Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Middletown Township

Pizza

Made for those who have a specific preference for pizza and prefer to seek out establishments that focus their craft on the pie.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria image 1
Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria image 2
Attilio's Villagio Restaurant & Pizzeria image 3
View all

Dining room evokes Little Italy vibe with decor reminiscent of a Las Vegas casino. Atmosphere stays peaceful and relaxing, ideal for family or couples. Menu offers New York-style pizza alongside full dinners and salads, with fresh dough and sauce made in-house.

Italian dishes stand out with superb flavor and consistent quality. Takeout matches dine-in with delicious meals and fast service.

Fresh and flavorful pizzas stand out here, with the buffalo pizza being a notable favorite. Consistent quality and friendly service make the pizza experience reliable and enjoyable.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always superb."

"I thought the pizza here was the best in Jersey."

"The dinners here are amazing, especially the Chicken Murphy."

Good to know

1

Attilio's is BYOB, making it easy to bring your own drinks.

2

A liquor store next door allows for convenient alcohol purchases.

3

Expect longer wait times on Friday evenings due to high demand.

02
Takumi Japanese Restaurant image 1
Japanese restaurant

Japanese restaurant offers a clean setting with a quiet atmosphere. Sushi features fresh fish and affordable prices, with rolls that highlight visible fish rather than excess rice. The place is kid-friendly and maintains a steady pace with sushi often going fast.

Food arrives fresh and tastes phenomenal with high quality ingredients. Lunch bento boxes offer great value and quick service.

Tuna pizza stands out with its bold flavor and is a frequent favorite. Other notable options include the bullfighter roll and cheese wontons that complement the pizza offerings.

People are saying

"The sushi here is amazing and a great price."

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"I loved their tuna pizza."

Good to know

1

Their regular Rolls and Signature Rolls are 50% off.

2

Takumi closes at 9:30pm during the week.

3

Pick-ups at Takumi are easy and convenient.

03
Romeo's Plaza image 1
Shopping mall

Typical New Jersey strip mall with a grocery store, pizza parlor, and some vacant store spaces. The atmosphere is super clean with a variety of shopping and dining options. Parking can be challenging, but pizza stands out as fresh and reasonably priced.

Food offers great value and tastes great with excellent quality. Dining areas stay clean, supporting a positive eating experience.

Fresh pizza slices come at reasonable prices with a tasty flavor. The place serves both pizza and pasta, making it a solid spot for pizza lovers.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be great."

"This mall has a lot of vacant store spaces."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Parking can be challenging, especially during peak hours.

2

The pizza and pasta restaurant offers reasonably priced meals.

3

There are several shopping options, including a grocery store.

04
Lubranos 36 image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant with a diner-style interior and family warm atmosphere that is often crowded and lively. The place is BYOB and offers a clean, inviting space despite some wear. It serves highly praised pizza and seafood pasta with a relaxed pace between courses.

Food stands out for its excellent quality and beautiful presentation. Italian dishes come across as amazing and delicious with consistently great flavors.

Neapolitan pizza stands out with a personal touch, as they make 10-inch pizzas to order without a fixed menu. Options like BBQ chicken pizza show variety beyond classic styles.

People are saying

"The dinner here is amazing, like Nona used to make."

"I thought I knew pizza until I ate here."

"The Italian food here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

It is a BYOB establishment.

2

Reservations are suggested due to the restaurant being always crowded.

3

For groups paying separately, a service charge applies to the total bill.

05
Panko Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Traditional pizza place with an old school vibe and large, comfortable seating fills with the aroma of freshly baked pizza. Atmosphere stays quiet during the day, creating a calm dining experience. Walls display pictures that add character but lack a clear theme.

Dough stands out with its quality and the sauce offers a slightly sweet taste with good flavor. Service is quick and attentive, making the food experience smooth and enjoyable.

Pizza features a crust that holds up well and an incredibly rich sauce with plenty of it. Prices are reasonable, with a $12.99 pizza offering good value compared to typical $17 large pizzas.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was to die for."

"It's got that old school vibe."

"The food here is awesome and really great."

Good to know

1

The price for two big slices is $7, a good deal.

2

Takeout pizza pie special is $9.99.

3

Dine-in and takeout prices are now the same at $12.99.

06
Rosie's Pizza of Middletown image 1

Small space with few tables feels welcoming and intimate. Pizza features sourdough crust and world-class dough, served whole only, creating a strict ordering system that manages high demand. Atmosphere is busy and popular, with a focus on consistent quality over quick walk-in service.

Pizza quality stands out as way above average in the area. Food consistently impresses with amazing flavors and unbelievable taste every time.

Sourdough pizza with basil and olive oil stands out for its light, delicious taste. The well-crossed dough creates a fantastic texture, and the pepperoni and meatball options add excellent variety.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza was one of the best I've had."

"The sourdough pizza crust is crispy, light, and airy."

"I thought the food was great, especially the pizza."

Good to know

1

You cannot just walk in and grab a slice or pie; they only sell whole pizzas.

2

Reservations are recommended to ensure you get your pizza on busy nights.

3

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

07
Chuck E. Cheese image 1
Children's amusement center

Children's amusement center offers vibrant atmosphere with varied games and an indoor play area including trampolines. Families gather for fun-filled outings where kids stay engaged and entertained. The environment balances lively energy with spaces suitable for children of all ages.

Food comes out piping hot and fresh with a focus on wings that stand out as very good. Options suit picky eaters and accommodations are made when items are unavailable.

Pizza here tastes like classic party slices from years ago. It stays pretty decent and keeps you fueled for hours of play.

People are saying

"It's so kid friendly; my kids had a blast and loved it."

"I found my love at the arcades, it's truly cathartic."

"I thought the pizza here was really delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect additional charges for attractions like trampolines, which cost $10 per child.

2

Many games may be out of order, impacting the overall experience.

3

The venue can get overcrowded, especially during birthday parties.

08
Valentino's Restaurant image 1
Pizza restaurant

Dining room offers a pleasant atmosphere with tablecloths during dinner. Pizza stands out as consistently outstanding and reasonably priced, making it a popular choice for takeout. Long-time customers contribute to a steady, familiar vibe.

Italian dishes range from good to great, with some pizza resembling fast food style but served in a family-owned setting. Food quality varies, as some delivered meals arrive ice cold.

Pizza sauce made with care stands out here. The ravioli vodka pizza and buffalo chicken pizza offer unique, flavorful options. Overall, the pizza is consistently good to outstanding.

People are saying

"I had the greatest pizza Iโ€™ve ever had here."

"I found the food here to be great."

Good to know

1

Prices at Valentino's are reasonable, with great takeout options available.

2

There is a $1 upcharge for crushed red pepper requests.

Discover more

Middletown Township, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...