Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New Jersey

Unique watch stores

You aren't interested in mass-produced timepieces that everyone else is wearing.

Based on 715 Opinions
+712
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Watches of Switzerland image 1
Watches of Switzerland image 2
Watches of Switzerland image 3
View all

Store offers a beautifully designed showroom with luxurious atmosphere and friendly, professional staff who create an inviting and personal experience. Spacious displays feature various high-end watch brands allowing hands-on viewing in a stylish setting.

Exceptional customer service stands out with knowledgeable staff like James, Maria, and Karen. The store offers a wide selection of luxury watches including Rolex Day-Date, Explorer, and GMT models, making purchases smooth and satisfying.

Exceptional attention from staff creates a memorable and dream-fulfilling experience quickly and personally.

People are saying

"The staff at this watch store are so helpful and knowledgeable."

"Adela and Aaron made my 50th birthday celebration feel incredibly special."

"The personalized service from staff like Mariella and Katherine makes the experience truly unique."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait for Rolex watches at this boutique.

2

The store has a great selection of watches from various brands.

3

Ask for Aaron or Philip for personalized assistance.

02
Queen May image 1
Jewelry store

Beautiful shop filled with unique jewelry and luxury pre-owned items creates a relaxed atmosphere where passionate people share their love for fine pieces. The selection includes vintage watches, handbags, and timeless treasures for various budgets.

A fantastic inventory of vintage watches and luxury timepieces stands out here. Staff provide expert help to find and care for authentic, pre-owned watches in perfect condition.

Offers a wide range of unique jewelry selections and timeless treasures. Includes luxury pre-owned watches with some rare finds across all budgets.

People are saying

"I found this jewelry store's selection of unique treasures to be amazing."

"The staff at this watch store are super knowledgeable experts."

"I found their jewelry selection to be unique and amazing."

Good to know

1

Queen May offers a wide selection of unique and high-quality jewelry.

2

Online shopping is available, allowing out-of-state customers to browse inventory.

3

Delivery is prompt, with items beautifully packaged upon arrival.

03
Rolex Boutique Short Hills image 1

Boutique offers a luxurious, welcoming atmosphere with elegant, well-appointed interiors and impeccable attention to detail. Staff create a comfortable, personalized experience where guests can explore watches in a relaxed setting with private seating and refreshments. The showroom displays a wide variety of sophisticated timepieces in a bright, immaculate space.

Rolex watches like the 2023 Submariner Date are available here. Staff such as Alberto handle purchases directly, making the process straightforward.

Purchasing a timepiece here feels one-of-a-kind and personal, not just transactional. Staff like Alberto and Christopher Grey provide specialized assistance that makes the experience stand out.

People are saying

"The knowledgeable staff at these boutiques made my Rolex acquisition memorable."

"The service here makes the luxurious shopping experience personal and exciting."

"Alberto's knowledge of Rolex watches is impressive and attentive."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for a personalized shopping experience.

2

Expect long wait times for popular Rolex models, potentially up to a year.

3

The store offers free parking at the mall for customers.

04
Shin Brothers Jewelers Inc. image 1

Jewelry store offers a relaxed atmosphere with family-owned trustworthiness and fair, upfront pricing. Selection includes unique, high-quality pieces and expert repairs that restore items to like-new condition quickly. Customers receive attentive service, including small amenities like bottled water while waiting.

Watches get handled with great care and set to the precise time when returned. Services include link adjustments and battery replacements, all at consistent low prices.

Offers a unique, high-quality selection of jewelry with great prices. Pieces stand out and attract compliments.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so kind and helpful."

"The staff here made me feel so welcome and comfortable."

"This Watch Store's service is so rare and they're genuinely good people."

Good to know

1

Jewelry repairs typically take a couple of hours and cost around $150.

2

Expect fair and upfront pricing on all jewelry purchases.

3

The store offers a unique selection of high-quality jewelry.

