Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Garfield

Pizza places

A pizza that respects the craft of the dough instead of just serving up a generic slice.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Aileen’s Cafe & Pizzeria image 1
Aileen’s Cafe & Pizzeria image 2
Aileen’s Cafe & Pizzeria image 3
View all

Small cafe with calming atmosphere and clean, well-organized space offers affordable prices and a varied menu including thin, crispy crust pizza and standout fries. The vibe suits casual meals with family or friends in a peaceful setting. Catering services add convenience for larger gatherings.

Food arrives fresh and hot with an authentic taste and great variety. The dishes consistently deliver delicious flavors that stand out in a small cafe setting.

Thin, airy, crispy crust defines the pizza here. The Al Pastor and Supreme Pizza stand out with bold flavors, and pineapple on pizza surprises with its taste.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and served hot."

"I thought the pizza was thin and delicious."

"The staff serving the wraps were super nice."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers a wide variety of food options for all meals.

2

Prices are affordable, making it a budget-friendly dining choice.

3

The cafe maintains a clean and organized environment.

02
The Firehouse Family Restaurant & Bar image 1

Old firehouse building with brick walls and firefighting memorabilia creates a unique setting. Atmosphere feels friendly and inviting, like gathering at a friend's house, welcoming all ages. Upstairs space offers room for family events, while the bar downstairs adds a cozy touch.

Food features thin crust pizzas, spicy garlic shrimp appetizer, and tender juicy roast beef. Dishes like calamari, antipasto salad, chicken marsala, and penne come fresh and flavorful.

Thin crust pizzas stand out with their crispy texture and balanced cheese and sauce. Varieties like the meat lovers and drunken grandma offer rich, flavorful options.

People are saying

"The food here makes you feel like family."

"The bar staff remembers your name and drink like magic."

"I thought the thin crust pizza was amazing."

Good to know

1

Karaoke happens every Saturday night, creating a lively atmosphere.

2

The restaurant is family-friendly, making it suitable for all ages.

3

Parking can be challenging, so arrive early to secure a spot.

03
Basil Pizza & Catering image 1

Pizza takeout spot with a clean interior and a family-run feel offers an atmosphere that feels like home despite an unfriendly vibe. The menu features authentic Italian flavors with standout items like homemade pasta and well-balanced pizza slices.

Food here is authentic homemade and made with care. Dishes come out fresh and deliver a next-level taste.

Pizza features a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and crust with toppings like mushrooms and caramelized onions standing out. Pepperoni pizza tastes fresh and delicious, baked just right every time.

People are saying

"This pizza has that perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and crispy crust."

"The homemade pasta is just like Italy."

"The food here tastes so authentic and homemade."

Good to know

1

High-quality ingredients are used in all dishes.

2

Sunday football features special deals on wings and pizza.

3

Reservations are recommended during busy game days.

04
Pazza Luna Restaurant & Pizzeria image 1

Old school neighborhood pizzeria with a casual and cozy atmosphere and a friendly, family-owned vibe. The place offers affordable prices and daily lunch specials, attracting locals looking for classic Italian dishes in a relaxed setting.

Food here is consistently fantastic and delicious with large portions that satisfy hunger. Plates come out together, making it easy to enjoy a full meal at once.

Veggie supreme and Sicilian slices stand out on the menu. Pizza quality ranges from average to very good across visits.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I found the pizza here to be very good."

"This local spot has good food and prices."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers daily lunch specials with a different selection each day.

2

Prices are very affordable, making it a great option for budget-conscious diners.

3

The venue has enough space for private events and gatherings.

05
Mill Shoppes Of Garfield image 1

Shopping center offers affordable food options with a focus on coffee and quick meals like pizza and quesadillas. Space feels clean and easy to navigate with a large parking lot nearby. Variety includes frozen drinks and calorie-conscious choices, supporting quick stops for food and essentials.

Quick build-to-order meals offer calorie-based options for easy customization. Warm food, soups, and frozen drinks are available, making it a solid spot for fast pick-up and on-the-go eating.

NY style pizza offers a delicious cheese pull and comes at a reasonable price. Convenience is a factor with options like Wawa pizza available.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the good coffee here."

"I walked around this mall and had snacks."

"I thought the food here was great."

Good to know

1

Parking is ample and convenient for quick access.

2

The shopping center offers a variety of food and drink options.

3

Prices are generally affordable for food and drinks.

06
Rose’s Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Simple, clean pizza restaurant with many tables and a familiar, jovial atmosphere. Staff engage playfully with customers, creating a pleasant environment. Known for best Sicilian pizza and long-standing staff, it stands out for its spectacular pizza and friendly vibe.

Food stands out for its consistent quality and excellent taste. Staff deliver warm, courteous service whether dining in or taking out.

Incredible pizza comes from a family-owned shop with decades of history. The pizza is consistently authentic and phenomenal, often paired with great sandwiches.

People are saying

"I thought the chicken parm sandwich was the best I ever had."

"I thought the pizza here was phenomenal."

"The food here is wonderful, especially the pizza and subs."

Good to know

1

Rose’s Pizza charges $1.50 for marinara sauce without informing customers beforehand.

2

Rose’s Pizza does not serve wings or cheesesteaks.

3

The prices for the fare at Rose’s Pizza were reasonable.

07
La Bella Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Brick oven and vintage decor create a cozy, old-fashioned atmosphere with Italian accents. Friendly staff contribute to a welcoming vibe in a mom and pop operation setting. The place offers a charming old-school feel without high-end renovations.

Food here is fast, fresh, and fair with a focus on good Thai dishes. Service stays friendly and quick even close to closing time, and the garlic knots stand out as a notable item.

Brick oven cooking gives the pizza a crunchy, fresh taste. The Sicilian pizza stands out as especially good, cooked to perfection with great flavor. Service is consistently friendly and fast.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be amazing and truly the best."

"I added meatballs to my eggplant sub and it was delicious."

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

La Bella Pizza recently reintroduced their menu with new items and prices.

2

The new owner is friendly and has improved the service quality.

3

Expect reasonable prices for pizza, but portion sizes may vary.

08
A&S Pizza Restaurant NY Style image 1

Pizza spot offers generous toppings and tasty dough with a clean, fancy setting. The menu stays consistent with a nice selection of options, including standout garlic knots and seafood pasta. Prices remain great for the quality and portions served.

Food inside the restaurant shows great presentation and amazing taste. Delivery can be slow, with orders sometimes arriving late and not as expected, including undercooked pizza.

Great crust brings a nostalgic taste, paired with pepperoni and sausage toppings that stand out. The pizza offers tasty dough and consistent quality in every bite.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was great."

"The food here is amazing."

"The penne vodka and chicken parm sandwich were very good."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times, often over 2 hours during peak hours.

2

Prices are generally affordable, with deals available.

3

A single slice costs $9.50, including garlic knots and a drink.

Discover more

Garfield, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...