Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Toms River

Pizza Places

A pizza that respects the craft of the crust instead of treating it like a fast-food afterthought.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
FAT Pizza Kitchen image 1
FAT Pizza Kitchen image 2
FAT Pizza Kitchen image 3
View all
Pizza Takeout

Spacious, modern interior creates a warm atmosphere perfect for families. Pizza boasts crispy crust and fresh toppings, with standout Sicilian slices. Allergy-friendly options show careful preparation and top-quality ingredients.

Pizza features an amazing dough unlike any other, with a crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and fresh toppings. Sicilian slices stand out, and the kitchen handles dairy allergies exceptionally well.

People are saying

"I thought FAT Pizza Kitchen served the best pizza I've ever had."

"The bread on these sandwiches is phenomenal."

"The place has a really cool atmosphere and interesting features."

Good to know

1

FAT Pizza Kitchen offers a wide variety of pizza options, including unique toppings.

2

They accommodate dietary restrictions, including vegan and dairy allergies.

3

Prepared meals to go are available, perfect for meal prepping.

02
LG’s Pizza & Pasta Toms River image 1

Family-run pizzeria offers a friendly atmosphere with a garlic aroma that welcomes guests. Thin, crispy crust pizzas like Margherita are fresh and hold up well even reheated. Clean, bright space serves popular Italian dishes with a warm vibe.

Thin crust pizzas come out crispy and well done, holding up well even when reheated. Margherita pies arrive fresh and hot, with an exceptional crust that stands out in the area.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, especially the pizza."

"I thought the pizza was some of the best I've had."

"It's a family owned small business that makes you feel like family."

Good to know

1

The grand opening is on August 31st, with free samples from 11am to 2pm.

2

Lunch specials change daily, offering a variety of options.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

03
Slice House image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with full pie display offers a cozy vibe. New York-style pizza is crispy by default, while the Sicilian pie shines with flavor. Prices are high but portions are large, perfect for leftovers. BYOB adds to the friendly atmosphere.

New York-style pizza comes out crispy by default with a Sicilian pie that stands out for its flavor. The spring belly pan pizza offers a burst of taste, making it a top spot for pizza in the area.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza was among the best I've ever tasted."

"This lunch spot has amazing food and huge portions."

"I loved their huge, fresh salad with lots of dressing."

Good to know

1

The pizza costs around $18 for a personal size pie.

2

Delivery is available for orders over 5 miles.

3

You can bring your own beverages (BYOB) when dining in.

04
Marie's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Old-school pizza spot shines with perfect crust and robust sauce. Dive-like vibe keeps prices low and portions huge, like the calzone as big as a pizza. Delivery reaches far, making it a solid pick for casual, hearty meals.

Thin crust pizza comes out well done with quality ingredients and a perfect crust. The sauce tastes good and the calzone is as big as a pizza.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be very good and delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The pizza delivery here is made to perfection."

Good to know

1

They deliver to locations far from the restaurant.

2

It is a cash-only business.

3

Normally, pizza takes about 20 minutes to cook.

05
PaciDough’s Pizza Joint image 1

Small pizza spot buzzes with 90s nostalgia and retro vibes. Sourdough crust shines on every pie, especially the Chicken Parm with fresh basil. Housemade ranch and clever menu names add to the lively, fun experience.

Sourdough crust defines the pizza here, offering a unique base that stands out. The Chicken Parm pizza features fresh basil, a rare and notable touch. Every pizza delivers consistent quality and delicious flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was excellent and delicious."

"I thought the meatballs might have been the star of the show."

"The homemade sourdough bread rolls really enhanced the cheesesteak's flavor."

Good to know

1

Expect wait times of up to an hour during peak hours.

2

The menu features unique pizza styles like Detroit and Sicilian.

3

Takeout is the primary service option; limited seating available.

06
Schiano's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy pizzeria offers a relaxed atmosphere with comfortable seating and pub tables. Large pizzas feature rich sauce that holds flavors well, paired with generous portions at great prices. Shared parking can be tight but quality keeps locals coming back.