05
Roman Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Store showcases beautifully maintained showroom with an elegant and inviting atmosphere that feels relaxed and non-pressuring. Staff offer warm, professional service creating a comfortable environment focused on special moments and unique jewelry experiences.

Offers a wide selection of Rolex watches and other luxury timepieces. Provides watch repairs often at no charge and delivers excellent service throughout the buying process.

Offers a unique selection including custom jewelry, limited-edition collector's items, and handset gemstone knives. The buying experience feels personal and enjoyable, with pieces designed to last a lifetime.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are knowledgeable and helpful without being pushy."

"I felt welcomed and valued at this watch store."

"I felt the experience was personal and caring, truly unique."

Good to know

1

Appointments are recommended for personalized service at Roman Jewelers.

2

Roman Jewelers offers a Restyle Event for custom jewelry design.

3

The in-house jeweler can handle repairs and customizations on-site.

06
London Jewelers - The Mall at Short Hills image 1

Jewelry boutique offers a relaxed atmosphere with a family-run vibe despite its mall setting. The space feels luxurious and inviting, featuring alluring showcases filled with fine jewelry. Staff provide knowledgeable and friendly service, creating a comfortable and memorable experience.

Outstanding service and trusted advice guide watch purchases here. Staff handle watch resizing and adjustments with care, ensuring a perfect fit for customers.

Jewelry here stands out for its elegant and unique designs. The selection offers pieces that are both beautiful and distinct.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are helpful, patient, and knowledgeable."

"Working with Kimberly at this Watch Store was a genuine pleasure."

"The staff here feel like family, making it a unique shopping experience."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide selection of luxury timepieces and designer jewelry.

2

Alberto is known for providing exceptional service and trusted advice.

3

The store is an authorized dealer for Rolex and Patek Philippe watches.

07
Kevin's Fine Jewelry image 1

Showroom features beautiful displays and a unique collection of fine jewelry with varied price points. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, fostering trust and friendship alongside professionalism. Comfortable seating and distinctive elements like an antique/vintage case add to the inviting experience.

Staff show deep knowledge in watch repairs and often save money by avoiding unnecessary part replacements. The store offers battery changes, watch resizing, and a wide selection including unique pieces like Ruby Red Michele watches.

A very unique collection of jewelry stands out here, with pieces not found elsewhere. The staff is knowledgeable and professional, enhancing the experience around these breathtaking items.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and kind."

"Jenny makes the experience personal and comfortable, treating you like family."

"The staff at this watch store are so helpful and friendly."

Good to know

1

Kevin's Fine Jewelry offers a unique collection of jewelry not found elsewhere.

2

The quality of jewelry is consistently high across all price ranges.

3

Custom designs are available for personalized jewelry needs.

08
M.S. Brown Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry store showcases sparkling clean display cases with artfully arranged collections featuring beach-themed charms and stunning diamonds. Atmosphere feels friendly and inviting, with on-site jewelry and watch repairs offering detail-oriented workmanship. Regulars appreciate trustworthy service and a wide selection that fits various budgets.

Watch repair happens quickly with great service. Experts handle everything from battery replacements to restoring old, stubborn watches to full working order.

Jewelry includes unique pieces made specifically for the area and a nautical collection. Selection features exquisite and beautiful designs not found elsewhere.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so nice and helpful."

"I got my watch battery replaced super fast."

"I found such unique and beautiful jewelry pieces here."

Good to know

1

M.S. Brown Jewelers offers jewelry repair services with a focus on quality workmanship.

2

Expect competitive prices on a wide selection of jewelry and watches.

3

Unique jewelry pieces are available, specifically made for the local area.

09
Earth Treasures Jewelers image 1

Store shines with immaculate design and gorgeous jewelry displayed in elegant showcases. Atmosphere feels friendly and warm, creating a relaxed yet exciting shopping experience without sales pressure. Advanced technology supports jewelry assessment, enhancing trust and quality.

