Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Upper Montclair

Seafood spots

Made for those who refuse to settle for anything less than fresh seafood when they are craving a coastal-inspired meal.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Gus & Co. Seafood Market image 1
Gus & Co. Seafood Market image 2
Gus & Co. Seafood Market image 3
View all

Seafood market shines with fresh fish and wild caught shrimp. Homemade chowders add rich flavor. Staff provide friendly service and deep product knowledge. Regulars prize high-quality salmon and lobster meat for top lobster rolls.

Fresh fish and wild caught shrimp stand out for their high quality and flavor. Homemade chowders add variety, and staff offer excellent product knowledge and friendly service.

People are saying

"I found the seafood here to be incredibly fresh and high quality."

"The fish here is from knowledgeable and kind people."

Good to know

1

The seafood market offers the highest quality fish available.

2

Prices are lower than dining out for a similar quality meal.

3

The selection may vary due to the owner's vacation schedule.

02
Fish Delish image 1
Seafood restaurant

Bright, open space with outdoor high-top seating offers a warm, friendly vibe. Fresh fish features a light, crunchy batter that stays crisp and flavorful. Creative fish sandwiches on brioche buns come with unique sauces, blending modern design with a neighborhood feel.

Fresh fish comes with a light, crunchy batter that stays crisp without being oily. The menu features fish and chips, shrimp Caesar salad, and creative fish sandwiches with unique sauces and brioche rolls.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and delicious."

"The cod sandwich was fresh, delicious, and unlike anything else."

"I loved the salmon dog with its generous portion of salmon."

Good to know

1

You can bring your own alcohol, which is allowed while dining in.

2

The menu features a variety of seafood options, including a lobster roll available on select days.

3

Prices range from $15 to $25 for main dishes, with some items considered overpriced.

03
Sushi Koshi image 1
Japanese restaurant

Small space offers intimate seating and raw bar views, creating a warm vibe. Fresh fish shines in well-prepared sushi and poke bowls. Outdoor seating adds a relaxed option when weather allows, making it feel like a homey spot for regulars.

Fresh fish stands out with well-prepared sushi. Poke bowls and shrimp tempura rolls deliver a transformative experience alongside shrimp sushi and soba noodles with veggies.

People are saying

"The food here is extraordinary and a religious experience."

"I thought the Japanese food here was the best I've ever had."

"I found the seafood here to be the best I'd ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Expect a small wait to be seated during peak hours.

3

There is a paid parking lot available in the rear of the building.

04
Meet Me at Madison's image 1

French-inspired modern design shines with a hand-carved sculptural wave ceiling and an open concept. Shrimp dishes like the crispy apple and shrimp appetizer offer rich flavors. Enjoy a lively vibe with live performances and relaxing outdoor seating.

Shrimp dishes stand out with the crispy apple and shrimp appetizer served on arugula and the shrimp and grits offering a rich, flavorful experience.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and the portions are generous."

"The brunch food was delicious and well-seasoned."

"The shrimp and grits here are delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary on weekends due to high demand.

2

Your whole party must be present to be seated.

3

Expect to wait if you don't have a reservation, especially on weekends.

05
Turtle + the Wolf image 1
American restaurant

Long, narrow space with intimate low lighting sets a romantic mood. Fresh oysters shine among seafood options like swordfish. Diners enjoy a relaxed vibe by bringing their own wine, adding a personal touch to the upscale feel.

Oysters stand out as a highlight, served fresh and flavorful. The menu includes swordfish and other seafood dishes that complement the variety of options like fried chicken and tartare.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, well-seasoned, and beautifully presented."

"The desserts here are very sugary and nothing special."

"The roasted suckling pig was cooked and seasoned to perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for dining at Turtle + the Wolf.

2

The restaurant is BYOB, with a wine shop conveniently located across the street.

3

Fried chicken nights are popular and served family style.

06
Toro Sushi image 1
Japanese restaurant

Japanese restaurant offers a calm, serene vibe with beautiful decor and cute origami. Fresh seafood shines in dishes like tempura shrimp and mango roll, though some fish may arrive frozen. Spacious layout and easy parking add to a comfortable dining experience.

Fresh fish stands out with options like raw shrimp and the tempura shrimp and mango roll. Some items like the Montclair roll mix kani and fish, but occasionally fish arrives frozen with ice crystals.

People are saying

"The sushi and rolls here are outstanding and flavorful."

"The service at this Lunch Spot is always friendly and attentive."

"The seafood here is really fresh and tasty."

Good to know

1

This location is BYOB, so bring your own drinks.

2

Parking is available and easy to access.

3

They offer a discount if you pay with cash.

07
Silantro Lime Tacos (Truck) image 1
Mexican restaurant

Food truck serves generous portions of fresh tacos and burritos at great prices. Shrimp tacos are fresh and well-prepared, standing out among seafood options. Casual atmosphere focuses on quality Mexican dishes like al pastor tacos.

Shrimp tacos feature fresh, well-prepared shrimp and stand out on the menu. Baja fish tacos include fish that staff cannot identify.

People are saying

"The Mexican food here has the best tacos I've ever had."

"The food from the food trucks here is incredible and very tasty."

"The shrimp tacos here are amazing and the seafood is fresh."

Good to know

1

The food truck offers generous portion sizes for a reasonable price.

2

Expect to pay around $10 for a meal from the food truck.

3

Prices at the food truck are considered affordable for the area.

08
Minoru image 1
Japanese restaurant

Small space with contemporary Japanese design and an open kitchen creates a cozy vibe. Shrimp and vegetable tempura features a crisp, delicate batter that pairs well with dipping sauce. Dim lighting and jazz music set a tranquil, intimate atmosphere perfect for enjoying clams in fragrant garlic butter.

Shrimp and vegetable tempura comes with a crisp, delicate batter and a dipping sauce that enhances the flavor. Clams in fragrant garlic butter with mushrooms balance richness and briny sweetness well.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and perfectly cooked."

"This upscale Japanese fine dining feels like a trip to Japan."

"The seafood here is incredibly fresh, with generous cuts of fish."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to limited seating.

2

Minoru is BYOB, so bring your own drinks.

3

Expect higher prices compared to typical Japanese restaurants.

Discover more

Upper Montclair, Montclair

Area guide
Loading Map...