Sauce quality stands out with a flavor that holds the pizza together well while eating. Portions come large and prices stay great for the size and taste.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had."

"The Italian food here has huge portions and is delicious."

"The delivery was fast and the food arrived hot and fresh."

Good to know

1

The menu has a great selection with many pizza options to choose from.

2

Portions are large, and a large plain pizza with extra sauce costs $17.

3

Parking can be challenging as the lot is shared with other businesses.

07
Vito's Pizza & Pub image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space buzzes with bright lighting and loud karaoke for a lively vibe. Crispy thin crust pizzas, especially the grandma pie, offer great flavor at fair prices. Skilled bartender at the compact bar keeps the crowd social and engaged.

Pizzas come with a crispy thin crust and plenty of toppings. The grandma pie stands out for its flavor and perfect cooking. Prices stay reasonable while the service remains polite and attentive.

People are saying

"The food here is excellent, with generous portions and reasonable prices."

"I was surprised how good the pizza slices were."

"Maryanne's service was excellent and attentive."

Good to know

1

Karaoke night features local talent singing from the 40s to 60s from 7pm to 10pm on Wednesdays.

2

Live music occurs on select nights, enhancing the dining experience.

3

Prices are reasonable for the quality of food and entertainment offered.

08
Villaggio Pizza Toms River image 1

Cozy spot with thin crust pizza and lively vibe. Offers quick, affordable meals with tasty pies like Sicilian style and veggie options. Regulars love the fast delivery and casual atmosphere for takeout.

Pizza features an excellent thin crust and a variety of styles including Sicilian and vegetable options. Toppings like bacon, ranch, chicken, mushroom, and cheese steak come together in very tasty pies that satisfy even picky eaters.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be delicious and flavorful."

"The delivery here is always fast and friendly."

"I experienced the best customer service here."

Good to know

1

Delivery time is typically around 12 minutes from call to delivery.

2

The restaurant is clean and well-maintained.

3

Prices are considered fair and affordable for pizza.

09
Naples Pizza & Restaurant image 1

Small pizza joint offers Brooklyn style pizza with a best tasting sauce and fresh chicken parm option. Cozy atmosphere and generous portions create a classic New York vibe. Family run spot draws a busy crowd with standout dishes like Grandma Pie and shrimp fra diavolo.

Outstanding pizza features a best tasting sauce and a fresh chicken parm pizza option. Family run with consistently great service and a strong reputation for Brooklyn style pizza.

People are saying

"I thought Naples Pizza & Restaurant served the best pizza."

"The food here is amazing, always good, hot, and fresh."

"Their pasta dishes, like Penne Vodka, are worth trying."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required for takeout orders.

2

Expect longer wait times during busy hours, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant offers a wide variety of pizza options.

10
Italy's Best III image 1
Pizza restaurant

Enjoy light, crispy crusts on pizzas like Taco and Brooklyn Sicilian, paired with homemade sauces such as vodka and pesto. Fresh pasta dishes come in large portions served quickly despite limited seating, creating a lively spot for Italian flavors.

Pizza features a light and crispy crust with a seasoned sauce that complements it well. Varieties like Taco Pizza, cheesesteak pizza, and Brooklyn Sicilian Pizza come hot and on time, with options like vodka sauce and pesto adding unique flavors.

People are saying

"The pizza and cheesesteaks here are amazing."

"I ordered Italy's Best Salad and loved it."

"I considered their pizza the best in town."

Good to know

1

Food is ready within 15 minutes, even during busy times.

2

Seating is very limited, so plan accordingly.

3

Credit card payments incur a hidden surcharge.

11
Dario Pizza Pasta Panini image 1
Pizza restaurant

Offers thin, crunchy crust pizzas with bold flavors like buffalo chicken and cheesesteak. Atmosphere is peaceful and quaint with attractive decor and a calm vibe. Prices are on the higher side, and guests can bring their own wine glasses.