Expert watch servicing includes cleaning and repairs for antique timepieces. Staff provide knowledgeable answers and a personable style when discussing watches.

Estate jewelry offers the most unique pieces with great prices. Pamela and Beth add distinctive touches to rings and necklaces, matching personal styles well.

People are saying

"This Ring Store has masterfully selected unique jewelry and rings."

"The staff's creativity and expertise helped me find unique jewelry."

"Beth is intuitive, knowledgeable, and a pleasure to speak with at the Watch Store."

Good to know

1

The store holds estate sales a few times a year, offering unique jewelry pieces.

2

Expect a welcoming atmosphere with no pressure to purchase jewelry.

3

They provide fair offers for selling jewelry, often higher than competitors.

10
Braunschweiger Jewelers image 1

Bright, clean space with a fantastic collection of vintage charms, rings, and lab-grown diamonds. Offers on-site repairs and quick watch band replacements, creating a direct quality experience with competitive prices. The atmosphere supports a well-curated selection that appeals to diverse tastes.

Watch repairs and maintenance happen quickly, including battery changes, band replacements, and link adjustments. Skilled staff handle tricky fixes like resizing and crystal screen replacements efficiently.

Selection stands out with a vintage assortment that feels exciting. Always find something unique during visits.

People are saying

"This jewelry store helped me create a custom engagement ring I love."

"The staff at this Watch Store are super friendly and helpful."

"I always found something unique during my visits."

Good to know

1

They had me in and out of the door for a watch repair in 5 minutes.

2

The replacement watch strap costs $25-$30 with no service fees.

3

Braunschweiger Jewelers offers customization capabilities in interesting finishes.

11
Fedko Fine Jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Space features well-lit, cozy atmosphere where visitors can watch a master jeweler craft unique, one-of-a-kind pieces. Jewelry showcases exquisite craftsmanship with designs that attract attention and tell personal stories.

Watch repairs happen quickly with battery replacements in 5 minutes. Watch sizing and servicing come with precise adjustments and excellent workmanship.

Jewelry here is made to order in a single copy, showcasing impeccable craftsmanship and unique artistry. Each piece tells its own story and the owner works on repairs and designs right in the store.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so kind and professional."

"I found the custom jewelry designs to be truly unique and beautiful art."

"I received plus service and the employees were kind."

Good to know

1

Fedko creates unique jewelry designs from quality materials with exceptional craftsmanship.

2

Custom jewelry events are held regularly, showcasing unique designs.

3

They can create any jewelry according to your picture.

12
Venus Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Modern showroom offers an amazing variety of jewelry in a beautiful, bright setting. Atmosphere feels welcoming and professional, with complimentary services like jewelry cleaning and refreshments enhancing the experience.

Watch batteries get replaced quickly and accurately by Johnny. Watch sizing and band repairs happen with precise fitting and care for every detail.

A wide range of unique jewelry designs stands out here. The collection features beautiful, one-of-a-kind pieces with strong attention to quality.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and knowledgeable."

"The staff at this Watch Store are so friendly and helpful."

"I found the most beautiful and unique jewelry designs here."

Good to know

1

The store hosts an anniversary event every year with special promotions.

2

Expect a festive atmosphere during the grand opening holiday ceremony on Dec. 6th.

3

Walk-ins are welcome, but appointments are recommended for custom work.

13
Austin's Fine Diamonds & Jewelry image 1

Jewelry store offers a comfortable, inviting atmosphere with a family feel and unique, classy decor. The space feels like entering a home living room, creating a welcoming, relaxed vibe without pressure. Attention to detail and top-notch craftsmanship distinguish the experience here.

Austin handles custom watch designs and offers quick, reliable watch battery replacements. Services include precise watch resizing and thorough cleaning and refinishing of watches and jewelry.

Jewelry features unbelievable and beautifully unique pieces with a very unique selection. Decor feels unique and classy, and the staff offers helpful guidance.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so helpful and kind."

