuben sandwiches feature delicious, well-balanced flavors and stand out among cold deli options.

People are saying

"The breakfast here is served with the friendliest welcome."

"The lunch spot's service is amazing and the second you walk in."

"I found the Reuben sandwich expertly constructed and delicious."

Good to know

1

Flemington Deli charges a 4% surcharge for card payments.

2

Parking is limited around Flemington Deli.

3

Menu prices may not reflect actual prices due to recent increases.

03
COMPTONโ€™S image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop shines with hot pastrami in its Reuben, offering a tasty, satisfying bite. Space feels immaculate and cool, with old-school Pac-Man and Connect Four on tables. Atmosphere stays chill and relaxed while keeping a clean, professional vibe.

Hot pastrami forms the base of the flavorful Reuben here. It delivers a tasty, satisfying sandwich experience.

People are saying

"I found COMPTONโ€™S to have massive, flavor-packed sandwiches."

"I recommend the American Food here to all my friends."

"I highly recommend the Reuben; it's very tasty and flavorful."

Good to know

1

The menu offers a fantastic variety of sandwiches and unique recipes.

2

Expect good portion sizes; they are generous with ingredients like turkey and sauces.

3

The shop is dog-friendly, allowing pets on the patio.

04
Berg's Smoked Meat & Poutine image 1

Cozy spot with a laid-back vibe and warm, smoky aroma. Reuben shines with thick pastrami that's juicy and well-seasoned. Outdoor tables add charm while mini poutine offers a tasty side.

Thick, tender pastrami defines the Reuben here, staying juicy and well-seasoned. The sandwich pairs well with sides like mini poutine and features a house-smoked flavor that stands out.

People are saying

"I thought the pastrami sandwich was out of this world delicious."

"The pastrami here is out of this world delicious."

"I thought the Reuben was amazing, packed with flavorful meat."

Good to know

1

Street parking is available near the establishment.

2

The indoor seating is limited, so plan for takeout.

3

Each sandwich comes with either coleslaw or potato salad and a pickle.

05
Pastrami hut NY Style Delicatessen image 1

Classic New York deli serves juicy pastrami in a spectacular Reuben sandwich. Generous portions come with crispy onion rings. Clean, inviting vibe recalls traditional delis with homemade menu favorites.

The Reuben sandwich features pastrami and stands out for its spectacular flavor. It pairs well with a side of onion rings.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always hot."

"This pastrami sandwich is piled high, juicy, and flavorful."

"I thought the Reuben sandwich was spectacular."

Good to know

1

Online ordering is easy and efficient for takeout.

2

The restaurant has recently lowered its prices.

3

Most menu items are homemade, ensuring quality.

06
Pastrami Grill Bistro image 1

Small deli offers open kitchen where chefs prepare sandwiches and provide meat samples. Pastrami Reuben shines with rich flavor and hearty layers. Cozy booths and nostalgic decor create a tight but inviting space, with most customers opting for takeout or outdoor seating.

Pastrami Reuben stands out with its rich flavor and satisfying layers. Sandwiches here, especially the Reuben, deliver a delicious and hearty experience.

People are saying

"I thought the pastrami sandwich was out of this world."

"This deli's pastrami is thick-cut, juicy, and better than Katz's."

"I found the pastrami and corned beef Reuben to be the best."

Good to know

1

Bring cash to leave a tip and avoid a 3% credit surcharge.

2

Seating might not be available during lunch or dinner hours.

3

Parking is available nearby for customers.

07
Kelly's Tavern image 1

Dark, cool interior with vintage decor and a heated bar contrasts with a large outdoor patio. Corned beef stacked high defines the Reuben sandwiches here. Live weekend music adds to the lively atmosphere enjoyed by families and locals alike.

Corned beef stacked high and perfectly cooked defines the Reuben here. Large portions make it easy to take some home, and the mini version packs a lot of flavor in a smaller size.

People are saying

"I thought the Reuben sandwich was the best I've ever had."

"It's a great Irish pub with an upbeat crowd and good food."

"The sushi here is spot on and the sashimi is the freshest."

Good to know

1

Bingo night happens every Wednesday at 7pm with no entry fee.

2

Expect long wait times on busy holidays like St. Paddy's Day.

3

A 3.5% convenience fee applies to credit card payments.

08
Dublin Pub image 1

Small bar with wrap-around design offers a lively, crowded vibe. Reuben features light corned beef and comes with sweet potato fries. Regular live Irish music adds an upscale Irish pub feel, though noise levels are high, making chat tough.

Corned beef in the Reuben is very light. It comes with sweet potato fries as a side option. The sandwich is served alongside other deli-style options like Hot Pastrami.

People are saying

"The American food, like the pot pie and shepherd's pie, is delicious."

"It felt like stepping into an authentic Irish pub with great drinks."

"I thought the Reuben was delicious, a solid 9.5/10."

Good to know

1

The pub is located steps from the Mayo, making it a perfect date day destination.

2

The parking situation is like city parking, with no dedicated parking lot.

3

They charge $2 for 'rocks' (ice), $1 for a mixer, and $13 for vodka.

09
Brick House Pub & Grille image 1

Small pub buzzes with loud music and a pool table that moves often, creating a lively, family-friendly vibe. Reuben sandwiches feature thinly sliced corned beef and sometimes Thousand Island dressing, though bread can get soggy. Karaoke nights boost the cozy, engaging atmosphere.

Corned beef in the Reuben is thinly sliced and tasty, melting in the mouth. Some sandwiches come with Thousand Island dressing and sauerkraut, but the bread can get soggy and the sandwich may not be grilled properly.

People are saying

"I was a regular during packed karaoke nights."

"The bartenders at this Local Spot make you feel like family."

"I thought the grilled Reuben was the best I've had."

Good to know

1

Karaoke sessions happen every Wednesday night, starting at 8pm.

2

Expect a busy atmosphere during karaoke nights, so arrive early for a good spot.

3

The pub serves food until 10pm on weekdays, but check for weekend hours.

10
Cafe Airlie image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers spacious seating and a cozy vibe downtown. Reuben features classic deli flavor with corned beef tasting like hotdog. Large portions and great bread-to-meat balance make it a popular quick bite spot.

Corned beef in the Reuben tastes like a hotdog. The sandwich costs about $19.50 each when ordered with others. It delivers a classic deli flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches were fresh and delicious."

"It felt like eating breakfast with family, everyone was so friendly."

"I found my Reuben sandwich to be great."

Good to know

1

Cafe Airlie opens at 7 AM but often runs out of key ingredients by 7:30 AM.

2

Expect to wait 15 minutes or more if you don't order ahead.

3

Parking is hard to find; consider calling in advance to place an order.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...