Pizza here has a thin, crunchy crust with a fluffy dough that adds great texture. Varieties like the buffalo chicken with grilled chicken strips and the cheesesteak pizza stand out for their bold flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I had ever tasted."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta and pizza, is amazing."

"The food at this Lunch Spot is great."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is BYOB and allows you to bring your own wine glasses.

2

Expect to pay around $21 for a large plain pizza.

3

Prices are comparable to seaside prices, not typical for the area.

12
Emilios Restaurant Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Enjoy perfect crust pizza with tasty sauce and good cheese in a quiet, out of the way spot. BYOB policy lets you bring your own wine, with ice and glasses provided. Cozy interior adds to the relaxed vibe, making it a great place for a casual meal.

Pizza features a perfect crust, tasty sauce, and good cheese. Sicilian pie and vegetable pie stand out as favorites, with consistently delicious and local flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and high quality."

"I thought the pizza here was always great."

"The Italian food here, especially the seafood pasta, is excellent."

Good to know

1

Emilios Restaurant Pizza is a BYOB establishment that provides ice and wine glasses.

2

Expect to pay $4 to $6 more for menu items than before.

3

A 3% fee is added for card payments.

13
That’s Amore Trattoria Italiana image 1

Dining room walls feature black and white movie stars, creating a retro vibe. Sicilian style pizza shines with a fresh crust and top-quality cheese. Calm atmosphere suits quiet talks, while patrons enjoy bringing their own wine for a casual but elevated feel.

Sicilian style pizza stands out with a fresh, tasty crust and well-cleaned ovens that prevent burning. The pizza uses high-quality cheese grandi and offers consistently excellent flavors, including notable pepperoni rolls and a Sicilian pie.

People are saying

"I found the Italian food here to be spectacular and authentic."

"The pizza here is really good for a lunch spot."

"I found the pizza here to be excellent and fantastic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for large parties to ensure seating.

2

The restaurant allows customers to bring their own alcohol.

3

Parking is available, but the area can be small during peak hours.

14
Al's Famous Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Extra large pizzas offer great value and unique toppings like Mexican taco pizza on Tuesdays. Atmosphere feels like a local pizza parlor with hot, delicious pies served regularly. Family-sized options make it perfect for groups seeking quality and flavor.

Extra large pizzas offer great value, costing less than multiple large ones. The Sicilian pizza and Mexican taco pizza on Tuesdays stand out for quality and flavor. Meat lovers and family-sized options are consistently hot and delicious.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"I thought the food here was delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

The extra large pizza is cheaper than buying 2-3 large pizzas.

2

Cheese steaks come plain unless customized.

3

They offer different toppings beyond the usual pizza pies.

15
Little Mia's Pizza (Silverton) image 1

Offers crispy crust pizzas with light cheese options and a $10 deal for great value. Staff deliver excellent service in a spot with a nice atmosphere but a slightly off vibe. Faces tough competition from nearby pizza places.

Fresh and delicious pizzas come with options like light cheese and well-done crusts. Staff provide excellent service, and a $10 pizza deal makes ordering regular and affordable.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I've ever had."

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

"I found the delivery experience to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Little Mia's offers a variety of pizza slices, including six different types.

2

They have generous specials available, though some may be ending soon.

3

Coupons are still honored despite changes to the specials.

16
Frankie G's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Enjoy old school Pizza Napoletana with rich flavors and a standout gluten-free option. The interior is very cute and the place stays clean. Prices are higher but delivery is fast and reliable.

Old school Pizza Napoletana stands out with its incredible flavor and quality. The menu includes a white pizza and a gluten-free option that many find delicious and satisfying.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The delivery food was excellent and delicious."

Good to know

1

Prices for pizzas start at $27 for a medium with three toppings.

2

They charge $4 for a regular slice and $5 for a specialty slice.

3

Delivery service is fast, but food may arrive cold if multiple orders are sent out.

Discover more

Toms River, New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...