"Austin custom made a beautiful necklace, paying such attention to detail."

"Austin customized my watch and refinished my wedding ring."

Good to know

1

The owner is GIA certified, ensuring expertise in gems and diamonds.

2

Expect a quick and fair estimate process for repairs.

3

The store offers jewelry cleaning services that exceed typical standards.

14
Walter Bauman Jewelers image 1

Massive, bright, and clean space showcases elegant jewelry displays and a spacious layout. Atmosphere feels comfortable and private, enhanced by friendly staff who offer homemade cookies and coffee. Reliable repairs and custom work complement a collection featuring exquisite estate pieces and dazzling diamonds.

Watch batteries get replaced quickly and bracelets adjusted with care. Repairs cover vintage watches and charm fixes, often with free service or fair pricing. Staff offers polishing and goes beyond just watch work.

A wide selection of unique estate pieces stands out here, blending beautiful designs with classic styles. Items come in various price ranges, all offered with the warmth of a family business.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so helpful and attentive."

"I found my forever ring among their unique estate pieces."

"The staff at this watch store make you feel like you matter."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required for jewelry consultations.

2

The store provides jewelry repair services, including vintage watch repairs.

3

Expect fair pricing on both new and estate jewelry.

15
Tahara Jewelry image 1

Shop offers custom jewelry and in-house engraving with a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Skilled craftsmanship delivers high-quality repairs and unique pieces, often exceeding expectations. Service includes quick fixes and lifetime backing, attracting those seeking personalized, trustworthy care.

Repairs happen fast, often within 10-15 minutes, with careful handling of watches and bracelets. Services include battery replacement, high-end Rolex repair, and restoring vintage pieces like pocket watches to pristine condition.

Designs show a modern and unique style. Jewelry pieces have excellent quality and stand out as totally unique creations.

People are saying

"The team at this Jewelry Store is so helpful and polite."

"I had my engagement ring custom designed at this Ring Store."

"The Watch Store staff were expert, kind, and provided wonderful service."

Good to know

1

Repairs are often completed within a few days.

2

They can clean and repair jewelry quickly, often within 20 minutes.

3

Custom jewelry options are available at reasonable prices.

16
Wolf Fine Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Store features a modern, beautifully designed layout with an inviting atmosphere. A window behind a curtain reveals master jewelers at work, adding a unique touch. The space feels welcoming and carefully crafted for an exceptional shopping experience.

Helpful and attentive staff assist with watch purchases and repairs. Watch repairs, including battery replacement and link adjustments, happen quickly with great care. The selection includes beautiful and vintage watches.

Scott Wolf offers artistic and unique suggestions for design and handles custom orders with quick turnarounds. Jewelry designs match or exceed expectations with precise customization.

People are saying

"They helped me craft the perfect engagement ring and guided me every step."

"They were so kind and patient with my kids during their piercings."

"The staff at this Watch Store are so pleasant and professional."

Good to know

1

The store offers custom jewelry design services for unique pieces.

2

Ear piercing services are available for children with parental consent.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash payments may not be advisable.

17
Belmar Jewelers image 1

Large inventory includes unique vintage pieces and antique jewelry alongside watches and coins. Atmosphere feels family-run and dog-friendly, with a focus on affordable repairs and appraisals done on premises. Customers find a trustworthy, educational experience for all jewelry needs.

A great collection of watches includes unique, one-of-a-kind pieces and a variety of brands. On-the-spot services like band length correction and sizing come with helpful advice for other timepieces.

A fabulous collection of one-of-a-kind jewelry greets you at the entrance. The store features unique watches and coins alongside its jewelry.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so nice and knowledgeable."

"The jewelry store owner, Joe, is so knowledgeable and honest."

"The owner's knowledge about watches is second to none."

Good to know

1

Belmar Jewelers offers jewelry repairs on premises.

2

They provide antique appraisals free of charge.

3

Expect a large inventory of well-priced jewelry and watches.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...